Home > Episodes > Yat Siu > Yat Siu - Why 2022 Is The Year of Blockchain Gaming & NFT Mass Adoption For Crypto & DeFi
[captions_button]

Yat Siu - Why 2022 Is The Year of Blockchain Gaming & NFT Mass Adoption For Crypto & DeFi

11,454 views •

CEO & Founder of Outblaze and Chairman of Animoca Brands

I am very excited about today’s guest, as he is, without doubt, one of the most important voices you’ll hear in regards to the ever-evolving world of decentralised finance and the blockchain.

For regular viewers of London Real, and those that have been following our movements over the last six months this interview will offer up a significant reference point for anyone keen to gain a better understanding of NFTs, the metaverse, blockchain gaming, and all that entails. For any new friends, sit back, take notes, listen and re-listen, because you’re about to take another trip down the rabbit hole.

As many of you know, at London Real we have pushed the boundaries recently, to bring to the fore the most significant figures in the world of cryptocurrency and decentralised finance. People like Robert Breedlove, Alex Mashinsky, Richard Muirhead and many more, who are playing their part in what I call “the greatest dislocation of wealth in human history”.

DeFi is revolutionising the world of finance, and if you haven’t worked that out, you need to pay very close attention to the interviews and information we are providing, as we are painting a picture of a world in the not too distant future, that can benefit so many of us if we all work together.

Yat Siu is an entrepreneur, investor, business leader and one of the most significant figures in the world of gaming and the blockchain. He has been at the forefront of technological innovation in the online gaming space for the last 10 years and as CEO and co-founder of Animoca Brands, he is forging new ground in game development, and the complex and often misunderstood world of NFTs.

As Yat points out,

“NFTs and blockchain games are driving blockchain adoption by delivering true digital property rights to all users.”

At Animoca Brands that means working with and investing in companies that share similar values and the common goal to bring more equity to the future of games, while radically changing the future of how we live, play and work, for the better.

As a young boy, Yat showed early promise, developing software on an Atari ST, before the company actually approached him with an offer of work. He was merely a teenager, but, it signalled a lifelong love affair with technology and its potentiality that grows stronger to this day. On moving to Hong Kong in the mid-nineties Yat set up Hong Kong Cybercity, the first free web page and email provider in Asia.

From here, he founded the company Outblaze a pioneering digital media development company that has been a global leader in Web 2.0 products ever since and offered the earliest version of cloud computing services. At Animoca he and his team developed gaming apps on the emerging smartphone market and have racked over 50 million downloads to date.

Yat was named World Economic Forum Global Leader of Tomorrow and in 2009 won the Young Entrepreneur Award from the Hong Kong Business Awards. He is a Member of the Board at BAFTA and the Asian Youth Orchestra and we are delighted to have his insight and expertise on London Real.

It’s very early days in the space, and yet there is so much happening. Trust me when I say, this is the time to get involved and take your seat at the table. Twenty years from now, people will look back and wonder how they managed to miss this opportunity, and a chance to shape a future financial system that is inclusive and prosperous.

This is why my team and I are going “all in” on this technology and infrastructure and plan on spending the next 10 years teaching, understanding, broadcasting, educating, investing in, profiting from and transforming this exciting new marketplace.

Yat Siu offers up another significant piece in the puzzle. He is an incredibly charismatic and engaging individual who is empowering innovation across the globe. He believes in openness and democracy as we build a brave new future with shared ideals. His goal is to establish true digital property rights for everyone, after all, to own your data is to own your future and with that comes freedom.

“that’s not the metaverse, that’s Disneyland.”

In short: Yat Siu is the co-founder of Animoca Brands, a games and blockchain company, and a gaming veteran who started at Atari as a teenager. He sat down with Brian Rose in November 2021 to explain why he thinks 2022 could be the year blockchain gaming and NFTs reach mass adoption, and why true digital property rights matter for everyone.

Yat argues that gaming is already a $160 billion industry that is still growing, and that adding NFTs and real ownership could turn it into a trillion-dollar one. He explains how smartphones brought billions of people into gaming, and how play-to-earn games let those who cannot or do not want to play at a high skill level take part in the game economy in other ways.

The conversation moves from games to the bigger idea behind them: an open metaverse owned by its users rather than a closed one run by a single company. Yat and Brian discuss Facebook’s rebrand to Meta, DeFi, play-to-earn economies in the Philippines, Hong Kong, and what “universal basic equity” could mean for the next generation.

Key takeaways

  • Gaming is the on-ramp to the metaverse. Yat says gamers already treat virtual worlds as real, with friendships and emotions, and are missing only true ownership.
  • Open beats closed. He describes a metaverse run by one company as “Disneyland”: fun to visit, but a nightmare to live in with no stake in it.
  • NFTs are stores of culture. Like a wedding ring or a Picasso, he says their value comes from the story and authenticity, which blockchain can now prove.
  • Gaming NFTs have clear utility. He points to an F1 Delta Time car that sold for $340,000 on the secondary market and can earn yield, unlike a depreciating physical car.
  • Play-to-earn unlocks value already in games. Yat says players create economic value that traditional games capture only through the 1.5 to 3 percent who pay.
  • DeFi supercharged GameFi. He credits DeFi’s liquidity pools and tokens with giving Axie Infinity and similar games the funding and liquidity to grow.
  • Digital property rights come first. His mission is to get ownership of digital assets into everyone’s hands, which he calls a path towards universal basic equity.

Why 2022 could be the year of blockchain gaming

Yat points out that gaming is larger than the film and music industries combined and still posting double-digit growth, because people do not grow out of games the way they grow out of other media. He sees games as one of the biggest carriers of culture today, which is why 8-bit art such as CryptoPunks feels natural to a generation raised on them.

For 2022, he expects AAA-quality titles to arrive as blockchain games, taking adoption from a few million players to tens of millions, and possibly 100 million or more. He says smartphones “amateurized” gameplay, and that play-to-earn now lets people take part in a game’s economy without needing to be good at playing it.

The open metaverse and digital property rights

Yat defines the metaverse as a virtual plane where people hold a real stake. A closed version built by Facebook, he says, would see users as renters who give away their data for free. He calls Facebook’s rebrand to Meta a masterful PR move to own the term, but doubts a closed ecosystem can compete with an open one over time.

Brian and Yat connect this to Web 2.0 versus Web 3.0. Yat’s argument is that when people own property they protect the systems that safeguard it, so putting digital property in users’ hands gives the majority a stake in how the metaverse is run.

NFTs, culture and play-to-earn

Yat explains NFTs as the open, composable layer for people who do not code. He gives the example of baby seats, which nobody had to ask Ford’s permission to invent, and says NFT owners can likewise build new uses on top of assets without the platform’s approval. In answer to jokes about JPEGs, he compares them to a Birkin bag or a Picasso: what you buy is the story, the community and the proof of authenticity.

He and Brian discuss Axie Infinity, the Yield Guild Games (YGG) scholarship model that grew up around it during the pandemic, and the traditional gaming industry’s mixed reaction. Yat says the shift to owning in-game assets is hard to reverse once players have experienced it.

DeFi, Web 3.0 and Hong Kong

On DeFi, Yat compares the Medici banks’ double-entry system to crypto’s token infrastructure, and says liquidity pools and tokens gave NFT gaming the funding it lacked in 2019 and early 2020. He describes how Animoca invests across the open metaverse, with over 100 investments, aiming to own a share of many projects rather than to control any one of them.

He also explains why he lives in Hong Kong, calling it a hyper-capitalist, global place that acts as a bridge to China. Looking ten years ahead, he describes interoperable blockchains, more equity for more people and a duty to tell children to own their digital property.

Who is Yat Siu?

Yat Siu is the co-founder of Animoca Brands, which at the time of this conversation he said was valued at 2.2 billion dollars after a 65 million dollar raise. He began his career at Atari Games in Austria at 13, founded Outplay in 2011, and co-founded Animoca, which moved from smartphone games into blockchain gaming and NFTs. His holding company also backs The Sandbox. He is based in Hong Kong and joined London Real in November 2021.

Frequently asked questions

What does Yat Siu mean by the open metaverse?

He means a virtual world owned by its users, with real digital property rights, as opposed to a closed metaverse controlled by one company such as Facebook.

Why does Yat Siu think 2022 is the year of blockchain gaming?

He expects AAA-quality games to launch on blockchain, taking adoption from millions to tens of millions of players, and possibly 100 million or more.

What is play-to-earn?

Yat describes play-to-earn as a way of capturing the economic value players already create in games, and lets people take part through owning assets even without high skill.

Why does Yat Siu compare NFTs to a Birkin bag or Picasso?

He says that you are buying the story, the community and the authenticity, not the material, and that blockchain makes authenticity provable.

What did Yat Siu say about DeFi and gaming?

He said DeFi’s liquidity pools and tokens supercharged blockchain gaming by giving projects like Axie Infinity the funding and liquidity to grow.

Chapters

2:52 | Brian introduces Yat Siu and Animoca Brands
4:28 | Why 2022 could be the year of blockchain gaming
8:03 | From Atari to smartphones: how gaming kept growing
11:50 | Passive play: taking part without the skill
13:10 | Gaming as the way into the metaverse
16:23 | Open metaverse versus Facebook’s Meta
20:26 | Why digital property rights matter
23:47 | NFTs as stores of culture
31:36 | Why JPEGs sell: status, story and authenticity
39:59 | Play-to-earn, Axie Infinity and YGG
47:30 | Are we all going to be at home playing games?
57:12 | Animoca Brands: investing in the open metaverse
1:02:46 | Young people and a metaverse revolution without bloodshed
1:08:08 | How DeFi supercharged blockchain gaming
1:18:25 | Moving from Web 2.0 to Web 3.0 thinking
1:24:16 | Hong Kong, China and cultural bridges
1:32:56 | How to get started with NFTs and The Sandbox
1:35:58 | Ten years from now and universal basic equity

Downloads

Full transcript: Yat Siu on London Real

2:52 This is London Real. I am Brian Rose. My guest today is Yat Siu, the entrepreneur, investor, business leader and gaming pioneer. You started your career at Atari Games at the tender age of 13 and went on to found the digital media development company Outplay in 2011. You co-founded Animoca, which provided gaming applications to the emerging smartphone market and has since become a world leader in entertainment, gamification and blockchain innovation.

3:18 Animoca Brands is now valued at 2.2 billion dollars after a 65 million dollar raise. Last month you believe that GameFi represents the future and that NFTs offer a new way for culture to be stored. In the digital world your plan is to build a global company with a big vision to deliver true digital property rights. For all. Yeah, welcome to London Real.

3:40 Great pleasure to be here, and thank you for this awesome intro. Hey, you’re welcome. You earned it, and so I’m just stating the facts. You really are an OG in the gaming space, and I can’t wait to kind of get into your brain to better understand gaming, because apparently 2.7 billion people in the world play games. I used to play Atari when I was a kid.

4:00 My mom got me an Apple II Plus and I used to play games there, but you know, as I’ve gotten older I play less. Games, and I think a lot of people don’t understand gaming or esports. And at the same point a lot of people are also playing games. Now we see this concept of the metaverse bumping into things like NFTs and now DeFi, which is something we’ve gone pretty heavy in, and I think you’ve got a great way of kind of tying it all together, so I’d love to jump in and do that.

4:28 Everyone is telling me 2022 is the year of gaming. First of all, do you agree with that, and kind of what does that mean, especially based on kind of a blockchain gaming perspective? How would you answer that to people? So maybe if you go a little back in terms of history, I would say one of the things about gaming is it would seem that almost every year is a year of gaming, and I think when you just take a look at where gaming was, say, 30 years ago, where it is today, it’s one of the few industries that continues to grow year after year, of the year and today, without blockchain and without sort of, you know, DeFi or anything like this, as an industry it is over 160 billion dollars, which is larger than the movie and the music industry combined, right?

5:11 And it still boasts double digit growth year on year despite the fact that it is apparently a mature business, right? So basically gaming continues to grow, and I think one of the reasons why that continues to grow has to do with the fact that young people are playing games, and just like yourself, you used to play Atari and maybe you don’t play games as much, but there was a leftover of those people who are your generation who still play games, right? And what’s interesting is when you think about different kinds of media, they tend to have a stop, right?

5:39 Where people, for instance, maybe they start watching, you know, children’s shows, or maybe they stop playing certain kinds of card games or whatever, because they seem to grow out of it, but with gaming that growing out hasn’t really happened, and so as a result the population continues to grow and the adoption continues to increase over time over the many decades, such that gaming will continue to grow regardless of the fact that as an industry it might appear mature, because young people who play games will play games as they grow older as well, and so what that also means is that now gaming is no longer just this momentary form of entertainment. It is actually one of the sort of greatest, I would say, disseminators of culture today. You know, we used to obtain our culture by watching TV.

6:23 TV shows, you know, maybe even older generations, it was radio, and today that’s all video games, and that’s basically, you know, because we identified with that culture more, elements of that gaming culture continue to survive and actually flourish as time goes on. When you think about things like retro gaming and all that kind of stuff, that’s all coming back. You know, like for instance, things like, if you talk about NFTs like CryptoPunks, I mean, CryptoPunks is 8-bit art.

6:47 What is 8-bit art? 8-bit art is gaming art, right? It’s gaming culture, really, that is basically sort of entered the space, into the general public, guys, not just, actually, you know, in a very particular niche audience. And so we completely look at 8-bit art, for instance, as totally acceptable and actually a form of culture. So gaming is really sort of, I would say, has always been sort of growing.

