Home > Episodes > Andreas Antonopoulos > Andreas Antonopoulos - Episode 3 - Mastering Bitcoin & Cryptocurrencies And The Future Of Decentralised Finance
[captions_button]

Andreas Antonopoulos - Episode 3 - Mastering Bitcoin & Cryptocurrencies And The Future Of Decentralised Finance

22,220 views •

First broadcast June 27, 2019

Blockchain. Cryptocurrency. These words tend to throw people for a loop. Chances are that you’ve heard them but don’t have a firm grasp of what they mean or why they’re important.

That makes you a part of Andreas Antonopoulos’s mission.

His goal is to educate as many people as possible about cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereium. Most importantly, he wants you to know how those currencies can give you back the freedom you didn’t know you’d lost.

The Importance of Privacy

You may only think about your financial privacy in terms of keeping your information away from thieves. As Antonopoulos explains, though, your own government could be sleuthing more than you realize.

Every transaction you make says something about you. In fact, there’s an entire short story called Ordeal by Cheque that uses personal checks to tell a family’s story.

The government can use your transactional information to gather information about you. They can learn about your political views, how you spend your free time, where you travel, and more. Then can use this information to target you, manipulate you, and impact elections.

The Problem with Government-Controlled Currency

It may be scary to think about the lack of privacy we have. Andreas Antonopoulos points out that this isn’t the only problem with governments controlling our currency.

Not only does the government know just about everything about you, but they can also respond by affecting your money. They could manipulate the currency any way they choose or put an end to it altogether. The idea of being left in the world with no money either in cash or in the bank is terrifying.

How Is Blockchain Currency Different?

Antonopoulos doesn’t make his way around the world speaking at major events to scare people about their money. He’s spreading the word about a solution: blockchain cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin.

Cryptocurrencies solve the privacy problem by the nature of blockchain technology. This technology uses data blocks to process information about your transactions. However, they don’t store actual identifying information about you.

In other words, your transactions are anonymous so no one can use them to manipulate you.

Cryptocurrencies also fix the problem of currency being controlled by the government. Instead of being under the power of a state entity, Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are digital and decentralized. There is no singular controlling power to shut them down or impact them on a whim, and governments don’t play a part in the process.

Learning from Andreas Antonopoulos’s Expertise

Andreas Antonopoulos is a tech leader, a certified blockchain expert, and a fintech mastermind. Most importantly, he’s someone who knows the true dangers of state-controlled currency. His goal is to help you protect yourself.

In his interview, Antonopoulos offers a comprehensive view into the scary world of traditional currencies. He explains the impact that the currencies already have on our daily lives and the risks we take if we continue to let them control us.

As he explains, transitioning to blockchain cryptocurrency and becoming a cashless society is the only reliable way to get out from under those risks and retain our freedom.

“Nothing goes exponential without going down, right?”

In short: Andreas Antonopoulos is a best-selling author, speaker and educator on Bitcoin and open blockchains, and the author of Mastering Bitcoin and The Internet of Money. He joined Brian Rose in London in 2019, on his third visit to the show, to talk about bubbles, privacy, financial freedom and what blockchains could mean for money and governance.

Andreas describes himself as the Walmart greeter of open blockchains: the first face many people meet when they get curious about crypto. His aim, he says, is to give neutral, useful education rather than endorsements, and he refuses to promote products, projects or ICOs. In this conversation he looks back at the 2017 mania, explains why booms are followed by winters, and argues that the winters are when the real building happens.

The talk then widens to money, privacy and power: how banks can lock people out of the financial system, why he thinks the choice ahead is between corporate-run digital cash and open peer-to-peer money, and how blockchains might allow new kinds of organisations. Andreas is also candid about the personal side, including his years of anxiety, his cancer diagnosis at 29, and his hobby as a private pilot. Nothing in the episode is investment advice, and he says openly that he does not think everyone should hold crypto today.

Key takeaways

  • Boom and bust is the pattern. Andreas says Bitcoin has gone through several bubbles, that 2017 was not the largest in percentage terms, and that nothing goes exponential without coming back down.
  • The building happens in the winter. During booms exchanges and developers are overwhelmed; he says infrastructure and better user interfaces get built when prices are low.
  • Education protects investors more than regulation. He argues that people learn to spot scams through experience and research, and that more than 99 per cent of ICOs were scams.
  • Diversify more than your portfolio. His advice includes diversifying skills, income sources, geography and currencies, and not assuming everyone is ready for crypto yet.
  • Privacy and access to banking matter. He shares stories of being asked intrusive questions about a book payment and of a man who could not open a bank account because of his place of birth.
  • An open blockchain has defining traits. Andreas lists open, borderless, neutral, censorship resistant, public and immutable, and says corporate coins fail most of those tests.
  • Money works like a language. He says money does not hold value itself but transmits it, and that whoever controls the flow of money has great influence over society.

Education, not endorsement

Andreas lives out of two suitcases and travels continuously, which he says lets him spend more time in regions such as South America and Southeast Asia where he believes crypto matters most. He is quick to point out the privilege behind that lifestyle, starting with holding British and American passports. He first read the Bitcoin white paper in 2012, when a coin cost roughly two dollars, and describes how almost everyone starts as a sceptic and then becomes fascinated.

On the 2017 boom, he says he told friends it was a time to read rather than to buy, and that he turned down offers he describes as up to a quarter of a million dollars for a single social media post. His rule for advisory work is that his name can never be mentioned.

Bubbles, winters and what lasts

Asked whether crypto was in a bubble, Andreas answered yes, then pointed out that real estate, student loans, bonds and other markets also looked like bubbles to him, with far larger consequences if they burst. He compares the shake-out to the dot-com crash and the 21 search engines before Google, arguing that failed companies leave behind people, knowledge and infrastructure.

He also describes cyclical bubbles, which re-inflate because there is something real underneath, as different from tulip-style bubbles that burst once. Recording when Bitcoin had recovered to around 7,900 dollars, he said he did not care whether the price rose or fell, only that developers kept building.

Privacy, exclusion and the crossroads for digital cash

A large part of the episode covers financial access. Andreas tells of months of paperwork to receive a 500-dollar payment from his Russian publisher, and of an Iranian-born developer in Berlin who had not been able to open a bank account in over ten years. He argues that cutting people off from banking is unjust and, in his view, counterproductive, and that being able to exit to open money can deter abuse by governments, which he links to cases such as Greece and Argentina.

His central warning is that if digital cash replaces physical cash, the world will end up either with money run by corporations that sit in every payment, or with open peer-to-peer currencies no one controls. He argues that a planned Facebook coin could not be borderless, neutral or censorship resistant because its issuer must follow the law in each jurisdiction.

Money as a language, DAOs and a disruptive mindset

Andreas explains money as an abstract symbol system that lets millions of people coordinate. From there he moves to decentralised autonomous organisations on Ethereum, using the thought experiment of a taxi that owns itself and a decentralised charity that sends all donations straight to people in a disaster zone. He suggests blockchains give us building blocks for experiments in governance, escrow and crowdfunding, and that a large share of ICOs, though mostly scams so far, hint at a future of global startup funding.

He describes himself as a disruptarian: every institution is eventually co-opted and needs renewing, ideally through non-violent change. His closing advice to young people is that they underestimate their options and their power, and that much of life is more random than we want to believe.

Who is Andreas Antonopoulos?

Andreas Antonopoulos is a British-Greek author, speaker and educator on Bitcoin and open blockchains. He is half British, lived in London for ten years and has no permanent home, travelling with two suitcases. His books are Mastering Bitcoin, The Internet of Money (volumes one and two) and Mastering Ethereum, and his work is available free under open Creative Commons licences at aantonop.com. In the interview he says his talks are funded largely by supporters on Patreon, that he took up fitness in his forties and that he earned his private pilot’s licence in 2015.

Frequently asked questions

What are the pillars of an open blockchain according to Andreas Antonopoulos?

He lists open, borderless, neutral, censorship resistant, public and immutable, and adds that privacy is needed for a payment network. He says corporate permissioned blockchains lack most of these.

Did Andreas Antonopoulos think crypto was a bubble?

Yes. He told Brian Rose that the 2017 run was clearly a bubble, but that real estate, bonds and other markets were also in bubbles, and that crypto bubbles can re-inflate because the technology has real foundations.

Does Andreas Antonopoulos think everyone should own crypto?

No. He said everyone should diversify, but that many people are not yet ready to hold crypto securely, and that his job as an educator is to make the technology easier and safer to use.

What does Andreas Antonopoulos mean by money as a language?

He describes money as an abstract symbol system that transmits value and lets society coordinate. Controlling it, he says, gives enormous influence over people's freedoms.

Where can I watch the Andreas Antonopoulos interview?

You can watch the full Andreas Antonopoulos interview free on this page, with the full transcript below the video.

Chapters

5:17 | Brian introduces Andreas Antonopoulos
6:28 | The Walmart greeter of open blockchains and life as a nomad
13:15 | How Brian and Andreas each came to Bitcoin
22:02 | Ethereum, ICOs and the 2017 bubble
35:44 | Why infrastructure gets built in the crypto winter
38:43 | Is crypto in a bubble?
48:34 | Banking barriers, Greece and why to diversify
1:00:16 | The option to exit as a check on government power
1:03:00 | Who is ready for crypto, and the Global South
1:12:40 | Peer-to-peer money and the digital cash crossroads
1:20:32 | Financial exclusion and the terrorism argument
1:35:29 | The pillars of an open blockchain
1:40:37 | Facebook’s planned coin
1:45:38 | Money as a language
1:49:43 | Autonomous organisations and the self-owning taxi
2:03:06 | Replacing intermediaries and rethinking institutions
2:13:01 | A hundred years ahead and being a disruptarian
2:22:49 | Daily habits, fitness and the best day of his life
2:33:48 | Flying, fear, anxiety and sleep
2:44:24 | Advice to his 20-year-old self

Downloads

Full transcript: Andreas Antonopoulos (aka Bitcoin Jesus) on London Real

5:17 This is London Real. I am Brian Rose. My guest today is Andreas Antonopoulos, the best-selling author, speaker, educator and one of the world’s foremost cryptocurrency and blockchain experts. You’re the author of four books including Mastering Bitcoin and The Internet of Money, and you travel the world advocating greater privacy and freedom in our financial lives. To date you’ve educated millions and are known for delivering stimulating talks that combine economics, psychology, technology and game theory with current events, anecdotes and history.

5:45 Andreas, welcome back to London. Oh, thank you so much for having me back. It was so much fun the last two times we did it and I’m glad we got an opportunity to do it again. Yeah, I’m so excited. It feels like you were here yesterday.

5:55 I feel like I know you and, uh, I always tell people there’s only one guest we have on to talk about crypto, blockchain, and that’s you, because you’re the guy that just, not only do you have an amazing history, you know so much about it, but you also you kind of, you know, you separate yourself from the economics of that business, so you are always this kind of, I don’t know, true source of information. That’s the way I look at you, um, because you know you go out there, really, I feel it’s part of your mission just to spread information, right? Did I read that right?

6:28 Yeah, I, I mean, I like to think of myself as focused on education, but almost like the Walmart greeter of open blockchains. Like the I’m the old guy who’s standing inside the door, you come in and you go, “Welcome, folks, can I interest you in some barbecue equipment in aisle four this month?” You know, it’s like I’m, for many people, the first face they see or the first video they watch when they get interested in crypto, and so now I’ve made it my mission to give people useful, neutral information that they can easily understand and guide them on a safe road into this crazy space with all of the drama and madness that’s going on around it.

7:14 Yeah, and there is a lot of craziness. I mean, I might want to actually start with kind of my own history and education of Bitcoin, and then I really want to talk about what’s going on with you. First of all, what’s it like to be in London, uh, compared to all the other places you travel? What’s your relationship like with this city? Well, I lived here for 10 years, I’m half British, I went to school here, um, and all of that.

7:34 So London is exactly as I left it. Uh, I arrived yesterday, it’s been raining continuously, it will rain continuously until the day I leave, so it feels immediately familiar. And yeah, I mean, I love London and I come back often, and when I’m here and when I’m talking to people who are here, you’ll probably notice my accent shifts and some more Britishisms start coming out of my mouth, um, so that’s one of the things that London does to me. Yeah, it kind of pulls that out, right?

8:08 Yeah. And otherwise you literally are non-stop traveling the world. I mean, we were talking earlier, you’re making a joke about Airbnb. I mean, you’ve basically been going from Airbnb to Airbnb for three and a half years, right? Yeah, so I quit having an apartment four years ago and now I don’t have a permanent base.

8:26 Everything I own fits in two suitcases and a little shoulder bag and I travel with that continuously. That’s all the belongings I have in the world. Um, it’s 46 kilos, or for our American audience, 98 pounds of stuff, and there’s this magical thing that happens when your stuff weighs less than you, and it takes a whole burden off, like just not having things. A very Zen way of life. Everything I need, I know exactly where it is because I have to repack it after two weeks and I just travel from place to place, which means half the flights because I don’t go back somewhere right, and now I actually get to enjoy the place I visit, because most of the time if I have a conference I’ll then stay for two weeks and get to see the city I’m in, whereas before it was airport, airport, Marriott hotel, conference hotel, airport, home, and I’d never see a city, I’d see it whisking by on the freeway.

9:28 And why’d you choose to go nomadic? What was the final straw? The final straw was when I realized that I had been spending less than a month per year in my house for more than a year. And in fact I was in Rio de Janeiro, I was on Ipanema Beach, I was having a cappuccino at 10 o’clock in the morning and it was April and back home in the United States, the city where I was living at the time was under about a foot of snow and it was continuously snowing, and three weeks from that moment I had another event in Buenos Aires, Argentina, and in between I was flying home to do what?

10:13 To pay bills, to restock the fridge, then have to empty the fridge, do laundry, unpack, repack, leave. I’m like, why am I doing that if instead I spent that week here? It’s a shorter flight. I’m having a cappuccino on the beach at 11 o’clock in the morning and it’s not snowing and I, it’s actually cheaper for me to live here than it is to live back home. So I did it and the cost of my life dropped quite substantially, in fact, because the United States, one of the most expensive places in the world to live, and it also allowed me to spend more time in the places where I think crypto is important, uh, specifically South America and Southeast Asia.

10:56 Okay, good, and I want to talk about those locations and why they’re important for crypto, but I’ve got a few guests actually that do what you do. I just had a yoga guy named Dylan Werner who does the same thing, a guy named Steve Maxwell, he just travels with that pack on his back and he’s becoming more popular, it’s becoming, Tim Sykes as well, a trader. Yeah, it’s becoming tremendously popular, this whole digital nomad lifestyle, um, but I think it’s important to remember that it also represents a unique and enormous privilege and even a demonstration of privilege.

11:31 First of all, I have a British and an American passport, that means I can go to 160 countries around the world for 90 days with no visas, no problems. Secondly, I can go to countries like, I’ve met a lot of people in my travels who I tell, you know, have you ever visited the United States? And like, I’ve been trying for years, I can’t get a visa, they won’t let me in at all. Successful people, people who have every reason to just visit as a tourist, can’t get in.

11:58 Um, same for Europe. And so that ability, it’s not a matter of cost, but there is an enormous amount of privilege that comes with birthplace, just a random fact of life that none of us have any control over. Right. Yeah, and that’s going to be relevant because I want to talk about borders and money and everything. So for anybody watching now, we’re going to get down into it and talk about, you know, the rise in Bitcoin over a couple of years ago, uh, blockchain’s implications, and then what is suitable for blockchain technology and what is not.

12:29 You did a great speech recently where you said throw out a word and throw blockchain at the end of it and does this make sense, and you said healthcare, asparagus, all this other stuff. So I want to talk about that, why, and why this conversation is important. Your last conversation with us, the privacy of your money and your transactions is something we really talked about and it’s something so serious that I don’t think people really think about. You know, people always are clamoring about the privacy on their devices and the privacy of their social media platforms and yet they don’t even think twice that all of their banking and transactional information is known by a company that we don’t really think much about, and that information is probably more crucial in understanding what you’re all about than all the posts on Facebook, so I’d love to talk about that as well.

13:13 Yeah, um, I was just having a bit of a memory lane going back through our episodes and my own experience with Bitcoin. I’m going to give you my quick background and then maybe you can give us maybe your quick background and then some of the big things that you’re seeing that we need to talk about. With, sure. So for me, the first episode I had on crypto was back in May 2013, and I had, of all people, Max Keiser from Russia Today on the show, who had been talking about Bitcoin for a long time and I didn’t know who else to talk about, um, I couldn’t find you at the time, and so Keiser came over and started talking about Bitcoin.

