Gymnastic rings cost about $30, have barely changed in generations, and according to Ido Portal they are one of the best training tools ever made. In this clip he explains why, then takes Brian Rose through a hands-on ring session in a London park, until the authorities step in.
It comes from A Moving Conversation, Portal’s 2016 return to London Real, and it is a rare chance to see one of the world’s best-known movement teachers coaching in real time.
▶ Watch the full episode: Ido Portal – A Moving Conversation
Why rings?
Brian asks why, of all the tools available, Portal keeps coming back to the rings. “Well, the rings are a genius tool,” he says, and gives his reasons. First, they move in 360 degrees towards your weakest pattern. Get stronger there and they find the next weak spot, over and over, which builds stability and strength.
Second, they are what he calls a closed kinetic chain tool: you move your whole body between two points that are not even fixed. He compares a lat pulldown with a pull-up. Lifting heavy on the machine does not mean much for your pull-ups or muscle-ups, he says, but the reverse carries over well.
Third, rings give just enough instability. More is not always better, he says: squat on a Swiss ball and you will never load your legs enough to make them strong.
Cheap, simple, honest
Brian notes that the price is right, and Portal agrees. Nobody can patent a ring, so nobody gets rich from it. What annoys him is when companies pad the handles, paint them in neon colours and sell a watered-down version for triple the price. Making and selling rings is fine, he says, as is genuine innovation, but degrading a good tool for profit is not honest. His first set cost close to $300; today they cost about $30, which he credits to the CrossFit community.
The Corset: body armour for play
Brian remembers Portal showing him a small muscle by his elbow that Brian simply did not have. Portal says it comes from ring work and from his “Corset” protocols. It “won’t get me the girls on the beach, but it will protect me,” he jokes.
The Corset, he explains, is a library of protective exercises collected from dance, gymnastics and martial arts, including his early years in traditional Chinese martial arts. The idea is a flexible body armour that lets you take more risks when you play, by strengthening joints, tendons and soft tissue so you can move with more freedom and less pain.
Coaching Brian’s muscle-up
Brian admits he was embarrassed by his own ring muscle-up. Portal will not have it: “There is no ugly motion,” he says, only a nervous system learning a pattern. His cue is to be “aggressively patient”: drive hard, but do not skip the checkpoints. The key one is pulling the rings to the centre of the chest before switching from pull to push. Go too early, he says, and you fall back down the ladder, like losing position in jiu-jitsu.
He then teaches the false grip, showing why it is simply the hand position you need at the top of the ring, and sets Brian up with false-grip pull-ups to the chest. The lesson ends abruptly when a Royal Parks official tells them they cannot attach the rings to the trees. Portal calls it restricted movement in action.
Ring training can be demanding on the shoulders, elbows and wrists. Build up gradually, and get qualified coaching if you are new to it or carrying an injury.
Who is Ido Portal?
Ido Portal is an Israeli movement teacher and the founder of the Ido Portal Method, a practice that draws on martial arts, dance, gymnastics and other disciplines. He became widely known for his work with Conor McGregor and teaches “movement culture” to students around the world.
This clip comes from his 2016 London Real episode, A Moving Conversation. He first appeared in 2014, and London Real later made a feature film with him, Ido Portal – Just Move, which you can watch free.
See everything Ido Portal has done with London Real on his guest page: Ido Portal on London Real.
More on London Real
Transcript
Transcript: Ido Portal – Why Gymnastic Rings Are A Genius Training Tool
0:00 Brian Rose: Of all the tools you could use, you choose the rings, and I’ve heard you talk about this before. It’s not the bar muscle-up, it’s not so many other choices you could make. But you’ve always said that this is the one that you think most effectively works certain shoulder structures. Why? Why these?
0:21 Ido Portal: Well, the rings are a genius tool. First, they will always move in 360 degrees to your weakest pattern, which makes it an ultimate tool for development. It’s like: you’re weak here, it will move there. It will make you stronger there. Now it will move here. Ad nauseam. So it makes you very, very stable, very strong.
0:47 Ido Portal: Second thing, they allow a phenomenon called a closed kinetic chain. Closed kinetic chain versus open kinetic chain movements. The ring is the ultimate closed kinetic chain tool. You have to manipulate the centre of mass of the body in between two points, which are not even fixed. Versus an open kinetic chain, where you manipulate the extremity towards the centre of mass of the body, which is fixed. Like a lat pulldown versus a pull-up, where I have to move my body towards the point, the anchor. On a lat pulldown I can do a lot of weight in the gym; it doesn’t mean much about my ability to do chin-ups, pull-ups, muscle-ups. But vice versa, it’s been shown in research to have greater transferability.
