Home > Episodes > Andrew Bustamante > Andrew Bustamante - CIA Super Spy: The Truth About Government Lies, Surveillance & UFOs
[captions_button]

Andrew Bustamante - CIA Super Spy: The Truth About Government Lies, Surveillance & UFOs

36,202 views •

Ex-CIA Covert Intel Officer & Founder of EverydaySpy

“Asking questions puts you in control.”

In short: Andrew Bustamante is a former US Air Force combat veteran and CIA intelligence officer, author and speaker, and host of the Everyday Espionage podcast. He joined Brian Rose in the London Real studio in November 2022 to talk about geopolitics, the war in Ukraine, China and Taiwan, how CIA officers recruit sources, and how digital privacy really works.

Andrew began with the World Cup in Qatar and moved to the war in Ukraine, which he described from a geopolitical point of view as a long, slow conflict of attrition. Throughout, he is giving his own analysis, which listeners may or may not agree with.

The second half of the conversation turned to tradecraft. Andrew explained his model of the three lives (public, private and secret), how an officer builds trust over roughly 30 hours of contact, and why he thinks the same techniques apply to managers, salespeople and parents.

Key takeaways

  • Geopolitics is politics plus geography. Andrew defined it as the relationship between nation states shaped by both their political aims and where they sit on the map, and used Taiwan and China as his example.
  • He expects a long war in Ukraine. He argued Russia is built for wars of attrition and that Western attention will fade, and put the odds of a large explosion or low-yield nuclear device from a non-Russian source at about 30% within a year.
  • Putin wants to be underestimated. In Andrew’s view this is basic spycraft: people who underestimate you decide on flawed information.
  • He sees China as a patient, long-term competitor. He pointed to its long planning horizon, control of rare earth supply chains and the importance of Taiwan’s semiconductor industry.
  • Everyone lives three lives. Public, private and secret. Andrew said that giving people full attention, rather than competing for it, is how spies move from the public to the private life.
  • Money is rarely the real motive. He said money is a tool that gets people something else, such as status, security or proof to a parent.
  • Metadata matters more than the message. He said even with end-to-end encryption, who you contact, when and where may still be visible to the platform.

World Cup, Ukraine and the Russian view

On the Qatar World Cup, Andrew said the main watch points for intelligence professionals are security and counter-terrorism. On Ukraine he said that Americans barely feel the war, argued that NATO’s approach to Ukraine was a long-running factor and that Russia sees NATO expansion as a threat. He also said Ukraine was not a fully functioning democracy before the invasion, citing a Freedom House score. These are his claims and views.

He predicted a long war of attrition, said Russia is unlikely to launch a nuclear missile at Ukraine or a NATO country, and discussed the risk of a smaller device whose source would be hard to prove. He put the probability of a large conventional blast or low-yield nuclear device from a non-Russian source at about 30% for the following year.

China, Taiwan and the balance of power

Andrew described China as a patient state that can set a 50-year plan, and said Taiwan matters because the island makes roughly 95% of the world’s advanced chips. He predicted China might move on Taiwan around 2024 and doubted that the US would go to war over it. Those are his forecasts.

He also discussed hypersonic missiles and aircraft carriers, the BRICS bloc, and how he thinks China’s economy could pass the United States by 2032. Brian brought in the idea of a future currency contest between the digital yuan and the US dollar.

How CIA tradecraft works

Andrew explained that espionage is the control of decisions: understanding what someone cares about, such as a general’s sick son, and building a human connection before offering a benefit. He argued money is the weakest lever and said sex is risky because relationships create emotion that cannot be handed to another officer.

His three-lives model was the centre of this section. People put most of their effort into the public life, share the private life with close friends and keep a secret life that very few see. By giving someone full attention rather than competing for it, he said, you move from the public to the private life, and he estimated an average person can be reached in about 30 hours of contact.

Life in the CIA, privacy and going off the grid

Andrew said he does not miss the work, though he misses the people, and that having a family changed how he felt about relationships that were not genuine. He described attrition at the agency and said some former officers moved into private intelligence and security.

On technology he said there is no real digital privacy: data is collected for convenience, advertisers, and for government purchase. He said metadata is more revealing than message content, and described how someone could drop off the grid by leaving their devices behind and using cash. He also named the work he does now, including executive coaching and the Everyday Espionage podcast, and pointed people to EverydaySpy.com.

Who is Andrew Bustamante?

Andrew Bustamante is a decorated US Air Force combat veteran and a former CIA intelligence officer. In 2007 he became the youngest US Air Force officer to command 200 nuclear intercontinental ballistic missiles from an underground bunker. He then spent seven years as a covert CIA operative. He now works as a private intelligence consultant, speaker and author, and hosts the Everyday Espionage podcast. He said on the show that his wife is also a former CIA officer.

Frequently asked questions

What is the three lives model Andrew Bustamante describes?

He says everyone has a public life, a private life and a secret life, and that tradecraft is about earning access to the private and secret lives by giving someone full attention.

What does Andrew Bustamante think about Putin?

He argues that Putin wants to be underestimated, calling that basic spy tradecraft, and that Putin's successor could be more hawkish. This is his own analysis.

What is geopolitics according to Andrew Bustamante?

Geopolitics is the relationship between nation states as shaped by both their politics and their geography.

Does Andrew Bustamante say digital privacy exists?

He says no reasonable expectation of full digital privacy exists, and that metadata such as contacts, times and locations is often more revealing than the encrypted message itself.

Where can I find Andrew Bustamante online?

He recommends EverydaySpy.com and the Everyday Espionage podcast, and says Twitter is the best place to reach him.

Chapters

3:05 | Introduction to Andrew Bustamante
4:09 | The World Cup in Qatar
7:16 | Ukraine and Russia through a geopolitical lens
15:45 | What geopolitics actually means
30:07 | Nuclear weapons and escalation risk
39:47 | Who is winning, and what Putin wants you to believe
47:11 | China, Taiwan and the semiconductor question
1:01:21 | China’s rise and the world in 2075
1:10:21 | Money, freedom and control
1:14:18 | Tradecraft: how spies get people to share secrets
1:17:06 | The moral cost of espionage
1:31:20 | The three lives: public, private and secret
1:43:23 | Thirty hours to a secret life
1:47:28 | Sex, romance and intelligence work
1:53:12 | Why questions put you in control
1:57:31 | Life after the CIA
2:01:44 | Why CIA officers left
2:15:17 | Digital privacy and metadata
2:22:17 | How to go off the grid
2:34:05 | What’s next for Andrew

Downloads

Full transcript: Andrew Bustamante on London Real

3:05 This is London Real. I am Brian Rose. My guest today is Andrew Bustamante, the decorated US Air Force combat veteran, former CIA intelligence officer, author, and award-winning speaker. In 2007, you became the youngest US Air Force officer in history to command 200 nuclear intercontinental ballistic missiles from an underground bunker with the highest military security clearance possible. You then spent the next seven years working as a covert operative for the CIA, assuming numerous identities and working undercover to foil terrorist plots and steal foreign secrets. Today, you use the mental, physical, and social spy skills you learned at the CIA as a private intelligence consultant, and you believe that anyone is capable of mastering their mind, leveraging their talents, achieving their potential, and becoming a hero. All it takes is the right training and hard work. Andrew, welcome to London Real. Wow, Brian, that was… You make me sound really cool.

4:09 You are cool. I feel really good about myself right now. It’s like my kids need to hear this. This is a technique the CIA probably uses, right, to lead people, but it’s great to have you here. So much to talk about. I appreciate it. And I don’t really know where to start. I was gonna start off with like top three things happening in the world right now, and I’m sure we’re gonna get into what’s happening now nearby in Ukraine because you’re a bit closer to the situation, what’s going on with China, etc. But I thought I might actually start with the World Cup because the first match starts in a couple days and the whole world’s watching. It’s usually a time when people celebrate and look at this, except for this one’s getting a little more criticism. And from you, from a geopolitical perspective, I’m curious, what do you see going on there, if there is anything going on there, to kind of note of what’s happening? Yeah, you know, it’s really interesting because the World Cup is, it’s in Qatar, correct? And I remember when it was announced to be in Qatar, there was a little bit of a spike in attention because folks were like, how are you gonna host it in the Muslim world? How are you gonna host it in a in a collegiate country, like an oil rich country? There was a lot of questions when it first came out, and it’s really fascinating.

5:16 Football, football as it’s properly known, soccer as it’s known in the United States, is this phenomenon that is so important to most of the world and basically unknown in many ways to the United States, specifically where I’m from. So it’s really hard to have a football conversation with anybody in the United States, and they most definitely don’t realize that the World Cup is happening, it’s happening in Qatar, and it’s a big deal. The things to watch out for, I know some some friends in the private intel world who are specifically focused on the security and the counter-terrorism aspects of hosting something in Qatar. You’ve got Sunni Shia issues with that, you’ve got the world politics issues with that, you’ve got geopolitics because who gets to play, who doesn’t get to play, does Qatar decide, does FIFA decide, do politicians decide? It’s a challenging situation, but at the same time the way I tend to look at any kind of sporting event is that sporting events are designed to be an escape from the noise, right? It’s a chance for us to just put sportsmanship first instead of showmanship, and we should celebrate the athletes. The athletes, they’re not the ones causing conflict, the athletes are out there busting their asses, man, working hard to master complicated techniques, work as a team, represent their country on a world stage, and my hope is that we’ll have an excellent World Cup. The infrastructure looks spectacular because Qatar has gone to great lengths to

6:52 Make it happen, so I’m hoping for positive things. Yeah, it should be interesting to watch. I know it’s been quite controversial and people are saying, you know, did they win it properly and then all the human rights things are under the microscope and there’s a lot of people talking, but I got a funny feeling once the soccer gets going or the football gets going people will check it, but yeah it is a great distraction for the world, but also there’s a lot of political things going on, as with the Olympics, right?

7:16 You want to win because it can take a lot of heat off your country or bring you a lot of prestige as the Olympics can help. I mentioned Ukraine, you’re closer to it now here and I’m wondering what are your views on what’s happening with Ukraine and Russia. You see things from a different, completely different picture than most people see things because you know a lot more what’s going on inside, longer term visions, things from a geopolitical standpoint.

7:41 What do you see when you see what’s going on in Ukraine and what do you think that most people don’t see when they read the headlines and you know hear all the scenarios. The latest thing was World War III was trending on Twitter a couple days ago and I’m in chats with crypto people and they’re talking about the nuclear fallout and where it’s gonna go around the world that’s going to India and you know people are planning for this. What do you make of it? Yeah when I being in being in Europe, being in the UK versus being in the United States and while I am closer now physically it still seems like in many ways the war is still very far from the everyday person’s life. In the United States we really don’t feel the Ukraine conflict at all. The average American does not feel it at all. We have very little reliance on Russia for anything. We are, if anything, our economy is benefiting from Europe’s sanctions against Russia because now that creates a vacuum of resources in Europe and the most logical person for them to turn to for the most logical country for them to turn to for that vacuum of resources is the United States.

8:45 So we have increased supply routes for liquid natural gas. We’ve got increased supply routes for shipping weapons. We’ve got more and more reliable or more and more people depending on us in Europe than we did prior to the 24th of February. So in the United States it’s the war in Ukraine is a very good thing for the United States and I think that’s something that most people are either glazing over or outright ignoring. That there is really nothing but net benefit every day that this conflict lasts for the United States. I love how you just cut through and just say things like this Andrew I hadn’t really thought of it that way you know but like you said it’s so separated I bet most people in America couldn’t point out where it is on a map yeah right and for them it’s so far over there don’t really know what’s going on no dependencies for natural gas no real worries about Russia doing anything no history of Russia ever coming through and causing wreaking havoc. If anything Russia the United States were allies during World War Two and that’s another thing that people are missing. Russia hasn’t changed much. They were the same country that in World War Two fought for the allied powers with one gun for every two soldiers. It was they were heroes at one time in world history the Russians were heroes. They would literally put a guy with a gun and behind him would be a guy with no gun and the guy with no

10:07 Guns job was to pick up the gun when the dude with the gun died. They are very skilled at wars of attrition. They are very patient. They are they are built of a different type of culture when it comes to protracted long-term conflict which is what Ukraine is. People keep thinking that Ukraine was it was it’s in multiple phases it’s when you look at conflict all what’s known as intrastate or interstate excuse me interstate conflict between two sovereign nations interstate conflict is protracted look at what the United States did when it invaded Afghanistan look at what the United States did when it invaded Iraq look what happened when when Russia invaded Georgia look what happened when Russia invades Ukraine right conflicts take a long time the first strategy was kind of a shock and awe strategy it didn’t work it didn’t work not just to the Russians surprise but to NATO surprise in the United States a surprise I’m pretty sure Zelensky was surprised there was a lot of people surprised by Wow we just resisted their assault on Kiev or Kyiv as they want to call it now because it’s the Ukrainian right Ukrainian name of it and why did that happen do we know why did it fail yeah strategically so Putin became very good at a certain model of of conflict it worked in Georgia it worked in Crimea 2008 2014 where he basically corrupted senior officials from inside so then when Russia announced that they were coming in

11:36 Those senior officials would bow immediately right it was an administrative takeover very similar to what China did in Hong Kong in 2019 when the administrators subjugate themselves then nobody else has a say that they didn’t have that network in place in Ukraine so it’s bigger to it bigger than Crimea or Georgia correct it’s much bigger but you also have you have this history of Ukraine’s application process to NATO and and NATO’s relationship with Ukraine whenever whenever people call this an unprovoked war it’s flat-out wrong it isn’t absolutely a provoked war Ukraine has been applying to NATO NATO has been dancing with Ukraine about joining Russia’s been very clear since 2011 that that would be seen as a threat Russia’s been very very clear for a long time that NATO expansion to the east is a non-starter for them and they see it as an existential threat right and they are technically correct that it is right correct they are technically correct that at the beginning of NATO NATO agreed that it would not move further east then what was at the time the Soviet Union but with the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991 now that changed the charter right so now do they treat former Soviet states as Europe or do they treat former Soviet states as the original terms so it took them six years to decide from 91 to 97 was this very confusing time where folks didn’t know like what do we treat a former Soviet state as and then Russia said treat them as for a Soviet and

13:09 NATO said well we might see benefit if we see them as as Europe and then already encroaching because Russia had less power then so Estonia went and Lithuania went and they started moving in a little Romania went yep I mean when right but Ukraine is the breadbasket of Russia it’s geopolitically very very important and besides the NATO application I’m sure some of your former colleagues are out there as well encroaching and doing all sorts of other things from economic means or other means that just make Russia feel insecure correct and you’re exactly right it’s the breadbasket of Russia that Russia as a country does not have the resources that it needs to sustain a first world population it has energy resources but food resources natural resources for for construction for lumber it doesn’t have the natural mineral deposits for gold silver coal you know any of the any of the rare earths that it needs those largely exist in former Soviet states the reason the Soviet Union was functional for so long was because the industrial center was Russia and it went to these Soviet satellite states for natural resources so then the satellite states didn’t have to develop an industrial base they just had to essentially be a source of natural of natural resources so there was a symbiotic relationship that was there until it all fell apart in 91 okay so now you really do have to think about how is Russia gonna survive without it’s