13:41 I had actually played around with Bitcoin about a year earlier and might have used some Bitcoin, I may or may not have used some to buy something on the Silk Road, um, and at one point I had an episode about psychedelics and that kind of thing, and it was later asthma inhalers is a very important product they had on the Silk Road. Oh really? So are you sure it wasn’t an asthma inhalation? Because they’re very expensive, especially in countries where they don’t have good health care.

14:05 Okay, interesting. No, I think it was a dimethyltryptamine that I later smoked on an episode, uh, in all candor, but at the time that was the early road, the days of the Silk Road, it was actually quite a user-friendly place with great reviews, and then it all went wrong and Dread Pirate Roberts and all that stuff. And I remember I had Thanksgiving at my house in 2013 and Max Keiser was there and one of my old banking buddies was there, a trader from Goldman, and they actually transacted uh, a one, a Bitcoin for a thousand dollars at my Thanksgiving table.

14:34 Well, I think that was one of the many pops, I think it came down from there. And then, look, I just started talking to you about it a lot, a lot of people started having conversations to understand what crypto was. And then the next data point, and I’ll tell you this, this is fascinating, was at a Christmas party at my company almost a year and a half ago where I was talking to the team and I realized that half of my team was invested in crypto and I was like, this is crazy, because it became a speculative instrument all of a sudden and it was this kind of a boom and I was just like, wow, this is weird, um, because no one else here was buying stocks and yet they were in crypto.

15:11 Um, so anyways, that, and then we saw some ICOs and then the price came down, and so that’s kind of been my weird little ride of personal experience with crypto. Yeah, and talking to you, which is fascinating. Yeah, um, so first of all, what do you think of some of those data points as far as what I remember of crypto? Because I mean, I’m surprised that how early you picked up on it and I think it takes quite an open mind to to pick up on this technology, especially when it was much less well known.

15:41 Today it’s a household name, you know, you see it’s on TV all the time, but there was a time when nobody was talking about this other than geeks and it wasn’t much before when you got involved, right? Um, so, and if you in fact got involved in the middle of 2012, that’s the same time I, uh, found out about it and started getting involved. Okay. You read the white paper on it and were just fascinated by the elegance of the technology, right? That’s correct, yeah, it just blew my mind.

16:11 And the price of Bitcoin then was roughly two dollars, two dollars. Yeah. Okay. And so I got interested and I started playing with the technology and reading about it and looking at the code and trying to understand it and finding that I couldn’t understand it, and that made me even more intrigued, and yeah, I mean, that’s that story, that path is one that a lot of people have. Um, first of all there’s an element of skepticism at first, which is absolutely healthy and there should be, right, in all of these things.

16:43 In fact, if anything, there’s not enough healthy skepticism in this industry, and then people start doing their own research, trying to make a list of reasons why this isn’t a good idea. In fact, I had someone who started writing a book, they were telling me they started writing a book about why Bitcoin is a Ponzi scheme and they started doing the research for that book and then abandoned it three quarters in because they disproved all of their points and they couldn’t, um, they kept finding evidence that all of the things they thought were actually misunderstandings and turns out it wasn’t, and then they got really into it. Pretty much everybody who gets involved in this technology starts with a very skeptical perspective and then perhaps ignores it the first, once, twice, three times they hear about it, and then eventually dipsito gets completely fascinated by it and then dives right in.

17:40 And I meet people who are on the other end of that journey and like, I quit my job. I was working for a bank, I was working for, you know, a corporation, I was, I had a secure job with a pension and I quit at all. I work for a startup or I’m self-employed or I’m doing consulting or something like that. So not just dive into the technology but change the trajectory of a career, starting a computer science degree for someone who is never into programming and they want to learn how to code because of their fascination with cryptocurrency.

18:15 It changes people’s lives. Yeah, absolutely. Is it cult, cultish, like people get into and they want to dedicate their life to it? I mean, you said you didn’t sleep and eat for days when you first read about it, right? But I have that response to technology, it wasn’t this specific technology, I had that response previously to other technologies that fascinated me, like the early internet, the first web browser, uh, the first open source operating system, my first computer when I was 10, that happened to me.

18:42 There are many reasons why people may get obsessed, right? Some people are driven by technology, they get obsessed by that, some people are obsessed by some of the political and ideological implications of breaking down borders and connecting the world and freeing people from control of governments and corporations, of privacy. Some are excited by the investment speculation and the possibility of getting rich, right, which is a terrible idea, um, but that attracts a lot of people, right?

19:16 So I would say the majority of people the first time they get involved in crypto, it’s probably because they heard that it’s some kind of investment opportunity, someone tried to sell it to them in some unscrupulous way, or they got pulled into a Ponzi scheme or one of the other cryptocurrencies that are more or less pump and dump scams, and then they discover that’s a pump and dump scam and they’re like, find others that are not, right? Um, no matter what the motivations, I think in the end the people who stay after the price does one of those find another reason to be interested. So they might come in because of speculation and mania and then the ones who were only motivated by that, they leave, and the ones who stick around a year into the crash have found other motivations.

20:10 They like the community, they understand the technology will be better, they’re driven by the political implications, and I tried to cultivate the understanding of the technology, so like, okay, welcome, you came because you want to get rich, that’s okay, you’re all welcome, now let me tell you about why you should stay: because of the technology, even after the price crashes. How do you feel when it’s the big speculation moment? Because like Bitcoin is almost like, uh, not your baby, but it’s something that you’ve had a relationship for a long time and yeah, 2017 we saw that it was just this massive speculative play, people are jumping in and all that stuff.

20:47 How does that bother you when people are coming in for that reason, or how do you feel emotionally when you see people make a lot of money, lose a lot of money? You got these people in Puerto Rico that went down and like took over San Juan and started throwing money around, and the ICO billionaires and like, what do you see, how do you feel when you see that stuff and what do you see? I mean, it bothers me to a certain extent. First of all, 2017 was the seventh or eighth bubble and it wasn’t even the largest one, because, you know, when you look at these assets or currencies, you got to think of percentages, right?

21:24 So when something goes from a dollar to 30, it doesn’t feel like a huge rise, but it’s actually a three thousand percent rise, which is bigger, which it did in 2012, right, which is a bigger rise than the recent one, it’s just the numbers are bigger now, right? But as a percentage, actually the spreads have been getting smaller, and every time this happens it attracts the wrong crowd. It attracts scammers, opportunists, pump and dumpers, pyramid schemers, and the ICO market enabled a lot of those people to make their own coin.

22:02 One of the things that people don’t realize, the reason this all happened in the ICO market, is because a new blockchain, a new open public blockchain called Ethereum made it so that you could build a scalable, secure, transferable, censorship-resistant, open, borderless blockchain on top, uh, by writing 20 lines of code. Okay, so the Ethereum allowed other people to piggyback on that framework to launch their ideas. It’s a programmable blockchain. So what do people use a programmable blockchain to do?

22:41 I have many ideas, all of which are interesting and fascinating projects, mostly around censorship and privacy, but that’s not what people chose to do. They chose to build these platforms to do massive pump and dumps and to launch all of these startups, which is interesting in the long run, because if you can fund startups with an international pool of investors and actually bring startup-like investors to people around the world who don’t have access to those investments, that can change the investment field, right? But that’s not what happened.

23:15 99% of them were just outright scams. Right, and maybe we should do some backup and do a few definitions for people that aren’t completely up the curve. So the original cryptocurrency was really Bitcoin. Yes, it was, been around since 2010, 2009, nine, January 3rd, 2009 was the launch. It was pretty much the only crypto that you would have been trading up until 2014 or ’15, really?

23:36 No, uh, there were a few others, right? The, the the altcoins, as they called altcoins or alternative coins, started in 2011 I believe was the first one. Okay. And they were mostly kind of clones of Bitcoin. Then by 2014 we had another round of altcoin growth and then Ethereum was launched, and Ethereum made it simple to, like, put building blocks together programmatically and build all kinds of different features, including ICOs, which stands for initial coin offering, and these are essentially crowdfunding schemes, just like an IPO is initial public offering of stock, and all of these companies that had various ideas, um, wrote a white paper, built a platform to do crowdfunding and then publicly launched their offering.

24:30 These were obviously unlicensed security offerings, many from different places in the world where they couldn’t be prosecuted, or no one even picked up on that for a while. Yeah, and that’s the thing, people see IPO and ICO, and an IPO usually is something that’s been kind of vetted by an exchange, the SEC in America, and you have to go through certain facts, right, quite a bit, and then you can invest in something that’s going public that might have a lot of growth opportunity, like we saw Uber do recently. Now, in ICO it’s a similar thought of raising money for events for investors, except this one has a blockchain and it’s immediately has some international liquidity, doesn’t rely on exchange, but and it’s tradable everywhere.

25:15 Everywhere, but there’s no regulation involved or very little. Yeah, and it’s important to realize that regulation isn’t what keeps investors protected, not really. In fact, in many ways what regulation has done is it allows investors to outsource the vetting and research they should be doing, right, and it creates a bottleneck, so very few companies can actually do this kind of crowdfunding, which leaves a massive gap in the market where many, many great startups never get to that stage because they don’t have a way to get funding, and then at the same time many, many giant scams and pyramid schemes are listed on the stock markets after being carefully vetted by regulators.

26:00 And if I name any of them while I’m in London, I’m opening myself to a whole bunch of lawsuits, but we all know them, right? Various companies that do, uh, what they call multi-level marketing, right, that are straight-up pyramid schemes but they’re listed on the stock exchange, and, um, and of course many funds that have had massive problems and have been Ponzi schemes, they go straight through the regulators. In fact, Bernie Madoff was the head of the regulatory agency, which tells you a lot.

26:31 We need to think differently about what protects investors. What really protects investors is education, and one of the ways investors get educated is by getting burned a bit, losing a bit of money in poorly thought and risky investments and then having to learn the hard way and try again and again until they develop a better skepticism and better analytical skills. You can’t outsource that to someone else, because if you go looking for information on whether something is reliable and real or not, the people who know how to use social media and use marketing and write fancy white papers are the scammers.

27:08 They’re going to get your eyeballs first, and this is what happened with ICOs. So it’s not inherent in the ICO thing itself that they’re scams, not at all. In fact, my prediction has been that in the long run, if we look at this from the perspective of a decade or two, the opportunity to take startups and give them to international investors and bring investors from all around the world to invest in startups, cut out the middleman, accelerate the possibilities, will force education of investors all around the world, so the investors who are less sophisticated become as sophisticated as you see in Western developed economies.

27:51 Until then the scammers will exist, right? And a large percentage of the ICOs end up being scams, more than 99% of them. Wow. Yes, and some of them are being prosecuted, um, slowly, but, uh, but this is a game that the regulators are losing because they’re operating on a completely different time scale, uh, so you know, it takes them three years to build up an investigation and these things were launching, you know, 10 a day during the peak, and many of them from jurisdictions all over the world, so you know, there is no universal jurisdiction for these things, and nor should there be, right, which means also very hard to regulate things in Puerto Rico and it’s possible, impossible, right?

28:34 Okay. And how did you feel in 2017 when Bitcoin’s going up to what was its high, 30 thousand dollars, 20 something? Okay, and Ethereum’s up and all these ICOs are happening, I’m sure everyone’s asking you what you think. What, what everybody who I hadn’t seen since high school was connecting with me and saying, “Hey, you seem to know about this stuff, is this a good time to buy?” I was like, absolutely not, do not get in.

29:05 This is, first of all, this is not a good time to buy. This is a good time to read, go read something, learn something, and until you feel comfortable to answer that question by yourself you shouldn’t be involved in this. And when you see something going like this, guess what comes on the other side of that? If you see an investment curve like this, it’s very quickly followed by an investment curve like this. Nothing goes exponential without going down, right?

29:31 And Bitcoin’s done this eight times already. It’s a common pattern, we’ve seen it, that’s how it grows, and the reason it grows like that is because there isn’t much in terms of short pressure to hold it down, so people to speculate on it dropping to keep a lid on the pressure, and there’s a limited supply, and all of the cryptos behave more or less in accordance with what Bitcoin’s doing. So if you’ve got something that has limited supply and you suddenly have a speculative mania that blows up, it’s going to go like this, which only further fuels the mania until it reaches a point where there simply isn’t anybody else who feels just as enthusiastic, and it pauses for a second, and the moment it pauses for a second the panic just drives it down.

30:21 This is what happens, and I’m not interested in that part of it, right? That actually goes against the message of, look, absolutely, this is an amazing tool. I mean, if the speculators, I mean look, if they weren’t in it, which I know you can’t say, speculators stay out and real investors stay in, but if, for example, the price had stability for a long period of time, people could see that this technology is going to be helpful for transactions and privacy and borderless.

30:45 Right, there’s no difference between speculators and investors, right? All investors are speculators, they’re just speculating with a different risk profile and some of them with very little research and information, and the reason this is bad is because a lot of good, innocent, slightly naive people lost a lot of money. Some people had their lives destroyed by this, and that, then, you know, apart from the morality of that in the first place and the impact that has on people’s lives, it changes the community, it causes damage to the community, so you have a lot of fractioning within the community, you have a lot of drama that comes up when there’s money on the table, people’s personalities change, like people get tempted, they start taking shortcuts, their ethics get compromised.

31:40 Power corrupts, money corrupts, and it was one of those cases where suddenly every conversation I was having had absolutely no depth, it had no substance, it was all about how do I get to the money as quickly as possible, right, or how much money I just made, or Bitcoin’s going here, so everything just became, well, I was being asked to become an ICO advisor. I can’t imagine 10 times a day. Yeah. I can’t imagine that the money that’s been thrown at you for that kind of stuff.

32:13 I can tell you the price it was. We published some of the letters, many of the people in the space who were being asked, they were offering a quarter of a million dollars for a single social media post and to put my name on their website. Yeah, does that test your commitment to your values and ethics or not even for a second? It tests my stomach and whether I can keep my lunch down. I mean, it was disgusting.

32:39 I put up a page on my, on my site where it said “Promote, advertise or advise for your ICO,” which was just a long page of why I won’t do it, and I put it on my contact page because people kept sending me contacts through whatever form they could find, so I put a form up there that just went straight into the trash, um. And it made you disgusted? Absolutely, because someone is ruining something you think is beautiful and damaging people’s lives and behaving in unethical ways and uh, and also they’re asking me to compromise my values.

33:18 I don’t do endorsements, I don’t do products, and I don’t talk about products, I don’t talk about projects, I don’t talk about people. I talk about technology, I’m not interested in the price, and I’ve never done that. So when all of these people were asking me to be their advisor, I was like, look at my work, I’ve consistently declined to do that, I’m not going to start doing it now. Certainly not. And you’ve never been tempted to be the CEO of some company or to the advisor to this, or I mean, I am the CEO of a company, I’m the CEO of, uh, actually several companies.

33:50 I’m the CEO of an education company, uh, an events company, a publishing company that’s now published six different books, uh, both my own and others, and, um, and a consulting company where I do advisory work. So this is one of the things I actually do, advise companies. The first rule of my advisory contract is you can never mention my name to anyone and I will never mention your name. That’s it, that’s the first rule. So a lot of companies that came to me, they said, “We want you to be an advisor,” and I’m like, okay, well, the first rule is you can never mention my name to anyone.

34:28 And where’d you go? It was a very easy way to clear out all of the, because they wanted an endorsement, that’s what they wanted, they wanted my marketing, and as soon as I took that off the table they weren’t interested in my advice. I actually do have a couple of companies that I work with and they’re interested in serious strategic advice and asking my opinion and helping them understand the market, which I understand quite well, and it’s not a big business for me, I don’t have much time, I don’t charge ridiculous rates.

35:02 Um, it’s about me having an opportunity to be involved in some of the development stuff, which I really enjoy doing and helping companies build better products or understand the market better. Um, and I don’t take clients and I don’t, uh, I don’t say yes easily to that kind of thing. The whole point of that is just to keep me in touch with some of what’s happening around the world. Okay, so crypto’s going up in 2017. Yeah, it’s obvious to you that it’s going to come back down, but people at the same time are saying, look at the market cap of gold, look at the market cap, the fiat currencies of all this, and now if crypto is going to be here to stay, and we believe it is because of the technology, right, that justifies 100x price, a thousand, 1000x price of Bitcoin.

35:44 Even if it does, that’s not going to happen in a month. Even if it does, at that point that curve has so outpaced the deployment of infrastructure, we need the development of scaling technology, the user interfaces that we need to onboard new people, the education that those people need in order to not lose the crypto that they just got involved in. We, there’s a pace that’s gated by the development of the technology and it happens in cycles, so there’s some infrastructure in place which supports a certain scale of applications and a certain set of capabilities within those applications, and then those applications get designed and produced with hopefully good user experience and user interfaces so that people can use them securely and easily, and that allows a certain number of people to get involved who previously it was too difficult, there wasn’t enough infrastructure, whatever, but that gets built in the booms.