7:12 Now what’s interesting about 2022, particularly for blockchain gaming, is gaming is a 150 billion dollar industry, 160 billion industry today, but with non-fungible tokens and true digital ownership rights, we think this will turn into a trillion dollar industry very, very quickly, and the year 2022 is interesting because many of the big games that sort of offer these AAA experiences and allow for the onboarding for people who traditionally would be looking for the kind of games that they would normally want to play in sort of traditional gaming are now available as blockchain games. This is where 2022 becomes really, really interesting. And so we’re not talking about an onboard adoption of “Oh, look, another one, two, three, four million players,” which is like a lot, but it’s going to be like in the next 10, 20, 30, 40 million players, meaning that the year 2022 we could possibly be seeing 100 million people or more basically playing blockchain games, and so 2022 could be a very, very exciting time.

8:03 Wow, that’s a fantastic synopsis. And while I’ve got you here, I mean, you were 13, I think in Austria working for Atari, then you went up and you were all over the mobile games, you know, back in the time when all of that became really hot, back in 2011. Now accelerated up to now in 2022. Just perspectives from watching all of that evolve. In some ways, is it kind of like what you said, Brian?

8:27 Gaming’s always popular and it’s always growing, you just only notice it in certain ways? Or have you also seen that this is now a new evolution, because of the blockchain space, because you can now play inside and outside of that gaming universe? Yeah, so one of the things about the big shifts in gaming growth has been, first of all, it has been just acknowledging that, you know, there’s a kind of skill needed for gaming to play, with a fun entertainment device that was interactive.

8:52 Those were the console wars in the early days, you know, Atari, then Sega, then Nintendo, right? You know, all these devices that came about, Sony PlayStation, the first generation, and then it hit a kind of a bit of a sort of slower growth, and that slow growth happened because the gaming sort of wasn’t the hardware limitation anymore. It was a limitation of skill needed to play the game, meaning that in order to play a game well, in sort of, you know, around 2007, 2008 and 2009, that period of time, pre-smartphone gaming, you needed to know how to use a console controller.

9:22 You know, we just had many buttons, and it was kind of complicated, right? And so it became sort of really much more what people define as hard for gaming. You know, people who play almost professionally, even though the esports industry really didn’t exist. And so it started slow growth, and we’re talking about hundreds of millions of gamers but not yet billions. And then the smartphone came about, and the real innovation that the smartphone delivered to gaming wasn’t the fact that it was a game in the pocket.

9:46 That was of course part of the access, but you know, Nintendo already had a portable game device with the Game Boy way before that, so portable gaming already existed before the smartphone. It was the fact that you could play a game and be really good at it through the swipe of the finger. If you remember Angry Birds, or even things like Candy, what it really did was it completely amateurized gameplay. So suddenly we found a market where there were actually billions of people who loved playing games but couldn’t play the games because they were just too difficult.

10:14 And sort of similar to what Instagram did to photography, the smartphone actually did that to gaming at large, where basically game designers had to now create fun and engaging games where the skill level was essentially easy to get into but obviously difficult to master. And it then got people into things like, you know, Candy Crush or like Clash Royale, or obviously Angry Birds as the originator of ominous. You know, these were simple gameplay but a lot of fun to play and very easy for someone to get into.

10:40 And that’s how the gaming industry grew from hundreds of millions of players to 2.7 billion today. But there are five billion people or so that are online today, and because everyone has a smartphone today, there’s actually basically a little more than 30 or 40 percent of the global internet-connected world that has had access to games but still chooses not to play these games, because for them even the swiping of a finger or the interaction is either too tedious or not fun or not interesting. This is where this introduction of gaming and value becomes powerful, as we have seen with things like Rev Racing or Axie Infinity or even The Sandbox, because now you can interact in the gaming world in financial value ways in a more passive way.

11:22 In other words, I can be involved in the game but I don’t actually have to play the game, because in order to be able to engage in this world I need to be a good player still, right? There’s still a amount of skill involved. It’s a little bit like saying you can’t actually play basketball unless you know how to shoot at least 10 hoops in a row. And that means if we do that, then actually we would be canceling out perhaps two-thirds of the audience, because we would never be able to qualify to be able to enjoy basketball, because we can’t meet that high bar right now.

11:50 That’s kind of what gaming is today. So in order for you to engage in gaming, you need skill, right? Even if it’s a simple skill, which, uh, smartphone has done, it’s still too hard for some. Now what if you entered the game where you could just watch it, and you could actually maybe buy, you know, your car and give it to someone else to race, and you can basically be excited about the outcome of the car? Or if you were, you know, having a bunch of Axies and you actually were renting it out to other players who were using your Axies, you would be a participant in the game.

12:20 You would be just as emotionally engaged, but it isn’t your skill to use. It’s not just a paradigm of offering value to the gaming system and offering sort of economic value, but it’s bringing in all the other people who wouldn’t wish they could engage in the gaming world but couldn’t, because the skill level was too high. Well, guess what? Now I can passively engage. Wow, all right, now that really helps me understand it much better.

12:43 So again, we’ll get to the value chain, because that’s fascinating, but you’re, you make a good point. I mean, NFL is one of the most watched sports in the world, but very few people could tackle someone in the NFL or even throw a spiral with a football, and yet people love to engage. Same with basketball. And it’s a good point about gaming. First of all, the Angry Birds yeah, like you said, it was simple to play and it got people involved, but I remember trying to play Grand Theft Auto, I think, 10 years ago, and the controller was so complicated.

13:10 I just wasn’t very good at it, and I kind of quit quickly, and it was again maybe only for a reserved audience that wanted to put the time in. But you want to get everybody involved in gaming based on their skill level, is that what you’re trying to do? Well, no. So I mean, yes, now of course we want everyone to get involved in sort of gaming, but really what we want to do is get everyone involved in joining the metaverse. And gaming is the angle to do that best, because gamers today already have a relationship which is quasi-metaverse.

13:43 So the metaverse obviously is not a new term in and of itself, but when you take a look at history, if we had talked about the metaverse 20 years ago, it would have been way too early for people to think about something like this being possible, because the audience of the world wasn’t quite ready for that. But now we’ve gone through three, maybe even four generations of people who have played games who are very comfortable with this, who treat their virtual gaming experiences really as very real. Anyway, and by real I don’t mean that they think there’s value there per se, but they look at these experiences as precious to them.

14:13 They look forward to the game, they make friendships there. There’s real feelings, emotions, love, hate, whatever feelings they have, those are real. And so now this virtual plane of engagement is very, very real to them and very meaningful. And so it’s missing that one thing, which is true ownership, and it’s missing something that makes it even more meaningful to them, not in an immersive way but in a substantial, maybe economic or emotional way. And that’s where the metaverse comes in, with true ownership.

14:41 And I want to stress true ownership, because only the open metaverse can really offer that, and that is actually what we are, what we care about. And gaming is essentially the way to get most people in there, because they already have a sort of, you know, metaverse 0.5 experience. And how do you define metaverse? If you had to tell my mother what the metaverse is, or tell someone on the streets, you know, you kind of described it there, but how would you tell it to a cold audience?

15:06 What is it? Well, at a very surface level, right, you know, for the basic one is, if it’s, it’s basically the virtual plane. It’s the metaverse in the sense that it’s the meta land, which essentially is a virtual existence where all of us, as you know, citizens of the world, as it were, citizens of the metaverse, would interact, you know, virtually with communities, and with one big difference. So I say the real matters just like in the physical world, only can really become real and meaningful to us when we actually have a stake in it, right?

15:37 And that’s what makes it real. If we don’t own a stake in it, just like in the physical world, then actually it’s not really real at all. It’s basically, you know, make-believe, or we’re working for someone else, but either way it’s not reality as we would define it, right? But to make it real, you have to own a stake in this. So our biggest differentiator, if you take a look at what, say, Facebook or even today Microsoft announced, or just about every other company, I’m just counting down to which company isn’t doing the metaverse pitch, right?

16:04 However, you know, looking at what companies like Facebook are doing, you know, they want the metaverse to be their place, to be under their particular environment. And you know, to me that’s not the metaverse, that’s Disneyland. You know, it might be fun to be there, but you actually don’t have ownership in there, and it’s fun to be there for a few days, but if you actually have to really live there for the rest of your life, it’s gonna be a nightmare.

16:23 It’s gonna be very dystopian. And that’s kind of where we think the open metaverse is different. And so I would say, you know, the real metaverse is the one that is open, and one that is owned by the majority, right? And therefore has the interest of the majority in mind, not the minority, which is what the closed metaverse is actually more like. And this is a discussion we have on this program all the time, this concept of kind of Web 2.0 to Web 3.0, where Web 2.0 is, was, was incredible innovations, companies like Facebook and Google that offered you all this access to information and we connected with people in an amazing way, but ultimately they were controlled by the gatekeepers, and the data owned by the gatekeepers.

17:04 So the equity holders of Facebook, um, got, one got the capital appreciation. Um, you know, Mark Zuckerberg basically made the calls, and it’s a great service, but you don’t own it, which means it will always be someone else’s version, and it also doesn’t necessarily grow as fast, whereas you look at blockchain and crypto assets it is kind of that ultimate Web 3.0, where it’s open source, open code, and so when you see an announcement like last week where Facebook’s literally changing their name to Meta and going Meta, and obviously they own the Oculus hardware and have for many years, you look at that as saying, well, wait a second, that’s still a Web 2.0 version of something that should be more 3.0 and completely individual ownership. Um, am I getting that right?

17:49 Yes, well, I think absolutely, and I think one of the things about Facebook, you know, first of all, Mark Zuckerberg is an insanely smart man, right? Let’s just be just to be clear. So as far as I think he’s mapped out the future and he knows where decentralization and blockchain and DeFi are going. I mean, he even tried to push out Libra right before it became Diem, right? Meaning that he’s got an eye for this and he understands what’s happening, which also means he understands actually what the power of NFTs represent, which could possibly unravel the current data kingdom that Facebook has set up.

18:21 So how do you combat that? Well, the way to combat that is to say, well, first of all, we need to own that term. So by calling yourself Meta, you’re actually, you know, basically arranging a sort of a scenario where when people have dinner conversations or coffee chats and they talk about the metaverse, Facebook will be the natural sort of point of conversation, because, oh, you’re talking about the Facebook thing, aren’t you? Right, because the majority of the world doesn’t quite understand what metaverse is.

18:46 It’s still only a minority that appreciates Web3 and understands what it truly means. So you could say it is a masterful PR stroke to basically try to claim that, and frankly very few companies could do that, because even if a new company emerges, there’s many companies out there called Meta already, but, uh, in fact our holding company of The Sandbox is actually called Meta, right? Um, it was that of course long before Facebook calls itself Meta. But the issue is that, you know, we’re not that famous, we’re not that influential, so we could call ourselves everything you want, it doesn’t matter, right?

19:17 But if Facebook calls itself Meta and rebrands itself, then everyone else will talk about that, and eventually they get to own the term metaverse, right? And I think this is, this is really, I would say, the attempt here to say that when people think metaverse, they should be thinking Facebook, and therefore naturally they would be going to Facebook to experience the metaverse, and that to me is, you know, arguably perhaps the biggest threat, because you know, this is where what we want to prevent, otherwise it’s going to be the same scenario as Web 2.0. That said, I don’t think it can succeed, because anytime you build in an open environment like this, typically speaking, the economies of scale and the benefits are open, are typically larger, and so if you’re trying to build a closed ecosystem, you always have to subsidize and sort of recreate and create the scales of economy necessary to maintain that.

20:04 In the physical world, we see this happening already. Anyone who does not participate in sort of free trade or participate in sort of global trade and global economies, in whatever ways they do, they get locked out, right? And essentially, actually, the economies are non-sustainable. You know, North Korea being perhaps a perfect example, that really just propped up for, you know, artificial reasons, but not actually really sustainable as an example, right?

20:26 And the same will happen basically in the digital world, but Facebook is big enough that he can afford to sort of play this out and try to sort of dominate, dominate that space as far as they can, which is why it’s so important to get digital property rights into everyone’s hands, because one of the reasons why the Web 2.0 framework has worked for Facebook is that people don’t value data. Data is the most valuable resource on earth, right? And it’s what powers, you know, Facebook and Amazon and Tencent and Google and all those companies, right?

20:56 All the company by market cap size, the biggest in the world, they’re all data-rich companies, and that’s because they’re getting our data for free, farming it, and then basically selling it back to us in the form of advertising and services, and we just willingly do it because we don’t understand the value of data, because we don’t appreciate that data ought to be a property that we create and therefore we own. Whereas in the physical world, though, you know, if I buy a house, or if I own this property, if it was inherited, I know it’s mine, and I will fight tooth and nail to ensure that it is always mine, or I have the right to pass it on, which means I therefore care about the institution that protects it. I care about, you know, who is elected in government.

21:37 I care about democracy because I care about the system that ensures my property is protected, and we all have a stake in this because we all own property. So it protects itself as a result of this majority interest, and this majority interest in the common, in a common goal, in the sort of, uh, framework of where you don’t own any data, which is basically Web 2.0. You’re renters. Actually, you don’t know what you’re protecting. There’s nothing you need to protect because I don’t own it anyway, so yeah, you just go take it, right?

22:07 And so it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy, so that’s why if we can create the ownership paradigm and have people understand that digital property is valuable, in fact, and that it’s something you ought to protect, then they start thinking, well, where is it stored, who owns it, and who controls it? Oh, wait a second, I don’t want to go put that into some place I can take it away anytime. That’s why, that’s why we’re in such a rush to deliver that. If you have a CryptoPunk, or if you’ve got, like, you know, a big piece of plot of land in The Sandbox that could be worth a million dollars, for instance, no way are you going to give it to someone who can take it away at any time.