14:30 Not like the United States that has all its natural resources there it’s not like the UK that can that has fantastic resources there it’s not like it’s not like Southeast Asia with fantastic resources right it’s it’s a different it’s mostly frozen tundra right and the aggression was happening with Russia because Ukraine was slowly being moved away from that and moved to the west whether it was NATO approved or not it was moving that way correct and that was the the low-level aggression for the past ten years correct and that there’s a there’s a trigger point there right and especially a trigger point when you think that as as one former Soviet satellite states gains distance from Russia other ones start to follow so you’ve got Azerbaijan and you’ve got Armenia and you’ve got Estonia and you’ve got these other countries that are watching what’s happening and deciding what do we do with that do we move further away do we double down on our reliance with Russia what is it how does it compromise us what do we stand to benefit and that’s not a that’s not a narrative that Russia really feels comfortable with for a long period of time now Finland just joined NATO so it’s a bit of a shock well this is also what’s interesting is that when you look at Finland and Norway technically what they did is they submitted a rapid application but it takes years to be approved so it was very symbolic by virtue of the fact that they that they

15:45 Signed that they applied but it’s been misreported misunderstood they’re not part of NATO they’ve just requested the review for NATO to accept them and they’ve got a massive problem because Turkey has has made it very clear that they don’t have any intentions of accepting either application and Turkey’s kind of a thorn in NATO just like Russia and China are the thorn in the UN so Turkey Turkey becomes a very difficult win for the rest of Europe when it comes to getting NATO to agree on policy and Turkey’s got a solid a strong relationship with Russia they’ve got they’ve got a history of their own internal challenges that that make their incentives quite different than what you would see from Poland or Germany in the UK right this is this concept of geopolitics can you explain to people what geopolitics means yes important yes really taught in schools I don’t think it’s it’s one of those things that makes its way into political science and then the academic definition is different from the operational definition so geopolitics is essentially the the relationship between nation states as it relates to both their political endeavors and their geography because the two play very different roles you might be extremely aligned to another country on the other side of the world geographically that makes it very challenging for for either of you to support each other politically you can support each other

17:11 But geographically you’re kind of alone we’re seeing that especially now with the rise of China because China and the US stand a polar opposite sides of the planet but also polar opposite sides of the political spectrum so when you take a country like Taiwan that sits very closely politically with the United States but very close very close geographically to China geopolitics become a very important thing if you think I mean a Chinese worship can cross out of Southwest China Southeast China and get to Taiwan and it’s 45 minutes right it takes the United States 12 hours to get to Taiwan in a high-speed airplane it’s no-brainer how fast something is gonna fall apart right be in that in geopolitics has to come to bear how do they how they and I want to get to China but I want to finish up the Ukraine yeah we will get there and and also geopolitics from where I understand I used to follow a group called strat for which is out of Texas and they think they kind of changed but I always said that the politics is almost defined by the geography which I think a lot of people don’t think about sometimes like the US tries to export democracy to the world but you might argue that certain geographic reasons will never support democracy and this is my question maybe about Russia Russia is this massive expanse of land all this crazy geographies and resources you know does it need more of a dictatorship to even function is one of

18:34 My questions and and then also in the long run they literally cannot give up Ukraine or they fall so thoughts on both yeah I mean you’re you’re right in a lot of ways the I have my father-in-law who I I will to the day I die I will love to disagree with everything he says because he’s my father-in-law that’s what you do with a father-in-law you just disagree with them carte blanche but I have to agree with him because he has this saying he’s a he’s a former Venezuelan is an American citizen who fled Venezuela and watches his country which was a beautiful country in the 70s and is now a disaster right just in a few decades but he watches Venezuela and he sees what’s happening in the US and he says you know he is a believer that countries have that is the governments they deserve right a country gets the government it deserves because Venezuela fell apart not because of politicians but because of the people who supported those politicians and that’s just what happens so whether it’s democracy or dictatorship or authoritarianism countries eventually gave they get the country they deserve so when you look at a place like Russia especially when you look at look at what the United States learned in Gulf War and won in Gulf War two they learned that democracy was not going to be easy to export to Iraq it was it may not ever take and that with a strong man leader in Iraq at the end of Gulf War one there was benefit to national

19:57 Security interests in the United States and that’s what people don’t people always take for granted because the narrative of protecting democracy is such a nice narrative right people don’t realize that we’re protecting democracy is not what we’re actually doing Ukraine is not a democracy Ukraine was not a democracy prior to February 24th that’s not my opinion that’s studies and research done by the Freedom House empirically gave them a three point eight out of ten score in terms of democracy it was a corrupt poor Russian satellite state trying to decide what it wanted to be next because just like you’re saying Russia is it lends itself towards authoritarianism it doesn’t lend to have a functioning democracy and you have a very educated foundational base of voters you need to have technology and industry in place to be able to positively represent and secure their ability to vote if you don’t have that you can’t have a truly representative democracy so it takes time to develop that right in the United States we had the United States as much as we love to talk about how awesome our democracy is we were founded on the principle of you didn’t get a vote unless you were a white man with property that’s how we that’s the birthplace of our democracy right race and and financial soundness their financial well-being because the idea was and democracy is always founded on the idea that you need to be invested in the success of your country for

21:30 Democracy to work if you’re not fully invested in the success of your country then democracy is bound to fall apart when you’re when you’re so poor you can’t make survival happen like places in in East Asia like places in Russia like places in in in Eastern Europe when you’re so poor that you’re totally ambivalence what happens in government you’re uneducated you don’t understand the things that they’re talking about you don’t have the technology to be able to to track or keep up with what’s happening that’s ignorance that’s the lack of education that’s a lack of resources that’s not the kind of person that can represent a democracy effectively it’s not and that’s what and so in America we’re kind of the do-gooders exporting our perfect system to the world kind of like probably you know the Catholic Church used to do when they went to South America saying we’re just gonna make all these people better like us but we’re not being very realistic about what’s going on or maybe even looking at our own system as well it’s not necessarily the right system for every every place at this point in time right that’s a big thing to say most people in America would have a problem with that yeah most people America do have a problem with that but that doesn’t make it any less true yeah right and you’re right there’s we struggle a lot with especially the United States we struggle a lot with the fact that we don’t live a

22:49 Representative life compared to the other humans in our species around the world we don’t we’re I mean our per capita income is like 400 times what the average poverty-stricken African or Southeast Asian earns like it’s just it’s we are so far removed from real life that we don’t recognize that our American existence is not representative real life and is as I walk through London I see the same thing right we’re so far removed yeah with our designer clothes and with our you know our outstanding public transport law and order when people cross the streets that’s not how the world works right and that’s how first world works right and yet we project everything on that rest of the world we assume they make decisions the same way we do and then we’re confused when these things happen that we don’t understand correct okay and part of that is playing out right now in Ukraine and Russia and so just to get back to it with the Russian people long protracted war I had Bill Browder in that seat a couple weeks ago who had a has had a long battle with I guess Putin he had the Magnitsky Act that he put in place to sanction anybody to win for their money if they were involved in I guess human rights violations and he says that well Putin can’t stop this war because he does he’ll die I mean quite literally also in Russia you don’t see a lot of retired presidents you know you see a few but you know you’re kind of in for life because when you’re not

24:12 President you’re probably not gonna survive very long so again do these all play into the decisions being made here absolutely so one of the things that we that that the world the Western world learned from the global war on terror which let’s not forget that for 20 years we fought a war on terror and didn’t win this happened at 9-11 it started correct and then 11 started in 2021 it kind of ended with that or I guess even in 2022 we still had a disastrous withdrawal from Afghanistan right but when you’re in the CIA I’m guessing most of the your work there was correct based on the war on terror correct what we learned from the war on terror is that the leader is the one that everybody focuses on but is often the one that is the least scary because that person came to be the leader not because they were extremely idealistic or ideologically driven or because they were the most vicious but because they were a unifying force in a panel of people that were much more diverse which means that behind Putin there are many much more scarier hawkish violent wealthy Russians so if if we see a change in power if that actually happens why in the hell does the world think it’s going to be better there logically based on what we’ve seen in the war and the war on terror if we take out Putin or if political pressure takes out Putin it’s going to take someone more ruthless and stronger than Putin to calm the people after that that’s not

25:42 Going to be a good thing for the West that’s not going to be a good thing for Ukraine that’s not going to be a good thing for any any country other than Russia and especially when we think again think through the eyes of a Russian the Russians they don’t think that this is like a political fight over Ukraine they think this is the West trying to eradicate Russia and when you think about it they have grounds to they have grounds to think that way that is absolutely this has gone from being a neo-nazi narrative to one hundred percent you can anybody can see this is a Western war waged against Russia through Ukraine and has that narrative changed it started as neo-nazis in Russia and is it now the West and you know who changed it was Putin right Putin changed it and his his own propagandists changed it like the West has played into that by design you know maybe it was by design I mean the guy’s very skilled former KGB officer right but the point is he couldn’t he couldn’t he couldn’t back up the claims that they were going into Ukraine to purify Ukraine of neo-nazis it was no such a ridiculous claim I hear that still mean you know tatted in the telegram groups in Russia yeah and they still they still try right but that’s a very narrow group of people that that’s why there was not widespread Russian support at the beginning okay but as sanctions are leveraged that hurt everyday people as sanctions are now

27:07 This last week we started seeing that that the UN or that the US was calling on the UN to sanction non-russian countries and non-russian people who are have business dealings supporting the Russian side now now we’re not even targeting Russia now we’re targeting the people who are supporting Russia that’s what does that have to do with Ukraine if you if you stop the flow of food and money and weapons and the development of commerce in Russia all you’re doing is hurting Russia you’re not helping Ukraine unless you land on the conclusion that hurting Russia is helping Ukraine and if that’s the conclusion you land on then who you’re really fighting Russia right so it’s it’s a sad state of affairs because now the narrative has changed in Putin’s favor he can now be honest with his own people before he had to lie to his people now he can be honest with the people and if you were faced in a truly a situation where you were being targeted exclusively because you were American or exclusively because you were British that changes the intimacy of that conflict for you right is the West trying to crush Russia absolutely always have been always have been but they’re but they’re not as relevant as they used to be they’re not developing with technology the resources are dwindling they’re no longer a major global power like they were in the 80s and 90s when you know I grew up right in the eyes of national security in the eyes of the way that the larger geopolitical infrastructure

28:34 Views geopolitics there’s only three what’s known as global power competitors GPC countries also known as near peer countries there’s only three the United States the world’s current superpower China the world’s the world’s projected economic superpower by 2032 and Russia the number two supporter of the number two exporter of weapons and energy around the world it’s those two things it either way and the weapons correct and the fact that the United States sits in North America and South it sits in the Americas yeah China sits in Asia Russia sits in Europe right it’s got incredible reach incredible power incredible history it’s got a lot of a lot of potential to break things and it carried on all the momentum coming out of World War two even now you know we’re seeing Russia a little clearer than we saw it before February 24th we see where its military is degraded we see where its its weapon systems have degraded we see some of the corruption that we’ve always known was happening in Russia but now we see how it actually plays out on the battlefield right I think China is seeing the same thing as they view what’s happening the whole world is watching because there’s something to be learned from watching what happens when Russia tries to invade Ukraine but we’ve also not seen Russia fully mobilized if you recall when the United States went into Afghanistan operation enduring freedom not a war right when

30:07 We went into Iraq right operation Iraqi freedom not a war the UN has gone on since to say that the the US wars in Afghanistan Iraq were illegal wars there has been no legal war since 1947 according to the UN Charter so when narratives say that Russia’s invasion of Ukraine is illegal yes that’s technically true according to the UN Charter but no war has been legal and what punishment has ever happened to any other country for waging an illegal war right I’m all over the place Brian because you’re like you the stuff you’re talking about is so interesting this is so interesting so all right what people really want to know is is there gonna be a tactical nuclear weapon deployed in Ukraine because that’s when everyone pays attention right because that’s when my kids start potentially breathing radioactive material and it becomes very real and dangerous at least that’s what seems to be on people’s minds as something that would be a game-changer yeah because right now like you said most people in the West just don’t care you know they might pretend like they care on Twitter but they just don’t care because it still doesn’t affect them correct so here’s what will not happen you will not see a missile launched out of Russia carrying a nuclear warhead that lands in Ukraine that’s not gonna happen you’re not gonna see Russia launch a nuclear missile that lands in Poland or Germany or France or the United States

31:29 None of those situations are gonna happen those are situations that stand no net benefit for the for Russia is there always a chance of course there’s always a chance of 0.5% chance a 3% chance a 1.2% chance whatever the probabilities are are extremely low because that escalates things to an uncontrollable level and that’s not what Russia wants Russia wants a long slow burn where the rest of the world just slowly turns their attention away from Ukraine and a war of attrition it’s what Russia wants and they just get it back and they just get it back if they don’t even need it back right all they need all they need is the influence all they need is is one or two territories they need Donbass and Luhansk just like they were target in the beginning they need a shadow government in those two places and they need NATO to realize that there’s no benefit going into Ukraine no benefit giving Ukraine NATO status because that’s gonna really piss off the Russians and nuclear weapons are a deterrent right now Russia does not want to go to war with NATO if they make Ukraine part of NATO that changes the that changes the calculation for Russia okay but NATO won’t do that exactly the word the wet missile doesn’t come from Russia but it doesn’t mean one doesn’t get detonate correct that’s exactly right and that’s another thing people don’t realize Russia is unlikely to create a tactical nuke that can be easily tied

32:46 To Russia if it comes in through Moldova if it comes down through Belarus if it comes in a briefcase if it’s a small yield bomb that isn’t clearly nuclear but detonated in a suitcase or underground somewhere in Ukraine as a message what does that do if it unless it can be tied directly to Russia it makes it very difficult for the legal structures of the UN and NATO to take action and again it’s not a NATO country look at what just happened with with the missiles that landed in Poland and killed Polish nationals right away the world jumped on accusing Russia the investigation later showed it was actually Ukrainian anti-air defense weapon it’s also interesting that then Poland didn’t hold Ukraine responsible for the inaccuracy of their own weapon they still blamed Russia because Russia is the ultimate aggressor if if a nuclear weapon goes off Russia already knows they’re gonna get the blame they also know that anybody out there Al Qaeda Isis some transnational threat you know if anybody wants to really make a mess of the world right now they just have to set off a nuclear weapon in Ukraine or even just a big conventional weapon that looks like it could have been a nuclear weapon because the whole world’s gonna collapse and make accusations faster than investigation can be carried out what’s the likelihood that happened in the next year that’s what scares me because the likelihood shifts and it’s shifts and

34:09 In wide shifts week to week a week ago two weeks ago it’s it would seem like that’s the next logical step from Russia’s current campaign of attacking infrastructure right they’re currently in an air campaign blowing up electrical grids and water grids and attacking the infrastructure which again people call illegal but according to UN laws it’s still a gray area it could be can say could be conceivably deemed as legal because Ukraine has broken human rights and mandated that all adult men between 18 and 55 remain in country and and potentially mobilized to fight so have they yeah yeah that’s what they did back in March okay and human rights that’s that is a violation of human rights it’s conscription is it’s yeah because they’re only it’s only for men so it’s immediately discounting women which is not something that the that the UN supports and then it’s targeted towards a specific ethnicity in a specific group Russia Ukraine or Ukraine right so now you’re you’re restricting freedom of movement of Ukrainian males 18 to 55 just because the Ukrainian males that is a violation of human rights okay so but we look past that but my point is two weeks ago I was it’s the next logical step now that Zelensky is willing to talk negotiation like Zelensky signaling that he doesn’t need to see all the same stipulations that he was saying before that that deescalates the conflict which is what the whole world wants to see is a de-escalation of