36:38 That’s the funny thing about it, it doesn’t get built in the booms, it gets built in the winter. So it’s getting built during the winter time. Okay. In the booms no one has time to build anything because you’re getting completely overwhelmed by all of this noise, when the exchanges are getting involved and the brokers are getting the money, is Coinbase was building up infrastructure and Coinbase was struggling to keep up, all of the exchanges were struggling to keep up, at some point they were were signing up a hundred thousand clients a week, um, during probably the first or second week of December, which was the peak of the craziness, right?

37:14 And you can’t do anything, you can’t think strategically, so we have limits to what can be achieved in any technology. Once you have new applications and new people come in and you get a bit more investment, that creates a need for more infrastructure to support the new people who come in to grow the scale, so we build more infrastructure, as soon as we do that that creates the possibility of new applications at new scales, so those get built, which then creates an opening for new users who previously found it too difficult to enter, and the cycle keeps repeating, and at that rate, even technologies that are growing at an exponential rate, um, or at least a super linear rate, um, 10% compounded here and here, 20% compounded here and here, like the internet, right?

38:05 Right. Um, that’s still a crazy fast rate and there will be corrections, but it’s not six thousand percent in two months, right? That at that point you’ve so outpaced the ability of the technology to even absorb that many people that you know what’s coming next, right? At least I did. And yet like any boom and bust cycle in humanity, and you go from the tulips to dot coms to anything, when we’re in the middle of it as humans nobody wants to hear the opinion, we don’t know anymore, delusion becomes the reality and we want to buy it and the emotion takes over and it’s fear and greed.

38:43 And I was being invited to, uh, media interviews non-stop and one of the things they asked me to do is go on and debate whether crypto is in a bubble, and so the interviewers or the journalists would stick a microphone in my face and go, “Do you think crypto’s in a bubble?” And you know, they were hoping I’d say no and I was like, “Yeah, of course it’s in a bubble.” And they deflated, me, they’re like, “Oh come on, where am I going to go with that answer?”

39:12 Like I was hoping to go to the other guest who was going to call you an idiot for saying it’s not, right? But they just deflated my balloon or, um, and so of course it’s in a bubble, it’s a very obvious and very extreme version of a bubble, but keep in mind so is real estate, automobiles, student loans, healthcare, education, the stock market, the bond market, the asset market, the commodity market, and in fact all of those are quietly in some of the worst bubbles we’ve ever seen, driven by 21 trillion dollars of debt in the U.S. and massive stimulus spending by all of the central banks, and nobody’s calling them a bubble, and if they burst we’re gonna have a much bigger problem on our hands, right? If crypto bursts, yet people are gonna get hurt, but it’s a fairly limited number of people on a fairly limited capital basis, who, the craziest of them invested big parts of their net worth but most people didn’t, but when the real estate market or the jobs market or corporate bonds crash or currencies crash, it takes entire countries, it wipes out the middle class, it causes long-term generational destruction.

40:23 None of the journalists want to talk about that, right? I steered the conversation in that direction, I’m like, yeah, guess what else is in the bubble? The S&P 500, like, uh, right, don’t want to talk about that. Yeah, and then of course the crypto people didn’t want me to talk about that, so I go out and I do an interview and I, uh, I remember it was a podcast, a popular podcast and they asked me, is crypto in a bubble? I said absolutely, it’s in a bubble, of course it is, in fact I expect we’re not going to go much further and I’m really worried about the piece of this, it’s going to cause some damage.

40:54 The very next week they did another podcast in another place talking about this interview and the screenshot, the thumbnail, was me in a Darth Vader mask and the title of the thing was “Has Andreas gone over to the dark side?” because I said the B word, I said bubble. And I was like, how could you say it’s in a bubble? This is because you’re such an advocate of the currency. They didn’t, they didn’t expect you to, see, I betrayed the doctrine by saying it’s in a bubble.

41:24 Yeah, it was a bubble and it was ridiculous, and as soon as it finished, um, I was very saddened by the fact that I knew a lot of people had been hurt, but I was like, okay, now we can get back to work, now we can start building, and I actually started writing my fourth book. Okay. Um, just about a week after the bubble burst. Okay, and so we’ve been in that winter now for what, a year and a half? And what is that actually?

41:51 We’ve popped out of the winter about a month ago, okay, at least of the deep freeze. All right, and Bitcoin started going up, so it went from about 20,000 down to, I think the lowest was about 3,100 US dollars, and then over the last month and a half it went back up past nine and then in the last couple of weeks retrenched a bit, uh, and it’s now at about 7,900. Okay. Yeah, all right, so you know, and these cycles keep repeating. A lot of people forgot about it, and then the funny thing is that one of the things that gives us strength is people hear that this bubble thing has happened and they’re like, okay, so it’s dead.

42:38 You see, the quintessential thing about bubbles that are not based on any fundamentals, like tulip bubbles, is they burst once, that’s it, they never reinflate again. Cyclical growth bubbles, which are in things that actually do have foundation, like real estate going, or in a whole economy, you know, growing fast and then going through this kind of cycle, or crypto, which actually some of it does have fundamentals behind it, re-inflates again. So now we had another big run up, I mean it doubled in price in a month and a half, which is again too fast, right?

43:18 But now it’s in play again and we’re going to start to potentially see similar behaviors. I hope not, I hope, but I hope people learned, but if you look at the price action over the last eight, ten years, it’s coming again soon, in the next 12 to 24 months there’ll be another breakthrough, and guess what, it’ll probably go over the previous price. I don’t know, maybe, um, maybe not, I mean it might keep going down again and we may end up back in the in the negative territory.

43:48 I don’t know, don’t care, don’t care. What I do care about is that over the past two years what has happened is a lot of the money that flowed in obviously turned into investment, a lot of people got jobs and got hired and some of them were developers and um, big exchanges and wallets and things like that, they were able to use some of the appreciation and price for their home holdings to invest in infrastructure, to build better operation centers, to hire more customer service people so that they could better withstand the next cycle, and out of that comes better software and more development. So developers have been hard at work, they really never stopped, the community’s grown, and once again you get to see who’s really in it for the technology and who isn’t.

44:38 The ones who weren’t, bye-bye, see you later, and you know, we’re hard building and you know, I’ve been building an education machine effectively to be able to scale what I do and get it to more people. Okay, well good. I want to talk about what you think are the five pillars of open blockchains, because I think the way you describe it is really important. I was just having flashbacks. I was in the dot-com boom, so I moved to New York City from London in around May, July, you know, back about July ’99, and I was the CFO of a dot-com startup, had about 20 million dollars raised, we were selling luxury goods on the web, we had no idea what we were doing, um, and I remember going out with all my buddies in New York City and just giving them the whole dot com, this is the future, Columbus in the New World, what was his ROI, and wrote it all up.

45:28 And I remember in like 2003 there was some company called Google and I just remember thinking nobody wants to even hear the word technology because ever, it was just played out, disgusting, I don’t even want to hear it because I want to move on to something else, and that’s why I ignored something like Google, because I was like, right, no one cares, no one wants to know. When in fact Google was obviously great technology and really useful stuff and it became another great company. And what people forget was Google wasn’t the first search engine, it was the 21st search engine, and in order for it to succeed 20 other companies, big, well capitalized, well-researched companies, failed, and that happens in any technology.

46:12 Yeah, railroads in America, it was a lot of the same thing, a lot of these massive companies built up, competed with each other and then bankruptcy, bankruptcy, consolidation. But that’s an actually a normal and even healthy way for capitalism to work. Agreed. You break it if you try to bail out the companies during their bankruptcies, because then companies that shouldn’t survive survive, and that’s a disadvantage to the ones that are actually healthy because they don’t get to pick up on the market the employees, the capital goods, the infrastructure that gets liquidated in bankruptcy and put it to better use because they’ve been doing better business.

46:50 And one of the advantages of this kind of washout cycle is that it takes out all of the pretenders and all of the badly chosen ideas and all of the bad execution and of course the scams, and but the infrastructure that they built up, the people who they hired and trained to build systems, that knowledge is still there, a lot of the infrastructure is still there, and it gets recycled, um, and so other companies then pick up employees and go in on a hiring spree. I hired more employees in the last year and a half, uh, than I did during the boom cycle. Interesting.

47:31 Yeah, along with that dot-com boom there was a big boom in laying down broadband cable, remember, in New York City, and it looked at it and it was going along with this tech boom and it looked in retrospect it was way overdone, we didn’t need such broadband, but that tech was then later used to propel the internet to the next level, so there always is positives. Absolutely, from these boom and bust cycles, right? Well, for the ones that actually have a foundational technology underneath it, it’s not just smoke and mirrors, right?

47:59 Okay, uh, and that’s the difference, those those technologies don’t go away. So for people listening, I just want them to understand kind of why they need to understand what a cryptocurrency is, in the blockchain, where, how this is going to affect their lives today and maybe in the next 10 years, to where they can understand, because some people will say, well, I don’t speculate in Bitcoin so this doesn’t have anything to do with me, but it actually does, because I think you can give people a really good framework of their own money. And, uh, you know, look, I’m an American citizen, I’m here in the UK, I have to file U.S. taxes.

48:34 If I want to open up a bank account in this country, when I’m American, nobody wants to know who I am, literally they go running for the hills. Yeah, yeah, because as an American citizen they have to report all this stuff into the IRS, the IRS can come and mess with them, and they actually don’t want anything to do with me. So I’m British and now that I’m American I can’t open a bank account with any of the banks here, right? Go figure, right? So I’m penalized from that.

48:56 Also I have a bank, I have a business in London but I collect most of my revenues in dollars, we do accept crypto for our Academy as well, and that’s why I had a second position about a year ago, but I actually can’t open up a bank account in the U.S. because the U.S. doesn’t want anything to do with me over here, because then I’ll have to open a dollar account and they want an entity there and I got to file taxes there, and so we think we live in this world where, oh, my banking is normal and free, but it’s not. Not to mention the transaction cost, the lack of privacy, um, and that’s for people who are incredibly privileged, a privilege, and also a totally above board, and I can’t run a business that’s helping change the lives in a positive way, I’d like to think, of millions of people, and yet I’m restricted by this banking system.

49:38 So it’s not, it, you know, this does apply to me, and God forbid I say something political on this show and then, you know, who knows what might happen to some of my money or my banking privileges or whatever or my travel. So that’s why I love talking to you, Andreas, and that’s why I think people should really pay attention now, because actually your money, your privacy is paramount to your existence and our existence as a society, but also to the freedoms we take for granted. Correct, and the funny thing is I don’t have to have that conversation in the countries where they don’t take those freedoms for granted or they don’t have them.

50:14 So in countries I visit where the government has caused problems in the past, so they’ve had dictatorships or they’ve had financial collapses and hyperinflation, this is all obvious and makes immediate sense. The problem is that in countries where we’ve had the privilege of stable long-term institutions and democratic freedoms but we’re gradually seeing many threats to these long-term institutions and freedoms, we take these so much for granted that we don’t realize how quickly those can be lost, how quickly we can go to a situation where the combination of surveillance and surveillance capitalism, kind of corporate surveillance and state civilians coming together and one wrong election and all of the things you thought were true are not true anymore.

51:03 We’ve seen that happen in country after country after country where, you know, the prime minister passes a seemingly innocuous law that changes term limits and then they win the next election and then they become president because they run out of term limits as prime minister, and then they pass a law that transfers all of the powers of the president and then they abolish term limits of the president and then they’re president for life. Right, you’re talking about Russia, Venezuela, or you could make a list, right? Easily.

51:32 Right, and much closer to home, you know, Turkey, for example. So the going from a secular democracy, even when the culture is very much steeped in democratic ideals and freedoms, to losing all of that really, really fast, uh, it can happen here. It did happen in Europe not that long ago, and you had personal experience of that in Greece, and your mom was there. Yep. And what were some of the realizations and implications that played out?

52:03 Well, I mean, Greece was basically asset stripped by the German banks in order to make sure they were capitalized enough to pretend they’re solvent, and, um, so they made loans, those loans were bad, and you know, one of the reasons the loans come with interest rates is because they carry risk. So what happens with a bad loan? You write it off, the customer defaults and you take the loss, but that was impossible because if they actually wrote off the bad loans they gave to Greece, a whole bunch of French and German banks would be effectively insolvent and they couldn’t allow that to happen, it would be a domino effect.

52:41 So instead they asset stripped the middle class, increase, and, um, riots, and to pay back the banks, the economy has now lost 40 percent. And how do you asset strip the middle class? What does that look like from a government policy standpoint? Um, half your pension’s gone even though you’ve been paying it, even private pensions. So you have a private pension, they force the private pension to buy government bonds that they then default on and then they nationalize the pension, and 40 percent of your pension’s gone, 50 percent of your pension is gone if you have a state pension, even more.

53:22 And in the meantime all of the taxes and all of the costs go up, so in Greece up to last year the VAT was 25% on everything including food, heating fuel, things like that, and even as the salaries and prices and pensions had dropped 50%, the prices of everything imported was up 50% at least. Um, and the government taxes the middle class at outrageous rates, like the average effective tax is more than 40% on the middle class. Turns out now Greeks are paying more taxes in the middle class than anybody else in Europe.

54:08 Wow. It’s ironic. And all of this is to make sure that Greece can continue to make payments on loans that should have gone bad. so that those payments can go back to Deutsche Bank and Paribas and all of the other banks in Europe that made these bad loans, so that they can keep those loans on the asset side of their balance sheet to pretend they’re solvent. Right, and this could potentially happen to any country.

54:34 I mean, this is what’s happened four or five times to Argentina, it’s, you know, it’s what was called shock doctrine, right? If you know the book, um, which, um, the IMF comes in, they give out, they do a bailout with loans, they impose austerity, they demand repayments, they force the country to privatize all the assets, sell it to private companies, um, strip the pensions, and then the economy crashes and then they have to take on more loans to pay the previous loans and the cycle repeats every 20 or 30 years. It’s a modern form of colonialism.

55:13 It’s been very effective, right? And we’ve seen that happen in Russia as well and other places. Yeah, Venezuela we talked about last time, it’s getting bad in Venezuela. And keep in mind this is not absent’s fault on the side of the borrowers, quite the opposite, the governments that are borrowing enormous amounts of money on behalf of their people, right, and then putting it to very bad use or straight up corruption and funnel it into private investors, you know, they walk away from this and then all of the repayment burden falls onto the next generation.

55:50 So you know, the mismanagement and the cronyism and the corruption that exists in Greece but also in Venezuela and Argentina and other places is out of control, but, um, you know, in the end no matter what a government does it’s always the people who pay for it and not the people who are tax evading, they’ve got a nice little nest egg. Remember the Panama Papers? Yeah. What they came out, that was when we had a revelation that all of the world’s uh, rich politicians and corporate executives were hiding trillions of dollars in offshore bank accounts, and the only thing that happened was that the journalists who broke the story was murdered.

56:36 Not a single thing happened other than that. That was like two, three years ago, right? Right. And then so among them were also many of the Greek politicians who were corrupt and nothing happened. Okay, they have the list, nothing happened.

56:50 So the individual listening to this, based on what you just said, should do what? Should they be careful of their savings in their local currency in their local country? Should they be aware of crypto? They should, well, at a very basic level they should diversify, um, you know, which is a standard tenet of any investment advice, right? What does diversify mean?

57:14 Diversify means diversify your job, your skill set, your investments, your assets, your, um, your geography even, right? So if you can work in a way where you have income from more than one source, using more than one set of skills, so if one industry you’re working in goes down the drain and the other one doesn’t, if you can more than one jurisdiction or geography, if you can have clients in more than one company or country, uh, for example, and I’m not talking about being an international entrepreneur, you can be an artist, a coder, a web developer, graphic designer, you can do a lot of things today which involve creative work online where you can have clients all around the world, right? And as part of that you should also think about diversifying your assets, and what people don’t think is about having all of their assets in one currency or in the markets of one country and what happens when that goes down the drain, and certainly not many people in Britain were thinking that before the Brexit vote.

58:29 More people are thinking about that now. And what was, what did Brexit teach us and what did it show you? Well, for one thing the currency crashed 20 percent and that’s without even Brexit happening. What it taught me is that a small minority of extremists with very good propaganda can drag a whole country in a direction where a lot of the moderates in the center are going like, what the hell is happening and how do we stop this, but they’re so fragmented and paralyzed by indecision and infighting and political, whereas the people who are like doing the populist or extremist position, they’re focused, you know, they’re connected, they’re aligned because they only have one goal in mind, whether that’s Brexit or other things like that, and the whole political conversation gets dragged in a position that not that many people want it there.