1:35 Ido Portal: So the rings are… this is just two reasons out of many. They also offer just enough instability, but not too much instability. Which is another misunderstood thing, as people think that instability is good, stability is bad. No, not necessarily. If you stand on a Swiss ball and you try to squat to get your legs strong, you’ll never get enough intensity, enough weight, to really get those legs strong. It’s an example where too much instability will hinder your development. But the rings will move just enough, and will still enable you to go through a lot of tension, a lot of intensity work. And there are many more reasons; just cutting it short.
2:19 Brian Rose: And the price is right.
2:21 Ido Portal: Price is right. Nobody can really patent this. Nobody can patent this, hence nobody can really make big money off of it. They take material, they make a ring, they sell you the rings. And I love it, because it has existed for a long time. Look at it: it’s a perfect circle. What can be wiser? It allows you to transition from working below the rings to above the rings. So what did we do? We padded the handles, we changed the structure, we connected it to the top, we painted it in neon colours and we sell it for triple the price. I don’t like it. I don’t like it and I won’t support it.
3:03 Brian Rose: You don’t like the whole idea of someone taking something that should be a basic human right, and commercialising it, and changing it, and charging a profit for it. That bothers you to the core, doesn’t it?
3:16 Ido Portal: Yes, especially when it’s about merchandise. You educate people, great, that’s something else. Or you sell a tool, you sell those rings, you made them with your hands, that’s great. You innovated something which works, patented, no problem. But when you water it down, when you destroy it in the process, and you make a profit, that’s not honest.
3:41 Brian Rose: Right. And you said to look at these rings, the wood, this width: this is what you want, right?
3:47 Ido Portal: Yeah. So cheap, so basic. When I bought my first set of rings, they cost me close to $300. And these ones nowadays, $30. So this is really thanks to the CrossFit community, which made it so affordable and available.
4:07 Brian Rose: There was one point during the seminar that you showed me your elbow, and you said: this is the muscle I have from doing rings. And that’s when I truly realised that you are an alien, because I looked at my arm and I didn’t have the same muscle that you have. And that comes from the stabilisation work you do?
4:26 Ido Portal: It is part of the ring work.
4:29 Brian Rose: Can I see your…
4:30 Ido Portal: Yeah, yeah. So that’s the muscle there.
4:37 Brian Rose: I don’t really have one.
4:38 Ido Portal: It’s a little bit different, huh?
4:40 Brian Rose: So this muscle there comes from…
4:43 Ido Portal: It comes from a lot of those Corset protocols that we’ve discussed. And this protection, protection over the joints, because the joints are placed in compromised positions and are being demanded: develop, or else. And the rings do that to a certain extent, and there are other things that we employ to protect the body. This muscle appears in many different areas. And these small stabilisation, auxiliary muscles, it won’t win me any bodybuilding competitions, it won’t get me the girls on the beach, but it will protect me.
5:22 Brian Rose: Yeah, and when I did some BJJ this week, I definitely had extra protection when placed in all kinds of compromised positions. Can you just talk me briefly through what the Corset’s all about and why you use that name? I know we didn’t talk about it, but just as a general theory, when you talk about protecting yourself?
5:42 Ido Portal: The Corset is a library of protocols that I collected from a variety of disciplines, from dance to gymnastics to martial arts, all kinds of pieces that I collected all over the world throughout my travels and my studies, from my younger years in traditional Chinese martial arts. And it’s basically my attempt to make a small encyclopaedia of protective exercises, to create a flexible body armour around the body so we can play better. Because my realisation was: when we play, sh*t happens. We take more risks, we move around, and we need a stronger constitution. And we need an ability to adapt, to go into the fire to a certain extent.
6:42 Ido Portal: And it’s about mobilising the body, but strengthening it at the same time. It’s about affecting the soft tissues, it’s about thickening certain tendons. And I’m not talking about this tendon strength that is many times promoted and misunderstood. The tendon is not meant to contract or to create motion, but it should take pressures. It’s about thickening cartilage and creating more synovial fluid motion, and improving your life, and feeling more capable, more pain-free, and having more freedom to move.