35:45 Conflict you didn’t give me a number of probability yeah so I would say right now we’re sitting at probably like a 30% probability really in the next year in the next year that you’re gonna see a large conventional explosion or a potential small-yield nuclear weapon that comes from a non-russian source yeah it’s go on and three one in three and what happens with a low-yield nuclear weapon like we don’t know like is there much fallout is there radioactivity no like low-grade nuclear weapons are really what tactical weapons tactical nuclear weapons that become they’re essentially big enough to to wipe out maybe 500 half a square mile or half whatever that is in kilometers is that like Hiroshima or something no no no no no Hiroshima was a large a large yield weapon and it was done above the ground it was a bomb not a missile right okay so so there’s a couple of things to keep in mind with nuclear weapons so thus the altitude at which they’re elevated has a lot to do with the radiation footprint that they make so the most strategic nuclear weapons actually detonate above like it while they’re still in the atmosphere they’ll detonate it at a mile above ground level and then that sends a fireball at its maximum size down to destroy all of life and a shock wave it sucks the air out from the ground and takes it up into the atmosphere and people like suffocate and then it it irradiates the entire ground and then shoots all

37:10 That dust up into the atmosphere so when you want maximum destruction you trigger a nuclear detonation at altitude when you want minimum destruction you actually detonate it at ground level because now at ground level the ground absorbs the smallest footprint of radiation and irradiated energy but the fireball still goes to its full size so you’ll burn everything you’ll still have a shockwave that goes you’ll still have a vacuum of oxygen that goes but you won’t have the same nuclear winter that you would if it was detonated from above so and Russia does not want to see a nuclear winter because predominant airstream will take it into Russia and they don’t necessarily want to get it into Europe because you know you get some very upset angry Germans and you don’t need that correct and then the other thing to keep in mind is the target right that what what would be contrary to the narrative that’s out there Russia’s targeting infrastructure Russia’s targeting military or or debatably military targets they are there when you’ve got a country that basically says that every male 18 to 55 is a potential combatant attacking the energy grid it makes it a viable target Ukraine’s decisions have given Russia the freedom to do the things that the UN and the rest of the world likes to criticize but it’s going to be sticky when this goes to an international court it’s going to be very sticky so the target of a conventional weapon or the target of a low-yield nuclear weapon it makes

38:35 The most sense for it to be Kiev it makes the most sense for it to be wherever they believe the center of government is because if they can essentially if they can either shake Zelensky or or neutralize Zelensky who’s gonna step up what’s the next step then right it’s it gets hairy it’s not going to be a place like Odessa it’s not going to be a place like Mikolayev it’s not going to be a place like Moripol those are places for conventional fighting but they don’t they’re not strategically significant enough to warrant a large detonation okay right and now they’re ruining their bread basket though I mean you take out Kiev I mean this country’s got problems for 20 years correct correct except that the Russians don’t really mind that because they’re just gonna send in they just want they want everyone’s will to break okay and that’s that’s the Russian mantra that’s their MO right and they’re not gonna stop they have it does not benefit them they’re winning this war you’ve said before and they’re gonna win this war and there’s nothing anybody’s gonna do about it and the US isn’t gonna get involved and Europe’s not gonna get get involved because nobody wants to get their hands dirty correct we’ve all just recently had experiences like Afghanistan and now we really know now if we had had to won those in 10-20 years we might get some idealists to go in but even then they know better correct it’s just not worth

39:47 It if you think about go back to our conversation about the World Cup all right when a soccer match starts when a football match starts zero zero who’s winning nobody one team comes in scores three goals who’s winning three zero the team with three goals is winning right Russia invaded they took 74,000 square kilometers or something like that in territory they’re winning well then the other team scores a goal back and now the score is 3-1 who’s winning it’s really clear in a football match this the team with three points is still winning the other team has one point and even if they get two points the team with three points is still winning we see Ukraine fights back and wins a counter offensive in the north that doesn’t mean they’re winning Ukraine pushes people back to the Dennifer River in in Kersin they’re not winning they’re launching a counter-attack they’re winning strategic positions on the field but there’s that’s a long way away from pushing Russian forces completely out of their country and maintaining their own set of governmental leaders if you look at those outcomes as the definition of winning I think most people would understand Ukraine is never gonna win this never gonna win this alright so in your mind this plays out by it’s slowly just fizzling in the world’s attention and they just say oh yeah that’s that war zone that we’re fatigued now of reading about and we just don’t care

41:12 Like there’s war zones and then it’ll just go under their control somehow there’s other things there’s other factors that weigh into that right yes the world is going to become less interested the world’s already less interested yeah right you Zilinski made a very interesting and under publicized statement right before the counter offensive in August August 29th it came out and he said that he could sense that the commitment from NATO in the west to supporting Ukraine was fading and that that was a big reason why he decided to launch a counter offensive he needed to show battlefield victory in order to demonstrate that there was still reason for the for Western powers to invest in Ukraine because what he sees and what he knows that not the average that the average person doesn’t know the US does not have access to the rare earth minerals that it needs to create new weapon stores so it’s sending all of its current weapon stores along with the Ukraine along with the UK to Ukraine but we’re not replenishing those stores because the supply chain to make new weapons is actually tied back in China which has been on a zero tolerance policy for Covid and restricting its manufacturing restricting this the spread of supply chain routes for everything from rare earth minerals to stuff as common as steel so we can’t generate enough weapons to protect our own country and that’s that supply chain issue is impacting

42:39 Ukraine so we can still send them money we can still send them you know humanitarian support but continuing to create they can’t generate their own weapon stores Russia can yeah it’s it’s a it’s a terrible situation I’m not a fan that it’s happening but realistically when I think about what’s in the best interest of the United States what’s in the best interest of of NATO at different stages in this conflict the shift the shift away from it being in our best interest to continue supporting Ukraine is very clearly taking place and politicians and individuals paying 400% more for energy in Germany right now they’re all starting to sense it too right a hundred years from now when my great-great-grandson is interviewing your great-great-grandson in this chair are they gonna be having a similar conversation about Russia and their power in the world a hundred years from now that’s an interesting question that’s an interesting question geopolitics would say yes there’s still these three major players and maybe that could phase out I guess we don’t know what’s happening with technology in the future but geopolitics would say like you said Russia is the controlling force in Europe and well it’s the controlling force in Europe right now yeah right we don’t know what it’s gonna look like in a hundred years and we own the sanctions that have been put in place now are designed to hurt Russia 25 years from now not

44:02 Necessarily right now which is why you’ve seen the Russian economy bounce back I feel like there will be some interesting conversations to be had the world of geopolitics might look very different frankly speaking Germany’s commitment to rebuild its army to become the largest military force in Europe that was a that was an announcement that I think was met with with fanfare and praise but let’s not forget how many wars have started from Germany so we may see a different a different power structure in Europe in a hundred years where a very broken Russia after the after all of this damage really sets in for them where a very broken Russia is just not able to compete with a very determined and very capable UK or potentially Germany okay just final questions Putin he’s a former spy like you KGB what what’s your hot take on Putin that we don’t what is he really like what does the world not understand about him his motivations and how does this play out after he leaves us for whatever reason yeah so Putin wants you to underestimate him it is a it is a straight-up spy playbook move this is spycraft 101 you want people to think that you’re unstable stupid physically or mentally impaired you want people to think less of you because then you have the advantage when people underestimate you they ignore you they belittle you they trash talk you whatever that is them putting themselves in a superior position above you which is a vulnerability because now you have

45:42 Superior information that they don’t have so they’re making all their decisions from a from a place of flawed data and you are not so when I when I see coverage about Putin I see I see him sitting in his seat with a big grin on his face very happy to see that the media is talking about how he has brain damage or see the media talking about how he’s going to be unseated from within by his own people like he wants he wants you to underestimate him if anything it’s been nine months of underestimating Putin and here we are still grinding away at a conflict still making accusations and claims and you still have 13 million Ukrainians who are who are refugees from their own country you have a hundred thousand deaths let’s not forget that back in what was it June Ukraine was saying that they had killed 80,000 Russians and that the Russians had only killed 14,000 Ukrainians it wasn’t until just a few weeks ago that the US that the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff for the US came out and set the record straight and said that they basically had equal attrition on both sides that’s just that’s Putin sitting there saying hey look world Ukraine’s been lying to you the great honest Ukraine has been lying to you about how many Russians and Ukrainians have died right there’s a he he’s letting he’s letting people do what people do because he knows people are predictable that’s a spy that’s spycraft 102 human beings

47:11 Are predictable creatures he wants you to underestimate him and he he knows that eventually with time we’re gonna degrade our faith and our commitment okay and as much as we the world demonizes Putin Putin successor could be much much worse way worse that’s the thing that really scares me is who’s gonna take over when Putin if Putin is taken out or if Putin is unseated from within it’s going to be because some hawkish leader thinks he’s not doing enough that’s a terrifying thought well okay and we are gonna get the spycraft but you mentioned Taiwan and China because so I want to get into this a little bit I guess that’s probably where we start because that’s where it’s gonna kick off you said by 2024 China is gonna take that 45-minute trip over and take over Taiwan why do people need to know what’s happening there because again does anyone care in America right if Taiwan gets taken over and they hear that’s where their chips are made does anyone really care or know what the ramifications are why do we need to keep our eye on China so the reason I keep in China is a China is a has proven to be for the last 50 years a strategically deliberate opponent just the way that they’ve structured everything from their economic structure to their political structure to their military industrial complex they are a very slow moving force that has a clear vision and it’s because they don’t suffer from democracy democracy

48:44 The vision changes every new president or every new prime minister every new you know every electoral season right even in the CIA you had new directive every four years correct because it’s a presidential appointee right right so there you get anything done you can’t have a long-term vision correct constantly here here here here well yeah China can set a 50-year vision and then on the path to that 50-year vision they can set a 25-year vision and a five-year vision and the whole country gets behind it because the Politburo knows that that there’s a there’s a rank and file and if you want to be able to one day be the premier you have to do your rank and file job forever and that’s not that’s not political survival that’s Chinese culture right it’s always been that way it will always be that way don’t forget they go back 3,000 years we go back 200 we go back less than 300 years in the United States they go back 3,000 years think about how much pride we have in our forefathers multiply that times a hundred right and it’s it’s insane yeah just quick aside you spend time in Abu Dhabi I spent time in Dubai recently and I was I was blown away by the progress it made the long-term vision and again I said well here you got this guy the in Dubai the ruler from the Maktoum family who’s been his entire life for this vision so again you’ve got a guy who’s 50 60 70 something years old who’s thinking we’re going this way but then you’ve got his family

50:10 Who’s gonna be picking up wherever he drops off and it’s their reputation on the line right and so they’ve got this long-term vision and you get to see I see things happening there that would only happen with a long-term vision regardless of the resources and they have amazing resources but still it was impressive to see matter of fact I saw a lot of things they’re doing better than our quote-unquote Western democracies there and I was like wow maybe there’s more to the rhetoric that I constantly hear that America is the greatest place and yeah but it it does suffer from that long-term strategy and planning right it loses that in the back and forth of how it was designed this the superpower or the yeah the superpower of the United States not the United States as a superpower but our mutant ability right the thing that makes our democracy so effective is the very thing that we’re complaining about right now it’s the fact that we are divided that’s what that’s what makes America work it doesn’t matter how progressive or conservative how left-leaning or right-leaning it doesn’t matter how fervent you are when it comes to making policies that affect the entire country you’re forced to move slow because the two sides don’t agree that’s what makes us strong but the more this is what blows my mind your hyper conservative person wants more than anything for there to be just hyper conservative people in office your

51:38 Liberal progressive people want nothing more than to have liberal progressive people in office if we actually take away the other party in the United States what does that make us a one-party system what is China a one-party system what our authoritarian countries one-party systems so we don’t ever want it we don’t ever take the time to think through well what if we actually got what we wanted right oh wait a second then we would actually be our own worst enemy right and America’s superpower is that you can have you have these constant forces against each other so the best idea hopefully wins and you can express yourself and you can innovate and that I mean that’s also what makes America great global power as well allowing that dissent to happen but you’re saying if they had their wishes they would be something that they they hate they would be something that they hate right and the whole thing would fall apart because the democracy would die right right we because we also in the United States Americans we kind of we take an issue with democracy we don’t really want everybody to be equal we want there to be fairness but we don’t really want there to be equality that’s why we argue about taxes tax the rich at a higher rate and we should give tax freedom to the poor that’s not equality yeah right America’s capitalist country and that doesn’t go hand-in-hand with a democracy exactly that’s a Gordon Gekko saying the movie Wall Street he says

53:00 To Bud Fox he said you’re not naive enough to think we’re living in a democracy do you it’s the free market it’s the free market he says right so the reason we need to pay attention to China is because China is the is the next logical evolution of what would happen to us if we got rid of one of our parties that’s the direction we would go they’re already there their hotspot is on Taiwan they really don’t have a beef with the United States the China if anything they want they want the United States to remain rich and they want the United States to keep buying Chinese stuff they like it that way but the problem is this Taiwan spur back in 1949 when Mao Zedong took over China the nationalist Chinese government fled to Taiwan that’s the government that helped us in World War two they’re living in exile on Taiwan and from there that’s how they built a democracy very similar our democracy the one China the two systems yeah one’s China two systems policy that’s that’s in place is largely a cop-out because the United States knows that they don’t want to wage war against China and China knows that a democratic efficient Taiwan is better for China overall because 95% of all the chips all the semiconductors in the world come from Taiwan they come from one company in Taiwan 95% crazy and just really good at it they’re just really good at it they’re not complicated they’re just little semiconductors right they don’t have the natural resources they get the natural

54:25 Resources they just happen to have the factory infrastructure to build it all okay what people what would be the impact people think that those semiconductors are used in your laptop and your cell phone so we’re like oh that’s not a big deal like they’re using our cars that’s not a big deal they’re also used in all high-tech medical devices they’re also used in microwaves they’re used in weapon systems the stuff that keeps us healthy that keeps us safe that keeps commerce rolling those are all based on these semiconductors if if China is serious about its 2025 goal of being the the high-tech industry supporter the the high-tech industry exporter for the world the only way they get there is if they take China if they take Taiwan otherwise Taiwan will always be that high-tech exporter not China okay so and that’s a commitment that Xi Jinping made when he launched the 2025 with the 2050 plan that was his 2025 goal that’s that’s coming in tight right plus you saw what what China did in Hong Kong to administratively change Hong Kong they’ve been taking those administrative change actions in Taiwan for the last seven to ten years so changing the laws changing the expectations politically so that when they assert control from the outside like being counter point of view they’re doing the right they’re acting illegally that’s why nobody intervened in Hong Kong because technically China was acting illegally they had changed the legal system in Hong Kong before they

55:54 Went in and started beating people and and you know beating them in the streets and optically they need to grab Taiwan because it just makes them look powerless makes them look like they’re not following through but like economically they don’t need to as long as they can keep doing business with Taiwan correct but they’re probably gonna grab it and they’re flexing their muscles and now the Communist Party is going more communist which is fascinating to me because capitalism got them where they are today yeah they don’t admit to that though right it’s their own hybrid version of right and so they’re gonna grab it and the US isn’t gonna do a goddamn thing about it that’s what they’re hoping for if they do it fast enough right the US won’t even have a chance to take action and but can the US can the US really do anything about it this this is where I split very far from academics okay academics out there will say all day long political science academics will say all day long that the United States will take action it must take action it’s a demonstration of their commitments to you know the rest of the world it’s a show of force and a show of power it’s a strategic target for their long-term projection the Pacific so academics will say that there’s all these reasons operationally speaking I’m how would the United States feel if one warship of US Navy personnel sank in the Taiwan Straits would we all of a sudden feel like