59:32 There’s a whole movie about the Brexit here and, you know, it was just talking about how they found a very small percentage of the population that if they could get them to move, and the ones that I think normally didn’t vote, but they get them to get out and be outraged enough to vote, then they could pop this Brexit thing. I mean, and that’s how you end up with populist uh, and more extreme-minded politicians everywhere in the world, and if this process keeps repeating three, four, five, six, seven elections further down, you have either a completely dysfunctional, uh, democracy where nothing works, which we’ve seen in countries like mine, Greece, or you have a dictatorship, which we’ve seen in Russia and China and Turkey and in other places like that.

1:00:16 It’s fundamentally linked to the money, or the money is a fundamental consequence of what’s happening. I think part of it is also the ability of people to opt out of this system and not get tracked along or taken hostage with it, and if people have the ability to opt out, if they have a form of exit, that gives them a power, and that power sometimes acts as a deterrent to the abuse of power by a corrupt government, for example. Let’s say you run the government of the perfect example would be Argentina and you have a big debt to repay and you have a number of choices, see how you’re going to manage your finances, how you’re going to manage your bonds and your debt.

1:01:02 Well, one of those choices is impose currency controls, lock everyone in the country, so that’s like turning the keys on all of currency flows in and out of the country, um, denominate all of the bank accounts in the local currency, so convert dollar balances that people have in their bank into the local currency, pesos or whatever else, forbid them from having foreign currency, importing or exporting foreign currency, now they’re all locked in, and then you drive up the interest rates and you inflate the debt away because you just drive the value of the money down. But the problem is what that’s doing is it’s stealing all of the value that people have put into building wealth for the next generation, basically investment they made into the future for their children.

1:01:49 Now imagine what happens when you know that the moment you start doing it they can all turn to crypto and there is no border you can erect to hold them in, uh, and they don’t all need to do that, maybe 10, 15, 20% of the population is enough to diffuse that entire strategy at this point. If 20% of them basically dump the currency before you get to do that and have already diversified and they start trading, um, then they’re gonna preempt that move and then the government has to choose another way of dealing with the problem. Right, so the people can take the power back.

1:02:30 Yes. Right, it’s like, it’s what they call the Chekhov’s gun, where you see the Chekhov play, when there’s a gun on the mantelpiece in act one, someone’s getting shot by act three, but the beauty of it, the play may change direction or people may behave differently just because it’s there, without getting shot. Right, so it’s like the middle class going, you know, putting down a stack of, uh, of Bitcoin, doesn’t exist physically but let’s say for dramatic purposes, and going, “Your move, government.

1:03:00 Right, I’m ready to exit, you want to take me hostage, I’m ready to exit.” Do you think everybody should have, uh, a percentage of their net worth in crypto for that reason? I think everybody should have diversified assets. Okay, but I mean you could, I don’t think everybody should have crypto today. Okay, and part of the reason is that if people don’t understand the technology and have not educated themselves, the process of selecting what to invest in, how to store it without leaving it on an exchange or having a third party manage it, which is just as dangerous, um, more dangerous than having money in the bank because crypto can be transferred much more easily, um, without the necessary knowledge on how to do some basic things about security and how to avoid scams, most people aren’t ready for that.

1:03:53 Okay, so I don’t think most people are quite ready now. I’m probably going to get a lot of flak for saying that. Our job as people who are involved in technology and education is to make everyone ready, and that means on one hand making the technology a lot easier to use and use in a way that’s secure by default, where if you use it the intuitive way it’s secure, you don’t have to think of a way to use it, right, it’s already secure, and then build better user interfaces.

1:04:25 We have to get it to the point where it’s very, very easy to use and very easy to use in a way that you have what some people in our space call monetary sovereignty, where you can declare independence in a small way, in a diversified way perhaps, or even some people, for some people ideological reasons, in a big way where you can take control of your own money and no one holds your money for you, and it’s not there yet. I mean, it’s not there yet for everyone. Okay, it’s there for some, right?

1:04:59 It requires a lot of basic hurdles, so not to be rich, that’s not the case, you don’t have to be rich. You can buy a tiny, tiny, tiny fraction, you can buy one pound, British pound, or one dollar worth of crypto if you want, you don’t have to buy a whole Bitcoin. That’s a big misunderstanding that exists, and you can start learning the skills and reading the educational materials for free, you don’t need to invest anything in that. What it does require however, and this is one of the reasons why we can’t really help many of the people who need this stuff the most, is it requires literacy, uh, often it requires literacy in English language, which is a big barrier to adoption, and it’s been a huge part of my mission is to make this multilingual as much as possible.

1:05:47 It requires numeracy, it requires some basic financial education, you need to understand some basic concepts, and it also requires a familiarity with complex technology or at least a willingness to engage with complex technology without being completely paralyzed. So I, you know, I can’t teach my dad how to do this, I can’t teach my dad how to do this, but he can use a mobile phone, which is complex technology. He uses a flip phone. Okay. He tried to use a smartphone, he’s 88 years old, he doesn’t want to, like, so he wanted to and he’s got an Android tablet, he’s very happy with that.

1:06:28 Are you frustrated by the fact that we don’t see Amazon and a lot of these places accepting crypto? Um, no, not so much, again because that’s not really that important because the people who need this, and I’m seeing a lot of this demand mostly in the Global South, right, they don’t even have access to Amazon anyway. Okay, you know, Global South, this is Africa, South America, uh, you know, central and South Africa, Southeast Asia, how are they using crypto right now?

1:07:03 Um, in some places it’s very vibrant, um, mostly the place where they need it a lot and they also have high enough levels of technology adoption, literacy, numeracy to do that, so Argentina is a great example. In other places there’s a big backlash from the government and setbacks. India, they banned exchanges from having bank accounts and basically shut down the legitimate side of the crypto sector, or not the legitimate, I should say the regulated side of the crypto sector, um, and all they left was whatever people were willing to do underground.

1:07:44 I have a little slogan to explain that to regulators and legislators, which is you can remove your country from crypto but you can’t remove crypto from your country. So what you do, if you ban it you don’t remove crypto from a country, it’s still there, it just goes into the shadows, right, which actually ends up funding unscrupulous characters, just like any other form of prohibition, drug prohibition, alcohol prohibition, whatever, and at the same time it just prevents not only the middle class from participating because they don’t want to go into that shady environment, mostly, unless they really need to, and it also prevents people from building startups and building infrastructure and building jobs and growth. Okay, but that’s a big step back, India’s such a massive market in terms of population and they could use it.

1:08:31 I was so, um, I was so encouraged by the early signs, some really great developments in India, they had a vibrant cryptocurrency sector, they don’t have enough investment opportunities, uh, the country has the largest holdings of gold in the world in the hands, private hands, basically every, uh, every woman in India owns a tiny bit of gold or even a lot of gold as part of a dowry. They know how to diversify as well, right? Yes, and they don’t trust paper money, they had a demonetization which was enormously destructive to the economy.

1:09:06 Okay, and which basically you wake up one day and they tell you, oh, the 20 pound note is no longer valid tender, you have 90 days to return it to your bank to exchange it for the new notes, and if you can’t explain where you got all your cash from, it will be confiscated. That’s financial education right there, chaos, that’ll sober you up. And billion and a half people who speak English, uh, in very large numbers, uh, who have an 80 percent undocumented, they don’t have IDs, forms of ID, and unbanked population.

1:09:39 It’s not 80 now, it’s a bit less. But wow, so perfect basically for the crypto market. Yeah, they totally need it, and also a large destination for international remittances because of the millions of Indians who live abroad and send money home to their families and get ripped off by money transmitting companies that take a big chunk of that. Right, Western Union takes massive chunks out of people’s. Yes, the poorer the country, the more expensive it is.

1:10:06 So you know, we’ve had all of these, um, developments and you know, to your point, does everybody need crypto or should everybody buy some? I think people who have a familiarity with technology, um, who are concerned about the way the future of the world is developing, who, um, want to take a gradual approach and learn a bit and then tipito, you know, like take a small reasonable invest, that’s always a good idea, it’s a good idea for diversification. At the very least you’ll get to practice with this technology and see what it’s like, which by the way is why I think a lot of your staff have done that.

1:10:45 We see a very, very strong generational component here, so millennials, which you know most people picture as teenagers but now, you know, 37-year-olds are millennials, or, um, so curious about the technology, grew up with technology, grew up with the internet, right? Um, the proposition, how about the form of money that runs on the internet instead of terrifying is promising, right? There’s a big gap generationally with that. Okay, and frankly don’t see other good avenues for investment, they see a lot of the other things as rigged games that they don’t really understand that are being manipulated, right, like stocks and bonds and mutual funds, which really are high transaction costs, somewhat rigged games, but I mean, you know that crypto has its own risks too, but, um, I think it’s also about a familiarity with or feeling that you can learn from one and it’s not uh, something that’s completely alien versus the other.

1:11:49 I think people should really look at things in a diversified way but yeah, no, I mean, I had my first piece of Bitcoin, I think it was like 2012 or ’13, and, um, so I’ve always played with it, the wallets, the storage, I lost, forgot where it was, it’s fun. The transaction speed is incredible, so I’ve been able to buy some things online with it and it’s just so fast, so incredible. Also, you know, not having a credit card processor when you’re a vendor, you realize how much of a pain that is, enormous, how skewed it is in favor of the customer sometimes, just like not realistically or not even in a favorable way, you’re at that, at their hands really sometimes by processors like Stripe, I love Stripe, but you know, sometimes if the processor wants to just turn you off for whatever reason, and we’ve seen this happen with, we were talking earlier about things like Patreon and the credit card companies, like all this stuff can be held hostage, they have enormous power.

1:12:40 Yeah, and who gave them that power, right? So we talk about crypto, especially Bitcoin, it’s right in the name, of the, in the title of the white paper, as peer-to-peer electronic cash. Peer-to-peer is a technical term that started with a form of networking called peer-to-peer networking, perhaps you remember Napster and BitTorrent and all of those things, P2P or peer-to-peer, encompasses the ethos of this entire movement. It’s about decentralization, it’s about them not having an intermediary in between you.

1:13:15 I like to call traditional payment systems “peer to corporation to corporation to corporation to peer” where you didn’t invite any of those three corporations into your transaction, they just injected themselves. And here’s the worst thing, politicians around the world are trying to gradually reduce the usefulness of cash until they can eradicate it completely, and this is driven by two things. One is a very, very cynical perspective that this helps, you know, grease the wheels of these payment companies and they pay and persuade politicians with lobbying that this is a good idea, and the other one is this very misguided idea that if you eradicate cash you eradicate crime, which of course you won’t because people will substitute cash with something else, and also if the only people who are allowed to be intermediaries are the large corporations, they will commit the crime.

1:14:12 It’s like if you want to rob a bank nowadays the best way to do so is to have a banking license, then you can rob the entire bank and or country um, with complete immunity or impunity. So it encourages this concentration of power, puts the intermediaries in a position where they can commit what I call mega crimes, where they impact millions of people, hence the metric system prefix mega. Right, right, so mega crimes is when you have a million victims and guess what happens if you rob one person and steal 20 pounds from them, you’re going to jail and you’re going to spend a long time there.

1:14:53 If you rob 2 million people of their homes and mortgages, right, you’re not going to jail, you’re getting a 10 million bonus from the bank and you’re retiring in peace and quiet in the countryside. That’s what happens, so mega crimes are much better to commit. Unfortunately you need a banking license to do those, which is why it’s a rarified kind of, uh, level of crime that only a few can participate in. Here’s the thing with the developments of crypto, we have the opportunity to do peer-to-peer, when you can make a payment from a person to a person, and we’re at a very dangerous crossroads in history, which is if we go to a future where digital cash is the only form of cash that exists, and I think we’re heading in that direction very, very fast, I think within 20 years people who grow up 20 years from now will never see cash unless they visit a museum.

1:15:56 If we go to that future, digital cash, we’re at a crossroads because we have to choose between two possibilities. One is digital cash that’s run by corporations that act not only as intermediaries in all of our payments but also act as deputized members of law enforcement for every government and or intelligence agency and or dictator who coops them to their means, and they have enormous power. That type of finance takes the worst of surveillance capitalism and the worst of surveillance states, merges them together in this fascist dystopia where every transaction you ever make tells something about your habits, your politics, your associations, your movement, your physical location, and on the one hand all of this data gets collected and shared among all of the intelligence agencies and corporations or leaked, and on the other hand if the people in power choose to, they can decide to debank you overnight, they turn off the switch.

1:17:03 Now imagine what happens if your bank account is shut down and cash doesn’t exist? Well, you can’t eat, you can’t buy food, done, you can’t use transportation, you can’t rent an apartment, you, they can literally destroy your life in a second. And if you think this is crazy, this is happening today in China. They have a system called Sesame, it’s called a social credit score, and they use your social media postings to give everyone a score as to how well they toe the line of political correctness, to the doctrine of the lead of the Communist Party.

1:17:42 People who have a negative credit score on that system are denied access to public transportation, they’re denied access to airlines, they’re denied access to trains, they’re denied access to jobs in the government, they’re denied access to apartments to rent. They’re doing that today, now, today. Those people have cash to go back on. What happens when there’s no cash? It’s a terrifying future.

1:18:08 And then there’s the alternative, and the alternative is a true peer-to-peer, or several, perhaps even thousands of alternative peer-to-peer digital internet-based currencies that do not belong or not controlled by any state, any corporation, that are run by rules that are collaborative, that depend on the participation of all of the people who use them, and they give you complete freedom and privacy to transact. That’s the crossroads we’re sitting at today, and most people have no idea this is happening. They’re like, cool, I can just use my debit card, it’s so easy, I don’t even need to touch the terminal now, I can wave it over the terminals, like I waved away democracy.

1:18:53 Look at that, so efficient, because we’re giving up that chance of an anonymous transaction which cash gives us or the P2P network gives us. Yes, absolutely. You told this story recently where you were trying to get a small dollar payment from one of your, from someone in Russia, right, and you were just saying how that became a massive issue, um, and how maybe 100 years ago it wouldn’t have been because people paid each other with cash. Well, no, I mean in 100 years ago we didn’t have a connected international world where people operate across international borders as much, traders who moved between countries, yes, they used cash but mostly they used gold, they used gold coinage issued by, among others, Britain and Spain and, uh, Germany, and they used those.

1:19:41 Yeah, until those stopped circulating. And what happened with you when you tried to get a 500 payment made from Russia, like what did you, it took five or six months, if I remember correctly, of back and forth, and who are these people? They’re my publisher. Great, who owns the company? List of all of the shareholders, what are their personal home addresses, what percentage of the company do they own?

1:20:02 It’s like, they translated my book. Um, but I had to go through this whole process of justifying to my own banks, the American bank, that these people were not involved in something. So it’s basically guilty until proven innocent. Of course, but also it disproportionately affects people who already do not have privilege. I’ll tell you a really, really important story about what happened to me recently, in fact last week.

1:20:32 So last week I was in Berlin and I was at a conference and I was talking about privacy and security and trust and the impact of cryptocurrencies, and after, I was doing a book signing at the conference and a guy comes up to me and he said, “I was really touched by what you said and I want to share my personal story with you because this is very, very personal to me,” and he said, “I have not been able to open a bank account in more than 10 years. Um, I’m Iranian, I was born in Iran, I haven’t been to Iran in more than 15 years.” Young kid who’s in his 20s, the last time he was in Iran he’s probably like five or six years old, maybe, right?

1:21:17 “I have a job, I pay taxes, I have a college education, I don’t break the law, I’m entirely above board, all I want is somewhere for my company to pay my salary so I can have a debit card and buy groceries. I cannot open a bank account, I couldn’t open a bank account when I lived in Malaysia for four years, I can’t open a bank account now that I live in Germany for six years. Every bank I go into, the moment I say my name and they ask me my place of birth, they immediately stop everything, I can’t open a bank account.

1:21:51 It doesn’t matter how many things I show them, I have no criminal record, I’ve lived in, uh, you know, free countries for so many years, and simply because of where I was born, something I had no control over, and I have no association with anyone in this country, I have no association with the government, no interest in the politics, just because of where I was born I cannot live my life, I cannot transact.” So you were talking about, you know, the British banks don’t like you, imagine, and this happened, this, the list of countries this happens to is probably more than a dozen nowadays, but it’s getting longer because we’re now getting more into these using currency as, uh, a weapon in trade wars and as a weapon in cold wars between countries and so sanctions and embargoes, etc., which of course hurt the innocent people who live in these countries more than they hurt the leaders who have Swiss bank accounts or American bank accounts, to be honest, because that’s a great tax haven, um, you know, these people through no choice of their own have done nothing wrong, are prejudged by corporations that have no obligation to due process, there’s no way to get out of this Kafka-esque nightmare.