22:41 Yeah, you’ve called this, like, digital colonialism, where they take our data and sell it back to us, and I think you’ve called yourself someone similar to, like, uh, someone walking around in the medieval times trying to tell people that you should have property rights, and everyone’s thinking, what are you talking about? I mean, you know, because we’ve been conditioned to give up our data because we didn’t know how valuable it was, and every now and then we see, like, a pressure point where we realize that last year we came up against some real issues with, uh, with freedom of speech and owning our content and getting to broadcast on Web 2.0 platforms, and it was a, a real good question of who owns this content, who has the right to see it? Um, who’s stopping it from being seen?

23:20 You know, is there real democratization here? And these were, this, we see every now and then these pain points come out, probably because we don’t have that digital ownership, and it kind of rears its head, and we realize that we don’t have that and so for you, that’s really important, for you is owning your own rights and data, which probably takes us right into the way you look at NFTs, and I think you’ve described NFTs as stores of culture because they embody a moment in history. You said, what is art?

23:47 Art stores culture. Also NFTs in the game is your identity, your history, etc. Can you talk to me about what is an NFT and how you see it from kind of the metaverse, and then how it also now comes into our physical world? So NFTs, as, as you pointed out, right, as stores of culture, where they’re cultures that are not necessarily only cultures, meaning for like a mass community, they could also just be your personal culture, right? So for instance, like a wedding ring, wedding rings are very personal to you, they’re not super valuable, maybe to the outside community, but to your own family and to your own very small community, they are priceless, but yet it’s still made of silver or platinum, you know, you know, it maybe has an etching on it, you know, that doesn’t make it special, but we have something that treasures it because there’s a story, there’s a memory, there’s something in there that means so much to us, and maybe only us.

24:41 Now that’s something you couldn’t do in the digital world because we didn’t own that asset, that asset was rented in effect, so we could maybe make an association, which we often do, but the actual ability to pass it on and really treasure that moment historically forever is difficult to do when we think about historical artifacts, religious artifacts for instance, you know, you know, thousands of years ago we treasure them very deeply because of the powerful idea that they embody, except that in and of itself, you know, maybe that cloth or that material isn’t special, but the powerful thing is that what it represents is unbeatable, right? Because it’s really, as people, we’re moved by these ideas and these concepts. Now let’s talk about NFTs and why exactly they are, they’ve become so powerful just as they’re parallel of in the physical world, and it’s because, you know, when you look at Web 2.0, the one thing that survived this ability to be truly free and openly composable was actually open source.

25:36 Everything is developed on open source today, even the biggest of companies like Google or Facebook. They all leverage open source today because it has the most weight, and it has the most weight because someone has built maybe a base code for, I don’t know, something very basic and straightforward, and then another person writes code on top, and actually what they’re really doing, right, is they’re adding through the addition of new code on top of the old code, mixing their culture, which is really, you know, a culture of code, but it’s still culture because we’re run, you know, the way the system works, the UX, the interface. It’s a representation of someone’s idea of how it should be done, which is his or her culture, and that gets represented in the form of that code.

26:15 That code has become so powerful because tens of millions of people contributed on a regular basis. That is the reason why IBM has to use it, and there’s a reason also why a five or ten person organization can now compete with the biggest of companies, and because of the fact that they have the world’s knowledge at their fingertips in terms of code. And it also burst companies like Google, like Huawei, like Lenovo, like pretty much every other company. That’s right, including the blockchain industry, right?

26:40 If it wasn’t for open source, actually the blockchain industry couldn’t thrive. So that’s a perfect example of how this open composability came from layers of experiences that were added on top of this to make this really data-rich, super, sort of data-powerful, shall we say, sort of super gravity effect in terms of the network effect that this code had. But there’s a problem with open source code, which is only people who know how to code can harness that, and most of the world doesn’t know how to code still in this century.

27:09 And you know, we try to solve this by doing Hour of Code and pushing all our children to learn how to code. Unfortunately, we can say that while we’re getting mass awareness, we have failed in getting mass awareness of how to code. Right, at the end of the day, we don’t have 80 enrollment in computer science in college, right? And so most of the world is still not studying computer science. So what that means is that actually we created a digital elite.

27:35 That digital elite is the people who know how to code, and they were able to benefit from that experience. Non-fungible tokens provide exactly the same framework in an open sort of data structure where you can compose on top, except now you can do it with assets that don’t require you to code. It could be a piece of art. It could be music, it could be anything that your imagination will create and allow you to create, because you no longer need to know how to code to get it out there, and people can also freely compose on top of it.

28:03 And as a result, one asset that may have been produced in a certain fashion, someone else can invent and create something new and create new utility on top of it, that actually becomes really powerful, because one asset may have been purposed for one thing but now has a hundred different use cases, because it’s used in five games. You could put a mortgage on it. You could lend it. It could be fractionalized. Now all these different use cases that are emerging through third parties simply because you own it and no longer need permission from the platform.

28:32 This opens up all new possibilities but really, it’s really doing what the physical world already had, but now in the digital context. And that’s what non-fungible tokens are able to do. They’re able to open this up to the rest of the world at a skill level that everyone can participate in, because non-fungible tokens are assets that you can participate in where you don’t really have to know how to code. One of the favorite examples I like to put about this composability is, like, in the form of digital cars, because you know, we sell digital cars with Rev Racing, for instance, or, or a formerly and what’s interesting is that in the physical world there’s so many industries that have developed you know, you know, on the side of people who own cars, without any permission of the car itself, whether it’s you know, drivers, mechanics, service companies, or baby seats.

29:18 I love the story of baby seats, because cars were, no, no, when Henry Ford made the car, he was never thinking, well, this is the car where my children are going to go. No, it was just 30 years afterwards that some people said, you know what, I think we, you know, we can use this as a way to transport our children. We’re going to do it in a way that’s more convenient. Let’s invent this clunky baby seat, and this was not done with permission from any car company, right?

29:39 And now, interestingly enough, car companies have to design the cars in a way that have safety standards that support the implementation of these baby seats. So you have a scenario where actually an external factor came in to influence the way you have to co-participate and co-create for the benefit of both. Right, that’s something that in a permission environment you simply can’t do, because some person who has no idea about you know, or empathy about the needs might just simply say, who needs this anyway?

30:07 And they’ll just say no to it because, you know, smaller organizations don’t have the sort of, you know, the innovation idea pool is so small that, you know you, you won’t imagine that’s possible. You just mix it, which is what happens all the time in digital platforms. So basically refuse access on the basis of it’s not suitable. But who said it wasn’t suitable? Why are you the judge of this?

30:27 Right, right. You know, I used to have a 1968 Ford Mustang when I was in high school, and I used to you know, I changed the color. It wasn’t factory. I changed the engine, I put the new rims on, and it was mine, and it meant a lot to me, even though it only cost me 1,200, which I had to earn through my summer jobs. But you know, that was my creation, and again I didn’t have to ask permission from Ford and I could go ahead and do that.

30:50 And so right now we see NFTs. The ones that make the news are these JPEGs, and I think a lot of people have a hard time seeing the multi-dimensionality and future of what an NFT can become. They can see it more through your games like Rev Racing, where you can own these digital cars and they can change over time. How do you try to get people to see the future of NFTs when sometimes all we see is an ETH rock, or all we see is, you know, an ape, and we’re just like, I don’t get it.

31:15 I try to tell people the first experience with the internet for most people was an email. I sent my first email in 1989. I was at MIT, and I didn’t send one for three years later because there was nothing to do there, and I thought that was the internet. Little did I know it would become something greater later. Are we in a similar stage with NFTs, and how can you kind of tell people that they’re going to change?

31:36 Well, first of all, I mean, I think we’re more advanced than the first email, you said, in terms of evolution. Good news, I hope. Um, but the other thing I would say is one of the things when people look at these JPEGs, and of course that’s the big joke within our industry, is like, oh look, I bought another JPEG for like a million dollars. You know how silly is that, right? But I think what it represents, that ownership, the power of that, is really the messaging, the art, the virtual aspect of it.

32:03 It’s actually really, if you think about historically, and I’ll go into gaming utility shortly after. But really, on those things, you know, whether it’s CryptoPunk or Bored Ape, it is no different than buying a Birkin bag, or, you know, having a Rolex watch, or buying a Ferrari, for instance. And what it does is it’s an invitation to a kind of, let’s say, membership, a proof of your success, maybe an inclusion of a club. When you buy a Birkin bag, what are you buying?

32:32 You’re not actually buying the materials it’s made of. Yes, maybe you think you can touch and feel it, but actually, in reality, 99.9% of that value is entirely virtual. You’re buying a story. You’re buying a creation of a wonderful, wonderful, you know, construction that might look beautiful in your eyes, because it was invented from the mind of that designer. Right?

32:56 When you buy a Picasso, what are you buying? You’re not buying the canvas or the material. You’re buying Picasso. You’re buying his story. You’re buying his idea, right?

33:06 And that is a thing. Now, when you talk about stores of culture, people sometimes buy things historically because they mean something. Oh, maybe the Renaissance period meant something to me, or when people talk about modern art in China, it means something for Chinese people, because modern art is kind of this sort of symbol of where China is today, for instance, right? Or when people buy, for instance, you know, for instance, a lot of people bought up old historical relics from the past as a way to sort of preserve their own history and culture.

33:32 Again, the material isn’t valuable, but the story and the power of, you know, those stories that are embedded in there is why you have it, and it means so much to you personally. Kind of like that wedding ring as well, right? And again, it doesn’t have to mean something to millions of people. It could. I mean, you know, the Mona Lisa is an interesting contradiction if you think about it.

33:51 That context, it’s, you know, arguably the most valuable painting in the world, yet it is the most accessible because you can download the internet anytime you want. You can go there, snap all sorts of photos you want. It’s in every magazine. But you know what, the reason why that original is so valuable is because the whole world knows it, right? And this is the thing.

34:10 When people say, oh, I can just download that JPEG, well, that’s great, but do you own the original? Because the one who does own the original, his, his piece of art just got more famous because you downloaded it and put it on your, put it on your screen. Thank you very much. Please keep doing that, because my original becomes more valuable. So that is one, I would say, when people sort of, uh, struggling with this thought, right?

34:32 I think this, what you’re buying, this authenticity, is when you think about everything you buy in your real world, you’re actually craving for authenticity as well. Would you buy a fake Nike or real Nike? Why do you want an original Apple versus a fake Apple? Like, what’s, you know, you know, why, why, why wouldn’t you get the fake one that maybe functionally does exactly the same thing? You want the original, right?

34:54 Because that’s the same thing, you know, when it comes to sort of NFTs, like, you know, those JPEGs that people sort of, you know, complain about, but the NFTs for utility in terms of gaming, those are more easily understood, but those have much more value, I think, in terms of people who are more, let’s say, pragmatic thinking, because, you know, the world is not all people who think the same way, right? In the same way that, honestly speaking, I struggle with the idea of a Birkin bag. I intellectually understand it, but I can’t get myself to buy one because I just, it just doesn’t make sense to me, right?

35:22 Just like now for some of us, we look at diamonds and we say, actually, that’s not really valuable, yet people desire. So, so, you know, each to their own, as one would say. But for gaming NFTs, the utility is clear, because you can make a clear ROI. One of our sort of, uh, F1 Delta Time cars is sold on the secondary market for 340,000 US dollars. It’s a lot of money.

35:44 The headline article wasn’t, oh my goodness, who spent 340,000 on a virtual car, how ridiculous is that? The headline was, here’s a Lamborghini that costs just the same, here’s the virtual car, which one makes you money? Right, and, and this is the thing. You know, we buy cars all the time as status symbols that are depreciating assets. It’s a, it’s, it’s something that tells us about who we are, and you had a virtual car for the same amount of money.

36:10 Not only does it last forever, it can generate 20, 30, or more yield a year. Right, well, geez, right? You know, in that sense it’s very logical to be doing this, and that is the reason also why these assets inside games like Axie Infinity or Land and The Sandbox, for instance, are becoming valuable, because there’s real utility in which you could be earning money from it. And so that’s where the gaming NFTs are logical. But again, you know, if you just, just consider everything you purchase, from the clothes from the assets you purchase yourself, what percentage of that decision making came from the actual sort of material value, the physical value?

36:47 And the chances are very little of it. Probably. Yeah, there’s some great ideas in there. Um, you know, it’s funny you mentioned the Birkin bag and why you buy it. The crazy thing is, is that these days you’re also going to display that bag 99% of the time virtually, right?

37:02 The picture of that bag on Instagram is how you really want to use that bag, whereas maybe 20 years ago you would show up to the party with the bag. Now you can get a 100x flex factor doing it via the internet, and also maybe even via the blockchain, proving that you own it. So that’s become different. I’ve been to the Louvre in Paris. The Mona Lisa is very unimpressive when you actually see it.

37:23 It’s tiny, and you know, it’s, it’s actually not that impressive, but the idea of it is the whole point, the story behind it, the idea that it is the most important and scarce asset, is what gives it all that value. And then you talk about the fake. Anyone buying the fake, you know, Prada bag or Birkin bag, again, that even shows they’re actually buying into the story and the brand, which is why they want the fake anyways. They don’t want to tell people it’s a fake, because they’re buying into the actual brand.

37:51 So even that shows this duality of us as humans, where you’re right, it’s not even the materials of that case, it’s because we want it to be the story. The real thing. People don’t go around saying, look at my fake Rolex, isn’t that awesome? Wow, I got a great deal, right? People actually would be embarrassed if they actually said that.