57:17 This is our fight if American soldiers died so that Taiwan remained independent from China which according to our policy right now it isn’t independent it’s already part of China right so if China actually exerted that control and took away the one China to pot two systems and made it one China one system is that worth American soldiers dying I don’t think it is I think operationally speaking our generals would know that our politicians would know that and we would say to ourselves economically China is just going to become a new exporter of semiconductors which we’ve already put in place this year our independence from Eastern manufacturing and semiconductors anyways to take place in the next 10 years is it really worth the fight or can we just can we handle five or seven years where we’re negotiating with China to get those semiconductors to keep our our medical and military infrastructures afloat while we spin up our own capabilities here in the United States domestically right and they’re probably not gonna squeeze us for that because it’s good business for now correct maybe in 20-30 years they will correct put the squeeze on the US but probably not in the next five right especially not if it’s gonna prevent large-scale military communications and also what is the US gonna do just circle a bunch of aircraft carriers I’m not gonna put troops on Taiwan and so then how do you even back it up this is not like and with the invention situation the

58:36 Invention of hypersonic missiles the reason hypersonic missiles are so important isn’t because they can go fast it’s because hypersonic missiles can can move faster than most anti-aircraft defense systems on aircraft carriers so hypersonic missiles are essentially just aircraft carrier killers they can they can be launched from the ground they can be on target within minutes or seconds almost something like almost undefeatable in terms of counter-air weapons and then it only takes one to neutralize an entire aircraft carrier we’re not gonna send four aircraft carrier fleets into Southeast Asia into the chart into the South China Sea to have four Chinese hypersonic missiles obliterate them do they have functional hypersonic they were the first country to have them but have are they are they in use they’re they’re being flexed and demonstrated the same way that we’re flexing and demonstrating hours yeah but to find one of those in the US ship would be also quite provocative correct correct but it’s more by accident yeah how how much more or less provocative would it be then then the US deploying for carrier vessels off the coast of China okay right all right so this is something to watch and it just means that China is gonna be a bigger economic player than the US in the next 10 years 20 years and that’s so that’s economics yeah economists are saying that by 2032 the United States will no longer be the

59:58 World’s economic superpower if things stay the same China’s happy if things stay the same taking Taiwan is just kind of a political point that Xi Jinping wants to have on his record to show his power he could just as well in a year change that 2025 plan okay and and you know paper it over and everybody’s gonna accept it but I don’t think that’s gonna be the case and if anything I think Xi Jinping is benefiting from Asia’s or from China’s stability in contrast to the United States instability that’s making their sphere of influence that much bigger and stronger which you’re seeing right now with the brick right Brazil Russia India China trading block you’re seeing that the world on the other side of the ocean the world is rallying around China so why 2024 it’s gonna be a big election it’s gonna be another Trump Biden showdown with DeSantis in there and with who knows who else is gonna announce it’s gonna be an ugly election in 2024 for the United States it’s gonna be two years of lame duck president before 2024 you’re gonna have this Ukraine conflict that’s potentially gonna go on for another winter and into next year and there’ve already been economic and energy specialists saying that next winter will be even worse than this winter for Europe so China’s just sitting here reading this he leaves right and they’re saying that I’m loving it perfect for them timing is if we don’t do it in 2024 when’s the next chance

1:01:21 That we’re gonna have to do it where it’s gonna be as quick easy and painless as if we were to do it right now okay now the Taiwan aside long term what do we need to know about China or what is there to do about China from an American perspective or a European perspective we’re so far it’s it’s depressing the truth is depressing this is where I become like I am the geopolitics the dentist of geopolitics nobody wants to hear me talk about it right but when you want to know the truth I’ll talk about it China has spent the 20 years that we were focused in the global war on terror China has spent that expanding its sphere of influence they control rare earth minerals worldwide the vast majority of what’s known known minds and known rare earth minerals from from Iceland to the Bahamas to Australia they’re either in mines owned by a by an umbrella company that belongs to a Chinese company or they’re shipped and refined in Chinese factories or on Chinese vessels so our future of technology is heavily controlled by China and then you’ve got China building relationships outside of democratic values through the Belt and Road initiative so in South America in Central America in Africa in poorer parts of Eastern Europe you’ve got this Belt and Road initiative that China can fund because it’s not confined to the rules of democracy and it’s it’s least property is its least airports and energy centers and like it can project

1:02:55 Itself it can project its power far and wide whether it wants to project its military power or whether it wants to align itself with another country and then give favor nation to that to that foreign country and then let them like support them with infrastructure we are quite far behind when it comes to the strategic global positioning of shipping infrastructure rare earth minerals military development than where China is right now and checkmate already it’s it’s not necessarily checkmate because economically we still have the advantage until 2032 2032 if nothing changes brother we’re our kids are going to be having a very difficult time it will be our grandkids will have it would take three generations before we would be able to see ourselves really pull back and take back over that position as superpower so let’s let’s project forward then what does the world look like and say you know 22 said you know 2075 you know where the US is no longer globally dominant maybe it’s China is twice as big three times as big as an economy what what do our grandkids children’s looks lives look like are they speaking Chinese for sure they’re speaking Chinese Chinese becomes the language of business English is no longer the language of business for a while there English will remain for 10 15 years but by by and large the Chinese will just like the world has adopted Western education systems Western values Western languages Western

1:04:25 Religions you would see the same thing happen with the new Chinese superpower because everyone would be incentivized to cooperate the reason everybody started learning English was because they were incentivized now you’ll be incentivized to learn Chinese you’ll be incentivized to be Buddhist you’ll be incentivized to ignore religion and you know run off of a central power party system not to mention the fact that if China does become the global superpower it’s proof in the pudding that a centralized single government unit is the superior form of government so you would see you would see Chinese projection of population in most of the developing world because China doesn’t have enough jobs for all of its own Chinese and it’s growing so quickly that it wants to export those workers other places the one China policy has made it so there’s a dearth of Chinese women so what’s gonna happen is mass growth of the mixed-race Chinese your Chinese African Americans your Chinese Latinos your Chinese Americans so you would actually physically see more Asian blood in more bloodstreams so by 2075 from the way that we look to the language that we talk to the way that we do business would be significantly different this is a Hollywood movie it’s a scary Hollywood movie is now we see and I’ve had about a bunch of blockchain people in here and I had a guy on my show a couple months ago he said world war three will not be a military war it’ll

1:05:51 Be a currency war between the digital Chinese Yuan and the digital US dollar as a CBDC currencies and that was what the war will be and if you take that a step further you know you look at what’s happening and I’ve heard with the digital Yuan and how it’s being used you know in conjunction with the social score system and the 5G technology and the you know the face recognition to like put this real authoritarian spin on life in China I think some of it’s true maybe some of its science fiction but I’ve had some pretty good reports saying a lot of that’s true I’m guessing that gets exported to the world as well that type of control correct because that kind of control is it’s efficient right you were just I mean you were just an UAE yeah are there police are there traffic cops in UAE no it’s all cameras right your national ID is tied to your passport and tied your credit card it’s extremely efficient you don’t need to have a huge police force you don’t need to have a huge law enforcement presence when you have digital surveillance and a threat and and a rapidly moving judicial system that isn’t based on proving you innocent before guilty right or proving you yeah you’re innocent until proven guilty so when you have a justice system that isn’t based on that principle things move much faster yeah and like you said everything is digitized there so it can all like yeah like that you’re gone yep you’re pulled you’re speeding down a street you get a

1:07:18 Notification on your phone we caught you your credit cards been charged your driver’s license over has already lost two points thank you have a nice day you’re friendly local government right that that’s what it’s like right now in UAE that’s what it could be like everywhere in the world the technology already exists it’s just a matter of whether the governments are willing to place it yet okay and so I was trying to expand small that probably gets exported to the world as well and this is going to happen has a high back to the probability probabilities this is high in 50 according to economists it’s already essentially virtually guaranteed right according to economists the probability is like 85% but does the size of the GDP to determine the outcome it’s not it’s not necessarily the size of the GDP it’s the it’s the leverage that you have for future economic growth depending on how you measure GDP there are some people who would say that Chinese China’s GDP is never going to equate to what the United States GDP is because of the population but when it comes to the true productive power of critical business and and core survival needs that’s what that’s what gives them true economic might we saw in what was it it may have been July when when Russian banks were unable to access their foreign reserves their foreign funds we saw that move as a way of bankrupting Russia once China saw the United States do that China pulled its currency out of US controlled banks it

1:08:58 Started pulling its currency and it started pulling its foreign reserves out of any bank that was controlled by US ally or US power because it recognized that that’s an unfair economic tool of war if they were planning to be peaceful they would have never done that they would have left their money stay right and then you also saw them flood the market with US dollars to put demand on the UN to increase the value of the end and decrease the value of the yuan and decrease the value of the dollar again that’s another move to show that they’re consolidating their own currency in their in their universe the United States has talked about a digital currency but they haven’t but they’re still letting cryptocurrencies play out which is we saw disastrously turned for FTX recently in China they outlawed digital currency three months ago it’s illegal to have a digital currency because they’re already making plans to create a nationalized digital currency in our administration I think Biden mentioned considering it in China they’re already doing it like you can see their speed to market if you were gonna gamble on investing in a company who would you invest in speed to market right there’s a there’s a need there’s innovation that they can make it happen the world is an economic world we’re not a free market everywhere but but money is the resource that makes things happen it’s it’s like it’s like fire was for cave

1:10:21 Men nobody cares about the actual dollar or the coin but it’s the power yeah I think um I mean so we’ve gone pretty heavy into the crypto and blockchain industry the last 18 months I’ve spoken to most of the major players and had conversations with them and and and thought a lot more about money as well as the Bitcoin maximalists who look everything through a Bitcoin world which is interesting as opposed to a fiat currency world one of them is controlled by governments and you know money can be printed when it wants and the other one it can’t and so you start to look at your life through that perspective of money and if you think about it long enough you start to realize that that money is not you know just something to have into a bank account it is life itself right and you know we we got into a big fight in 2020 for freedom of speech and our major technology platforms wouldn’t allow us to put certain messages out and we kind of fought back and said we should be able to say what we want and have these open discussions but financial freedom without that doesn’t it there’s nothing to talk about right and we saw when people pull funds or restrict to that that’s higher up in the Maslow hierarchy than speech I would say right because that’s your very essence of anything you want to do and I think we’re I don’t know I’m seeing it more with crypto is that you know that money is life to a certain extent and free

1:11:37 Money maybe means a free life in any type of controlled money means your freedom will go correct one of the first things they pulled on us was our PayPal account got suspended you know immediately when the other things they want to do with us and it you could just see how that will stop you dead in your tracks yeah it’s amazing your financial freedom is the foundation of all freedom it’s why people talk about wanting financial freedom and there’s different definitions of financial freedom and I think they’re all valid whether financial freedom is having so much money that you don’t care about money anymore or whether financial freedom is having a set amount of money that you live comfortably within six of one half dozen of the other but your point is exactly right without money without the ability to generate money or live within the money that you have you’re always under control right control is always there you either have it or someone has it over you it’s only it’s a binary calculation there is no in between right if you’re not the one in control then the question you should be asking yourself is who is the one in control of my money of my time of my day of my mood of my of my thoughts of my feelings that’s when CIA taught me that concept it was uncomfortable until just you know until I learned that it’s true as children you’re under your parents control in the school system you’re controlled by teachers and by

1:12:59 The principal and by the infrastructure of your school in your career you’re you’re governed by the rules of good practice and whatever else and your bosses control how much money you make and taxes can controls how much money they take and you’re not in control of anything right and then even your 401k and any effort you have to save your money you only really have it if you can get it back out if you can’t and banks lend against your money so if the bank loses your money is gone you know it’s a wonderful life is the movie that shows when you run on the bank and the bank doesn’t have reserves you’re out of luck so you really don’t have control and that’s a terrifying terrifying thought which is why so much of what we do and intelligence is take control from people who have already given control up because when you’ve given up control a lot of times what ends up happening is you’re trying to find someone better to control you you’re not ever looking most people don’t look to take control back themselves they say it but what they really mean is I want to give my control to someone else who I trust more than I trust the current person right that’s you don’t like your boss but that doesn’t make you want to be an entrepreneur it makes you want to work for someone else it’s just giving control to someone else right it’s it’s a twisted way the human brain works because up here we’re still very much cavemen we haven’t evolved here like

1:14:18 We’ve evolved on our cell phones are evolved in our in our laptops and this is basic tradecraft why because you’re trying to control people or understand people no in espionage you’re controlling people that’s exactly what you do you’re controlling scenarios you’re controlling world events you’re controlling decisions that people make you’re controlling them it’s we use the word manipulate you’re manipulating factors that with high probability will drive a human being to make certain decisions so in essence you’re controlling their decision-making process without them knowing it that’s the essence of of human intelligence of human tradecraft what’s an example of that so if you want if you want someone to give you a secret that let me give you a real-world example if you’re talking to a general and you want that general to give you a troop movement that’s happening in some foreign country they shouldn’t tell you the troop movement it goes against their best interest they were trusted by their government to understand you know the the value of the secret of that troop movement but guess what the most important thing in a general’s life is not the troop movement it’s his marriage or his oldest daughter or his son with cancer or his aging mother right he’s a human being first and a general second so when you come in and you show sympathy for that that’s sick son or you show you share a story about your

1:15:44 Own aging dying mother now there’s a human connection to you that human connection supersedes their loyalty connection to to their job and then when you layer on top of that a a financial or or real-life benefit hey your sick son can’t get the care he needs in your country but I can facilitate him to get the best care in the world in Switzerland or Sweden would you like me to do that and you’re like I would love for you to do that I I can do that it’s just you know we need some kind of leverage because I’m not going to ask you to pay for it that the cost is exorbitant but you know Sweden would be very interested in knowing what your troop movement is gonna look like in Turkey whatever it might be right now all of a sudden it’s it’s a currency secrets become a currency and the general was controlled by his government to protect the secret now he’s controlled by you to disclose the secret because what the one thing that you know when you’re talking to somebody who’s under someone else’s control is that that person can be controlled so you’re already one step ahead of them they don’t even realize it and then you also have to convince them that the information they’re giving you is not going to hurt other people sometimes sometimes they want the information to hurt other people they just don’t want to be the one to because they don’t believe in it well they don’t want to be the one that that does the work right

1:17:06 They want to stick it to their boss they want to stick it to their their president or they want to you know if it’s if there’s if it’s Pakistan in India if you just if you tell either side that their information is gonna hurt the other side most of them are gonna jump up and be like absolutely let’s do it let’s high-five let’s if I can stick it to the Pakistanis or I can stick it to the Indians right so so visceral is there their conflict with each other okay and when anyone hates that much then they’re compromised themselves all right and so you’re taught to get inside people’s heads and fuck with them with a purpose yeah with a goal is it ever a dark learning this stuff yeah very dark it’s it’s you know it’s not dark to learn it I think to a certain extent learning it is a little bit like learning math it makes sense it’s psychology it’s just applied psychology like applied mathematics right the dark part is when you realize that you like it or that you enjoy it or that you see the benefit of it because then you start asking yourself if there’s something wrong with you you start asking yourself like am I a bad person am I a bad person because I believe that that convincing this person to work against their best interest is good for me and therefore I’m gonna do it but that’s not necessarily a spy thing that’s something that every business owner every entrepreneur every parent we know what that feels like right have you ever

1:18:30 Lied to a child to protect the child yes you’re still lying to the child but you rationalize it as good for the child you lie to your parents like we’ve all lied to our mother our mother gave us gave birth to us she raised us she she protected us she changed our diapers but we’re still gonna lie to her face now as adults we’ll rationalize it right and nobody likes to come face to face with the fact that we make these decisions it’s even worse when you know systematically how to hijack someone’s decision-making process and get them to take action that is not in their best interest but is in your best interest when you know that and you choose to take action on that you can’t help but stare yourself in the mirror and ask am I a good person am I a bad person who defines what a good person is who defines what a bad person is had did you get personally conflicted during your time did you have moments of personal conflict you must yeah because you must be doing things sometimes that maybe you don’t even agree with and then also you’re compromising people you’re developing a personal relationship with I mean you know karma’s a karma’s a bitch you must have felt that at some point yeah you I’ve never carried karma very far personally that’s something my wife is Buddhist my wife is also a former CIA officer so karma was always very real for her but it’s interesting because to a certain extent she believes that the trauma that she’s going that