1:23:18 Right, so they’re in a financial jail into which they’ve been convicted without the trial and from which they can’t escape because there’s no appeal, and the banks can simply say no for no reason without even telling you why, and that’s it, there’s nothing you can do about it. And of course when a bank account is now required to do almost anything, try renting an apartment without a bank account, without showing bank statements, or try running a business without a bank account. So you know, if you need an ID to get a bank account, you need bank out to get everything else, but it’s not a right, it’s a privilege, and it’s a privilege that’s controlled by a private corporation that is running under rules imposed by a government bureaucracy, not because of some law that’s passed but because of some administrative decision they made recently, and you can just cut off millions of people from access to the world economy, make them non-people from the perspective of their ability to transact with others.

1:24:27 We have to stop this. Not only do we have to find a better way but we have to unroll what’s happening already, and to me that’s the biggest imperative. This is about the other six billion people and we’re very far away from it, the technology isn’t ready, but the direction is right. And what about people that say we have to watch the money, that can fund terrorism and all these bad things, because that’s kind of why a lot of these laws were put into place?

1:24:57 Well, that’s a common argument for it, but look at the facts. Terrorism is funded primarily by state institutions. Terrorism is funded by countries, their intelligence agencies, their State Department or Foreign Office, we have our dirty little hands. When I say we, I mean Britain and the U.S., funneling billions and billions of dollars to the very governments that committed terrorist attacks. Let’s not kid ourselves, right?

1:25:36 My president just signed an arms deal with a country that dismembers journalists with hacksaws in their embassies. This is, uh, nothing happened, nothing happens, right? So who’s funding terrorism? We are, with our tax money, directly, and so are hundreds of other governments around the world. Terrorism is war by asymmetric means and by those who have a smaller budget, and it’s often funded by the very same budgets that fund war and also stopping.

1:26:18 So first of all, giving surveillance capabilities over everything we do as a totalitarian solution to stop crime has never worked in the history of humanity, and what it has done is it turns the state institutions that have that power and surveillance capability into terrorists themselves, right, of a more subtle kind. They don’t blow up people in markets or drive vans around and kill people that way, no, they do it in a much more subtle way. Like if instead of blowing up a van in the market, instead you starve three million people in Yemen, is that less terroristic?

1:26:56 Terrorism is the imposition of violence in order to achieve political means. Kind of sounds like that fits the bill, but because it’s done at arm’s length, through an ally, through an executive order that goes through the State Department, etc., it’s not something we pay attention to. People being given freedom of transaction and the ability to control their own money is how the world has worked for thousands of years. It didn’t cause an enormous amount of terrorism, quite the opposite.

1:27:30 What has caused enormous amounts of terrorism has been the enormous increase in state actions and shadow wars, that’s what’s caused it. And so removing the ability of people to transact, cutting people off from the world economy, condemning them to poverty, removing their ability to access resources across borders and build a better future for their children, that will most definitely create more terrorism. If you give people the ability to transact and give them the freedom to build a better future for their children, they use their money to buy healthcare, sanitation, clean water, education.

1:28:09 That’s what they do, all of the statistics speak to that. So I think that’s a very cynical argument and the idea that we can control human behavior by proxy by giving this enormous power of money and banking to a few select unelected people, I think it’s a very dangerous idea, it’s a totalitarian idea. So it’s just like we said the church and the state, we should separate the bank and the state. Absolutely, separation of money and state in 20, 25 years will be considered an obvious idea, of our second enlightenment, that all civilized people do.

1:28:48 If your government does not trust its own people the ability to control their future and have freedom to transact as well as to express themselves, to associate, to speak, that says a lot about your government, not about its people. Right, it’s a litmus test. Yeah, and yet we’ll go on the streets and protest our right to speak or our right to privacy or we’ll go after these social media giants, but nobody really goes after their right to privacy with their banking information and their spending information.

1:29:23 It’s something that seems to be off the radar. Well, because the people who are cut off from the world financial systems, the people who have already been embargoed, sanctioned, shut down and cut off, they had, they have no means to do that. Right, they’re out there, they’re speaking, they’re protesting by their millions, right, we see it every now and then on CNN, those protests get shut down pretty fast. What about the rest of us, should we be more concerned about the information our financial institutions have on us?

1:29:59 The rest of us will become like them. This is the really important thing to realize, which is that justice, as Martin Luther King said, justice denied from one is justice denied for all. Right, or even better, peace is not the absence of violence or war, it’s the presence of justice. You want a peaceful world, you need to make sure that everybody has access to justice, and that means among other things the ability to build a better future for their children, which most humans will do out of a biological imperative, and not let the tiny, tiny percent, which is less than, you know, one in a hundred thousand, who are sociopaths determine the policy of the entire world and allow you to the moral weakness to just cut off millions of people from access to the world economy, because that then creates much worse monsters.

1:30:58 You know, the thing is we’ve allowed fear to dominate the political discussion, I think, and it’s a lot, what will, what will the children think, think about the children, what if they see something raunchy on television, or what about the terrorists, so what about the criminals, so what about, you know, criminals have already always existed, they’re not going away, if you suppress these technologies criminals will still use them. They have, you know, pretty good track record of using the most advanced technology they can because they have the right profit motives and risk motives to do that. What you’re stopping is the people who will use it for good from using it, and you’re concentrating power in a way that’s very dangerous.

1:31:46 Um, but I think we need to be less cynical about these things and really have more hope in humanity. Do you ever get in trouble? I mean, do you do you ever worry about being banned from travel by talking about these ideas? You know, I have, again, I have an enormous amount of privilege. Um, I do get in trouble, I get in trouble um, with individuals, not governments.

1:32:18 Um, you know, some of the things I talk about offend people, um, I’ve been threatened many, many times, I tend to get threatened by various extremists, and for the most part I don’t have trouble with governments. Then again, there are certain places I can’t travel to because it would just be crazy dangerous for me to go to those places, such as, especially with the things I say, I don’t want to start naming them. Okay, that’s going to make it even worse.

1:32:52 Okay, even worse for me. All right, but places you’ve said things about their central banking procedures or no, where I’ve said things about their vicious, brutal dictatorships. Okay, so, um, no trips to Turkey anytime soon? Not anymore, unfortunately. I’ve been to Turkey, it’s a lovely country with wonderful people, but you’d rather not chance it now because I’ve not, with the situation they have now.

1:33:15 No, because it’s dangerous, because it’s dangerous for people who speak, it actually, as of last year they’re the world’s number one jailer of journalists, that says everything you need to know. So you know, there are some places where I can’t go, but other than that, no, I’m not worried about, like, certainly not worried about the US government or the British government shutting down my right to travel. First of all, they can’t because I have more than one password, passport.

1:33:44 Okay, um, but secondly, at most I’d get harassed at an airport for a few hours. Okay, and why do individuals, “I hate you so much,” I mean, why, what do you say that bothers them so much? Because everything you’ve seen seems to be making sense, you know. Well, what makes sense to one person offends somebody else, it’s just a matter of numbers, but I’ve I’ve been enormously lucky in terms of having this platform to have my voice heard and have my ideas out there and be able to discuss them in a very public way, and I have a lot of followers on social media and that brings a certain statistical aberration, which is, you know, one in a thousand people has sociopathic tendencies.

1:34:28 You gather a million people on social media, that means there’s a few among them who will get enormously offended, they’ll take something personally, and then they’ll threaten. Okay, it’s just something that comes with the job. Gotcha, all right, it’s like a lightning rod. Um, yeah, exactly, and I think it happens to I mean, it’s not something specific you say, like it happens to completely innocuous personalities as soon as they have a certain number of uh, followers or they have a certain influence in the media.

1:35:00 Yeah, it does become a numbers game, although I’m just with everything you talk about it just seems like, yeah, I mean J.K. Rowling gets hate mail. Yeah, for Frank’s sake, but hate mail is one thing, you know, a kid’s and death threats, right? Yeah, a kid’s author, just to give an example of someone who’s completely innocuous, right? Um, we talked earlier, the blockchain itself, what would you think it’s going to be used in the future, and what is it just obvious that it’s not going to be used in, or it’s just being thrown out there because it’s a buzzword?

1:35:29 So to me I think one of the important things to realize is what is important about the blockchain and what capabilities does it enable, and I’ve talked about the five pillars, um, and you can add a few more, maybe talk about the seven pillars, but so the pillars of a blockchain that I care about are it has to be open, meaning that you should be able to access it and use it without any vetting or authorization or setting up an account, just download software and participate in the network, no one gets to tell you no, you can’t be part of this. So it has to be open, it has to be borderless, this is an internet technology, it’s fundamentally borderless, where you come from, where you are does not matter. It has to be neutral, uh, blockchain technology, let’s give an example of payments, it does not care who the source is, who the destination is, what the value is, it routes from one end to the other, just like the internet doesn’t care about source, destination or content.

1:36:26 That neutrality is a critical component for freedom as well as very, very rapid innovation and the development of new capabilities. It has to be censorship resistant, meaning that no one should be able to stop a transaction from happening, whether that’s a payment or some other form of transaction, or block people from participating in the system, and censorship resistance does not mean censorship proof. You can shut down parts of it, you can deny, deny, disrupt access to parts of it some of the time, you can’t disrupt all of it all of the time, just like the internet, some parts of it go down, like last week Google had a really big hiccup, sometimes you can’t access certain sites from certain places, but eventually determined people always find a way to get around these restrictions and find a clear path no matter where they are, no matter what they’re trying to do, and that’s important.

1:37:24 I also think it has to be public, so the system has to be open and everyone should be able to verify it, which means it’s also transparent. In terms of payments you also need privacy, uh, without privacy then many of the other features become weak, like if you don’t have sufficient privacy then you can’t prevent it from doing a transaction but you can be punished afterwards, right? So because if I get a million pounds in Bitcoin to my account and it’s public information, then I might be able to be found out or taxed or something after the fact.

1:38:01 I’ll give you an even simpler example, if I send money to, uh, someone who is a citizen of Iran, I’m in violation of the State Department and Treasury rules. Okay, um, it’s a felony, right? It’s as simple as that. But also, you know, if you buy an inhaler from the Silk Road or something else like that, buy something that is perfectly legal in the country where you are, you know, perfectly little to consume, but is illegal in another country that you have an association with or that you visit later, right?

1:38:31 Okay, so that’s why privacy is important. Privacy is important because even in free countries because it’s a fundamental human right, but it’s even more important to non-free countries because in those countries your political associations, um, can be very easily not only scrutinized but also disrupted um, by control over finance. Okay, a couple other things, was that, we mentioned everything there? No, I think I mentioned everything, and immutable is one of the characteristics that we see in Bitcoin and others, which is once you’ve recorded something on the blockchain it can’t be erased from history or reversed.

1:39:09 Um, immutability is a characteristic that builds over time, so if I make a transaction now, for the next hour or so it could probably, with a bit of effort, get reversed. Uh, after it’s had six confirmations, as we call it in Bitcoin, uh, six ten minute periods have passed, six blocks have been mined, it’s pretty much guaranteed to stick around. After a day uh, it is immutable, uh, the probability of reversing that transaction has dropped so low. I’ve made this prediction, I say, you know, in our generation we say it’s as good as written in stone and our children will say it’s as good as on a blockchain.

1:39:48 You know, okay, it cannot be changed, and that brings some very important applications. You can do things like proof of existence, I can record a document and say this document existed on this date, and once that’s recorded on a blockchain, after a day I can always prove, look, on that date it was there. Um, and that’s very useful, very useful. And so Bitcoin and Ethereum have all these things, all these different six characters, to different degrees. Okay, so everything has some mixture of these characteristics, so you’ve got to think of them as a kind of a multi-dimensional set of, like, bars, right, so you could have five out of five on that one but only three out of five on the other one, and you have to make your own assessment, and also they change over time, things become more centralized or more decentralized, you have to be vigilant.

1:40:37 But then there are also a number of corporate, centralized or permissioned blockchains, as they’re called, which have none of these characteristics, so they’re not open, they’re not borderless, they’re not censorship resistant, they’re not neutral, they’re not public, they’re not transparent, they call themselves blockchains. Facebook is launching, presumably next month, uh, their own coin. I don’t, we joke and we call it Zuckbox, um, but they’re going to call it GlobalCoin I think, or something like that, right?

1:41:09 Um, and the irony of course is it’s not global coin because it can’t be borderless, and the reason it can’t be borderless is because as global as Facebook is in most of its reach, its jurisdiction is very carefully controlled, so if you are a US citizen who has Facecoin you can’t send it, or Zuckbox, you can’t send it without restrictions, they’re going to be subject to the same laws that PayPal has, any of the other big banks, so it can’t be borderless, it can’t be neutral, they have to know the identity of both parties in every transaction and those parties must be allowed. It’s not open, they have to be vetted in order to participate, uh, it’s not censorship resistant, they have a legal obligation to censor transactions, certain transactions, right?

1:41:56 Okay, um, so therefore it has none of these characteristics, which means it doesn’t qualify as what? And, oh, it doesn’t qualify as what in your men, in your minds? For me it doesn’t qualify as revolutionary, interesting or impactful to the future. Okay, it’s going to impact banks because it competes very directly against banks. If you’re a banker you should be terrified now, because you’ve got Bitcoin coming on one end, open, peer-to-peer, borderless, you know, you can’t play in that game at all because it’s an alien thing, right?

1:42:25 And then on the other end your best business, which is making payments and using technology, is now being threatened by a company that knows how to do technology much better than you and has a dopamine playful algorithm that can make people addicted and 2 billion users on day one. You’re screwed. All right, so you’re excited by this development because it ultimately will help the crypto market, but you’re clear to say this is not crypto as we know it, as far as it doesn’t serve the same market, right?

1:42:56 It doesn’t serve the same market, it might serve some markets and it’s an interesting experiment, it will promote the whole, um, space, but it doesn’t serve the same market as the open private to peer crypto. Okay, but will it be successful, do you think? Oh, I think of course it will be successful. They tried to do that a few years ago, or no, no, I don’t think so. I mean, let’s call it GlobalCoin or Coin or whatever they’re gonna call it, I don’t know if they did, I mean there’s all of these rumors that swirl around that everybody gets excited, etc., but the other thing you have to realize, and this is really, really important, more than anything else, this is a surveillance coin.

1:43:40 It is uh, the worst kind of surveillance coin connected to the worst kind of surveillance company that’s exercising the worst kind of surveillance capitalism, right? So you want to play in that? I would never. I don’t have Facebook applications, I don’t have an account, I don’t use it, it’s not on my phone, I would never touch that stuff. You want to go there, great.

1:44:04 Remember every time you make an easy transaction and you hear the little ding ding sound of that, remember that’s the sound of democracy dying, that’s the sound of independence dying, that’s the sound of personal privacy dying, and you just made someone rich while killing all of the things that matter in free societies. That’s harsh. It’s true though, it’s true, it’s the absolute reality. Yes, Grandpa likes sharing pictures. Yes, but Grandpa also used to be free and his grandchildren are not going to be, so every time he shares a picture you’re watching democracy die a bit, and absolutely.

1:44:40 Yes, they’re manipulating elections, they’re manipulating our dopamine responses, they’re manipulating attention, they’re spreading radicalism and extremism, they’re spreading misinformation that’s leading to the greatest measles outbreak in the world ever seen, they’re spreading conspiracy theories, and they’re doing all of that while driving advertising and your personal information to, you know, to people who are monetizing it, and now they’re going to get in the money business, and now they’re going to get into the money business and if you let them they’re going to be very successful with that and eventually they’re going to beat the banks at it and then Facebook’s going to be your bank, good luck ever escaping that. Yeah, I mean that’s the thing, I mean people get very sensitive about their information and privacy and Facebook, but that having your money, which is another form of free speech, right, is that the way you talk about it is absolutely it as a form of speech, can you explain that to people?

1:45:38 Well, money is a language, you know, if you look at it from a very raw perspective, uh, money doesn’t have value, right, and this is an important thing that most people don’t immediately understand, is that money itself doesn’t have value. Money is a vector for transmitting value, it’s how you express value, but the value isn’t in the money, it’s in the product or service you bought with it and it’s in the labor you gave in order to acquire it in the first place. That’s where the value comes from, there’s nothing intrinsically valuable in the money.

1:46:11 Some forms of money in the past had intrinsic value, with gold and things like that, because that was the best way to establish it in the beginning, but money doesn’t need to have value, in fact it gets a bit in the way. What you want money to do is communicate value, and it allows us as a society to coordinate markets and behaviors by saying, “This is important to me and I’m going to express that to you by giving you three tokens of appreciation that I had to work for.” And the time cost of money is one of the most important characteristics.

1:46:45 You know, we value money, most people value money based on how many hours of personal labor and effort it takes to acquire it. That’s why at some point it becomes funny money when you could acquire it trivially and you don’t work anymore for it, but other than that, in most social environments money is the way we express things. So if you look at it, what is it? It’s an abstract symbol, symbolic, right, and that symbol is used to express something and to assign a measure of value to it, so it has semantic value, it has meaning.