38:11 And this is the thing. Now with blockchain, that authenticity actually is provable, right from the source, right away. It’s literally like if you’re walking around and you’re wearing a fake, it’s blinking red the whole time, which basically is actually great for creators, because now they can actually verifiably prove, you know, whether it’s a fake or whether it’s an original, because it’s on blockchain. And I think this is also the community aspect, which is so powerful, because it’s no longer just about getting validation from the original creator, who maybe potentially might sue you if you’re fake.

38:40 It’s a community of, or people who have an original, are not going to accept someone who has a fake. They’re just going to say you’re not part of it, you are a fake, right? And that actually sort of, it’s being excluded from that community when you so desire to be part of that community, which is why you, you know, associate yourself with these assets is actually, frankly, the bigger threat. It’s a bigger deterrent. You don’t want to be caught out, because otherwise you will be forever banished from that community you so want to be a part of.

39:10 Yeah, I did a video on Monday where I put up a picture of a bunch of monkeys out on the savannah, and I was saying not much has really changed you know, back then we were all, you know, fighting for social order, who was grooming who, who was doing this and your, your, um, your social order got you rights of access to mating, to eating, maybe even survival. And we’re still programmed in to do that, whether we realize it or not, and like you said, being, um, being removed from the community is probably the, the worst possible thing. I mean, what do we do in prisons?

39:39 We put people in solitary confinement. And so everything we do, whether we like to admit it or not, is all vying for position in the social order. It’s your LinkedIn profile, it’s the suit you’re wearing, it’s everything. It’s all of us doing that. So once we can admit it, it’s an easier way, I think, to try to understand some of these NFTs and these metaverses.

39:59 Um, I want to go further on that point where you said that in, in a game like Rev, you have an asset that actually creates a return. Now, um, as opposed to, like you said, a depreciating asset like a Lambo in person. You know, I forced myself to dive down the, um, Axie Infinity rabbit hole a couple weeks ago, and, um, I’m telling you that I went on there on a Sunday I bought my Axies. It wasn’t easy. I had to get my MetaMask wallet out, pay my gas fees.

40:24 I bought my three Axies. I put them on the screen and they had their first battle. Actually, one of them died, and I was like, I fell off my chair, because I thought I just lost a few hundred dollars in ETH, but it was just in the game. He reappeared later. I was like, okay, cool.

40:36 But I could I, first time I got it, I said, okay, wow, these are real assets that were created by hard work by other people that I had to buy in order to participate in this game, where I could then earn tokens that are now exchangeable on the blockchain for fiat currency if I wish. And I know this is changing economies in places like the Philippines, where people are now turning this into a living. People are now allowing people to rent these assets and play this for them, and I’m starting to understand what you’re creating with The Sandbox and many of your other companies as well, where these things are no longer virtual environments.

41:10 They, they border right back into the physical, and they really are a clear demonstrator that the metaverse is here to stay, and it’s, it’s really part of who we are as humans. Um, tell me just your thoughts on this, and if I’m getting any of that stuff right. You know, when, when it comes to seeing what these games do as far as utility? Yeah, first of all, you, you get it completely right, and I think, you know, I mean, you know, we’re very fortunate to have been sort of the lead investor of Axie Infinity, or Sky Mavis, back in 2019.

41:39 And I gotta tell you, that was a difficult race, because everyone was, you know, back then you know, uh, sort of Bitcoin itself was, you know, not doing so well. So the, the world was fleeing fungible tokens and then here we are trying to sort of, you know, market a non-fungible version of that, and imagine how much fun that was. But you know, the thing is, um, you know, the thing that’s, that’s fascinating about when you think about what happened in the Philippines with Axie Infinity.

42:04 It didn’t happen because Axie set up an office. The Sky Mavis team set up an office and did something there and built it out. It happened because, you know, you know what ultimately became YGG, right? Uh, basically set up this experiment independent of Axie, and just said, hey, let’s do this. We own these Axies, we’re breeding them.

42:22 Let’s use this as a way for people to actually sort of survive through COVID and make them make an income. And then they saw it work, and it’s an example of this open composability that can take place without the permission of the platform. You know, Sky Mavis is a Vietnamese-based company. They, you know, obviously have empathy for what happens in the region, but they don’t know exactly what’s happening in the Philippines, and, you know, why did the same phenomenon not happen in the Philippines, ever, in Vietnam where they’re based, versus the Philippines?

42:49 Who knows. Right, but it just happened somewhere else, far away from their home, from a third party who was a friend of the company but obviously not working for them, and then ended up building this construct that now has basically taken over the world in terms of potential of what sort of a, sort of a guild really means, which is not actually just playing inside a game to have membership, but playing inside the game to actually make income and a living. Right?

43:12 And that basically is an example of that third-party composability and, and that’s the power of it, because new people and new innovations will likely emerge because of the fact that you have passive ownership on this one, but you’re completely right in terms of that. This will completely change and has already changed many aspects of, you know, where the future of work is going to go. When you think of, we think this is a great sort of solution to many of the problems we’re going to see in the future, because honestly speaking, the only reason why a lot of jobs exist in the physical world is because of politics, because they need to maintain them, because if we actually were honest about it, probably you don’t need, you know, truck drivers anymore, right?

43:49 You probably don’t need a lot of people in agriculture that we have to do. Probably don’t need a lot of people manufacturing the kind of things they’re manufacturing, because in fact robots can do a better job, and this has been one of the big issues. And there’s one argument that says, oh my goodness, you know, human society is going to end up being useless, and we have to find a solution. Okay, universal basic income, right? That’s kind of one, one, one construct, which we’re not fans of, uh, and then actually with this one, we were this construct of your time, your creativity, and your data, meaning that you are the creators of your own equity every single day, right?

44:23 Actually, that means that we’re getting towards an age that we can describe as a universal basic equity, because we’re actually the creators of our own equity depending on how we engage, and for that we get paid. Now, what is Facebook, for instance, without his users? Nothing, and yet here we are giving our time for free. Actually, they should be paying us for our time, right? Because we make them sort of wealthy.

44:47 In traditional games, the conversion rate is about one and a half to three percent, industry averages, which means 97 or more percent don’t pay a dime. But the one and a half to three percent would only pay because of the 97 playing with them. Right? If they’re not there, then I don’t have the incentive to pay, because I don’t have the competition dynamics and all that kind of stuff, right? And so again, that 97 is essentially there playing the games for free, when all the value ought to be shared across the network.

45:13 And that is what play to earn does. It simply delivers the value that was already inherent from an economic substance perspective in the system, and unlocks it, which is what tokens on blockchain do to all industries, right? It’s not just specifically in gaming, but it just happens to be a very effective one, because actually billions of hours are spent, uh, built by people playing games. That is the equivalent of free labor, and that has value that is not fairly distributed to the people who play them.

45:45 Whether it’s worth 10 cents, one dollar, 10,100, that’s a relative question that is dependent on the economy and the value of the game, but it is still value that is generated. And that’s the issue, right? Players play for free because they’re having fun, because they’re getting social status, and don’t think of it as something that is essentially worse than, you know, slave labor, because at least maybe even slaves get paid something. So, so, that’s, uh, that’s kind of where this is, and, uh, and once people realize this, why would they ever play a game where they don’t have ownership and where their time is never rewarded?

46:20 I don’t think, I don’t think there’s any going back. Which is why this is a very big threat to the traditional gaming industry, which is why on one hand, you know, our shareholders like Ubisoft came into our last round because they’re fascinated by this, and they think this is the future, and they’re willing to sort of go deeper in this. But you have other ones who are completely rejecting it because they’re threatened by it. You know, Steam banned everything related to NFTs and blockchain literally just, uh, just, I think a week or two ago, right?

46:45 That’s an interesting reaction. You know, they’re citing all sorts of reasons, but you know, these are red herrings. Actually, I think Valve itself understands what’s going on, because they’re smart too and realize that actually they could completely change the gaming industry and actually completely dismantle the Steam business model, and that would be a threat. It’s almost like, uh, banks banning crypto assets, but we can talk about that in DeFi shortly.

47:10 Again, innovator’s dilemma. You would expect certain types of these reactions, but like you said, once the user gets accustomed to, I don’t know, owning their own money, having control of it, or like you said, being compensated for their time in gaming. How will they go back? Um, my mom is probably watching us right now. She’s 76 years old in San Diego, and she would say, what are you guys saying?

47:30 Everyone’s going to play video games in the future, and like, what do you get what do you say to that reaction when people say we’re all going to be at home playing video games? That’s the future of humanity? Well, first of all, I don’t think that, I, you know, your mom certainly, my mom would have thought That we’d be all sitting on desks on a computer but you know, and if, if someone took a photo of where we are today in our working environment and then sent it back 50 years ago and said, this is the future.

47:59 Probably everyone said, oh my goodness, goodness, we’re all zombies staring at these weird tubes that look like a television, and we’re going to be stuck there and just doing this, right? You know, which is what we do, right? So you know, I I would say that, you know, while we can imagine where it is, actually to me this is just an extension of what we already do today, except instead of looking at a PowerPoint and then an Excel and at a spreadsheet and some word docs, we’re actually engaging in a very rich world that has a lot of interesting things happening in there, which could have, you know, the boring stuff, but can also have the actual, uh, sort of fun stuff embedded.

48:36 And so I actually think our entire interaction model will change, because now we’re not bounded by those physical limitations, because actually humans are very much about imagination and creativity, right? And so this, this tube that we’re looking through, that lens that we look through, when you look at it externally, it might feel terrifying, but actually when you’re inside it, it’s very very rich, because your mind is active, right? Your imagination and your creativity is just flowing, and so you can actually do a lot more things, and you can actually just think about what the computer did just to work productivity, right?

49:07 Despite the fact that we can’t physically move, we’re sitting in front of the computer, and yet we have superpowers as compared to, you know, are the generations before us, right, because we have the computer, but yet we don’t need to walk there. We don’t need to be physically there. We don’t need to interact that way, and yet our productivity and our capabilities are amplified because of that. So this is going to be the world of gaming. We will be amplified in our capacity, but in our creative capacity, because we can do stuff.

49:36 You know, education is an interesting example where we’ve been training our children to fit a world that frankly is in the past. and all the things we’re learning are really sort of not what the future needs, but we do it because, you know, we think that’s where the world is, because, you know, schools tend to teach the past, not the future. That’s just the way they’re constructed. But you know, in this, in this thing here, or really, you know, all sitting on those computers, so-called playing video games or engaging these worlds like The Sandbox, where you’re creating assets.

50:06 It’s actually really creative activity that you’re doing, and you’re doing creativity without specific limitations. I think of the potential there to be much more richer, and I’m also saying that we’re not just playing one world, we’re actually able to play a multitude of worlds and a multitude of experiences because we can hop in and out wherever we want to. You know, I think the world actually ought to be celebrating more diversity, which is really, if you think about it, the hub of innovation comes from, you know, diverse inputs and diversity, but you know, because of what’s happened, we end up really being siloed into these areas.

50:40 Centralization has homogenized culture, right? When in fact culture should be much more free. You know, I, I, you know, growing up in the 80s, there was music everywhere. Every, every other week there was some one-hit wonder that emerged right, and then disappeared, right? But we were exposed to different types of music and different types of, today.

50:59 You know, I go to Spotify. It’s like Spotify is telling me what I should listen to, and as a result actually it’s starting to homogenize, for instance, music or other formula culture, because we’re all consuming the same thing, but in fact maybe that’s not what how the future should look like. I think you once said life is a game when people ask you about how it plugs into gaming. I thought it was a great point, and I mean, and I was having this conversation with one of our booking guys right now, and I said, well, we’ve got someone who works for us virtually and helps us book guests I said, if they book, yet, then that’s a big win, and we’re like, wow, that’s really good, and they do a great preparation for it, and that’s a big win, and then we’ll send them some tokens known as dollars and say great work, and I asked my book, I said, how is that any different than someone playing Axie?

51:44 You know, they’ve been creative they’ve come up with a strategy, they got delivered some value, and they got some points that are now tradeable on the blockchain or on The Sandbox. So again, when people start looking at it this way, you can say that, yeah, you’re parked in front of computer, you’re giving your energy, your ideas, your creativity. How is that game any different than your virtual workplace or even your interactions with Facebook, etc. It all becomes very much the same thing, especially when you have it connect back to real-world assets via the blockchain and NFTs that you can now take out of the game, and I think you once said assets should exist to support the game as opposed to games that exist to support, um, the assets.

52:25 I think is what you’re saying. I might have got that wrong, but the way you’re talking about this future is you can take your assets and go from experience to experience and that the games of the future need to cater to those transferable assets. Is this future vision that makes you super excited and what you guys are doing? Yeah, so we think NFTs are the center of the experience. A few years ago we coined this term where we said, you know, because of NFTs and blockchain, content will become the platform, and what that means, what we’re saying there, is that we will build and experience things because we own these assets and because people will build stuff for us because they want to tap into us, which is very different from the way we experience content today.

53:07 We experience content, or experience virtual goods, you know, in games as support assets inside those games, right because of the fact that the game itself doesn’t actually care about the value of the assets. The assets exist to support the game, right? So that’s all it is, which means it’s disposable, right? And therefore you can always nerf it, because if it doesn’t serve the purpose of the game, as in the gameplay, which is the purpose, to make money for the game studio, right?

53:32 Then we have to change it, and that’s because games obviously have a, they serve a minority, which is about making money for the game studio, and therefore everything in there is valueless. Now, in an environment where you own the asset itself, in order to bring a customer into your environment you need to demonstrate that this is a valuable experience to you. How do you do that? By basically showing that you have offered value to the assets that you might already have above and beyond you buying some new assets.