1:19:54 She went through at the agency was her way of paying back the karma that she generated in a previous life right so it’s a it’s an interesting world if you want to dig into karma but yeah the personal conflict comes frequently you’re conflicted with the cases that you’re working because they’re real people and they are totally unaware of what you’re doing and then you’re conflicted with the purpose behind the mission itself right am I doing this because I’m taking a child sex trafficking ring down it’s easy to hurt a person when you know you’re ending a ring of something that’s immoral but when you’re hurting a person so that you can get trade secrets on what the G20 summon is gonna agree to in regards to whether or not they’re gonna whatever make make some other country part of NATO now you’re like is it really like is that secret worth ruining these five people’s lives and that’s before we even get into trade secrets right what’s the next electric vehicle that’s gonna be manufactured in China what’s the trade deal that’s gonna happen between Vietnam and Cambodia you know who’s who’s gonna agree to the concrete deal to lay the runway for the new International Airport in Phnom Penh you still getting to those those are those are national security secrets they have a benefit to national security but you’re are you really gonna ruin people’s lives for those secrets and the answer is yes the answer is if it protects American lives

1:21:23 This today or 15 years from now it’s deemed important enough you’re not ruining American lives you’re ruining Vietnamese lives or you know Cambodian lives or Chinese lives or whatever else it’s not the same right and we’re recruited we’re hired and trained because we can live in that space and while we feel the conflict it doesn’t it doesn’t compromise us to the point where we stop working we just kind of rationalize it and move on because you’re controlled because we’re control ever at DF guys raise your hand and say you’re controlling us the way we assume when you’re teaching us to control other people you know it’s that is that is the big elephant in the room for many many years what ends up happening is you learn these skills and you go out and you operate and you’re so full of ego that you’re like I am so powerful I can’t believe I can do this this is I’m I’m a CIA officer I’m a secret undercover officer this is amazing and then two three tours into it you realize that the way that our hiring process works the way that our promotion process works the way that our assignments work is just another graduated step of exactly what we’re doing to agents below us and I think that’s why you see especially nowadays CIA is suffering from mass of attrition right now I think what’s happening is that those mid-career ists of the current generation are asking themselves that question and saying well shit you just taught me that if I’m not in control I’m being controlled and now

1:22:50 I can see how I’m being controlled do I really want to stay here because if I take these skills and I’m just the first one to talk about it openly there are you pretty much yeah that when it comes to how to apply CIA skills to everyday life I don’t know why no one’s ever talked about it before probably because they just they left CIA and went on to be very successful in their own industry but it’s that’s why they do it that’s why they go and get into security they go and become authors they go and become consultants or they become you know security specialists or they go work for Google or Apple or whatever else because they know they can step into basically any role learn the role quickly because that’s what we were taught to do undercover manage the chain manage the personalities up and down the chain turn everybody into a loyal follower of you and you basically you’ve written a ticket to an easy life it’s a it’s a fascinating thing the only time your life is hard is when you stay at CIA and there are plenty of people who stay thank goodness because they stay so that I don’t have to our country is safer my children will have a more secure future because of the people who stayed so I will forever be grateful that’s why you don’t hear me say bad things about CIA because there are men and women making very real sacrifices to be under control by CIA to do what’s in the best interest of the United States not in their own best

1:24:09 Interest how well does this stuff work it works like clockwork it’s it’s a powerful reliable tool it’s been it’s been crafted not even by CIA it was crafted by mi6 before us they taught it to us we’ve coordinated with the five eyes if you if you don’t know what the five eyes are the five eyes are Canadian intelligence the United States intelligence UK intelligence Australian intelligence and New Zealand intelligence we’re kind of five allies that share transparency in all of our Intel training human intelligence practices tradecraft practices operations etc so it’s called the five eyes or the five eyes Alliance and we’ve all shared information to make sure that we are the best most capable intelligence services in the world when it comes to human intelligence okay we don’t have the same kind of viciousness and and authority to kill that you see in in Israel we also don’t have the kind of ability to leverage digital surveillance against our own people like you see in in the Emirates or like you see in China so there’s different authorities but according to Western democratic practices you know we’re the best that we can be how does Russia rank in there Russia’s SVR is a is an offshoot directly from KGB and they are extremely skilled at penetrating foreign intelligence and foreign governments that’s why just a week ago you saw two two contractors supporting classified US Naval research compromised to an unknown

1:25:49 Foreign country you’ve seen doctors in the army in the last month get arrested on espionage charges for working with Russia right Russia’s very actively penetrated the US military the US intelligence infrastructure the FBI CIA and it’s it’s well known it’s well pop it’s well published because they they understand us very well they understand how we think they understand our vulnerabilities Americans have some very obvious human flaws like what like ego like greed sexual repression we we we believe that we are always right so we have this fundamental flaw in in getting attention we want attention all the time it’s that weird sort of like superstar status we’re nobody but we still want everybody to pay attention to us as individuals as individuals interesting right it’s so I mean Russia Russian culture doesn’t celebrate the individual American culture does so just imagine how easy it is to get an American talk them up brag about how smart and beautiful and handsome they are and all that American wants to do is hang out with you you’re like oh you’re my friend who makes me feel good like now I don’t have to be the wingman for this handsome guy you’ll be the wingman for me because I’m so cool and you get it now that’s the person that you’re gonna invite to every family event and every Thanksgiving dinner and when when something happens in your life where your boss pisses you off or when you don’t get the promotion

1:27:21 You’re looking for you’re gonna take it to your best friend and say can you believe it man I’m the one that does everything for this company I’m the one that knows everything about the engineering department I’m the one and the only one that has access to certain networks and they’re not even gonna give me my ten thousand dollar promotion and then that person’s like you know in the open market the free market economy somebody out there would probably pay you twenty five thousand dollars for your information you want me to go find somebody who would do that yeah yeah you know what that would be awesome like that’s how it happens okay and this person’s American yeah in that in that example like your Americans are very Americans are very easy to compromise right I should buy another American or buy a Russian who looks like an American exactly do they have those absolutely that’s that’s another thing the Russians do better than us Russians have what’s known as deep seed operations so they’ll seed somebody from a young age into a culture specifically to master the the local language master the mannerisms have a very real career history someplace if you’ve if you’ve met or heard of Jack Barsky he was he was one of those original deep cover officers for Russia okay back in like the 80s I’ve heard of that so they are good at that and we don’t do that because guess what our budgetary cycle rotates on five years

1:28:37 Right takes a lot longer than five years to run a seeding operation and maybe there’s humanitarian concerns as well you don’t put teenagers in there yeah okay so the interesting all right so this is the way you compromised and do you feel like once you learn these skills and you went out of the real world you’re like playing with toddlers sometimes you just walk in or is it not always that easy yes it’s not always that easy because because again people have a people have different nexus ease of control so as an example I’m sure you’ve met people who are extremely faith-based right very very faith-based it’s very hard to take control away from someone’s faith because if they believe God or they believe nirvana or they believe whatever they believe it’s hard to shift that nexus to something you can you can take control of but when you’re dealing with somebody who who they the person they worship is themselves or the person the thing that they worship is their wife or the you know the thing that they worship is their business it’s much easier to to manipulate that person because you can very clearly draw a line to how helping you helps them achieve their goal in the other thing right so some people are just more malleable than other people it doesn’t mean that anyone is bulletproof it’s really about the energy and time investment that you have to make to take control of somebody else that’s the that’s where it becomes

1:30:02 An economic model okay right if you’re trying to it’s the same thing with with customer acquisition if you would apply it to a business if a business wants to acquire a certain customer then it has to ask itself the question how many how much time and how much investment does it take to acquire a customer a CPA a cost-per-acquisition if the cost-per-acquisition is too high then they actually change the kind of customer that they target if the cost if the cost-per-acquisition is sustainable then they’ll just all day long they’ll just keep tagging the right customer and bringing them in because they know that that customer is going to be worth a certain amount of revenue so it’s a very mathematical model just like that where if you want someone to help you if you want if you need someone to close a deal make a hire give you a promotion buy your product it really is just a matter of being able to identify those people have a minimum investment and getting to take a specific action that benefits you it’s not always total life control like we had at CIA it’s more of controlling a very specific decision that you want someone to make hmm Wow and when you go out there in the field you talked about money reasons what are the ways to control people at sex and romantic relationships that big or is it they’re like three key things that you do and is it like money is it power is it sex so money actually is the weakest because if you’re

1:31:20 Trying to if you’re trying to win someone over with money I mean you and I had the same conversation just earlier today money is not the most powerful thing right money is just a tool that gets us something else when you understand that’s most people understand that on a fundamental level that money is a tool that gets them something some people want money because they want to look powerful to the opposite sex some people want money because they need to prove to their mom and dad that they weren’t the failure some people need money because they need to pay for the cancer treatment for their child or for their mother right but money is just the tool to get them something else I’m having a flashback because I used to work in the city of London with all the bankers and I would take them out to dinner and we got to these fancy restaurants and at the end of the meal I’d always look at him and say why are you doing this play in this business and they’d be like the money and then I would I would dig deeper because I’d be like number why are you doing this like and then it would always be I want to show those kids in high school that I mean something I want to prove to my dad on this I want to get those girls to finally notice me it was always about something else it’s never about the money exactly each person was very unique to their story and it wouldn’t always be obvious unless you drill down a little bit yeah so you’ve

1:32:29 Had the experience yourself and that’s that’s exactly what it’s like money is not money is money is the easy answer it’s the easy I don’t have to think too hard to just say that person’s a greedy bastard not there’s actually much more to that and if you’re willing to put the work in to figure out why somebody else wants something then you have you’re you’re traversing into a different life that they have had I have this model that I try to teach people called the three lives and if you’ve heard it or stop me anytime tell me every human being has three lives they have a public life a private life and a secret life your public life is a life that we put 80% of our effort into it’s why we dress the way we dress it’s why we shave the way we shave it’s why we choose the jewelry we choose right we use certain words we make certain friends we watch and talk about certain TV shows that’s because we want to be observed by other people a certain way that’s our public life but our public life isn’t real it takes a lot of effort for the public life then the second life is your private life if everybody who meets you knows your public life it’s only your closest friends your closest acquaintances that have your understand your private life this is the life where you know that when you take off your shoes your feet stink right your mom knows that your girlfriend knows that your kids know that whatever your best high school buddy knows that this

1:33:55 Is the place where people know that that you don’t like shellfish unless the fried and you know you secretly love romance comedies from the 1970s right that’s your private life your public life people don’t know that and you don’t want them to know that but your private life people do it’s the people that are in your in your close network that’s where you bond and build long-term relationships in your private life but that’s still not the the most sensitive space the most sensitive space is your secret life inside your secret life there’s usually nobody or maybe one or two others ever in your entire lifetime that will get into here this is where people know that that you used to torment animals when you were 11 years old this is the place where people know that you you know you slept with some girl in high school because you were drunk and you don’t even know who she was right this is the place where all of your shame and your guilt and your your darkest your darkest questions about yourself this is where that lives we all live in this place at some point every day but when we’re around people we’re either in our private life or a public life knowing that all people have these three lines the the tradecraft technique to win control over somebody is to get them to let you into this if you can sit next to somebody in their private life their loyalty to you is beyond question because subconsciously they

1:35:22 Know that they’ve been compromised you know their darkest secrets so subconsciously they know that’s true but prefrontal cortex rational thinking what they’re thinking is it’s the only person I trust right I trust this person with my life I would go to war with this person I would trust this person you know with whatever I hope this person takes care of my kids if I ever die that’s the person who lives in your private life so when you’re trying to secret life your secret life yeah yeah when you’re when you want to win control over this person all you have to do is get into their secret life and then they rationalize that they trust you subconsciously they know they have to right they kind of retrofit it well once they let you in they can’t you don’t get out right because then and okay cuz the once you’re in then of course the con the front vortex says well that I have to trust them and now I do trust them and then they start making these decisions like that they’re maybe don’t seem rational at all correct because I mean you’ve seen this happen it’s common in cults it’s common in in hostage situations that’s not what that syndrome is that is exactly that is it really yeah even though they don’t necessarily know your secret life but in those situations specifically what ends up happening is the hostage is under hostile control for so long right that their their shame and their guilt is tied into the

1:36:40 Fact that they’re a hostage right like they’ve they’ve defecated in front of you they’ve thrown up on you maybe you’ve raped them as the crit as the as the hostage taker maybe you’ve raped the hostage well now all of this person’s darkest most shameful memories basically all involve you anyways so then they get confused and essentially they feel a sense of loyalty to you because you’ve you’ve seen them through this despicable series of activities and nobody else out there will ever accept them Wow yeah we’ve seen it where they’ll go and try to defend these people in trials and all and it was like what are you talking about this person that did all these things to you Ponzi schemes advanced scams con men these are all con the word con in con man you know what the word con stands for I do because I read your stuff but tell people it stands for confidence a con man is really just a confidence man and that doesn’t mean that that person it doesn’t mean a con man doesn’t appear to you as a confident person a con man wins you over because they make you feel confident and then in your confidence you associate it with them so now you’re like oh it’s you and me against the world that’s what a con is interesting a con makes you feel confident and to do something and later you realize wasn’t the right thing to do you may never realize it was the wrong thing to do right because you’ll always defend it now that secret world I mean how do you get in

1:38:13 There because most people guard it with their lives and like almost quite literally only let one or two people in there their whole life yeah and it’s it so the way you get in is by understanding first that most people actually don’t guard it for many people it’s not that they’re taking active precautions to prevent people from going in for most people it’s the fact that nobody’s interested right no one ever looked but it’s in plain sight and especially if you’re trained to see it you could see it pretty quickly correct even by observing them correct my questions yeah a couple questions simple observation and then of course also understanding that everybody’s conditioned differently conditioning is how you’re raised your everybody’s brain is trained that’s the term is conditioned it’s conditioned by their culture their religion their education their parents everybody’s conditioned to get to someone’s most darkest secrets in their secret life you have to first learn how they’ve been conditioned and accept how they’ve been conditioned but essentially what happens is we’re all living our lives like we’re the most important person we’re the center of the show we’re the center of the universe we’re all that matters and when you take two people who both believe that they’re the most important thing in the world and you put them in the room together they’re competing for attention they’re not they’re not

1:39:32 Giving each other attention they’re competing for attention I I cook a really good steak oh well I cook a better steak or I was taught to make steaks by a by my dad I was taught to make steaks by a gourmet chef everybody’s competing for attention that’s what social media is when you flip the script and you’re the person in the room who’s not competing for attention you’re giving attention freely to the other person what ends up happening is they reveal things they talk outside of school they give too much information they compromise themselves just because their defensive technique they know how to fight against someone who’s not giving them attention they don’t really know how to defend against someone who is giving them attention right and then that’s how you very quickly become you cut through someone’s public life and get into their private life just because you’re giving them attention and then you just kind of keep on pouring on the attention you start asking leading questions you start using like authentic vulnerabilities of your own yeah and they’ll gonna they’ll bring you into their own their merrier vulnerabilities when you give them something from you they’ll tell you something from them yep perhaps funny thing about vulnerabilities are they don’t have to be true right you can say stuff like you know my marriage has been really rough and sometimes they really just think about whether I should just cheat on my wife just to