1:47:20 So abstract symbols that have meaning that people exchange with each other, we call language. That’s what it is, it’s a peculiar language, it’s not a general purpose language like English, but then again neither is C plus plus that we use in programming, or PHP or HTML, that doesn’t make it any less of a language, it just makes it a language of narrow scope and applicability. Money is a language of extremely narrow scope and applicability but enormous power because what it expresses is value, especially the value of human time, which is extremely valued, valuable to people, and therefore it allows societies to coordinate on what they communally decide is valuable by aggregating the information of every individual decision you make as to is this worth enough of the time value I’ve put into work today?

1:48:13 Do I want it enough? Do I value it enough? And if you do, you send a signal that other people also coordinate with, that sets prices that allow us to say, okay, we need more of this good because that good is important because people are buying it. So it’s a coordination mechanism, and once you realize that, you realize that it has a few characteristics that are really important. First of all, because it’s a language that helps society coordinate the allocation of resources, many of your freedoms depend directly on your ability to express that language.

1:48:48 Um, controlling that language is enormously powerful, if you control the flows of money you can control a lot of social activities as well as expression of personal values, which is what the central bank, which is the censorship and the surveillance capitalism angle of this, and um, also if you free it completely, um, then it gives a degree of personal liberty that is enormous. Then you can look at it from a technical perspective and say, well, if it’s just a language, oh, we can make it entirely digital, it doesn’t need to have physical form, we can communicate it instantaneously to any part of the planet, borders are meaningless, um, race, religion, nationality, gender, you know, none of these other social constructs are meaningful in the context of that language.

1:49:43 So true neutrality means anyone or anything to anyone or anything, you don’t even need to be human to engage in the activities of money, software agents can do it, which is unique to Bitcoin and other open public blockchains, is that until now only humans or associations of humans have allowed to have ownership of assets under law, and now in fact perhaps not involved, but in fact software agents can independently own money without any human supervision, which is another mind-blowing thing that we haven’t considered the implications. Does that mean AI could create companies in the future to satisfy human demand? We can already create autonomous companies that operate without human supervision, they’re called decentralized autonomous organizations or DAOs, and that’s actually one of the really interesting applications that comes out of Ethereum, which is another open public blockchain.

1:50:41 Ethereum is not about payments, it’s about governance and running software that acts autonomously, so you could have a corporation that has plenty of shareholders but no bosses, or plenty of employees but no bosses, or no employees, no shareholders and no bosses and operates on itself. One of the little mental things I like to throw out, like a memetic idea, is what happens when you combine um, ride hailing services with autonomous vehicles with decentralized autonomous organizations and cryptocurrencies. You could have a cell phoning self-driving taxi, which is a taxi that by coincidence, by accident or deliberately, became emancipated, as a taxi that owns itself, that drives itself, that owns and charges money from its customers and pays for its own electricity, maintenance, gas or whatever, that doesn’t have a human owner at all, it might even have shareholders or not, um, and it’s just out there existing as this entity, right, that survives in this world and makes a net profit obviously.

1:51:52 Sometimes now belongs, that doesn’t belong to anyone. Yeah, that’s, and which is the most efficient, how could that possibly happen? Right, and the best kind of idea of that, which is almost like a little sci-fi story, is, well, it was owned by a person and that person died without a will or any heirs and no one noticed because the taxi continued to work, and so it became emancipated because it became an asset that’s intestate, it’s not being inherited by anyone and no one seized it or stopped it from operating, so the morning after its owner died the garage door opened and it went out on its taxi rounds autonomously without noticing that anything changed because of that.

1:52:31 So you can actually see scenarios where this happened, this is based I read this article about, they have this phenomenon in Japan where old people die in their apartments and they’re not discovered for two or three years because all of their banking is automated, the air conditioning is on, their their pension check keeps arriving in their bank, it pays the rent, it pays the electricity, and nobody notices they’re dead because there’s no one around to notice, they don’t have any heirs or relatives. And now imagine if that person owned an autonomous taxi business and died, it can happen, just keep going. Almost like the emancipation of slavery, right, like, you know.

1:53:10 Well, no, but there’s no agency here, right, there’s no agency. Um, and to some people this is a scary future, and of course, you know, whenever you come up with these crazy sci-fi ideas you can make a Black Mirror episode out of it and you can look at all the dark sides of this. You know, a lot of people would think about autonomous organizations that do malice, but I like to think of it in terms of what about building a decentralized altruistic organization, like a decentralized charity, a charity that collects charitable giving, donations in cryptocurrency, and then in response to activities that happen in the world, for example noticing keywords about earthquakes or tsunamis in particular regions, right, then distributes these charitable donations directly to people who are in that country, perhaps by saying, “Show me a geolocation on your phone that proves you’re currently in the disaster zone and I will send you a small amount to help you out.”

1:54:07 And then you’d have a hundred percent of all donations go directly to charitable uses, zero operating costs, zero people in the middle to take advantage, complete transparency, open books, and you could have an autonomous charity with no humans involved. Bizarre, I know, but this is within our future. Yeah, I’ve thought about it oftentimes, and like you said there could be the malevolent aspect of maybe a, um, autonomous crypto shakedown group, it would just go right, a digital extortion organization.

1:54:38 That’s going to happen for sure, I mean it’s already happening, right? Of course it is, with you, but an autonomous, self-replicating system that extorts. Yeah, that’s going to happen too, right? That’s actually happening with different government institutions and NHS and all that stuff, anywhere you have, uh, improperly secured computers or probably backed up computers, someone will help you see the error of your security and backup ways by throwing a little spanner in there.

1:55:03 Yeah, it’s fascinating when you think about, like, Adam Smith, the invisible hand of capitalism, is this thing that this system was created to where everything is created for the right reasons, it comes in place, there’s supply and demand and all this stuff functions effortlessly, and if you really believe in that system then money should be able to go wherever it needs to go with no frictions. Even if you don’t believe in that system, here’s the one, the weird and wonderful thing is that these systems are, whether we like it or not, they’re neutral to politics. You want to build a decentralized autonomous communist cooperative, go ahead, write the code, you could build it as a smart contract, you could deploy it on a blockchain and it could communally pool all of the incomes of all of the participants and then distribute them from those that have to those that need, an equal proportion or whatever algorithm you put in there, you can implement any form of governance, there’s no particular form of governance.

1:56:04 Now some will be more successful, some will be less successful, governance now becomes a competitive endeavor of competing operating systems or software systems that exist on these platforms. It’s wild, it’s going to disrupt a lot of social institutions, and it’s coming just at the right time because what’s already disrupting a lot of these social institutions is globalization and the increasingly interconnected and scalable nature of humanity, meaning that all of the institutions that work so effectively that came out of the Industrial Revolution, all of these 18th and 19th century institutions that we take for granted today, from parliamentary democracy to the modern corporation to stock exchanges, all of these things happened in the last three, four hundred years, all of those institutions have hit scalability walls.

1:57:02 They no longer solve important global issues that you can’t contain within borders, like climate change and pollution and war and human migration and global poverty and things like that. They no longer are accountable to the people who they’re supposed to be accountable to, you know. When, for example, when we had uh, the beginning of the American system of government, um, every single congress person represented 10,000 people, now some of them represent 10 million people because the population has increased.

1:57:44 How do you do that? Not scalable, concentrating decisions in one city on a country of 350 million people, badly unscalable, right? And if you create pyramid structures, the further away the top of the pyramid is from the bottom, the less information flows up and down, the more disconnected people become from the impact of their decisions. Pyramid scheme, representative democracy doesn’t scale, so what do we do instead? And by the way, I’m not arguing against democracy, I believe in even more, and more, I believe in direct democracy and more localization, make decisions locally that affect the people who are involved in those decisions, skin in the game, um, you know, so all of those institutions need to be re-envisioned for a modern, interconnected globe where communication travels at the speed of light and circles the globe in a matter of seconds, where the problems in one country cannot be contained and become the problems of everyone very, very quickly, either because of refugees or pollution or war or other, you know, poverty and hunger, etc.

1:58:56 And how do we solve those with better governance? I’m not saying crypto and blockchains are going to solve all of these problems, don’t get me wrong, I’m saying here’s a technology that might actually give us building blocks to do interesting governance experiments and maybe we start those experiments by building a better corporation with more accountability, shareholders, or a better local council for a small village, um, with transparent voting, um, maybe we build systems um, that allow us to have more easy flow of trade and commerce at first, and then if those work well we take them to the next scale. What I do know is that these scales, these systems can scale two levels that the previous systems couldn’t, so just as the internet took communication to a global scale and surpassed the limitations of newspapers and television and radio and the things we had before and telephones and really pulled the world together and also created a lot of ugly things, now we’re doing the same with money with cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, and the same with governance with blockchains like Ethereum, and there’s another 2000 blockchains, some of which are complete to not try out scams, most of which are, and some which are doing interesting little experiments, a little niches, and are going to teach us something.

2:00:26 Um, one of the things I love about this space is that it’s exploded, we’re having the Cambrian explosion of experiments and diversity in this space. What are some of the cool ones that are happening out there? I’m not gonna name any of them. because I’m gonna, I named the two that I’ve written books about, that I’ve studied the most, the others I don’t have enough time to study them in depth, but also an endorsement is a dangerous thing. All right, and I don’t endorse any of these, even for investment, right?

2:00:55 I’m talking about, I see interesting experiments in technology. Okay, and that could change the way all of our institutions, like you said, that have been grandfathered in for hundreds of years, might potentially work. Exchanges, we can now do healthcare, trust, security and currency on the internet, and just like the internet brought many huge advantages to the world and a lot of ugly things, it’s going to do the same now for money, trust and security.

2:01:25 Um, in many ways these early experiments, this Cambrian explosion of opportunities and possibilities in the blockchain space, it’s very confusing to people, there’s too many things going on and it’s moving too fast. I look at it a bit like a scientist and a technology focused person, which is one of the things that’s great about these experiments is that we learn a lot even if they fail, and if you look at science we actually learn more if they fail than if they succeed. If they succeed, you know, the narrow set of circumstances in which they succeeded this time in this context, if they fail they demonstrate a way that they can fail suddenly and catastrophically, which teaches you a lot more, right?

2:02:17 So if you look at one of these projects and they implode or their governance breaks down or people exploit a loophole or find a bug, you’re like, ah okay, so that’s how you blow up a blockchain, interesting, let’s not do that, and all of the other blockchains learn that lesson for free. Right, right, and some of them succeed, uh, or at least succeed for now under the current context and evolve a bit and then we’re like, okay great, we know what works, uh, or at least what works at this scale, let’s keep trying. Wow, it’s really fascinating, this whole autonomous network is really interesting because, yeah, I think about, like, the great startups we’ve had in the last five years or startups, like whether it’s an Uber or Facebook or whatever, but those were all humans in situations where they had to put their life on the line, they had to go raise capital, they had to convince people and try.

2:03:06 What if there was an autonomous network that was just constantly testing, experimenting, and when the capital was there would just go in and, you know, imagine the inefficiencies it would solve, and, right, it could be on one hand scary but on one hand just a billion dollar corporation just popped up in the last four months, no human ever would have thought about it, but some AI piece that was locked into a crypto thing just did it and now it did this massive you know, improve something, maybe in healthcare, maybe in charity or maybe in this, and now it’s just there. Even the example you just gave, and I’m just gonna dis a billion dollar company that just went on IPO, but Uber, what exactly does Uber do other than take twenty percent? They use it, it’s peer to corporate, they write software.

2:03:50 Okay, but so the reason I trust the driver is not because they’ve been vetted by Uber but because I look at the reputation score they have from other riders. Right, right, and you can do vetting, you can outsource the vetting part, that’s not hard, you could outsource that to another company and only accept users who have been vetted for that very you know, there is room for some vetting when you have the opportunity for people to come into contact in that way, that can be dangerous. And they act as an intermediary for the payment, which ensures that the driver will be paid and that I won’t pay more than I agreed to.

2:04:32 Great, we can do that with an escrow contract, we don’t need any company to do that as an intermediary and certainly not at a cost of 20%. They match riders to drivers. Well, they do that, but they only do it if the driver is running that application, and they do that in competition with five other companies, as a result they fragmented the market so there’s not enough drivers or riders to compete with them, and they create monopolies that are completely unnecessary.

2:04:58 Um, you know, they write great software, like, well honestly we could do that open source at this point. The idea was great but the execution has created this hierarchy where, where does most of the money go? Most of the money goes into debt servicing on, you know, on low interest, highly leveraged debts that they’ve been getting in order to expand their monopoly status, and I’m not just picking on Uber, I pick on any of these billion dollar unicorn technology companies and give me a good reason why they can’t be replaced by uh, a collaborative application that connects peer to peer without all of the intermediaries that cost a lot of money.

2:05:43 And so this is also from, and people hear that like, oh, that sounds a bit communist, right? Actually the exact opposite, we’re talking about increasing efficiency by reducing waste and shortening the distance from production to consumption or from supply to demand. Right, right, ultimately the work’s being done by a driver and the value is being provided by a customer, and that applies to Airbnb, it applies to a ton of other things. At some point you realize that there’s no need for a company.

2:06:23 Now in the internet era we already realized that in terms of there’s no need for a phone company if you can have a phone app, and that’s why Skype is free or any of these other messaging and video conferencing things are free, is because there’s no need for a company to take a percentage or value just to transmit communications, right? We’re going to see that happening, this is going to drive the second big wave of disintermediation on the internet, which ironically is going to disintermediate many of the first wave unicorn billion dollar companies because you don’t need them anymore. Interesting.

2:07:03 It’s going to take a while because at the moment there aren’t enough customers who have cryptocurrency access to it, the software and the infrastructure isn’t ready for all of that, but the ideas are already stewing, and so the sharing economy, yeah, is actually much more interesting if you envision it as a peer-to-peer sharing economy based on commonly agreed decentralized autonomously operating structures that provide trust, reputation, you know, and control the interaction so you can’t cheat each other, but otherwise don’t make any money of this, or if they do make a bit of money it’s in order to fund more software development. They do it in a completely decentralized manner. Yeah, it’s fascinating, I mean think about that, market capitalization of 80 or 100 billion dollars just being distributed back to the network, um, and then it being replaced by this peer-to-peer, the drivers get paid more, the customers pay less, and you have one less unicorn company.

2:08:00 But who cares? Goldman Sachs will lose an important destination for their debt products. Now the only thing that Uber needed to get started though was a massive capital investment, which took belief by other humans to get it started, right? And that’s something that would be hard to be done by an entrepreneur network only we had some kind of crowd funding mechanism that opened to a giant global pool of investors who otherwise didn’t have good investment opportunities and they could simultaneously improve the future of their children by taking a bit more risk, and that’s why ICOs are not just a scam, right?

2:08:42 They are now, almost entirely, but they are also the future of crowdfunding, right? Because we disintermediate a lot of the, it’s really ironic because this space got flooded by venture capitalists in 2014 and what got borne out of it actually disrupted venture capital first before any other industry. Yeah, it’s crazy because the ICO is quite beautiful in the way it’s laid out. Yeah, it just wasn’t used to the great means, and it also kind of, you’re right, kind of made, uh, those initial venture investments, well it takes them out of the loop, doesn’t it?

2:09:16 You don’t need them anymore. You don’t, and also you bridge this enormous gap that exists between the early, early, early stage organic funding where you have a founder who’s basically using a credit card or their savings or friends and family to invest in a tiny, tiny startup, and then you’ve got this gap, there’s a bit of angel investment in between but that’s mostly prevalent in the US, and then you have to get pretty successful before you can go for VC, and by that point the pipeline gets really, really narrow, so only a few companies make it that far, and then from there to get to a public offering. What if you can bridge that gap now?

2:09:55 Of course there will be a lot of scams and a lot of these companies don’t deserve to raise money, but here’s the interesting thing, this round of investors now are not so fast to invest in ICOs, the ones who got burned the previous round, they learned a very important lesson, right? And you know, when you look at the history of investors in the United States versus developing countries, like you look at investors, let’s say, in India, right, the difference isn’t better vetting, the difference is a hundred plus years of experience that has been passed down three generations or four generations. The reason American investors are harder to cheat with stupid investment schemes is because they’ve internalized a lot of the “looks too good to be true,” you know, um, 10% compound a month, uh, return on investment is probably a Ponzi scheme, and so they see these things and are immune to the obvious scams.

2:11:00 There’s a danger here because the scammers generally go for the least educated, the least informed, and usually also seniors who are in a more vulnerable age or even have, uh, cognitive issues and don’t remember uh, what happened, uh, recently, but you know, the way we build better investments and more security into the system is not by introducing the 19th or 20th century regulatory framework of institutional regulators, it’s by building a decentralized vetting and regulatory organization. You could actually build within the programmable systems themselves better mechanisms for trust, like for example putting the investments in escrow where the people who are involved in founding the company or who are running things get a small percentage of the money, the rest of it sits in a pool controlled by the shareholders, they dole it out, right, as needed based on repeated pitches and not just one take it all and run, right?