53:57 This is no different than someone sending you an invitation because you own a Ferrari. Why do they send you an invitation because you own a Ferrari? And you know what, you probably like fast cars, and you know, you probably got a bunch of money, so let me go and, you know, pitch to you, you know, this Piaget watch, for instance. Yeah, that happens all the time, because they associate what you own, and therefore offering you value-added services, you know, which you may or may not have asked for, because they want you as a customer.

54:23 And so in this future, this is, this is already playing out. If you have a Bored Ape, you’re a desirable customer. If you’re a CryptoPunk, maybe even more desirable, right? If you’re a Sandbox land owner let me pitch you all these other land deals, because you know what, I think you might like this better. Right, this is where I think it’s going to happen.

54:40 As a consumer experience, it’s more powerful, because people will come to me and also the gravity of the assets. If I own them, I want to make sure that the assets have even at least retained, if not increased, their value. What am I going to do? I’m going to encourage, as a community, that more game environments use them and interact with them, because it’s good for me as well, right? So I think it creates a very nice virtual cycle of value where you can build a game that has community ownership, and these assets, the more free they are and the more they travel, the, the better it is for, you know, all communities, frankly speaking, right?

55:17 But this is a model that doesn’t work for game companies, because right now, because they’re not on blockchain, they don’t have a way in which value can be transferred back to them. So every time they would allow a user to leave the game through this kind of interoperability, they actually lose that customer, and that’s it, right? And so obviously that doesn’t work for them. That’s why they have to construct, you know, the tallest of wall gardens if they can, to make sure you can’t leave, and then just trap you, right?

55:41 Which is, you know, I mean, you know, I, I grew up in Austria in the 80s. You know, I basically, my mom used to work in, in Germany in music, uh, and she used to work at the Komische Oper, so I crossed the, across the border between East and West Berlin, and the only reason why people from East Berlin couldn’t freely move is because there were these tall walls that, you know, at the potential sort of threat of life, um, if you were trying to sort of leave. That’s basically walled garden environments in the digital world.

56:10 You know, you don’t get killed, but you lose everything, right? If you leave, you are actually saying, okay, I leave, but I have to give up all my time, all my effort, everything I spent in this game, not just money but social value, everything. That’s the, that’s the, that’s the trap they built for us. Yeah, I actually went through Checkpoint Charlie, I think in 1986, right there in Berlin, and I went and saw East Eastern Berlin. My mom took me there, and so I saw these completely different worlds that were just a few blocks apart because someone decided to build walls, and those people could have contributed massively to the West Berlin economy or could have done amazing things, but they were trapped there in this kind of artificial, like, wall garden, like we see with still a few countries in this world, and it just seems to be a travesty.

56:57 Not only is it not really humane, but also you’re just so much value and creativity is being locked in there, right? It could be opened up. Right, absolutely. I want to get your thoughts on DeFi, but first I got to find out about what you guys are doing inside Animoca Brands. You guys are doing so much.

57:12 You just announced, um, a raise for The Sandbox and I know you’re doing things with Snoop Dogg in there as well, and you guys seem to almost kind of license or pull brands into the gaming universe and allow them to kind of thrive on their own. I’m trying to get my head around exactly what you guys do, but maybe you could tell me, and then tell me about some of your games as a way of maybe describing it. Sure. So first of all, I mean, the way you think of Animoca Brands is, we’re looking as a goal to really sort of deliver digital property rights.

57:44 That is our north star. That is our big mission, to deliver digital property rights, and so we very early recognized that there’s no way that we could do this ourselves, and in fact it would be a little bit of a sort of hypocritical if we wanted to deliver digital properties to all, just all by ourselves. Right, you know, so, so that’s one of the reasons we decided to make investments in the space, and frankly we can’t do it ourselves anyway, and that is how we got early into OpenSea and Sky Mavis and Dapper Labs and WAX, Decentraland, and, you know, and of course The Sandbox, which is, uh, you know, part of Animoca Brands, and a whole host of other companies that we’ve got.

58:16 We’ve done over 100 investments. And we’ve done, you know, over 12 acquisitions, actually more probably at this point, you know, and we continue to want to do this, and just to be clear, we don’t have an ambition to be controlling any one of these Sandbox runs very independently, and while we are still majority owners, you know, we fully expect that in the future The Sandbox will be completely decentralized and will be owned by its users, because we really believe that the only way any unit, any society, can actually sort of survive, you know, for a long run, if not forever, is if there is a majority interest in its success and that means that the players themselves have to own it, right? And that is how we construct everything.

58:55 So from that perspective, it’s almost like if we’re, you know, building up the next New York or the next Chicago or the next Hong Kong, and our ultimate outcome will be, we’ll own maybe 10 or 20 percent of the real estate, and, you know, own some businesses in there. We think that’s a great outcome, and we will do this across multiple places around the world. We don’t want to run them. We don’t want to control them, because if we do, we actually become what we actually don’t want to be in the first place.

59:20 Right? And I think this is the reason also why we can make all these investments, because if we have such a big sort of, uh, sort of involvement in everything that is open, it actually means that whatever we’re building ourselves, whether it’s tools, services, or other metaverses, we have to continue building it open, because it’s not just something that we philosophically believe, it’s also in our economic interest to do so. Right, um, and that’s, that’s, that’s the construction of it.

59:45 You know, ideally half investing and sort of having sort of, you know, a stake in everything that is in the open metaverse, ideally, and the other half, you know, constructing and building things that the open metaverse might need. Right? And the approach that we’ve taken is that, you know, we are often you see us buying game companies that have audiences and users but, you know, aren’t yet on blockchain, and so what we do is we acquire these game companies that already have users, and then bring them and onboard them with, with the concept of real ownership in the digital context and basically supercharge their economies, and that has worked very well for us.

1:00:19 And of course there’s now other companies out there essentially emulating that model, which is fine, because if we have a shared network effect across Web3, then there’s more people who enter the space. Actually, the rest of the ecosystem grows, which means that even the other half of our portfolios will also all rise as a result of that, which is basically what we’re experiencing in the moment. And so most recently, you know, one of the other things we’ve done, both with our own fundraisers, like bringing strategic people like Sequoia or Ubisoft or, you know, LCD Kingsway, all those guys, you know, with The Sandbox, who just recently brought in SoftBank.

1:00:52 And again, you know, SoftBank is amazing and a legendary investor, you know, of, you know, really, if you think about this sort of birth of the internet, actually, is, you know, one of the most important players, and to us that was really important to bring them in as well, because they invested in the open metaverse with The Sandbox, which means now they have a stake in helping the open metaverse succeed, rather than going for, you know, another Roblox, for instance, which is you know, fun and everything, but doesn’t care about constructing open and wants to build walled gardens. And so that’s part of our mission as well. You know, we’re bringing in investors and partners and everything, because the capital, you know, money itself is no longer really that scarce, as you well know.

1:01:32 However, the money that is special is the one that has influence. SoftBank is an example of an influence. Once they are sort of, you know, tasting the potential of the open metaverse, the open Web3. Hopefully they’ll continue to invest only in Web3 things, and that sort of power that comes in actually becomes the influencing factor that we want to see happen. That is how we combat the likes of Facebook or maybe even Microsoft that wants to control that space, whatever well-intentioned they might be, because once they actually have the power, because they have the majority of that network effect, unfortunately bad things will happen, because, you know, absolute power tends to corrupt, and that’s the problem we see historically.

1:02:14 And in fact it’s been played, it’s been playing out right in our eyes right now, in sort of, you know, what’s happening inside Facebook, right? Do you see just obvious parallels between this and crypto assets like Bitcoin and Ethereum, and the banking world and the government, where we see, you know, a lot of pension funds and banks now investing and talking about this, and countries adopting it, whereas you still have central banks and fiat currencies that are probably going to still hold on to their control mechanism? I mean, you’re doing something quite parallel here with gaming in 3.0.

1:02:46 Well, first of all, I think, you know, people used to think that, uh, internet original, internet one, was kind of a parallel universe, right? Um, that somehow didn’t touch the physical world. Well, clearly that wasn’t true, right? And I think Web3 is exactly the same. The reason why it feels like a parallel universe for people who are not in Web3 is because they’re not there.

1:03:04 They don’t experience it. I remember back in the day as well, when smartphones came about, and we, you know, we were telling our, sort of, uh, game studios at the time, look, we got to move on the smartphone. This was in 2010, right? You know, and we came out with a first big mobile game really at the end of 2010, and in 2011 it sort of took off, right? And many of the console game developer guys were just like, I’m not touching mobile games, that stuff is trash.

1:03:28 Why would I ever demean myself in making product for something like this? And that’s because they never used a mobile phone. They didn’t use a smartphone. They were using BlackBerries. They’re using different devices, so their frame of mind was just completely unable to understand it, because they weren’t in it, right?

1:03:44 And, though, that’s, that’s the same is true for what’s happening with Web3. The people who are in Web3, they just can’t talk enough about it. They will never go back to the old one, right? Once you’re in there, like, once you’ve taken that red pill, you’re just, like, way down that rabbit hole, you just don’t want to get back out anymore, right? But how do you explain that to someone who’s not even there, right?

1:04:04 That’s the, that’s the hard part, right? And so, so there is of course the fear of the unknown, but there’s also the other thing, which is, you know, like the incumbent issue, for you know, companies, people themselves have incumbent natures too. I’m a successful finance person in a way that I understand. I can sort of do, sort of, intrinsic analysis of fundamental value, right? You know, all these things that they’ve known, which has served them so well in the past.

1:04:30 The problem is that that model doesn’t serve this young generation at all, because the opportunities that they had are all gone anyway, right? You know, they already have real estate, they already own a stake in the physical world, right? And the young people that are just emerging in this world, who just went through four years of college and are in debt, they’re looking at this and saying, what’s there for me, right? And so, you know, normally in history this is the beginning of revolution, right?

1:04:57 And the revolutions in those areas tend to be quite bloody when you look at historical context, which is not great. But with the metaverse there’s actually this new development, because of the way the world has developed, where actually people who are digitally native and comfortable that’s their opportunity. It’s like this age of exploration, where they can go out and discover new lands, and they don’t have to go to space to do it. They can do it right here at home in the virtual plane, and that’s actually what’s so powerful and different here, and as we’ve seen so many times in history, you know, young people do create a revolution, but this one doesn’t have to be bloody.

1:05:30 This one just moves people over, because they’re going to create all this wealth and all these new opportunities in the metaverse, and they’re populating this at rapid hyper speed, eventually to the point where, you know, people who are not from that are going to come to recognize it and say, you know, maybe we need to take a look at this more seriously. But I don’t think it comes at the expense of them. So I don’t think it’s zero-sum. That’s the thing.

1:05:54 You can be very successful in the metaverse, and it’s not going to take away the benefits of someone who is not in the metaverse, who’s already made it, as it were, and owns his land and lives there quite nicely, because he owns his property already. He’s fine. He doesn’t need to. He doesn’t, he may not even need that, and that’s perfectly okay. I’m having flashbacks to maybe like 16, 1700s of people leaving Europe and going to America because of their values, their poverty levels, whatever.

1:06:22 Um, you know, being ostracized, and you could go to a new place with, um, potentially all this brand-new capital. You could create value for the world that would then add value to everyone else, and in that way it wasn’t necessarily destructive. It was actually constructive in that way. Maybe this is, maybe a similar parallel. I don’t know.

1:06:41 Just thought about that. I think so, and what’s also interesting, if you think about those who ended up leaving Europe and basically populating the U.S. actually, their ideals, the experiment about, you know, democracy and, you know, all the particular sort of things that America stands for, that idea actually started to influence the world, and went back to the, call it, old world, and influenced their ideals, and had people start talking about, you know, freedom and sort of democracy and what that meant in a very feudal society at that time as well, and had a direct impact as to what people thought maybe the world should look like.

1:07:17 And I think that could happen with the metaverse too, where people who are in the metaverse are influential and are basically extolling this new idea about how the world could be, and so the rest of the world might go there. But in this case, perhaps again it will be done, maybe, in a much more peaceful manner. Yeah, no, I think that’s a great, great metaphor. And it’ll be interesting to see how people look onto the metaverse and maybe adopt certain things or come for a visit.

1:07:39 I was trying to describe a hard fork the other night to my students inside the DeFi Academy, and I came up with, like, the Boston Tea Party was one of the original hard forks, where a bunch of people said, you know what, we don’t want to be subjects of the king anymore. We don’t want to be taxed without representation. We’re going to hard fork this way, but to do that you got to have a bunch of people that want to go there. You’re going to have to choose a code, you’re going to have to choose a path, and it ended up being like that hard fork, where you’re like, okay, we set up something new, a new protocol, a new way of doing things, and then you know, people took things from that in the future.

1:08:08 Um, so this is a really interesting parallel. I want to get your thoughts on DeFi. Yeah, because I’ve never seen anyone in gaming put it together like, like you did. You know, you, I believe, said that the evolution of DeFi was a supercharger for blockchain gaming, and I thought that was such a powerful statement. One of the reasons I want to get you on here today, what did you mean by that?

1:08:26 Because I’ve never heard gaming people really give, pay homage to, say, the DeFi Summer of 2020 and all the innovation that came from a, like a borrowing and lending perspective, and attribute that to some of the success in gaming and future NFTs. So when you think about the classical banking infrastructure out there, right? What did banking really do to the physical world? It essentially supercharged economies because of trade facilitation, lending, and these things, that all these things were necessary in order to have global trade and have the ability for people to do merchant transactions.