1:40:50 Try it just once and if they’re already cheating in their private life that’s the kind of person that’s like oh man I totally know what you’re talking about and then boom let me bring you into my private life right and if it’s someone really guarded maybe they don’t react the way that they would if they weren’t and then you know something’s there so you can try a few of these and even if they don’t go right away depending on if they if they don’t overreact or react the same way then you’re like okay there’s something there right back to that and what’s interesting is once you’re in someone’s private life trying to break into secret life they also without training like what I’m giving you right now is what we at CIA would call this you you are now trained you’re trained in this technique so now whenever you and I talk about this technique we’re talking as peers right this is a technique and we’re talking about it so we’re trained untrained people they don’t have the vocabulary they don’t understand the science of it but they may still feel intrinsically like it’s true so intrinsically when you’re in a private relationship with somebody you already anticipate that they’re gonna share vulnerabilities with you and that some of those vulnerabilities are gonna make you feel uncomfortable and some of those vulnerabilities are gonna be things that you can relate to so what ends up happening is as you’re probing to get

1:42:00 Into their secret life they just feel like you’re that much more invested in the private relationship that you have so you’re exactly right you can keep probing you can keep testing you can keep exploring until you hit the right nerve to get in you won’t have to explore very much because what’s really happening is you’re always pouring the attention on to them so they just they walk you they walk you right there it’s the same technique that you can use we’re talking about it in human espionage terms just think about how this applies to the average middle manager right the average middle manager who isn’t important enough to own the business gets ignored by the boss wonders whether or not he’s going to get the promotion to vice president or director he’s got all sorts of concerns and stress in his life but every employee that works for him is oblivious to it and they don’t care if anything they probably think that the manager’s life is easy so one employee who comes in and shows the manager attention and accepts and kind of shares with the manager what the manager already knows is hard about their life that manager now prefers that employee over all other employees just because they get they understand the private life of that manager what can’t you ask that person to do ask them for a choice assignment ask them for a choice project ask them for a promotion ask them for a good review at the end of the year you can ask them

1:43:23 For anything and the chances the probabilities of them saying yes or much higher how long is it took you to get from someone into someone’s secret life from meeting them it depends on the it depends on the person but I would say if you’re if you’re dealing with an average bell curve person right normal cognitive ability normal education normal life normal existence right you can probably get into their secret life I would say within about 30 hours of contact 30 hours of personal contact 30 hours okay so whether that means you go on a road trip with them or whether that means you have dinner once a week for 30 weeks it’s I would say it takes just a little bit longer than a day in terms of total time on target and it really is logging time that’s the metric that’s consistent like you said road trip you know it’s just longer adding up it has to be continued of continuous not necessarily not necessarily because it’s really yeah what’s interesting about people is people don’t change quickly people largely stay pretty consistent it’s why if you’ve ever had a friend that you haven’t seen in five years and then you see them and you’re caught up in like 15 minutes yeah they’re pretty much still the same person a little gray or a little extra wrinkles but they’re the same person right we don’t change we don’t evolve very quickly so because of that we can use that to our advantage when you’re trying to build access to that secret

1:44:41 Life because they don’t change much which means oh right when you you start going in and digging in and you come back a week later you haven’t changed enough to where you have to rework it right if they care about their daughter when their daughter’s two right guess what they’re gonna do when their daughter’s seven okay still care about their daughter is this the bulk of the work you do but you did as an operative yeah as a field officer collecting intelligence in the field the vast majority of what you do is you cultivate relationships to get high-impact secrets sometimes you’re cultivating relationships from a total stranger right so you meet them for the first time and then you have to log those 30 60 90 hours whatever might be based on the culture because cultures are all different you log the hours you build the trust and then you start exploring what secrets they’re willing to share now versus what secrets they may not share until you’ve had another 60 90 120 hours of time on target before they’ll actually share so that’s what that’s that’s called a full lifecycle development or a full lifecycle recruitment you go from from there a normal person all the way to there they’re a faithful reliable source of secrets all you have to do is ask it’s a full lifecycle recruitment and they know who you are sometimes sometimes sometimes you need to tell them because that makes them feel special or confident it’s

1:46:03 Another form of letting them into your secret life okay by the way I’m I was sent here to do this what you say by the way I’m this guy sometimes sometimes you say exactly that phrase right hey you suspect you suspect that I’m intelligence and you’re right and I’m here to help you and we can still be friends and we can still have a symbiotic relationship because you know what they want now and right it sticks together correct sometimes it goes wrong I guess and sometimes it goes wrong it and very it rarely goes wrong because there’s a natural human tendency to rationalize the choices that we make so oftentimes even if somebody gets to the point where you’re where you come out and you tell them hey I’m I’m CIA and I can get your information into the most important hands in the world and and we can make your family stronger and more resilient because of it even if they know it’s the wrong thing to do they’re thinking in their mind frontal cortex rational mind they’re thinking I suspected this I kept meeting with this person I kept doing this thing I’ve already given him secrets I’ve let him pay for how many dinners he’s taken me to the Bahamas and back I’m already in too deep so let’s keep going right and if anything now they’re like can we keep it secret like you’re not gonna tell anybody you’re not gonna write and you’re like oh no we’re gonna meet in secret we’re gonna have secret communications channels we’re gonna do

1:47:28 Secret this secret this secret this and that actually makes them feel comfortable okay now all of a sudden you’re like we’re gonna be super secret no one’s even gonna know and that comforts them but they won’t get found out okay um you’re a guy I’m sure there’s women in the CIA do the women use sex or sexual attraction to get the job done and then and is that common and there are there rules and limitations and does that work better so first let me let me make sure I highlight that yes there are women and not all relationships are are man to woman right so sometimes you will find yourself in a case where the person is cooperating with you and they are a man because they are attracted to you right so especially in parts of the world where homosexuality is still heavily hidden you may not even realize that you’re dealing with someone who has interpreted your interactions as romantic interactions okay so yes it happens it have attraction happens and it happens often it’s something you’re kind of looking for because it shows that someone is moving from public life into private life because now they’re acting in ways that show their attraction you don’t want that it’s not better the whole idea of sex espionage the whole idea of sexual intimacy as a recruiting tool is fraught with danger because a true institutionalized asset is an asset that can that will provide secrets to anybody in your agency you just are the

1:49:00 One that institutionalized and prepared them because what could be even more secret than you and me meeting in secret if I’m not even the one meeting you if you’re meeting with my friend Buster right so now I need you to talk to Buster and not talk to me and that’s gonna keep it even more secret that you’re talking to me right and that’s that takes an institutionalized person who understands on a core basis of benefit and risk and if you have a sexual relationship or a romantic relationship right away you can’t turn that over to somebody else okay but I’m guessing it gets even worse because sexual relationships imply emotion and that emotion can change we all are in relationships correct so talk about make one day wake up and just say I don’t like that with him and look what he’s been doing with me and make an emotional rational decision that a friend would never make right Emma I’m just guess no you’re right you’re right you’re right because you’re understanding human beings you’re proving the power of the tradecraft tradecraft is not magic it’s not even it’s not even really science it’s just understanding how the human existence how the human experience is already built into us already wired into us we give more freedom and more allowance to a friend than we do to a sexual partner or an intimate partner we will forgive a friend easier than we will forgive an intimate partner we have lower expectations of a friend than we do of an intimate partner we will see a friend

1:50:21 And that friend could get fat hairy whatever and we don’t care they’re still our friend but uh whoever your physical intimate partner is if they get fat and hairy you’re kind of like I’m not really so interested in you anymore it’s a completely different type of relationship so what we want is not just that friend status but the best friend status even better the confidant status you know me so well I trust you with everything right okay that being said sometimes the sex can get you in the door with someone who’s hard to crack or faster or sometimes it can it can make something happen the the appeal right the appeal can get you in the door but you know you it’s important for us all on the inside professional intelligence officers and I’m speaking from the United States point of view Russia absolutely still engages in what’s known as Ravens and raw and I just lost Robbins yeah it might be Ravens and Robin birds okay yeah but they like male sex operations and female sex operations sparrows sparrows and Ravens okay so Russia is still very active in in sparrows and Ravens if you get someone to have sex with you they’re compromised period and because they do seeding operations get them to have sex with you and then get them to marry you and then be married to them forever and just always keep just sucking up secrets right that’s that’s their mo can you also use the sex act as a tool later for threatening and leverage and things like

1:51:49 That too in in places like Russia and China they absolutely do that right CIA we have all sorts of challenges that prevent us from going down that road and then we’ve also got best practices that prevent us from going down that road so for example every CIA officer in the United States is a US citizen it’s illegal to force a US citizen to commit an act that they don’t want to commit right you can’t you can’t make a soldier have sex with somebody else you can’t make a spy have sex with somebody else that’s it goes against our own values and human rights that are protected and codified by law so that’s one reason why we don’t do it even though we see some of the benefits to it we don’t do it ourselves but that doesn’t mean that a female a female case officer who’s handling a male target and that male target is sexually charged by that female case officer there’s nothing that says we can’t have that female case officer hire a prostitute on behalf of that target and then basically be like hey you know I want to be your friend but I understand you have needs I want to help you have those needs satisfied so here you go that’s how you get into someone’s private life and secret life okay gotcha and it’s probably it’s probably even even better correct like so you guys are actually cuz who’s in control in that situation right and you don’t have that a weird emotional charge that can go hot and cold and ruin the operation correct and now that every

1:53:12 Time that that asset of that target wants another prostitute right they just go back to the same person and say hey we did it once could you hook me up again could you take care of me again right that’s an outside United States I know it’s very uncomfortable for people in the United States to think about prostitution or human trafficking or sex trafficking it’s very common in the rest of the world so it’s that’s a tool that compromises many many people Wow okay just to finish off with some of the tradecraft things I mean I think you covered some pretty interesting stuff is there anything else alongside of that tradecraft thing that’s the stuff that you use on a regular basis that is important for people to understand so the one that I always want to make sure people understand is the power of questions right most we’ve talked a lot about control if you’re not in control then you’re being controlled one of the simplest ways to understand how control works is when you recognize that asking questions puts you in control we think that if we’re the one talking we’re in control it couldn’t be more wrong in this conversation that you and I are having you’re in control you’re asking the question I’m responding to the question you’re choosing the direction of the conversation you’re choosing how long we sit here and talk you’re choosing when and how much you’re gonna let me share because you can interrupt me at any time because you’re the one in

1:54:33 Control right when when we let ourselves ramble and talk all the time what we’re actually doing is giving up control the people around us aren’t even listening to us anymore when you’re the person who sits there and chooses selectively when to interrupt with a question you’re taking control and you’re taught this and to do that to a very high level black belt level to where you can guide things peak things and take them places they never thought they could go in five questions correct getting to the secret life I guess correct always not always it takes you can always get there you can always get there it’s just a matter of efficiency it’s a matter of how many resources it takes how many hours on target it takes because every hour that you spend on one target is an hour you don’t spend on another target right and you’re taught not to let anyone in the secret place correct we’re taught that our secret place is where we are compromised now does that does that save us no there are plenty of former CIA officers who become spies for a foreign government we’ve had three of them arrested in 2021 right it’s it’s a it’s a gentleman’s game but it’s still a very real skill based game and when Russians the Chinese have really been eating the unit the the US they’ve been eating our lunch cracking into CIA contractors CIA staff officers they’ve been doing incredible things to penetrate the US intelligence infrastructure with American

1:56:02 Assets with American assets Chinese handlers right recruiting American assets who are also inside CIA FBI NSA or inside the military industrial complex in Booz Allen or or Raytheon or you know you name it that’s who they’re targeting right now and they know they know how to get into an Americans head hmm have I had CIA assets on my show it’s I I would I wouldn’t say that I know whether you’ve had assets on your show but I would absolutely say that your show has come under scrutiny of some intelligence service somewhere okay because it’s what you create is too valuable for them to ignore it they could you’re you’re bringing in world leaders you’re bringing in leaders in their industry you’re bringing in minds that are on the cutting edge of innovation you’re essentially doing most of the targeting for them and then you’re having these personal conversations where they’re sharing information that most people don’t know it’s a valuable intelligence source so I’m doing trade craft for them you’re doing trick well if they’re listening you know where to send a check I mean I go deep here cuz like a lot of times I’ll go deep with people to where you know they’ll telling me things I’ve never ever talked about before that’s what makes our episodes really good sometimes but I’m sure I’ve you know compromised some people we’re taking them to some secret places they’ve compromised themselves man right you just led the way I just let

1:57:31 The way um do you miss being in CIA I don’t miss it I don’t miss the work sometimes I miss the people because the people are really pretty special they they sacrifice everything to keep us safe to keep my mom safe and my kids safe and my grandparents safe and like those are those are the kind of people I like hanging out with but I do not miss the work as interesting as it is it’s complicated disappointing dark work it’s not as it’s not nearly as fulfilling to me as what I find in the outside world where you get to have real impact on people’s lives you get to build genuine relationships you get to create something productive instead of always creating something that’s destructive right intelligence is something that you create so that you can dismantle somebody else’s plans so it’s it’s like to karma yeah a little bit did that bother you that your relationships were mostly not genuine it didn’t bother me as much prior to having a family when I was 28 years old and CIA asked me to to be a spy I was you couldn’t get me to say yes fast enough right it’s just like let’s go let’s go it’s gonna be an awesome life but then I fell in love with my wife who I met at CIA we had our first child who was born when we were undercover and now all of a sudden priorities changed and now it wasn’t just my life now it was my life intertwined with my wife’s life and intertwined with my child’s life and the decisions I made impacted both of them so

1:59:06 It became something where I was very realistically I very intense intentionally and intensely I wanted to have a life with relationships that were genuine for them and for me because when daddy comes home that energy rubs off on them because otherwise it’s not going to affect your daughter when she’s one to five if you’re still in the field except maybe you don’t see her right but other than that would it no it’s it was more about being able to have friends that grew up with my kids and being able to know that the people I’m bringing into the house are truly genuine friends never sure because yeah you’re never really sure and especially when you know for a fact that you’re bringing in bad guys because you’re trying to cultivate a relationship with a bad guy you would do that bring them into your house oh yeah that’s I just assume you’re overseas in Afghanistan somewhere no no oh thank you yeah you’re in g7 countries yeah absolutely at home sometimes absolutely just think about it just just one of the best ways to get someone to disarm someone is to put them in front of your toddler let them carry your baby right it’s it’s laughable no I laugh you just cuz but yeah when I was in the city like some of my broker buddies would say the same thing yeah take their client out and put the baby in their hands it was like a running joke because like after he does that then he kind of almost has to do business with it exactly at least can’t jack you over in

2:00:27 The field as quickly all right so you would use these techniques all right that’s a bear all in in CIA you’re all in you have to be all in what do what other option is there you can’t be like one foot in just to see I’m assuming that like you when you’d go overseas and you do it over there and you know it’s most of the time most of the time you’re using your family as a tool in your tool that your tool a tool in your tool belt to make it happen your whole family has gone overseas with you right your whole family is deploying with you it’s not sometimes in a place like Afghanistan yes they’re they’re remote assignments and you might go and you might do something for three months or six months by yourself but if you’re gonna go to Paris your whole family’s going to Paris if you’re gonna go to Kuala Lumpur your whole family’s going to Kuala Lumpur and it’s just a revolving door of of interesting targets maybe they’re Russian maybe they’re Chinese maybe they’re terrorists maybe they’re traffickers but they’re if if a child and a homemade spaghetti dinner is gonna disarm them enough that you can ask questions that get you into their private life it’s game on that’s what CIA operatives do in all girl operatives in all countries do and that makes that that’s dangerous for their families correct and the guy is the 50 year old guy in the CIA that’s been doing that for 30 years like what happens does he go through multiple