2:12:10 Um, where you have the, um, the owners and directors sharing control over what we call a multi-signature wallet, where it takes three out of the five people to sign so the CEO can’t just dive into the bank account and head to Aruba, where you have reputation scoring and, um, distributed research, like a distributed organization that pays people to do due diligence on investments, and the people who are best at due diligence based on their history get rewarded more by the very shareholders who want to invest in these things. We can build mechanisms for the 21st century to solve the problems of the technology that we built in the 21st century, we don’t have to go back and say, you know, it’d all be better if it was run by a king. Right, right, that’s what it really, well said.

2:13:01 100 years from now, what does this world look like if it’s gone the way you hope it will? I can’t even tell you what’s going to happen in crypto 100 days from now. Well, tell us, you know, it’s not going to happen in a hundred years, it’s not going away. Okay, 100 years from now, if it goes to where you want it to go, yes, what is, uh, what is, what does my day look like when it comes to my money and my spending? Is everything completely decentralized?

2:13:25 Is it all crypto? I don’t know, um, I think what happens is I think what happens is we live in a world where there’s far more equal access to opportunity and to the basic, um, to the basic human necessities and rights. We already live in a world where no one needs to go hungry, unfortunately we live in a world where people go hungry every day unnecessarily. I think a lot of young people aspire to that and then they hit middle age and they’re like, ugh, we can’t fix it, it’s impossible, right?

2:14:00 And it’s not, the history shows that things are getting better and better and better even though they look grim, they’re actually nuts, violence is down, uh, preventable deaths are down, life expectancies are up, fewer people go hungry every year, fewer people die of preventable diseases every year, the world’s getting a better place. Now can we accelerate that, can we better distribute resources where they’re needed and match with needs? A lot of that is inefficiencies that are mostly political in nature, and I think the internet gave us a glimpse of a more connected world and now we need to redisrupt the internet because some parts of it got awfully centralized and surveillance based.

2:14:44 Um, and cryptocurrencies now give us a second breath. I predict that in 30 years we’re going to have to disrupt with something else because to me the one lesson of history is that no matter what invention you create or new movement or reform or revolution exists in the world, within 30 years, within one generation, the people who are alive for it have started dying and or don’t remember much about it, the younger generation never knew a world without it, the people who gained the most power from it tried to co-opt it, and as soon as they climb the ladder they pull it up behind them and go, “See you, suckers,” and you have to re-disrupt things. You know, we think about disrupting banks today, think about what banks did in the 16th and 17th century.

2:15:33 At that time the only person who had an account, who could draw debt and write a check, was a king. That’s it, that’s it, there was only one person in the realm who could write a check drawn against the treasury, right? There was one bank, just one, and that was a modern invention, the idea now that everyone can, and in fact they don’t, we’ve surpassed that. I find it amusing that today the privilege of kings and queens is the things that, if the grandpa or grandma pulls out a checkbook in the line in front of you in the supermarket there’s an audible groan from 30 people, like, really?

2:16:16 But that’s a beautiful right actually that we’ve forgotten about, but that freed billions of people and raised billions of people from poverty, the modern corporation, that today in many ways has become, in some parts of the world, kind of this grotesque exploitive, exploitative system, was the first time anyone other than kings and aristocracy could invest in something, some venture, you know, and in those days venture meant actually going somewhere, like, here’s a ship, go find something. Um, those were the first ventures and the first corporations, and today many people in the Western world have access to an enormous array of ventures that they can invest in, but all of the systems eventually get co-opted, so the one enduring thing through all of history is the nature of change and the need for change.

2:17:15 Everything has to be disrupted. When people ask me if I’m politically left, politically right, a capitalist, a communist, I say I’m a disruptarian. I believe that every thing that we put in place, every reform, every new thing that we build is great because it brings new hope, new freedom, change. I’m very progressive in terms of wanting things to change and improve for people. I think there was no golden past, but we can have a great future if we all work with it, but no matter what, things will get co-opted, things will get compromised, things will get ossified and solidified and sclerotic, and then you need a new round of change and a new generation of hope to shake things up a bit, um, because if we don’t, the only way out of dysfunction usually is violent revolution and violent change, and it’s much better if we do it with nonviolent change, and I I strongly believe in non-violence and what we can achieve with collaboration and, uh, technology actually, but we need to have a disruptive mindset, we’re disrupting everything every five or ten years and be willing to do that, because all the young people that are into this blockchain now, 20 years from now they might be holding on to it with different dear life.

2:18:44 Oh right, when the next generation is saying, “Come on, we’ve got to move on.” You know the saying which is like, when everything that exists in the world, uh, when you’re born and into your uh, teen years, is as the world has always been, everything that comes into the world when you’re in your teen years to your early, you know, 30s is new and exciting and wonderful and full of hope. After you’re in your 30s or 40s, anything that comes into the world is an abomination against nature and should be stopped because it’s destroying the natural order of things and all of the things that were good and great when you were a child, right?

2:19:29 And so generational change is what drives humanity forward, right, the cycle of, we need young naive people who have not yet internalized the idea that it cannot be done and have the audacity to do it anyway because that’s the only success there is. And you know, I find myself at times afraid of new things and uh, uncomfortable with change and find it harder and harder each year to learn new things and to adapt and, um, to keep myself relevant. How old are you now, roughly?

2:20:04 I’m 46. Okay, really? I thought you were in late late 30s. Thank you so much. And what, where are you going to be in five years, like, what do you want to be doing?

2:20:12 I know you got a big team now, you see, like nine people. Yeah. You’ve six books, you’ve got education companies and all. Well, I have four books, the publishing company that I work with has published more. I have four books: Mastering Bitcoin, The Internet of Money volume one and two, which are non-technical and about why open blockchains matter, and Mastering Ethereum that was published in December.

2:20:34 Okay, I’ve distilled my focus at the moment to one simple, let’s call it a mission statement, as a cliche, which is educate as many people as possible in as many languages as possible about the future impact of open blockchain technology, and that’s my mission, it’s very simple. Um, and I added a few things, the “as many languages as possible” is in the last couple of years I’ve really focused on internationalizing my work, um, and because it’s the non-English speaking population that needs this the most. Exactly, exactly.

2:21:10 So I’m learning Spanish as fast as I can myself, as well as getting all of my work translated through an army of volunteers and supporters. Is Spanish the biggest force multiplier when it comes to a language, of a single language that can have the greatest, I mean English is, but, uh, second to English I would say it’s a tie between Spanish and Chinese. Okay, I mean because English maybe you’re already preaching to people who don’t need it as much as other people.

2:21:34 Exactly. So yes, I’m wondering if they asked, so Spanish and Chinese for our technology? Absolutely. Okay, and the impact you want to have on education, it’s Spanish and Chinese? Yes.

2:21:43 Okay, at first. And we mentioned India before, but like when you look at China, uh, you know, what do you see there? Hope? Well, they banned cryptocurrencies uh, two years ago. Um, well, they’ve banned cryptocurrencies five or six times in different ways and they always announce and then it actually doesn’t do what they said they do, but they banned exchanges.

2:22:05 They banned exchanges from having bank accounts, they haven’t banned personal ownership of crypto, so it’s just kind of moved underground, uh, which you know, if you want to be cynical, it’s so that the people who are part of the ruling party can stuff their digital wallets as full of cryptocurrencies as they can as they devalue the yuan month after month after month. Um, and you know, now that I’ve said that it’s going to be difficult to travel there, but you know, that’s always what happens, you can’t get crypto out of your country, can only get your country out of crypto. Um, so they’ve disrupted and damaged the local industry, um, but it hasn’t stopped the capital flight and the and the erosion of their currency controls.

2:22:49 Okay, tell me about you personally, what’s something you do every day that’s non-negotiable so you can continue to function as Andreas and, you know, do the work that’s important to you, because I know you’re always in different places. I read every day, uh, so it’s very important to me both as a form of leisure, uh, as a form of calmness but also to keep learning, so I read books non-stop as much as I can. Um, I try to get outside and walk every day, I try to do some form of fitness every day, and I try to avoid getting into the thick of it with emails and social media until late in the morning whenever I can.

2:23:30 When I’m writing books I actually push it back to 3 p.m. um, to avoid all of the destruct, sorry, distractions and drama of social media. Uh, I used to be a couch potato computer geek and fortunately in the last three years I got into fitness for the first time in my life and that’s been a huge change for me, it’s made me calmer and more centered, healthier, more energetic and stronger, and so like I’m the best shape of my life of 46, turning 47, that I’ve ever been before.

2:24:07 Wow, does the brain work better too when you’re taking care of the body? Yeah, and also because I eat better, I think I just cut sugar out completely from my diet, I don’t really eat too many carbs at all, and yeah, more mental clarity, more calmness, less anxiety. It’s been a real game changer for me. Wow, if I would ask, like, five of your best friends, what is Andreas’ superpower, like what would they say is the way that you can get all of the stuff done that you do, what is that one thing?

2:24:39 Um, I think they’d probably mention two things. One is my ability to explain difficult concepts in simple ways, and that comes from a lifetime of teaching and public speaking and trying to explain things to others, so a lot of practice. The other one is not practice but it’s this thing I’ve had since I was a child, which is a very, very strong memory, especially for things I’ve seen, so pictures, reading, numbers, uh, almost photographic, eidetic memory as it’s called, and I’ll read an article on Wikipedia once and then recite it like a year later.

2:25:24 I don’t know how it works, I really, it’s uncanny, but it allows me to absorb a lot of knowledge by reading and remembering things which then I can use in what I’m explaining. I can come up with metaphors and analogies and throw in, you know, facts and stories and relevance, information, not always perfectly, I make a lot of mistakes, I have a good facts checker that corrects them, but that’s probably what people would say about me. And you’re not afraid to get on stage and go for it, like you really put yourself out there a lot, don’t you?

2:25:55 I believe it’s very important to speak with truth, and, um, the people can sense when you are emotionally invested and being honest and authentic about what you say. I speak exactly what I have on my mind when I do, all of my talks are improvisational, most of the time I don’t actually know what I’m talking about until, I like, after the talk or germ while I’m saying something I’m like, whoa, that’s, I wonder where that came from, and, uh, it’s just flow, right, it’s I put myself in a sort of trance-like flow and I do my thing and, um, and I get emotional and I get into it and it’s real, it’s most real time I in my life is when I’m on stage, and part of it, you have to be vulnerable to do that, you have to say things that are very personal, uh, connect to the topic and the audience and be willing to put yourself out there and say things that maybe people are afraid to speak, right?

2:26:58 They’re like, what if I’m judged, what if people think I’m crazy or stupid, or if I say the wrong thing, or if you let that get in the way you lose all of the authenticity and power of your speech. So I learned that, fortunately, early on in my life. I bombed, I got embarrassed, I, and it wasn’t the end of the world, and the more I spoke from the heart, the more I spoke with vulnerability and connection to what I believe in, the more people responded. And the beauty of the internet nowadays is that you don’t need to adapt to your audience at all, you just go out there and you do you, and there’s at least 10,000 people in the world whose only interest is to watch that and nothing else, and they’re like, “This is it, this is the thing for anything,” and no matter how niche it is, you know, and you watch these people who are just so passionate about what they love to do, right?

2:27:53 It’s like, “I hand built an irrigation system from my asparagus farm, like, here’s a YouTube video of the 16 ways I put the pipes together,” and you’re like, who would watch that? And then there’s a hundred thousand views of people who are like, “This is it, it’s the best channel I’ve ever seen.” The internet gave us that, you know, the ability to go super niche, and I love it because it allows me to just be me, whoever likes it loves it, whoever doesn’t like it, they can go somewhere else, I don’t care.

2:28:22 It’s really well said. Um, what was the best day of your life and the worst day? What comes to mind? Oh, um, that’s a, that’s a, that’s a tough one, um, I wasn’t expecting that question. I might have asked you this before.

2:28:41 Yeah, I still don’t expect it every time, I probably should have prepared better. That’s all right, comes to mind. Oh, best day, uh, worst day of my life. Well, I recently lost someone in my family, it was very, very painful. Um, so loss is hard, and one of the things I realize is that increasingly that’s an aspect of aging, right?

2:29:06 So, um, being surrounded by people who are older, having the generation of my parents uh, age, my parents, um, and then experiencing loss again and again and again and the sudden realization that this is going to be the theme of the second half of my life, if I’m lucky enough, if I’m lucky enough to live long enough and not, and not be one of the people, but like the longer you live the more you’re surrounded by loss, and I’m beginning to realize how terrifying that can be and how hard it can be and really, really sad. Um, so that’s scary, and you know, one of the worst things that happened to me has been that has been lost. Um, best thing that ever happened to me, um, the phrase “your cancer is in remission.”

2:30:06 Can’t get much better than that. Well, that happened to me at age 29. It followed one of the scariest years of my life when I first got the C word diagnosed, so I was very, very lucky, I got it early, it was, uh, testicular cancer, highly treatable at the time, decade earlier not so treatable. Wow, very common in that age group of men. Exactly, it’s the one that hits very early, but 10 years earlier it wouldn’t have been treatable.

2:30:30 I think the University of Indiana treatment protocol that they developed was only 10 years old, I didn’t have to use that because I was one of the lucky few who caught it early enough and it wasn’t a very aggressive form, but other people who survived that survived it because of these new treatments. Wow. So you know, the most bizarre coincidences in life separate survival from not, life from death, so that was life changing and a weird but also great moment in my life.

2:31:06 What did it teach you? Um, well, it wasn’t that that taught me anything, that taught me nothing, that was just a huge relief. It was the year preceding it that taught me that, well, I can’t take anything for granted, this could be it, and gave me a completely new perspective on my life and what I wanted to do. I within one year I run out of to give, just immediately depleted, balance zero, and I achieved that rare state that most people achieve in their 80s when they suddenly have zero efforts to give and they just start living their life, not for tomorrow because there isn’t much tomorrow, but for right now, for what you really believe in, with very little fear because what’s the worst thing could happen to you?

2:31:54 Cancer, done. You know, death, possible, might as well move on. That perspective at 29 was enormously powerful, enormously powerful, and it changed my life. Um, of course within the next five to ten years the memory fades, the routine re-establishes itself, you lose track of what’s important, you forget that you’re mortal again, and but there’s still that little climber, that memory, and I can go back to that and go, ah, none of this matters, it’s all right, there’s a bus waiting around the other corner and it could be all over, I’m flattened, right?

2:32:39 I think that’s one of the beauties of age which I didn’t appreciate it as I was getting older. When you were very young you’re immortal, and that’s great because it allows you to take enormous risks and do things that are crazy, but then the realization that you’re mortal is also a very powerful moment and it can actually free you up to stop worrying about things and get on with things. As the Buddhist saying goes, uh, every, um, every man has two lifetimes and the second one begins when you realize you only have one lifetime.

2:33:17 So that’s a powerful, right? I heard that like a few days ago and it was the first time I’ve heard it, so it’s so powerful. Yeah, yeah, but again you can say that all day and it means nothing, but the moment you, it becomes a very imminent and possible reality or at least even plausible reality, it rocks your world in an unpleasant way, and then when the good thing happens you’re like, ah, okay, how can I use this? Yeah, yeah, that’s powerful, thanks for sharing that.

2:33:48 Um, uh, when you, uh, what would we be surprised to learn about Andreas, something you do daily or every week or so that has nothing to do with crypto or Bitcoin, or some pleasure of yours that you do that we’d be surprised? I I don’t know if I’ve told you this but, um, one of my hobbies, or probably the biggest hobby I have, is I’m a pilot. So I, when I was 19 years old I was in college here in London and a friend who was a glider pilot, who flew in, I think it was in Hertfordshire, who flew gliders in Hertfordshire, said, “Why don’t you come along and go for a flight?”

2:34:29 And I mean, I’ve been in commercial planes and I enjoyed flying commercially, I was like, this could be fun, so I went and I was gripped by it. I was like, I want to do this, I want to learn how to do this. And then it took me like almost two decades to finally get enough hours, but I started taking private pilot lessons immediately when I was 19. Glider lessons or, uh, powered, power and glider. Okay, and every year I’d managed to get, you know, five or six before I ran out of money or time.

2:34:59 When I had money I didn’t have time, when I had time I didn’t have money, the you know, the other Catch-22 of youth. And finally in 2014 and 2015 I did it intensively, uh, it was one of the things that, uh, a brief interlude during crypto winter allowed me to focus on the things I care about and not postpone them, and I got my private pilot’s license in 2015, flying mostly Cessna 172, four-seater single-engine aircraft, and now it’s something I do as a hobby and I love it, I love it. I, as I travel around the world I go to these little municipal airports and I rent a Cessna and I go flying, um, and I see the country from a different perspective and I get to do air traffic control in a different language sometimes, even though it’s supposed to be always English.