1:08:59 Right? Banks became these facilitators of trust and liquidity that enabled classic merchant services and labor, and labor activities, to actually flourish. Right? So that’s what DeFi is. What’s interesting though about DeFi and the whole token economy of blockchain is that, normally, in the traditional context, merchant services came about first.

1:09:19 I mean, if you think about the invention of the banks by the Medici, the whole double-entry system was really the beginning of how do we actually verify a transaction between two parties. Oh, the double entry, right? You know, that sort of, sort of debit and credit. Okay, I mean, as, and you still use that system today, which is crazy, but anyway, here we go. Um, you know, they designed that system to facilitate trade across Europe and create a banking infrastructure to do that, right?

1:09:44 And that was really the innovation that the Medicis put forward. With crypto, it happened the other way around, because of the token infrastructure, because of Bitcoin coming first. There was a financial construct that essentially created a bank that essentially had incredible liquidity where people were just going in, really, from a belief system but not a real utility. And then with, you know, DeFi you were able to tap into that liquidity, generally for inflationary tokens, right?

1:10:10 And just sort of, you know, fund value and maybe mean value but not actually any intrinsic value in and of itself that was sort of based on labor or, or some, some service, and that infrastructure was growing into billions of dollars of size, right? And then, you know, when, when, when blockchain games, which were already developing years before, I mean, you know, that wasn’t something that sort of just suddenly emerged. It was developing really, then the ability to actually tap into that liquidity and provide a sort of decentralized financing service to the players that is what supercharged the economy, because now you had a banking layer that was already ready, but it was waiting to provide service to something that was actually meaningful.

1:10:51 GameFi came in and said, we can be that meaningful. you know, when Axie basically issued, you know, what was the SLP token? It was really only meant to be a sort of a currency, you know, to be used in breeding. but essentially as a mechanism, ultimately, to sort of earn value from that, you know, they opened the liquidity pool and people started just trading into that liquidity before this is defined. Right there, if that didn’t exist, then there wouldn’t have been a mechanism for players to cash out, or for players to exchange value between, between that.

1:11:20 So the liquidity pool was actually, you know, not a new concept in and of itself, but actually really supercharged the potential for the earliest version of Axie Infinity to grow, and of course that was something that didn’t exist before, because you had centralized exchanges who would want to list you, and, you know, they charge big fees, and, you know, all that kind of stuff, right? But you were still under the control of what that particular exchange wanted. And the other problem was that maybe it would have happened if exchanges back in the day understood gaming and said, hey, you know what, we think we should be back in gaming projects, let’s do that, but they didn’t, because at heart they were traders, so they were all thinking finance.

1:11:56 Right? I mean, trying to push NFT gaming and NFTs generally in 2019 and even early 2020 was really hard, because the majority, so because the non-blockchain world was like, what the hell are you talking about? And for the people who were in crypto, they’re like, I’m not gonna want the non-fungible version of a token. I can’t trade that, right? That’s that, that hasn’t, that, you know, everything was about liquidity, liquidity, liquidity.

1:12:18 Right? So, so therefore putting liquid, having this liquidity system put in place, because all they could do was talk about that, was the perfect thing for gaming to say, great, now you built this liquidity, let me tap into that, and basically GameFi was born. Wow, it’s fascinating. I had Stani Kulechov in here about a month ago, um, actually in person, because he’s in London, and uh, he runs Aave, obviously, about 23 billion locked up. Um, he’s got 2,000 NFTs on his phone, and he said you know, the next step is to fund NFTs.

1:12:48 So again, it’s one thing to have an amazing pool of fungible tokens but to get these NFTs in a funding scenario, it opens up so much. And again, I used to work in finance for 15 years. I started on Wall Street, I worked in Chicago, I worked in the City of London for nine years and credit derivatives, and I tried to explain to my students inside our DeFi Academy that this unlocking these basic lending and borrowing building blocks, it just opens entire economies up.

1:13:11 And I used to trade fixed-floating swaps in New York City, where there was off-balance-sheet instruments where you could manage interest rate risk. The fact that those were liquid meant that you could ask for student loans, to people, corporate finance. It just opened up this whole world, and even though you can’t necessarily see it, it’s what has given this market a lot of liquidity and depth. And again, even if you look at something like a stablecoin, a lot of my students, uh, you know, bought some stablecoins and said, Brian, why aren’t these going up?

1:13:38 And I said, well, that’s, they’re designed not to go up, but they’re also one of the basic building blocks of everything behind the scenes that gives all the liquidity that you enjoy. As you said, like an Axie Infinity player, when you can sell your SLPs, you know, within a few cents, a bit off for spread, you know? Back when I worked in Chicago, there was a pit of 300 ex-American football players yelling and screaming in the Chicago Board of Trade at the futures exchange, and they all own memberships that cost a million dollars a year, and they were in there yelling because they were providing liquidity.

1:14:10 That was the liquidity pool back in the day, and they also had access to information, et cetera. But when I saw what DeFi was doing, uh, and I saw that now they were finding a way to give tokens to liquidity providers and do all of this innovation. I’m telling you, when I saw this six months ago, I was just all in. I was like, I can’t believe the innovation, I can’t believe the value locked. I mean, when I was working on Wall Street, no one ever called me up and said, guess what, if you use my brokerage service, not only will you get equity you know, we’ll give you a great service, we’ll give you equity in the company that you can use as tokens for the future.

1:14:44 And everything’s transparent on the blockchain. I mean, it blows my mind, and so it’s great to see someone that’s not just straight in the DeFi space, seeing what DeFi does for the rest of the space, and, um, again when we get the financing of some of these NFTs as well as the fungible tokens I mean, it really starts to get interesting, doesn’t it? No, totally. I mean, you know, at the end of the day, even, you know, today what powers economies, at the end of the day, is the liquidity of the markets.

1:15:11 Right? You know, and maybe only a small part of the world, you know, really sort of interacts with it, because we just take it for granted. You know, we don’t have to understand how the banking infrastructure works, and so on, but the liquidity that’s provided essentially greases the system such that it can actually move fast, and, and, and effortlessly through, because without it you then have these sort of, you know, sort of, uh, friction points in where you can actually transact.

1:15:35 Um, the stuff, the other thing of course that’s really powerful here also is that because DeFi is open, you can build new innovative constructs on top of this, right, where basically you know, people didn’t think about lending NFTs before, but now there was liquidity and now that’s possible, and you have platforms like NFTfi that emerge that actually allow you to do the lending, the fractionalization of NFTs as well, where you can take these assets and do stuff around that as well. So you’ve got, you know, new platforms that are emerging completely outside of you know, the original idea of what these NFTs were designed for, innovating on top of that and essentially combining DeFi and NFTs, or NFT gaming, everything else together, because they’re all openly composable in the first place, and that’s just, you know, that’s, that’s really, really, really, really powerful, and, and I think the other thing that we love about this is that this is a way in which we really teach financial inclusion and knowledge to the masses.

1:16:32 Because when you’re engaging in culture, for the most part, right, you’re engaging in it because you love it, but you don’t understand that there’s a value behind it, and, you know, in schools they don’t teach you about that stuff. I mean, you know, most, most kids don’t know anything about finance until they go to college and have debt, right? Which is a horrible way to experience, you know, your first sort of real economics. But in this environment, actually, when you recognize that actually this has value early on and there’s liquidity in that market, actually I think it replaces the need for a school to teach you about that, because that becomes your early interaction.

1:17:03 Our children play games at a very young age anyway, and they have the mental capacity to understand actually what is sort of, you know, economics, you know, because they are trading cards or they’re doing stuff already. Now make that real for them, and I think that’s really, really powerful. It’s so exciting. You know, I’ve, uh, I’ve gotten my mom now at 76, um, you know, into DeFi, and she’s got some ETH and a MetaMask wallet. I got my 17-year-old daughter, who was on the show a few weeks ago and talked to her about this concept, and got her on a wallet.

1:17:33 I’ve got two sons, four and five years old, so they’re getting close, I think, to getting those and having those assets. But our doorman here in the building, I just sent him some ETH last night, because I think when people actually see it and play with it, they can start to see the use, and then when they tap that into a game, and, and, and start connecting the dots, I think it’s the best way to move people forward. Um, I’ve got to ask you a question. I, you were quoted by saying, in essence, the companies we invest in must be open to openness, and, and yet you’re talking about this new future where everything’s open.

1:18:03 I was, when Stani was here, I said standing, what’s the future? And he said, my job is to make good code, because if my code’s not good enough, then nobody’s going to use it, and my platform’s dead. It’s this weird shift in thinking from 2.0 to 3.0. And yet, you know, you and I are about the same age. You know, we grew up in a society where you know everything in our DNA is around capitalism and equity holders controlling it.

1:18:25 How do we make this brain shift to this kind of open world? And again, it’s very hard, I think, for people to do in general, right, but also capitalists to do. How do we make that shift? It feels like you’ve done it, but it seems like the people you talk to that invest in your companies are, you know, almost by definition stuck in a 2.0 world? Well, I mean, I think, you know, it’s a great question, because it’s, it somewhat touches upon the value systems of individuals as well, right?

1:18:53 You know, when you think about, sort of, you know, you know, you know, what is socialism, what is capitalism, what’s in between, right? Or are we in an age of social capitalism, you know, where do we sit, right? And I think, I think, uh, this is the part where maybe, you know, for me it’s at least personally, the way I grew up, I think, definitely influenced the way I think about the world, as I think it’s true for everyone, right? And, you know, I grew up in Austria, which is frankly quite a socialist country, right, during you know, really the era of the Cold War, which is in the 70s and the 80s, right?

1:19:23 You know, Vienna had the United Nations, you know, was frankly really right at that border where frankly it probably ought to have been an Eastern Bloc country, but somehow wasn’t, right? So all sort of covered in between, and the dialogue that we were exposed to as children, you know, was very much around, you know, Cold War, you know, freedom, capitalism versus communism, hyper-socialism, whatever. But yet in Europe we didn’t have the same narrative as maybe some people had in America, for instance, because, you know, it was the socialists who were in power as well, who were sort of talking about sort of a socialist version that was, you know, obviously, you know, not communist, but had elements of capitalism built in there, and we’re thinking really about sort of constructing sort of an equitable framework.

1:20:08 Right? And I think Germany is perhaps a great example of something that survived, that where you know, you have rent controls, which, certainly in a very capitalist environment, you would say, why should I have rent controls? That is against my property rights. I should be able to charge anything I want. Right?

1:20:21 On the other hand, rent controls provides for a happier, broader society, because the foundation was less based on equality but more based on equity, around this idea that well, we have to create a little bit of a level playing field, otherwise we’re going to sort of disrupt society, and whatever. And, and so I think this is basically, you know, what, what, uh, when we think about the future I think it’s the same thing, but with one difference: we can choose to be where we like to be, because of the construct of, in with, in which the tokens are designed. So I don’t consider, for instance, you know, Bitcoin to be a very equitable system at all, because if you’re early, great, but if you’re not, you pay the price.

1:20:59 It’s as simple as that, right? So to me it’s perhaps the most fair economic system out there, entirely based on equality, but there’s nothing equitable about it, because an actual equitable system would probably think around, well, if you came late to the party, no problem, let me figure out a way where you can kind of get in and still be included, because we’re all a happy family, blah, blah, blah. Right? And you know, there’s a group of people who really believe that, right?

1:21:22 And the kind of people who also believe in affirmative action, and they’re not going to talk about whether it’s good or bad, but there’s a reason and thought behind these policies, to create a more equitable and inclusive society, but there’s also an argument to be made for, well, you know, why should I be paying for this, you know, on top of that? You know, it is my money. It is what I earned, you know, and I was here first. Why should I be surrendering, you know, your value on something that I understood better than anyone else, right?

1:21:48 Which is, you know, perhaps, you know, sort of an uber kind of capitalism, which, by the way, is practiced in Hong Kong. Like Hong Kong is extremely capitalist, right? Um, and I think they both have their pros and cons. And as a, and in the metaverse, you can choose to be where you want to be. If it’s not the kind of world I want to be, then I can actually migrate from one system to another, because I know no longer, sort of, um, sort of walled in by the physical borders.

1:22:14 Right, before I couldn’t immigrate because I needed a visa. You know, I would lose my assets if I went across, because I can’t bring my property across. So it was hard for me to do that, but in the digital world I can actually go wherever I want to be, and what I think is powerful about that is that it forces a rebalancing of all economies, because the customer, or your citizen, as it were, can actually easily move to someplace else that he might like better in a world where you have true mobility, right?

1:22:43 Like really effortless mobility. It is incumbent upon the metaverse to make it attractive for you to stay there in a sustainable manner, rather than construct borders and walls to prevent you from leaving, which is how people lock value. So I think this, to me, you know, I don’t know what that system will look like, because we’re still in the early stages of figuring it out, but I think this rebalancing means that we have a way in which societies in the metaverses will be built in such a manner, or they will have to look out for that, whether it’s a bit more equity or a bit more quality or whatever, whatever that may be, right?

1:23:16 If you don’t have the borders, you don’t have the militaries, then you ultimately have to serve the customers, which are the citizens, right? And create a new reality. And maybe I want to go live on a commune for a year, um, and maybe I’ll go to that metaverse, right? And share everything, and then maybe that will get old, and I want to go back to the capitalist metaverse. And so that, those, hopefully, will be options that are provided for us.

1:23:37 Yes, and I think it’s happening already today. I mean, if you look at chains, for instance, different chains have different consensus mechanisms. These consensus mechanisms are really a value system, right? Is it proof of work, is it proof of stake, is it proof of authority, right? These are all actually a form of consensus.