2:01:44 Marriages yes does the family know sometimes the families know sometimes the families don’t know but now you’re getting into the place where where when when you’re a 50 year old man at CIA you were probably recruited in your late 20s so you’ve been doing the job for 20 something years it only takes about four or five years before you start realizing you’re controlled so to continue on for another 20 years you have made the choice to compromise yourself to CIA you have made the choice to put CIA above your benefit your best interest and your family’s best interest and that is exactly why there is rampant alcoholism narcotics abuse divorce adultery it’s a it’s a hard existence to make a career out of being at CIA and the longer you’re there the more you compromise yourself the easier and the better it is for CIA to keep you there because now they get all of your experience but they also need to keep you there so that you don’t end up becoming a loose cannon or a liability okay you said since 2016 there’s massive attrition in the CIA but surely this stuff has been going on for 50 years or ever since I guess World War two was over so why now so the attrition is I think a sign of cultural change to two big things happened first after 9-11 the intelligence community completely transformed it tripled in size by demand from the Congress and the 9-11 Commission the 9-11 reports they funded and enforced the intelligence community

2:03:19 To rapidly expand the intelligence community didn’t know how to be big it only knew how to be small because that’s what it was during the Cold War so now all of a sudden we have thousands of spies when we used to have hundreds of spies and we have all of this effort on the global war on terror so we’re filling up bases in Afghanistan and we’re filling up bases in Iraq and remember we’re not just filling up the one place in Kabul we’re filling up multiple military bases in multiple rings around the country and the same thing going on in Iraq right trying to grow an intelligence network to combat terrorism and terrorism was happening everywhere so you’re sending counter-terrorism officers to all different parts of the world anywhere where terrorism is either transiting or where it’s being staged so you’re talking about Pakistan you’re talking about Dubai you’re talking about the UK any place where where terrorists would either target transit or train that’s where your your spies are going to try crack hat nut well then you spin down the global war on terror so you know president Trump comes in he starts he on his own was a leader that created division at CIA because he didn’t trust CIA and CIA serves at the behest of the president so people who had spent their four eight ten years of their career building up their CIA career to then have a president that just rejects basically anything from CIA should he have

2:04:46 Trusted the CIA I president Trump exercised his rights as the executive he’s the customer when you’re the customer you should have sold decision like sold discretion over what you purchase he didn’t want to purchase from CIA it didn’t help that CIA you know accused him of being a Russian plant and all of the stuff about espionage and none of that’s gonna help make the president want to do business with you but president Trump was just the first one to say you know what I’m not I’m not gonna fund you I’m not gonna listen to you I’m not gonna respect or appreciate you I’m gonna find other means to do it because the CIA is thinking we have longer-term goals than this president that shows up every four years correct so they would argue we’re doing the right thing for the country correct then you said the customer quote unquote is Trump who’s just saying you guys aren’t doing what I want you to do correct and then they’re doing power struggles back and forth correct and there’s really no power struggle right when you can just take away funding and shut down operations so then you ended which you did okay so then you end up having all these career professionals who are defunded and now instead of doing interesting things like they wanted they’re they’re doing peon stuff piss on stuff that that nobody cares about and they don’t know how long it’s gonna last is this four years or is this the next eight years of my

2:05:58 Career right am I gonna am I gonna retire under a Trump administration and that’s enough uncertainty that many of them on either on principle or out of fear of the future of their career they just chose to bail and then there was a huge flood of people leaving CIA and going into the commercial sector which is also dangerous which is also dangerous because why you get spies in the corporate business you get spies in the corporate business who only know how to do one thing and they’re not doing they’re not transitioning because they’re excited to start businesses or be in corporate America they’re just running away from something so now they’re all like they’re they’re loose cannons they’re unpredictable they they’re a variable that no one can account for and what do they end up doing potentially many of them ended up going and becoming intelligence officers for other countries training or carrying on mercenary intelligence operations it became so common in fact that in 2020 I think in 2020 or 2021 CIA sent out an official statement telling CIA officers ex-CI officers to stop working for foreign governments stop accepting foreign contracts stop working for foreign governments or they could face prosecution in the future even I was picked up to go to Dubai I was picked up to go to Abu Dhabi working for a commercial company that I later found out was just a cutout for the Emirati government right and as soon as my wife

2:07:23 And I figured that out we were in that position where we were like well this is not what we thought we were doing right so we chose to leave and build our business a different way what’s a cutout it’s the the cutout or the idea of an umbrella company means that there’s a larger parent company that controls the decisions and then they just subsidize or they they create a subsidiary that’s a different name maybe a different majority owner but they still they still own the subsidiary okay right so that’s why you’re working for a corporation because basically the government correct and the work you were doing you’re like I’m just working for another government and I don’t want to do that and not only that but I’m working for a foreign government right just with legal or not illegal but definitely not smart okay yeah so that the big big chunk of people went and did that and then a lot of people went into security space a lot of people went into the private intelligence space private intelligence was how Trump got around CIA he just hired private intelligence firms to become his new CIA sounds like a mess it’s it’s it was an interesting time because there’s things that the privatized world can do that the bureaucratic world cannot right so there were some very beneficial discoveries out of it but then at the same time you don’t have the strict oversight of security clearances and controlled information etc etc so it gets

2:08:47 It definitely gets messy did you watch that movie on Netflix called gray man oh yeah I’m actually friends with the guy who did who was the CIA advisor on that on the side for okay for gray man so that crazy guy was the private contractor who do whatever he wanted correct who was former CIA right now I get it and he was like I don’t give a shit cuz I’ll do whatever I want I couldn’t really get it at the time but it just plays okay so that’s all real that’s all real it’s fascinating because I don’t know much about what you do or did but it felt real like and it felt very complicated but so that was all somewhat accurate yeah I mean gray man is a gray man is a great flick it’s a great movie it was great movie I loved it it’s a great movie and and I wouldn’t say that the operations are representative of what we actually do there’s they’re way too wasteful too explosive too dangerous whatever else but the relationships between the contractor the CIA officer the CIA officer to the other CIA officers like their relationships and specifically the way that they talked to each other was that is exactly how we talk to each other we are derogatory and we are crass and we are cold when we talk to each other because there’s no reason to be anything else right there’s no reason to sugarcoat stuff we just just tell me tell me how it is because we mainly have 15 seconds to talk there’s no HR department not in the field okay yeah

2:10:01 It reminded me of Wall Street on the trading desk yeah where it’s just like Lee said we don’t have much time and we don’t give a shit and there’s money on the line and that’s all that matters anyway correct so fuck you and if you’re junior then you’d be treated that way and and if you’re junior and you get treated that way and you keep up you’ve got a you’ve got a rock-solid career ahead of you right yeah and yeah and you respect and then you treat the next junior the same way yeah and I actually kind of miss those days a little because it was real I guess you could say it was very operational man it’s very tactical yeah there’s something you take an action you see the benefit of the action you move on to the next action everything’s a five meter target go go go go go yeah we get older we get more skilled than a different set of skills and now we’re shooting at 25 meter targets and I don’t know if you shoot guns when you fire a 25 meter target it takes a while after you’re out after you’re out of bullets it takes a while to walk down 25 meters and then see how you did it’s not like five meters where you just fire and you see a hole it takes a while to get the feedback so it’s a very different kind of life now right it’s yeah and if you try to bring that life into the corporate life they’re not used to it they’re not ready for you right they want you to adapt to this new world maybe a politically correct world

2:11:14 Kindler gentler world a woke world a woke world it’s it’s hard to deal with it first cuz it doesn’t always work work or maybe what doesn’t it doesn’t transmit information accurately enough I was talking to a good buddy of mine at NSA who’s who since out of NSA and we were specifically talking about the woke movement and I was asking like you know what is your thoughts on when you sit across from somebody who insists that you use pronouns or you know whatever it is you you you’re sitting across from clearly a female who insists that they’re male or clearly a male who insisted their female and classic classic intelligence officer answer he was like it’s real to them doesn’t have to be real to me he’s like if I want them to get closer to where I need them to get I’ll call them whatever they want to be called right because they’re going to see me respecting their status as a sign that they can trust me he’s like I don’t have to actually believe it I just have to call them they or them if that’s what they want to be called it doesn’t have to make sense hmm it’s interesting yeah I gotta ask you a couple topical questions do it Jeffrey Epstein did he kill himself I you know I don’t have the answer to that I’ve if I did have the answer that I would tell everybody but I do think that it’s a it’s shrouded in mystery it’s one of those conspiracies that may very well turn out to be true and those are the worst kinds of

2:12:31 Conspiracies because those are what make more conspiracies happen okay and then him as an individual do you think he was compromised by intelligence absolutely absolutely he was compromised by intelligence a man like that as connected as he was with the with the vulnerabilities that he had the Russians would be interested the Israelis would be interested the Columbia’s would Columbians would be interested I mean the British would be interested he was absolutely an intelligence target if not a full-blown asset for somebody and he might have known it or not known it correct being used as an asset correct and most likely most likely he would have accepted it if he knew it because he would have seen it as an insurance policy against all the other buffoonery that he was and he was the greatest operative ever because he was using everyone else’s assets true also yeah and it’s so he wouldn’t be an operative he would be an asset right he wasn’t trained by an intelligence service he was recruited as a source of information by a trained intelligence officer but he’s exactly the kind of person that we would be looking for not not Americans Americans don’t recruit other Americans but to an Israeli or to a Russian or to a Chinese he would he’s a fantastic fit he’s hanging out with all of the elite in the United States and all of the elite in other parts of the world and not not to do wine cruises at sunset right he’s he’s

2:13:51 Doing illegal acts with the most elite people in the world compromising them and getting their information it’s a it’s a spies dream it’s a smorgasbord right so he’s like I want to be on the island and there and I’ve just got you know I’ve got a decades where the work correct right there in my lap yep I know this guy was doing this with doing this was doing this and I’ve got all this stuff so right and if you’re the handling officer like it couldn’t have been an easy job because Epstein had an ego he had you probably couldn’t trust everything that he said he’s he was probably not a a well-vetted or authentic source but in terms of access and even just being able to you could just put a chip on the guy’s shoulder and suck up cell phone data from the people he was hanging out with and that alone would be an intelligence operation worth it you just mentioned cell phones what about tech and Pegasus and is this stuff people need to think about is it becoming something that’s gonna be more prevalent in the future or is it just happening all all the time right now Pegasus is this virus I guess you can put on iPhones that basically take over the iPhone and I don’t know you know more about so when it comes to tech stuff when it comes to data I think it’s important for people to understand that there is no privacy there is no digital privacy that you can reasonably expect everything everything technological that we touch was created for our

2:15:17 Convenience that’s why technology exists it’s for our convenience when something’s built for your convenience it has to pay itself off some other way so partially they collect our data so that they can make the process they can make the system better so they learn what we’re interested in and then they roll that out in the iPhone 13 a right whatever it might be or the Google pixel you know to why who knows what it’s gonna be called but they’re they partially collect your information to improve the quality of the system but they also collect your information so they can create big data sets that they use to create new offerings that they already know you’re gonna be interested in or to sell the data to advertisers or other businesses that want your that want the data from your target set those are two main areas where your data is compromised the third big area is that the government by law cannot collect your personal data but the government can by law purchase your personal data from a place where you have given them permission to collect your personal data so most of the government’s data sets don’t actually come from them collecting the data that’s a very expensive operation they can just write a check and basically become a monthly subscriber to Google data services or Apple data services or you know the Amazon data services you name it and that’s the way they collect your data and it’s fully legal then because the

2:16:49 The company has your permission to collect data and the company has signed a contractual agreement with a user okay now did they give up all of your data then to the government or is that why you want end-to-end encryption and how reliable is that I was in Dubai recently and one guy said what’s up it goes to CIA telegram it goes to the Russians close what he said telegram goes to Russians whatsapp goes to the Chinese signal goes to the Israelis really yeah what’s up goes to the Chinese what’s up goes to the Chinese isn’t it meta meta that has that company they own it they own it they didn’t build it it was built by a Chinese company and they set the data out of there yeah yeah still absolutely that’s how the world works man so it’s tick-tock is developed by the Chinese right Huawei basically is the manufacturer for all satellite or all communication systems that sit at the top of our nuclear silos around the world around the country so that’s a Chinese company that owns the communication systems that communicate between missile silos so it’s it’s a messed up world in many many ways but but to your point the the data that’s shared is not necessarily the data that we think is shared end-to-end encryption and what you’re actually sending on signal or what you’re actually sending on whatsapp the the data itself the message the plaintext message is encrypted end-to-end nothing else is encrypted end-to-end who

2:18:16 You are who you’re sending it to what your cell phone numbers are the date timestamps on when you sent it the geographical location of your cell phone and their cell phone when you sent it when they received it all of that which is known as metadata all that metadata is is open open to whoever controls the platform that provides the service that is way more interesting than the comment inside right nobody cares about you and I having a virtual conversation about the World Cup that’s wasted time to review that but what they do care about is if you and I are connected via cell phone then what cell phones are you connected with and what cell phones that you’re connected with are also connected to my cell phone right and how can we try and how can I say intelligence apparatus use that to get closer to you me or one of your guests because I’m guessing many of your guests also give you their cell phone number so now they essentially have the cell phone number of your guests that ever having to go to your guests so my day is being tracked by intelligence services if I was if I sat in China or Russia or Israel I would make you a priority target okay and they can I am too don’t worry welcome to the club it’s okay and do they put like Pegasus on my phone or they can just do it through data services they wouldn’t want to put Pegasus on your here’s the problem if they put Pegasus on your phone they take control of your phone but as soon as you find

2:19:31 Pegasus on your phone the whole phone gets tossed you get a new phone a new SIM card a new IMEI identifier and now they have to start all over again and now I’m more aware as well right the people who want to take control of your phones those are not intelligence services those are criminals cyber criminals want to take over your phone because they’re trying for a different goal the short con just to grab things yes yeah it’s not even really a con it’s a hack right what the what formal intelligence services want to do is give you confidence confidence that your information is secure confidence that your information is yours to control and what like it’s a con you have the confidence in a con not them so they want you to feel confident and comfortable because people who are confident and comfortable they act in okay you mentioned Mossad earlier what’s Mossad like you know we know the CIA you know you mentioned some of these other intelligence services how are they different how’s the relationship or the respect from CIA Mossad is more like the CIA that we see in the movies than we are CIA in real life is more like office space or the office it’s really more like silly cubicles and interpersonal dynamics and who brought the cookies today and who brought the donuts yesterday kind of thing it’s really not as interesting as the movies make it out to be Mossad is more like the CIA you see in the movies they are

2:20:53 Extremely professional they’re they actually do seem to kind of fit a hiring motif like they are fit they are usually good-looking like they they are quite particular about who they let in CIA will let in all different types partially because they want a diverse workforce but also partially because they’re regulated by federal regulations that they have to not discriminate based off of looks age gender pregnancy status whatever else right so we have all these different these laws in place that that the agency has to adhere to as a government organization not every government does that and then Mossad is also they they face a very different threat than what we what we face we’re not facing existential threats there’s nobody out there who’s trying to eradicate the United States there are multiple countries out there trying to eradicate the entire existence of Israel yeah so different nexus different tolerance for risk and a different level of of rashness in the kind of operations they run that doesn’t mean they’re sloppy it just means that they’re bold right and they’ll do things that other agencies won’t do because we’re too afraid of well what if it lands on the front page of the New York Post right they’ll just assassinate people and jack them and do all sorts of crazy stuff they’ll let it land on the front page of the post at least the guys dead that that shooting of that Iranian nuclear scientist guy with that remote