2:35:55 Wow, and land in little airports in the middle of nowhere, on islands in Malaysia, in flying over the tip of Africa in Cape Town, flying in Australia, flying in Europe, uh, flying all over the Americas, and just, and it’s been fantastic for me. Wow, my grandpa used to fly and my dad used to fly and my grandpa was a farmer in Colorado and so they had crop dusters around and stuff and that’s how he started, and then he used to fly, I used to fly, uh, Robinson R22s. Oh, very nice.

2:36:29 I’ve actually taken an R22 lesson. Okay, they’re devilishly hard, they are helicopters. We used to see the gliders as well out here in England and you’d see them just in this one area and they’d be you know floating around and we would stay obviously away from you guys, but, um, yeah, rotorcraft are crazy, they’re just these little lawn mowers in the sky, highly unstable but really exciting. Yeah, I like the fact that in a plane, if you let go of the controls, which most of the time you’re not touching the controls or you’re just keeping one finger on them just for reference, uh, they just keep going, right?

2:37:02 Like if you properly set up your aircraft it will just keep flying in the same direction and altitude as you did, it’s a stable machine. Yeah, uh, and even if the engine quits there’s a lot you can do and it keeps flying, it doesn’t just fall out of the sky, not so much with a helicopter, I mean you can autogyro it but it’s much trickier. But what I love about this is, uh, like many of the other things I enjoy, like motorcycles and cars and things like that, is that it’s a combination of technical skill, motor skill and something that is a whole body experience.

2:37:33 So for planes there’s physics and aerodynamics and a bit of math, uh, there’s this very methodical and detail-oriented attitude you have to have to the science of it, but also the respect for this machine because it can kill you if you’re not careful. Yeah, um, and then when you’re in it and you become one with the vehicle and your body is flying through the sky at, you know, 200 miles an hour and with a couple of fingers, just light touches, you can be anywhere you want in the sky, and that feeling is the best thing in the world. Yeah, it’s very meditative too, isn’t it, because your mind has to be on all these other things including your survival, and, uh, you said all these physics and things, and yeah, I used to love it.

2:38:22 I got about 50 hours in and then when I started training jiu-jitsu I forgot about it, but at the time it was powerful, um, and scary as well. I tried to keep it up and I tried to do it even though my travel schedule is crazy, um, and I recently managed to build up my hours again and do a lot of flying in California, that’s a lot of fun. California is amazing to fly, I love that. Um, what scares you? Ah, what scares me, the same mundane things that scare everyone.

2:38:54 Um, I’m scared of my own failure, I’m scared of disappointing the people I care about, I’m scared of the uncertainty and lack of control that we all have because control is an illusion, you know, the world’s whirling around me and me not having control of it, and honestly I’m scared of losing my way, uh, that’s also something that I think about a lot. Um, you know, I’m in a situation where a lot of things are happening very, very fast and I don’t want to lose touch with what’s important to me, what I care about, who I am, what I stand for, what I believe in. It’s very, very easy when all of the blah blah is happening all around you to lose touch of that, and I actually, I watch people in my industry and other industries who just start changing so fast and their behavior, their principles get diverted really, really quickly, so that’s something that scares me.

2:40:06 Okay, and what keeps you awake at night? Nothing, I sleep very well, I have a noise machine. So I battled with anxiety all my life and one of the things about anxiety is that it can make it very difficult to sleep when you have a lot of anxiety, and I went through a period especially around 2009-2010 when I had very serious problems with anxiety and I didn’t sleep. I had ruminating, right, like is that how it manifested itself in the sleep or was it also just, oh no, it was the whole full spectrum, no, I had like panic attacks, uh, really, really bad, it was the ability, I took disability from work, I had to stop working, uh, I couldn’t sleep at all, I was a mess, um, and I gradually worked my way out of that with a combination of cognitive behavioral therapy, I strongly believe in having someone you can talk to who is an ally and neutral and compassionate and professional so you don’t burden your loved ones with that, and introspection and mindfulness, which are part of that, and um, and gradually things got better and now I sleep really well.

2:41:23 Wow. I have the occasional day when things get derailed and jet lag doesn’t help, but I have a very regular sleep schedule, I sleep at the same time, I wake up at the same time without alarm clocks, I sleep through the night peacefully and I think a lot of it has to do with the fact that I know who I am now to a degree that I didn’t before, and I’m at peace with myself, my actions are aligned with my principles, the work I do is enormously satisfying because it feels meaningful and I get to reconnect with the things that matter to me on a daily basis. Fitness also helped a lot.

2:42:01 Yeah, and, uh, yeah, I sleep great. It’s amazing how those things can solve a lot of quote-unquote problems in life. You know, it’s amazing how addictions and anxieties and insecurities fall away if you can find something that aligns with your principles and connects you back with people that give something back to the world. I don’t know, I found that a lot of my battles that I had 10, 15, 20 years ago I don’t fight anymore because I’m doing something I feel great about and I feel connected also back to this world where I didn’t always feel that way in my 20s and 30s.

2:42:36 Well, I mean they’re all manifestations of basically toxic emotional states, so guilt because you have cognitive dissonance between your principles and your actions, shame, which is a very toxic emotion, and maybe because of trauma or other people treating you poorly when you’re a kid, and fear, which is the most toxic, right, or some swirling miasma of all three, um, and that’s why people seek outlets or behave poorly, um, and I’ve had to deal with all three, so um, I don’t much anymore. Yeah, I’ve had my journeys with all three as well and I currently don’t much either, I’m very grateful. Um, well, most people either have the journey with that or they simply don’t know that they have the journey with that because they’re um, hiding it from themselves and it’s a difficult place to be.

2:43:32 Yeah, it’s true, we all kind of go through those extremes, right? Yes, part of the human psyche, you have to have those emotions too. I wish we could turn them off uh, sometimes as a geek I dream of a world where you have an emotional, um, what’s called an emotional regulator, like Lieutenant Commander Data in Star Trek, right? So you’re like, fear, turn it down. Of course that wouldn’t work so well, within a week you’d, all the dials would be at 11 and you’d still be a mess.

2:44:02 Yeah, but it’s an interesting thought experiment to think about. Yeah, for sure. Um, Andreas, I always ask a few questions at the end, I’m gonna ask you, uh, those right now. If you could make a phone call, uh, to the 20-year-old Andreas and give that young man a bit of advice based on everything you know now, personally, professionally, what would you tell him? What was he like?

2:44:24 He was painfully shy, self-conscious, insecure, often scared and quite traumatized from his childhood. So what I would say is it gets better, but most importantly it gets different, and in ways you can’t even imagine, it gets weird, it gets strange, it changes in ways you couldn’t even fathom, nothing seems to connect and to not fare so much. But of course the 20-year-old wouldn’t hear any of that, I mean that’s the problem with it, right? Is that I could even have lots of people telling me that and until I had the life experiences to internalize those ideas, you know, even if I heard that phone call I wouldn’t act on it, I wouldn’t be able to even understand it, right?

2:45:27 Yeah, so which I guess is why time travel doesn’t exist. Exactly. Uh, on that same note, best advice you ever received, could have been from a parent or a co-worker or someone in the crypto space, something come to mind? I mean, a lot of it is very cliche advice which is very easy to read and very difficult to Uh, last part of that to that 20-year-old that’s watching, listening to us right now, advice to them. I mean, they’ve heard a lot of ideas about privacy, about money being almost, you know, a mechanism of speech and of will and of what we need to be worried about, advice to them about things they can make, simple steps or ways to prepare themselves for the change or to prepare themselves for the world we live in now, to where they’re not caught out, they’re not in distress, they’re not starving.

2:46:49 Um, what would you say? Um, none of the advice that I have to give is applicable to anyone else who doesn’t have the same circumstances as me, and I think there’s a very big mistake we make to look at people who have been successful, who have achieved things, and say, “How did you get there? Tell us your secret.” And their secret only applies if you had the same context when you were starting out and all of the probabilities lined up in the same way, which means none of it applies.

2:47:22 Worse, a lot of the time we’re perpetuating selection bias and survivor bias. They got there, and you’re talking to them, because they happen to be the ones that succeeded. You don’t get to talk to all of the ones who failed following the exact same advice or trying the exact same shortcuts but getting the timing wrong by two seconds or whatever. So I don’t know that I can give advice like that, other than most people severely underestimate the power and range of capabilities and even the range of options they realistically have.

2:47:56 And I so did, I, you know, that’s something that comes with maturity, age and walk. When I was in my 20s I thought I could do a lot less than I could. I thought I had fewer options than I do, I have no choice, or I thought the number of choices I had was limited. It’s infinite, and the power we have as individuals both to endure things that we think are unimaginable and to succeed in ways that we think are impossible is much greater. If young people knew how much power they have, the world would change very, very quickly.

2:48:37 You know, and you see it sometimes when an idea catches a lot of people and you’ll have a situation where all of the students in that country decide not to go to school the next day because they want reform of this particular circumstance in their life, and everybody’s like, that will never work, and after two days they’re all like, oh dear, right, that certainly did work. Yeah, or simple examples like that, you know. Um, and it doesn’t always work, but the point is we have a lot of power both as individuals, in the power of our words, the power of ideas, the power of our thoughts, and you don’t have to have any money to have those things.

2:49:24 Um, and but also the power of our choices and our principles and how we apply them in our lives and how those affect others around us, and if I knew how much I had earlier I may have started even earlier with uh, the things that I dare to do today that I wouldn’t have dared as a 20-year-old. But at the same time, you know, that’s all good and well, but I’m the one who didn’t die of malaria at three years old, right? I think all the time of the other Andreases, like think of the multiverse, right, how many of those branches are extinguished every choice I made, every random thing that happened to me that got me to where I am today.

2:50:07 I find it fascinating about how many of those branches dead end, you know, I didn’t die at childbirth, neither did my mother, I didn’t die of a preventable disease or dehydration by the age of three, I didn’t die of vaccination preventable diseases because I had access to those things, I didn’t starve to death, I didn’t get killed by a militia in my village, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. There’s so many paths that end long before, and one of the things that I’m struck by as I get older is how random life is. My least favorite expression in the world is “everything happens for a reason,” and my true crude credo and worldview is everything happens for no reason at all.

2:50:55 We live in a universe of utter chaos in which the trajectory of a particle 20 light years away may change your life in ways you can’t imagine in 20 years when it gets here, right, and or destroy your life completely, and it’s like you’re riding this canoe on white waters and you are firmly convinced that all of the paddling you’re doing is really, really making a difference. It’s making a tiny difference, but in truth where you end up is up to the river, not you. And that is a terrifying idea, but it’s also a very powerful idea, um, because if you stop worrying about all of the control you don’t have, you can get on with the important job of paddling and enjoying the scenery that’s rushing past.

2:51:50 Yeah, yeah, but don’t get too caught up in the idea that you have a plan because the universe will laugh at that. So nothing happens for a reason. I love that perspective. Uh, Andreas, as usual, uh, when you come on we talk a little bit about blockchain and crypto and a lot about life and philosophy and personal freedoms and all that, and that’s why I love talking to you, because every time you’re here it just, like, makes me really go back and really think about these things, and I think people that are watching are really thinking about, like, oh, I was just gonna use the Facebook coin, like I never thought about why I wouldn’t, and you know, I was just going to do that and I never thought about how my bank is that, and all these things that maybe five years, 10 years, 25 years from now will play out in a way where we’re somewhere we don’t want to be because we didn’t protect those little personal freedoms being eroded every day, we didn’t stick our hand up and say, “Hey, what about these people, how come this isn’t happening, why is this over regulated?”

2:52:48 So I love these ideas and I hope everyone just really takes some time and meditates on these things and really engages in, like, thinking about all these institutions, what they do on a regular basis, how they use their money every day, um, how they can’t use it. Um, what would happen if something kind of went weird and wrong? I always think about what happened if I went out on the, if I was on the lam, like being on the land these days, it’s like, you know, what if for some reason, like, you know, the government didn’t want me to do something?

2:53:16 Like, I don’t think I’d last more than 20 minutes in this city with the surveillance. So it always makes you think, like, who’s really in charge and what freedoms do you have. Um, one of my favorite, um, rappers named Ice-T says, uh, he says “freedom of speech, just watch what you say.” That’s what, these great lines, and I think that’s a lot about what you talk about, you know, we have these freedoms or these illusions of freedoms but they’re only to a certain extent, you know.

2:53:40 Um, so I love what you say about that stuff and I like how you’re very cautionary about the things in crypto and you’re very careful about what you say as well. So, um, thank you, it’s been a real pleasure, I enjoy these interviews a lot and I think the last one we did was probably one of the more personal conversations I’ve had with someone and it was very uncomfortable. When I left here I was just, maybe I shouldn’t have said all those things, second guessing myself, um, and then I realized no, this is what I believe in, which is just be myself and be vulnerable, and the response was unbelievable.

2:54:23 Like so many people contacted me after that and said, you know, I really appreciated just seeing you as a person and hearing these more personal things. It’s actually one of the favorite videos that people quote, uh, was from the previous London Real one, so it reminds me why I enjoy doing these, and, uh, thank you for doing such a great interview and bringing that out. Oh, my pleasure. I remember, you know, we got into some deep moments there and it was really powerful and you know I know it’s uncomfortable time but it just really connects a lot of people right into you because you share this human moment and they’re like, wow, and they’ll just always remember and they’ll, that it it makes them connect more, learn more, listen more, and it’s just such a powerful thing.

2:55:06 So thanks for being there and sharing this time as well, and look, I hope to see you back here once every couple years regardless. I hope so too. Yeah, to plug in, let us know what the current state of things are and what we need to keep thinking about and being reminded of and how we can all just make these intelligent decisions, you know, to design the future that we want and not one that’s being designed for us. So yeah, well, um, it’s been a real privilege to be here.

2:55:33 Um, just for reference, this is city number three of a seven city Europe tour that I’m doing in 28 days, more than 20 appearances, and other than two commercial conferences that helped pay for some of the expenses the rest is all funded because of Patreon and the people who support me directly from the community. One of the great things that’s happened for me in the last year and a half is that I’ve been able to tap in directly to the same people who appreciate and value my work, funding it through platforms like Patreon and allowing me to be completely neutral to do exactly what I’ve always done, who fund me for no other reason but to continue to do the work I love to do. And every time I go to one of these events, um, people will line up and come and say hello to me and I’ll take a photo and they’ll say like, “Aren’t you tired of, like, smiling for photos with all of these strangers?”

2:56:38 I’m like, no, all I’m thinking about the entire time is this is my job, this is my job, I get to do the thing I absolutely love more than anything else in the world and for some reason this has become my job and I am so lucky and I smile so wide when I think that, so it’s just a wonderful opportunity and it’s what gives me the ability to do these things. Yeah, no, that’s so incredible, I love it. It’s the biggest smile I saw on you all day, so I know it is.

2:57:11 That’s incredible and I love the fact that you can keep doing what you’re doing with Patreon, so it’s great, and uh, if people want to last night, no strings, no bosses, no, it’s working directly for the community, and it’s one of those things, well I mean it’s got the centralization problems with the payment networks etc., but, um, essentially I’ve been hired by more than a thousand people and I work for them and they represent the, you know, the thin end of a giant community that supports my work, uh, and it’s incredible. That’s incredible. And your website is andreastonopolis.com.

2:57:45 Uh, well, the easiest way to remember it is A-A-N-T-O-N-O-P or A-Antonop, uh, A-Antonop is my Twitter handle, my YouTube channel, my website, aantonop.com. Okay, um, you know, you can find all of that, go there, the books are there, the Patreon links are there, follow you on social, all that good stuff. Yeah, and all of my work including my books are available under open Creative Commons licenses, you don’t have to pay to read them, you can if you want to buy the paper book or Kindle and you’ll pay for the packaging, the convenience, but you can also find all of my books online for free and download them and share them under open licenses and mash them up and use them to build courses or do something else, translate them into other languages, so all of my work is available for free and open.

2:58:31 That’s awesome, man, I would expect nothing less from you. So it’s part of what drives me. I know, I appreciate it, I’ve always been drawn to your mission, this, like, the mission you’re on, um, to just put yourself out there and make all this stuff happen and you’re super congruent with it. So thanks so much for everything you do. Thank you, and, uh, we’ll see you back here in another year or two and tell us the state of the union then.

2:58:51 Yeah, all right, cool, thank you all

London Real logo Chat
×

Private call with Brian Rose

See how the AI Investment Club works, and decide for yourself

Every Monday, AI founders pitch live to our members. Book a call to see if it's right for you.

Check Brian’s availability
Brian video thumbnail
Private call with Brian Rose
Watch Brian’s message