1:23:53 There’s a two-thirds majority, is it 51, is it, you know, whatever, right? These are all, and we’re experimenting with this. There’s no clear answer, just how democracy isn’t exactly clean either, right? You don’t have, you know, the democracy that has been practiced in the U.S. versus what’s happening in Europe, or to certain European places, are, you know, actually quite different. Um, and yet they still function and work in their own particular ways.

1:24:16 You’re our first guest from Hong Kong, uh, since we launched DeFi Academy, and you said before people in Hong Kong are chaotic, enterprising, and messy. If you want to have innovation, be a disruptive entrepreneur in an established framework, Hong Kong is great. Can you tell me why you moved to Hong Kong, why you stayed there, and how the city maybe is how woven into your culture and the proximity to China? Is it a plus or minus? So, I mean, in my case, I guess you could say that, although it’s not technically the definition, I guess I was always a quasi-third-culture kid, if you will, because, you know, I grew up as a, you know, a Chinese, ethnically, but I speak fluent German.

1:24:53 I grew up in Austria, right? And I can tell you, in the 70s and 80s there were very few Asian, little Chinese people, right, in all of Austria, for that matter, right? Um, and, and then, you know, afterwards, you know, working, and then I went to the US, and frankly that was my first culture shock, because I saw so many Chinese people in Chinatown in Boston. I was like, oh my goodness, all these Chinese people. Right?

1:25:14 To me that was actually more, the sort of, that was more sort of a, sort of a dislocation of experience than actually, sort of going there, because, you know, I had not witnessed that before, right? Um, and then obviously landing in Japan, and then, and then Taiwan, and then Hong Kong, right? So I think those experiences shaped you somehow, right? And what I, what is what I do appreciate about Hong Kong, despite the fact that, like all places, it was probably difficult to work there, um, you know, and it was a place that when I came to Hong Kong was a colony, right?

1:25:42 All, you know, and actually it was just really introducing the parliamentary system that’s known as Legco, you know. When I got there, it wasn’t something that was well established at all. You know, it was, in fact, you know, although I didn’t experience this myself, it was only a few decades ago that actually there was segregation in Hong Kong, right? When I got there. So, so you know, we’re talking about a society that had a legacy of a history that I had studied but obviously hadn’t witnessed that before, and experiencing that from the perspective of an English-speaking foreigner, in a sense, but essentially looking and sort of being very much like a local, right?

1:26:18 Um, it was, it was an interesting sort of way to sort of live both worlds, the kind of traveling sort of, you know, two cultures, you know, or multiple cultures, in sort of one, one sort of, um, in one place. So Hong Kong was that, right? And, and there were some interesting things around Hong Kong as you evolve and see what’s happened, you know, from the 90s to the 2000s to where it is today. It’s that melting pot. It’s the place where English is the official legal language, and yet we’re all Chinese, right?

1:26:43 You know, it’s, it’s a place where you have, you know, people from all over the world, you know, German, French, English, British, Canadian, whatever, right? All mixed up, and yet still it is technically a Chinese territory. Right? There’s very few countries in the world that can say the same thing, that are also very much mixed up, because we don’t have an Italytown, or we don’t have a sort of Irish town, or something like that in Hong Kong. They’re all kind of together in a way, you know, whereas in the, in the US you have these, still these interesting segregations, although it isn’t very much mixed, but you have these cultural segregations of, you know, you know, Chinatown or Japantown, which, which was kind of alien to me at the time, but I’ve come to appreciate that as well.

1:27:25 So this is kind of where Hong Kong is. Right? And Hong Kong is also very dynamic because of the fact that it is hyper-capitalist, which has its pros and cons, but certainly on the pros, it means that there is access to capital, and it also means that when there is money to be made, there’s a lot of activity that can help sort of do that. And because Hong Kong is really an island, really, I mean, Kowloon is technically in connected, but, you know, it doesn’t have agriculture.

1:27:49 It does this. You can’t build a business that only serves Hong Kong. You’re forced to build a business that is global from the outside. And of course, you know, in recent times, you know, also very much China-focused, but definitely in the past Hong Kong was very much a center for at least pan-Asian, if not global activity, and the biggest companies that emerged from Hong Kong were all the ones that had a global lens or pan-Asian lens, but which also meant that the kind of people that it attracted was like that, and you know, it wasn’t necessarily in technology, but it was in trade and commerce and logistics and finance.

1:28:21 Right? And so Hong Kong is, you know, I would say one of the global capitals of the world, right? You know, along the lines of New York or London. You know, those kinds of places. I think Hong Kong is up there, you know, with them, because of that, and that’s actually where you have this sort of meeting of interesting people and diversity and thought, where you can then create sort of you know, new ideas and sort of that melting-pot effect that you can see in places like Silicon Valley or in New York or London as well, because, because you have people from all over the world coming together, sharing their sort of diverse, diverse perspectives.

1:28:56 Now, to your question on China, I think, I think Hong Kong serves an incredibly important role here, while obviously, you know, with the geopolitics in mind, it is going through some difficult times, clearly, as frankly the world is. I think Hong Kong’s role remains as the bridge of the world to China, as China, you know, when Hong Kong emerged, actually China wasn’t yet as influential as it was. Right? Um, in fact, you could argue that China depended a lot on what Hong Kong could offer it, from a sort of export and financing capability, and all that stuff.

1:29:25 Of course, this has changed today, but I think Hong Kong’s role is really the bridge of the world, to continue to have active and positive dialogue with China, and this is, you know, important because China is, you know, obviously the other emerging superpower. Right? And in that scenario, you need a place where people can actually meet safely and have a conversation around where that goes. I actually think Hong Kong is more ideal that way, because still English is the primary language of Hong Kong, for instance.

1:29:53 The legal language is English, while also you have Mandarin, and you have Cantonese, and other forms of here, you know. You can’t have this dialogue in San Francisco in the same way that you can’t have this dialogue in Shanghai, right? That, that, that bilateralism can’t exist in those territories directly, but they can exist in this sort of you know, quasi-a, sort of, uh, independent territory of Hong Kong. So that’s where I think this will go, and the multi-layering of culture is why I think it’s important, because, you know, I think I said this in another, in another event, but you know, we may not disagree with our world views and our politics, but we can still love the culture of each other.

1:30:33 Chinese food is still the most popular food, you know, probably in many cultures, at least certainly in the top three, whether it’s in the U.K., whether it’s in the U.S., right? In the same way that people love burgers and steaks in China, right? And we also enjoy movies and visuals and art. You know, people watch kung fu movies in the West, and people watch Western movies, and then, like, Marvel Cinematic and everything, and everything that stands for in China, right?

1:30:58 So we can still interact with each other in the context of culture and in context of understanding each better, while we may still disagree maybe even fundamentally on other things, and I think this is important, because if we stop doing that, then actually we’re going to end up in a pretty dark place in the future. Yeah, that’s a great, great way of bridging those two cultures. I just thought of the movie Enter the Dragon, you know, one of the classic Bruce Lee movies, and that was actually a cultural collaboration, because you had a Hollywood studio making a movie in Hong Kong, and I’m sure they had, uh, Chinese cinematographers, because you had the crash zooms and all the great stuff from, you know, Chinese kung fu cinema mixed with the production quality and script at the time of, like, the Hollywood and ended up becoming, you know, one of the greatest films of all time.

1:31:44 Uh, and, uh, it’s what I think of when I think of Hong Kong. I think it’s, I think it was the world’s first introduction. Right? Yeah, I think it’s great, and I think it’s interesting, right? Because that’s why, you know, we think of non-fungible tokens, just to bring it back to NFTs, is actually the mashup of those cultures can happen now on these assets, because people can layer experiences on top of it.

1:32:04 You know, my, one of my sort of favorite examples in the world of food is fortune cookies. It’s not Chinese at all. Bring a fortune cookie to anyone in China to look at it and say, what is this? I have no idea. It doesn’t even taste good, right?

1:32:15 But, uh, but it is the introduction, perhaps even the iconic symbol of Chinese food, certainly in America, and, uh, and that is sort of a mash-up again of, you know, cultures and sort of bridges, bridging that, and that’s really what this is: composing on top of other people’s ideas and creating something new that sort of bridges maybe a new culture but is connected to another culture. Yeah, and now that I think about it, even Bruce Lee embodied that himself. I mean, he, you know, took all that history and culture and martial arts background, moved to Los Angeles, and ended up creating his own martial art by taking the best from boxing and all these other arts, and, you know, maybe that was one of the original NFTs somehow.

1:32:56 Uh, there’s lots of parallels. Um, yeah, what are steps that people can take right now, now that they’ve hopefully had their minds blown by all this stuff, to kind of move forward into the metaverse? You’ve once said, quote, start by buying your first NFT, not with the intention to make money for you, but with simply a desire to learn from it. I’m actually getting my students to do the same thing right now in my Academy. They go to OpenSea, which I know you’re a shareholder of, and I get them to even buy an NFT that’s out there for free, just so they can understand the experience and start that journey.

1:33:26 What do you recommend people doing from that perspective, and from a gaming perspective, how can they start on The Sandbox, for example? Yeah. So, you know, and I think it’s also a cost issue, right? Because you don’t necessarily know The Sandbox is great, and I would have always encouraged anyone to try that out, but it is Ethereum based, which also, and, and you know, a first part of land will cost you at least three, four, five thousand US, so it’s not for everyone right?

1:33:49 Because it’s like literally buying real estate. Um, but you can experience and go to the Discord and learn and talk to the communities, and I think the very first thing I would say to people is, join the communities first before you even buy an NFT, right? Because they all sit mostly in Discord, some of them Telegram, but just go there and interact with them, and you’ll find that they’re very welcoming, and they, they want to work with you, and they make suggestions, and that’s how you learn.

1:34:12 You kind of join the community first, right? You know, it’s, and it’s, it’s no different than you know, you know, entering a new country and you want to buy your first home. You’re not going to just go crash land and say, that’s the first apartment, let’s go buy that, right? For some of us we might have that privilege, but for the most part we have to be very sort of centered around what you can afford. So what you do is you, you meet the locals, right?

1:34:34 You go talk to them. You maybe talk to an agent. You understand what’s valuable, what’s not. You go through a process of research, you know, when you want to buy real estate anywhere around the world, you know, and, and how do you do that? Well, in the digital context you go to the Discord channel, you engage with the community, and you say, hey, I’m new here, I’ll learn about this, I’m interested in buying these NFTs, and I guarantee you, you will have a flood of people messaging you, either privately or publicly, and saying, here’s what you should do, blah, blah, blah, all that kind of stuff, because they want you here, right?

1:35:03 We’re at that point where everyone is very, very welcoming, because they want you to be part of that community, and you’ll learn about that, and that is the research that will come to you, or you can then make a decision to say, you know what, I want to buy this, I want to do this, or maybe, you know, just like how we have it in the physical world, we might just buy the NFT because we want to show we’re part of the membership. We’re like, hey, I love this community, you know what, let me just buy that, because I want to show that I’m a part of it, and I want to continue to be a part of that, right? But that feeling can only happen when you’re there.

1:35:32 If you’re not actually there and experiencing it, then you would just think of it as buying something hollow. Right, right. You know, like, and that’s, that’s, that’s that’s the problem, you know, when you just do it, um, and you’re not knowing why. Right? So I would definitely recommend people to start off that way, and again, not with the intention of making money, but really with the intention of learning but also taking it as serious as you would buy a property or a car.

1:35:58 Okay, really good advice. Last couple of questions. 10 years from now, we fast forward, it’s 2031. What are you doing? What is your daily life like, and what has the world changed into?

1:36:09 You must be thinking about this, you know? Tell me both, because you don’t seem to be losing any speed with what you’re doing over there. Um, do you ever think about that, and what do you think it will be? So, while I have a vision of where I think the world will go, I don’t know that I’m working at it in terms of this is where it goes five or ten years, because really the future changes literally week by week at the pace of, way, way, things are going. But, you know, in general I would say my hope is that there will be this complete open metaverse, where even the largest of companies, just like with open source, are now participating in the open universe, allowing for this transaction and trade of devices basically built on some form of blockchain.

1:36:53 I think there’ll be many different blockchains around, but they’ll be interoperable with each other, and essentially we have sort of this asset validation that happens across, and you can really sort of have this freedom of movement and freedom of trade of these assets, and we, as a society, will be paid for our digital activities you know, through our time and through our data, and I think, I think in 10 years from now this concept of universal basic equity, I think, is going to be much more commonplace. It may not be called universal basic equity, but it’ll be the same concept, because essentially we get paid for our activity in clear terms for the value we provide by adding to that network effect, which then means that we will have a society as well that will have generally more broader equities.

1:37:36 I think it is the framework to me, or there will be more equity in the world, because we all have the ability to engage in that in capacity, because the, the constructs of scarcity are no longer restricted with physical limitations, right? And that’s the, that’s the part where people sometimes also struggle with this. Well, if it’s not actually scarce, right, then you know why is it valuable, for instance, right? But the scarcity comes from you because it’s your mind, it’s your creativity, and it’s actually scarce because, you know, you’re not going to live forever, so whatever you’re thinking of will have a finite date, sadly, right?

1:38:08 And that makes it truly precious, and what makes it precious is whether you choose to work, or whether you choose to spend it with your family, or whether you choose to build a new business. That is how you choose to spend your time, and that is what’s really scarce, and that is the basis of where I think the world hopefully will go to. And for ourselves, you know, I mean, I don’t know, right? But generally, if it’s 10 years from now, I can, I actually think I’ll be continuously still kind of doing what I’m doing, maybe in different ways, but still actively building, you know, the open, open metaverse and engaging in it, uh, because I think ten years from now there’s going to be new challenges that will emerge that will be also coming there, and I think if we do it right, we will continue to be meaningful players in the space, to try to help shape it, so we have a role to play, but not as one that owns a space, but just simply one that is an influential voice, as everyone else has a sort of, a sort of, um, an interest in its success, because we own a stake but we don’t control it, and I think that’s kind of where I would like it to go for, you know, all the major players in the digital world.