2:22:17 Controlled gun out of a flatbed truck or something that happened a year ago I was pretty impressed with that they’re either they’ve dropped motorcycle bombs bombs with like sticky bombs that they just they drive by on a motorcycle and stick it right at the car and then drive on right there’s it’s that’s the kind of stuff that American CIA officers we like dream of being able to do that sort of thing but we’ll never be able to get just a couple more digital questions if I want to go off the grid right now and just completely disappear could I do it absolutely really absolutely you could and it wouldn’t be as hard as you think it’s just a matter of recognizing that when you’re off the grid it’s not you that’s off the grid it’s your devices that are off the grid right right now Brian Rose is defined in your mind as you the man in the suit who has your beliefs your ideas and your intentions but to the larger world Brian Rose is defined as ones and zeros transmitted from your cell phone or if you have two cell phones from your two cell phones plus your iPad plus your laptop plus all the Wi-Fi places where you log in right that’s who defines you so if you wanted to go off the grid in many ways it would be as simple as just taking all your devices and putting them on that desk right there and then walking out the door the whole world would think that you’re right there in fact you would be somewhere else layer on

2:23:32 Top of that that you take your money out in cash instead of having it in in credit cards or bank accounts you don’t even take it all just take a chunk of it and then pay for cash pay for cash services with cabs pay for cash services when you go to the grocery store pay for train tickets airplane tickets boat tickets in cash harder to do these days only buy a little bit to do sometimes only if you’re really trying to go in and if you’re trying to take the most convenient or luxurious route it is very difficult to do I promise you that we could go to Gatwick Airport and there would be somebody there willing to fly us outside of outside of out of England for cash in their private plane not their private jet but in their private Cessna right somebody would say yes okay but they’d still stamp me at the border and that might be an electronic footprint if so we would find a way to pick an airport that didn’t do like an uncontrolled airport okay that doesn’t have passport control gotcha you’re a good guy to know all right and so then like you said stay off the digital grid use cash and then once you get to the other side yeah you can get right back on the digital grid because who’s Brian Rose these devices once if if you and I were to step outside right now and pick a lady’s pocket where she put her cell phone away but maybe didn’t lock it right away it would take us three seconds to pick her pocket and now we would have

2:24:53 Her cell phone to the grid who are we we are that lady they’re looking for you you’re sitting in here but now you have a fully working cell phone you can still use GPS you can order an uber you can do whatever you want to from that other person’s cell phone you can go right into settings and make sure that it doesn’t lock on you again okay right so I set up a new digital identity but the money thing is harder unless you’re because then to set up the bank account you need identification the way that you would handle that is if you if you wanted to retain your money if you had a large amount of money if you didn’t you’d have to find a way of making money correct which if you can start a business here you can start a business anywhere but my point is if you wanted to protect a large amount of money you’d have to send it to an offshore bank account you would incur fees to send it to the Bahamas or to st. Kitts or who knows wherever like you could send it somewhere where it’s now protected you’re not the owner by name you’re the owner by is by a code and then you’re all of your access credentials are verified by numerical codes so it doesn’t matter who you claim to be the person who owns that money is the person who knows those codes so now you put it all offshore it’s all coded and put away you cleanse yourself digitally you jump a border you reestablish yourself somewhere else and now you go right back and you put in your actual code and

2:26:08 Then you bring your money back to yourself again right that’s why offshore bank accounts are so valuable because they they are a barrier of privacy that keeps the owner away from trackable data that’s important if you’re like I mean imagine it’s not built for criminals it’s used by criminals it’s built for the billionaires out there who if somebody knew that you were a billionaire you’d be a target for a thousand and one reasons so now the billionaires have a way to basically put their money someplace where nobody knows that person is a billionaire and then I’d create a new identity at that point if you wanted to yeah essentially you would create an alias which wouldn’t be like a passport and a driver’s license it wouldn’t be bureaucratically covered it would just be a name that you choose and then I just stay away from the bureaucratic stuff try to live a life without a driver’s license or get some fake one to pass through the blah blah blahs correct stay off the grid which is doable it’s doable and it’s not that different even in the US in the US in the US so perfect example right if you wanted to live off the grid in the US you wouldn’t live on the East Coast or the West Coast you’d go into the Midwest when you want to live off the grid when you want to disappear from sight you have to go to more rural places where people are more trusting in general of other people and less dependent on technology so the same thing is true if you’re going into Europe or Asia or

2:27:30 Whatever else you’re gonna go in you’re gonna go deeper into the heart of whatever country you’re in which again is counterintuitive most people think if you want to hide if you want to hide close to a border if you want to hide you hide right in the heartland nobody’s looking for you there it’s fascinating okay so it’s doable mm-hmm okay you and I tell faces facial recognition software comes in you know what I bet you and I could do if you ever want to do an experiment I’ll bet we could get ourselves across the city of London with no identity and no money and I bet we could find a way to do it and nobody would know that we’re us in the process no identity well why would I normally identification well if you wanted to live off the grid you would essentially be traveling with no identity okay and no one would recognize me or I wouldn’t have to use my identity we would we wouldn’t use our identities because we would try to what I’m proposing in this experiment yeah is that we either dawn basic disguises and cover identities like you’re Bob and I’m Willie yeah who knows what we start here we pick some other location 25 miles away we leave all of our money and our digital identities here and we just go and you would be shocked at how easy it is to actually get other people like businesses you name it to just help you without any questions at all and boom you’re gone you’re gone and it’s cost you nothing imagine doing it’d be that

2:28:53 Much easier if you had your own cash it would be that much easier if you put the plan in place to put your money in offshore account but I’ve got the confidence that you and I could do it on a weekend all right it’s a date next time I really want to do this next time we London I really love to try some of this trade craft stuff awesome amazing there’s that movie spy game with Robert Redford and Brad Pitt where he kind of teaches him spycraft and he’s like see that woman up there you have to be having a coffee on her balcony in five minutes go do you know that movie and there’s like some of that accurate with the trade craft I don’t remember the movie I know of the movie I don’t remember the details but those are the kind of challenges not the five minute timeline is a little unrealistic but we actually do have week two at the farm you have a coffee challenge where you have to get somebody a stranger to buy you a free cup of coffee it’s one of the hardest challenges you have because it happens so early in your training they don’t really teach you how to do it they just teach you the skills around it and then you have to go make it happen and you’re often Langley at some Starbucks you’re not at Langley you’re at our secret training site but yeah oh so there’s but they’re real people there or there’s fake people there there’s there’s fake people on the site because it’s a controlled environment right but it’s a it’s close

2:30:00 Enough to cities and towns and whatever else okay that’s that some of our some of our missions are to go out and integrate into normal society and just see what it feels like to ask somebody for a free cup of coffee or trade your expertise in in football and see if somebody cares enough about your football experience to sit down and have a conversation with you when you say you have no wallet what do they do right it’s it’s that kind of experimentation okay the farm is the training ground for the CIA correct in Langley or in Virginia or other places correct in a secret location that is that I can’t disclose but it’s somehow on Wikipedia why is it called the farm it’s it’s called the farm because we’re a bunch of animals it’s basically all the students there are like animals and all of the instructors there are essentially our caretakers so they’re feeding us information they’re putting us through like we’re jumping through hoops for them we’re chasing our tails for them we’re doing all sorts of stuff for them it’s kind of a derogatory joke to talk about how we’re broken down into into farm animals it’s the CIA is much more like the military than I ever thought about it if you think of a CIA operative you don’t think of them as these you know loyal Americans that sacrifice themselves for country like you would like a Navy SEAL or that they get subjugated or a is during that but it’s very much like that

2:31:22 Isn’t it it is and it’s very you know it’s one of the things that keeps me out here talking about it all even though I know people don’t like hearing about it and people don’t agree with me and and I’m sure that there are plenty of people at CIA who cringe whenever they they hear my name but nobody nobody knows this there’s no reason that this information couldn’t have been shared by some other officer at some other point in history it’s just this unnecessary addiction that we have to secrets these the the true dedication and patriotism of CIA intelligence officers is something to be celebrated not something to be hidden and kept secret the next generation of CIA officers are going to be patriotic you know red white and blue-blooded heroes that will never ask for rewards or awards or even public attention they’re going to make all that sacrifice knowing that they’re not going to get recognition that is truly something that we should be celebrating and if if all I can do in my career is make sure that people understand like you just did have that realization where they realize like hey we’re not they’re not driving Lamborghinis eating at the best restaurants and staying in the nicest hotels they’re slumming it in third world countries where their life is very really at risk and where they most likely have food poisoning and they’re ruining their digestive system for the rest of their adult life that is much

2:32:45 More realistic about what’s going on in CA officers life but you’re doing a great job of recruiting for them yeah kind of me that does a joke either as well because if people know when they’re going into something they’re doing something you know really for their country you know and then people respect them for that of course maybe they can’t tell them what they’re doing yeah but maybe that helps Jason Bourne and the born identity movies are those more accurate than not I I really think that they’re more inaccurate than anything okay there I would love I’m sure that if we watched it together especially I’d be able to find something true about it but from the level of technology that they use to the whole the level of training that Jason Bourne has and all of the memory loss stuff and the real-time satellite tracking now that’s real but the mind games and the power battles in between them that’s real that may be real I don’t I don’t remember the movie well enough to be able to say you know an example of one way or the other what’s next for you and yeah what are the big things on your horizon I mean you consult companies right now some big ones like fortune 10 companies I guess you probably can’t tell me what you do for them but maybe I can and then personally you know what were your plans for the next five years yeah absolutely so I actually do quite a lot of executive coaching believe it or not I came in under the guise of you know offering services that gave them

2:34:05 Critical business intelligence instead what ended up happening is executive coaching happened business development happened helping folks with their HR departments their sales teams that’s much more of what I do now than I ever thought I would ever do to be very frank it’s been a interesting evolution in my business because I never would have thought that that would have been something that my skills would apply to until I started seeing how my skills applied so a big chunk of that is what the future holds we’re actually moving more into the realm of supporting high net worth and supporting senior executive individuals and teams in achieving business and entrepreneurial goals because the skills that we have applied very well in that space they’re not necessarily big companies but just like high net worth people are entrepreneurs not necessarily like fortune 10 companies sometimes yeah hundred thousand employees or 50,000 employees but also sometimes smaller groups correct so a lot so when you when you’re talking about ultra high net worth people oftentimes they created something and then they sold it off they had a big exit and now they’re independently wealthy trying to build something new so that’s one of those instances where they don’t have a big company but then what also happens is when you network with those individuals they also have a foot back in their own home company or they have peers in

2:35:18 Their network who run other companies so that’s where a lot of that that consulting and coaching happens is in those two arenas and then we have we have mainstream projects that we’re working on also we just recently signed a TV deal that for a new TV show that’s gonna go live in the US in the US is in summer of 2023 I’m in an NDA so I can’t talk about who or what or any of those things but it’s gonna be a ton of fun maybe if I get into your secret life you’ll tell me yeah we’re not there yet and then and then we’re also working on a book so my wife and I have created a book a memoir and we’re in the book proposal and we have you know our team of agents and writers and everything else that are helping us and we’re hoping to have that closed before the end of the year which would if I understand the publishing world it might be another 18 months before it goes live but those are two big mainstream projects that we’re working on and then we’re just constantly growing our own podcast and our own business and doing what we can to to spread the news and spread the skills and so you are a PhD in emotional intelligence is that what you would say I would that phrase I would never call myself a PhD I actually do like the phrase emotional intelligence okay I would just never I hesitate to ever call myself a master of something because there’s always people better than me you are that’s what you brought out of the CIA correct is

2:36:37 That emotional intelligence training and now you’re applying it in the civilian world in business so you go into someone’s business and you’ll say have you thought of this from an emotional intelligence perspective sort of we’ll go in there and we’ll say hey we’re gonna increase your sales conversion rates by by 11% and we’ll do it in 90 days and here’s how we’re gonna do it because we’re gonna do this with your sales staff we’re gonna do this with your customer base we’re gonna do this with your advertising we’re gonna do this with your marketing it’s ones and zeros it’s systematic you all it takes to get people to take action is to talk to them the way they want to be spoken to address the needs they believe are the most important needs to them show them a person who actually who seemingly cares for them and then the next the next step is they do what you tell them to do whether that’s giving you a credit card or signing up for your services or or pulling back a court order or or you know settling out of court it’s all very it’s all very predictable and very systematic but you have to get people past their inclination to fight right that’s people’s core inclination is this a battle of dominance it’s a battle of will if you want to really win the battle you got to be you got to look past the will and past the dominance because that’s what the other person’s focused on you want to be like if you think of a rock in a road if you’re

2:37:59 Focused on staying on the road you’re never gonna get past the boulder the advantage is that there’s all this space that’s not on the road if you can just work around the rock you win that’s that’s the hardest part of the day of the high net worth people by definition aren’t used to not fighting sometimes they’re not used to not fighting but they also absolutely understand the value of cheating or short cutting or working around that’s you don’t get to be ultra high net worth without knowing how to do you don’t get there without having a little bit of both right and they might sometimes have been stuck in a in a fighting loop in this area whereas but they have been in the other place before correct so they have been in a compromise or they have obviously recruited a lot of people to do what they want to do in order to get that position because otherwise they wouldn’t be there right that’s fascinating um well thank you Andrew really enjoyed this conversation my pleasure you can probably talk for six more hours I will take you up next time you’re London let’s do some tradecraft that’s awesome let’s do it I don’t know if we can film it but we can do it before and after or something like that and yeah if people want to get ahold of you websites podcast names all that stuff Twitter is best for you Twitter is best for me if you really don’t like me and you want to see what other people who really don’t like me have to say

2:39:08 That what happened hate follows I love hate follows on Twitter you know a lot of haters I got a lot of people hate you I think people hate me for a few reasons first they think that if I’m wrong it means that I’m a fake when your intelligence is hard wrong is what you are most of the time wrong is how you being able to say I was wrong is one of the things that make a really professional intelligence officer we don’t try to say oh we were right that’s that’s that’s fake stuff phonies say they’re always right anybody who’s successful knows mistakes and errors are part of the game you make them often because the more attempts the more times you swing the more chances you have to hit something out of the park but that means there’s a lot of strikes along the way so a lot of people hate me because they think that because I say something wrong I make a wrong prediction or I make a wrong assessment or I make a wrong analytical point that I’m not legitimately CIA so then they love to hate me but then there’s also plenty of people who just don’t like to hear the truth they don’t like to hear that CIA is that the United States is making good out of this war in Europe they don’t like to hear me talk about the fact that that Europe wants to separate itself from the United States or that China’s befriending Pyongyang and Iran and moving forward with a new kind of access they don’t like hearing that so they don’t want to hear that so they

2:40:35 Think that by yelling at me I’m gonna stop talking but to get to your point if you want to follow me on Twitter it’s at everyday spy feel free to blow me up there all of my social media handles are at everyday spy my home page my website is the best place to go hold me that’s everyday spy calm and then if you are a podcast person if you are into audio podcasts specifically I have an iTunes top 10 podcast called the everyday espionage podcast very cool awesome man very great meeting you I was watching you on some show a few months ago and I just told my team I was like we got to talk to Andrew and I’m so glad we did so to be continued next time you’re in London let’s have another conversation and do some tradecraft as well not that I’m looking to get off the grid but just you know just a case it’s good to know so yeah wishing you all the best minute and thanks so much for your honesty and I love talking real with real people so yeah appreciate what you do man my pleasure thanks for having me man next till next time you guys take care

London Real logo Chat
×

Private call with Brian Rose

See how the AI Investment Club works, and decide for yourself

Every Monday, AI founders pitch live to our members. Book a call to see if it's right for you.

Check Brian’s availability
Brian video thumbnail
Private call with Brian Rose
Watch Brian’s message