1:39:10 I see digital equity as that way of delivering property rights to all, right, and actually as a way where we can actually sort of really, oh, sort of, then have our digital, oh, by holding our digital data, we have our digital, we basically own our digital life, which basically means we actually have real freedom to do what we like to do, which is really, you know, in the end of the day what we can all hope for. And in that idea, you know, that’s the idea of America, right? I mean, you know, when I was in, when I grew up in Austria, um, I didn’t know what America was like at all, and actually visiting America, I actually visited there.

1:39:47 I came there, actually, in the early 90s, and my first place was, you know, actually in Worcester, Massachusetts, which was not a great place at the time, right? Because of the height of recession and everything. It was completely not what I imagined America to be like, because America was just recovering, or just coming out of, you know, a pretty bad time, but the idea of America was all-powerful, right? This idea that you, you could build a better life, or that that you had, sort of, you know, equality, freedom for all, you know, right, human rights, all these things that, sort of, you know, America stood for.

1:40:21 That is, that was the powerful thing, and I think to me the open metaverse represents the same thing, which is we’re never going to get there exactly that way, right? Utopia, or the best environment that we can think of, is something to strive for, but in that sort of attempt at perfection, we will continue to chip away at making it better, right? And so what we need to do is make people understand how that better future could be like, and therefore we all want to go there and sort of influence the world that way.

1:40:49 So I think this is where we’re going to be 10 years from now. You know, we’re not going to be at the end point. I don’t think we’ll ever be at the end point, but we’re going to continuously evolve there and go in the right direction, I would hope. Do you think this is one of the most important inflection points in humanity, whether we can go one way or the other, when it comes to the future of our species, by owning our own digital property rights? Is it that important?

1:41:12 I think it’s absolutely important. I think it is, you know, perhaps the most important paradigm that we need to understand. I think we have a duty to tell all of our children and everyone in the world that you must own your digital property, because if you don’t, you will get left out, and if you get left out, in due course, in time, what will happen is that just because of the economics involved and everything, you will, you will no longer be able to participate in that, or you’ll be left behind as well.

1:41:40 You know, this is the problem about digital divide. This is the problem about, you know, access of information, right? It’s all this, it’s the same thing. We have an opportunity to actually push everyone roughly at the same time. I mean, of course it’s not exactly the way that it’s going to work, but, you know, this type of thing is, I think, really, really important, because data is the most valuable resource, and in the future, it’s already here anyway.

1:42:03 You know, labor is not valuable at all, right? And so you need to own your stuff, and where are we going to go when everything is produced for you anyway? It must be, you know, that you own property, you must own equity. And it’s not going to be physical equity, it’s going to be the meta equity, the virtual equity, and you must own that, and, and I think, I think this is so important, it is so fundamental, because this is also the way in which we have stability.

1:42:29 You look at governments today, the kind of governments that have high land ownership as a ratio, and that have generally sort of a ratio of property rights that is sort of abundant, I would say, as a percentage distributed through our population, tend to be very stable, right? Because everyone has a stake in that. We can, but the ones that don’t, or basically land ownership is distributed really by a small ratio, tend to be quite unstable, right? And that’s simply and the same will be true in virtual equity.

1:42:57 It’s no different, right? Because at the end of the day you’ll end up working for the minority, and that will always cause unrest. Yeah, I love this concept of universal basic equity, not universal basic income. And I agree with you, this is still probably the most important fight of humanity, and it’s not a foregone conclusion that we’re going to win, right? And that’s another important point, and so the next few years are going to be crucial, and um, it’s very exciting to be alive in this space right now.

1:43:27 I tell all my students and the people that will watch this show, that I know you’ve probably heard it before over the last couple thousand years, but this is probably one of the most exciting times to be alive, with so many important things happening, and so many demands that we make the right decisions. Um, and I’m sure you feel it. I mean, this is an incredible space to be in. Yeah, I feel I feel quite blessed that, you know, we’re in a position that we can help shape the space, right?

1:43:51 I don’t, I think not, you know, not many people haven’t have a chance to be really at the center of this, and I think we’re very fortunate that we can, and I think that for us this is something that, um, is meaningful to us, and that’s the reason we’re in such a rush. You, you see us in the news like almost every week with one deal or two deals or something we’re doing. You know, we’re doing this because we want to make sure that the open metaverse is constructed as quickly as possible, right?

1:44:16 And we can’t do it ourselves, which is why we’re funding people and supporting them to do that and bringing in capital to do that because we need as many people there, right? It’s like democracies don’t function, you know, just because you have 100 participation right? You don’t need that, but you need at least sufficient participation for democracy to actually sort of work, to have an interest in the commons, and that’s what we need to do, but we only have a single-digit percentile of the world that understands digital equity, that understands actually what owning, sort of, digital property rights really means.

1:44:48 So the work is cut out. We need to get to 30 or 40, right, which basically means billions of people, and that’s why NFTs are so important in gaming. NFTs, because we think gamers already have a relationship with their virtual goods as one of ownership, even though they don’t own it, and so if we can succeed with that, and why we’re so focused on this is that we can just go to someone who’s already halfway there and just move them over. That’s why gaming and NFTs is so powerful.

1:45:13 Uh, we think yeah, and again I want to thank you, because you’re the first person that’s finally put all these pieces together here on London Real, and I’ve been searching for, you know, yet, to be honest, for the past six months. Um, because for me it was the gaming, was the, the other guys, it was the kids, it was these sports guys, and that I couldn’t understand how it was part of me, but now I believe you’ve really put it all together, to where I think you’ve made it really easy for people to understand. And, um, again, we’ve been broadcasting for 10 years, but the last six months has been all into DeFi, crypto, and blockchain space, and we plan on doing it for the next 10 years.

1:45:46 You know, yeah, I get asked all the time why are you guys doing this, but our mission has always been about democratizing information, and try to put ideas out there that will help everyone benefit, and I just see this is one of those things, so for us it’s just a continuation on that mission, and yeah, I just wanted to say thank you. I appreciate everything you’re doing over there, the energy you bring to it, and I would just say to anybody listening here, remember we are a small percentage, like you said, it’s single digits, as far as people that even own crypto, and let alone even understand the ramifications of that and the potentials of the metaverse, and yet you’ve got, you know, Facebook there with our announcement last week, which, for all the bad there, it’s also a massive endorsement that we’re all going in the right direction.

1:46:26 Right? If that massive of a company and that really smart guy is putting all of their focus there. Um, I had a guest on the other day that said Ethereum was the greatest thing that ever happened to Bitcoin, and all the maximalists turned over, you know, rolled over and were squirming, but it was a good point because it was amazing PR for that asset, and I would say maybe that announcement by Zuckerberg is a great thing to push everyone’s focus on this open metaverse.

1:46:49 Absolutely. Um, I think it gives people this question mark of, well, what is the metaverse really, and at least the discourse and dialogue is now happening, and I think the important thing now is to make noise and explain to people, you know, what a metaverse really ought to be, and why it shouldn’t be centralized, for instance. And that’s the you know, and people are talking about that, and I think the one thing that does serve us really is that as smart as a man Zuckerberg is, and obviously as great an organization that, you know, Facebook has built, which is amazing, um, they have abused their trust, whether this was intentional or not.

1:47:23 You know, people don’t trust Facebook, so I think most people will say, you know, I’m not sure I want to live in a, in a in a Facebook type of metaverse, and I think this is the, the, also the opportunity, because they have endorsed it but they are not necessarily the face for it, because people don’t trust them. But that is where our work has to come in, and those of all of our friends, because we need to also demonstrate why our version is better, why we need to be there, and it’s not a foregone conclusion, as you said, because by building open, we have to be more complicated, you know, we got to deal with DeFi wallets, you got to deal with all these things that are decentralized, that are somewhat unfriendly. You know, and you look at the Philippines with Axie.

1:48:04 More people have crypto wallets than a credit card in rural Philippines, so it’s a clear demonstration that, uh, when you have the right framework for it, actually the complexity of DeFi is not an issue, because it’s still easier to open a crypto wallet than opening a bank account, right? So it’s not actually that difficult. It’s just that we become accustomed and a little lazy, that everything online should really just be a click of a button, but that’s a mistake, because that’s like, you know, saying, well, we take our democracy for granted, let’s not bother voting because it should be working.

1:48:34 All right, but we don’t, for all the right reasons, and I think it’s the same here. You know, our role is not only to make it convenient and easy for people to get there. I think if we make it too easy, too convenient, then we don’t understand the mechanics, and we lose actually the aspect of, you know, the decentralized nature and why that’s important. Otherwise, you know, convenience comes at the cost of centralization and that means, you know, you’re surrendering your assets.

1:49:01 You need to understand what you’re doing, and I think this is this is really important. So the education for us is consequently harder, because we’re trying to get people into a decentralized space. We have more steps to do there, but, you know, once you’re in there, you don’t want to leave. Yeah, that’s a great parallel and a great point you just made there. Part of what, what I do in my DeFi Academy is get people to set up their first hot wallets and cold wallets and deal with centralized exchanges, and then I push them onto Uniswap, and they do a DEX and a liquidity pool trade, and it starts to get a little scary in there, because it’s not this beautiful, customized, centralized user experience, but they get through it, and once they’re through it, they realize, well, this isn’t as strange, as scary as I thought it was.

1:49:42 The narrative I’ve been told my whole life, that I’m not smart enough to manage my own money or understand my own money, is wrong, and, um, that I can take ownership now of my finances, like I’ve taken ownership over my health and my mindset over the past 10 or 20 years. And so that’s a really good point that you make, so thanks for that. Yeah, is that it’s not supposed to be easy. It should be a little bit challenging, and that also comes with it, real ownership rights and also real knowledge and experience with these assets that you get to control, and no one else does.

1:50:10 So yeah, thank you for that reminder. Um, I’ve got a lot of students that kick and scream on the way, but, um, but they’re all getting there. And I love this comparison with, with Facebook. Again, they say absolute power corrupts absolutely, and so you get a network like that, it does have some of those PR issues that we should question, just like people question central banks when it comes to currencies, and look at those through the lens of, you know, Bitcoin and Ethereum, ultimately the blockchain and open source.

1:50:36 And I’m going to go a little deep here to finish off. It requires us to be the best versions of ourselves every day, doesn’t it? We have to be transparent. The tribe gets to see us and see if we’re showing up every day and pulling our weight, and that is how we ultimately, I think, create a better community, but that makes it hard, like you said, right? You’ve got to show up every day.

1:50:54 You’ve got to innovate, you got to prove. You’ve got to be transparent. Um, but maybe it’s how we get to be the best version of ourselves. So those are my thoughts. Yet, um, appreciate you being here.

1:51:05 Uh, I think you need to have more of these philosophical discussions, because I think somehow with the space you’re in, you might understand all of this space better than anyone else. I really do think that. Um, from being in that, in that foot in the gaming universe, I think you’re seeing what’s happening before the DeFi world does, and some of the other Fi worlds here. So I think we can learn a lot from your experiences. So yeah, I really appreciate what you guys are doing.

1:51:30 Follow Animoca Brands because you guys do have a press release every week, which is, it’s almost hard to believe. Um, you know, something came out yesterday, last couple days, on Sandbox, and I was like, wait a second, I’m pretty sure that’s the same company that also just did the big race for themselves, and you guys are doing big things, and it is an important, you know, land grab, pardon the pun, but you really do want to make sure we open up this metaverse going forward. So thank you so much.

1:51:55 Um, if people want to follow you or learn much, uh, more about you guys, what’s the best way to do it? Well, you can follow Animoca Brands on Twitter, um, or you can follow, you know, my, my Twitter account is ysiu. Um, you know, I, I post quite regularly there as well, you know, my thoughts more so on Twitter than say on Medium and so on, just because I guess this is where a lot of the sort of sort of, you know, NFT guys hang out as well. Um, so that’s probably the best way, but, yeah, on our website you can also sign up on a mailing list, and, uh, no, thank you very much for, for, for this opportunity to explain what we’re about and why we think it’s important, and I think the work you do is equally important, because it’s disseminating that information, broadcasting it to the world and telling everyone why, why this is so critical.

1:52:40 Yeah, thank you. So it’s been our pleasure, and again, we’ve really been welcomed in by this whole community, uh, with open arms, and it’s, it’s been fantastic, and the energy here is amazing, and yeah, I think they saw, art history, we just said our 10-year anniversary last week, and, um, we’ve just been, you know, putting out information, and, you know, uh, fought pretty hard for freedom of speech last year against some of the big platforms, and I even ran to be Mayor of London here, and so I got to see what politics is like too, which could really use some help from the blockchain at some point. And so, um, it’s been a great journey.

1:53:11 We feel like we’re in the right place with the right eyeballs. So again, thank you so much, appreciate what you do. Please come see us in the studio next time you’re in London, and, uh, wishing you guys all the best, you’re doing incredible work, and thank you so much. Thank you. All right, folks, there he is.

1:53:26 Follow this man, follow Animoca, doing incredible things. We’ll see you next time on London Real. Take care, bye.

London Real logo Chat
×

Private call with Brian Rose

See how the AI Investment Club works, and decide for yourself

Every Monday, AI founders pitch live to our members. Book a call to see if it's right for you.

Check Brian’s availability
Brian video thumbnail
Private call with Brian Rose
Watch Brian’s message