7:24 Brian Rose: OK, very good. What did you see in my ring muscle-up? It needs some work, to say the very least. I was almost a little embarrassed to put it up online or to show it to you, because it was in such a basic form, and I know my knees are coming up. But I’m learning, and I think I’m getting that neuroplasticity and starting to get through the movement patterns. And it came from you showing me those basics at the [unclear], where I knew that if I did these things, I would get there. I used a lot of that exercise, that motion back and forth, for a minute. It’s a very painful exercise. And I was just wondering what I should do to take myself to the next level when it comes to these.
8:06 Ido Portal: First, it doesn’t look ugly to me. There is nothing ugly. There is no ugly motion. You’re going through a beautiful process where your nervous system is tuning itself and perfecting itself in this pattern. It can be tighter, it can be more technical, and that can be through the help of collective knowledge, someone like me stepping in and taking you through this huge leap with technical cues and help. And it can happen also by yourself, through your intuition and just working that pattern, which will be more limited maybe, but will definitely also happen.
8:45 Ido Portal: So we need to get you a little bit tighter. We need to get you aggressively patient, which is a very important combination when working on the rings. You need to drive and reach certain positions very strongly, and yet you need to pass through these checkpoints, and you sometimes kind of skip some checkpoints. For example, as you’re pulling to the centre of your chest, that contact is our first checkpoint to start to initiate the transition.
9:16 Ido Portal: A muscle-up is from a pull into a push, and you have to smoothly transition between a pull and a push, and what is in between them is sometimes very tricky moments. So you have to consciously touch that chest. You have to touch that checkpoint, Charlie, and then you can transition very smoothly. If you initiate the transition too early, it will look jerky and you will kind of fall through, fall back down the ladder.
9:47 Ido Portal: It’s a little bit like the hierarchical positional thing in BJJ. Once you’ve got to a mount, you don’t want to fall back into a knee on belly. So you can only progress onwards in position. So here, once you’ve got up there, you don’t want to go back down. You want to transition and continue to drive onwards.
10:13 Brian Rose: Should we try one?
10:15 Ido Portal: Yeah, let’s do a few exercises to lead up to it first, to make sure we clean it up. Since those rings are pretty smooth… I always prefer the unpolished rings.
10:30 Brian Rose: OK, because they have a little more grip.
10:32 Ido Portal: Yeah, they might rip the skin a little bit more, but they have a little bit more grip. So you might want to use a little bit of chalk.
10:40 Brian Rose: OK. Do you need some chalk? I’ve got some liquid chalk, is that all right?
10:44 Ido Portal: Yeah, I’m not a fan of the liquid chalk, but it’s better than nothing, and especially when you travel, it’s usually more realistic.
10:55 Brian Rose: Yeah, I’m going to get some other stuff. So use chalk.
10:58 Ido Portal: I will not need much. Sometimes I ask people: smell it. Does it smell like something you would swallow?
11:05 Brian Rose: No.
11:06 Ido Portal: In the military, when you find a piece of plant and you’re not sure if you can eat it, what’s the first thing that you do? You rub it on your skin to see if there is a reaction. So if you wouldn’t swallow it, I wouldn’t put it on my skin either.
11:22 Brian Rose: So you’re not going to do it?
11:24 Ido Portal: No, it’s OK, I can get away without it. Yeah, so one of the first things is just to get this very nice false grip. And sometimes people just do it with a flexed wrist, but I actually also supinate, the pinky down, and I bring my elbows in. And you can even just lightly test that false grip and see if that grip is deep enough and strong enough.
11:49 Brian Rose: OK, so I remember at the [unclear] you said to kind of start gripping it up here, and then…
11:59 Ido Portal: Yes, yeah, that’s a very nice grip. Yeah, and just lean back slightly, and kind of try to extend the elbows and maintain that tight grip.
12:09 Brian Rose: Right, and turn it as well.
12:13 Ido Portal: Beautiful, yeah. And now pull yourself up to the centre of the chest. Nice. And repeat it maybe three more times.
12:20 Brian Rose: I still haven’t got to the full hang up to the muscle-up.
12:30 Ido Portal: Yeah, it should be coming very, very soon. Very soon, yeah.
12:34 Brian Rose: But I find the grip is very important. And if I can get really locked in on the base, then I feel strong, and then I can really concentrate on the movement. But if it feels slippery, I feel like…
12:46 Ido Portal: That’s true, that’s true. And the reason is: what is really the false grip? Why are we using that grip? It’s actually very simple. If you look at my hand when I’m in a support position on top of the ring: if I just grip the ring and I lock my wrist in place and I take my elbow down, I reach the false grip. So now actually, the false grip is a way for us to make sure we would be able to transition between these two very efficiently.
13:23 Ido Portal: Now if I slide slightly out, that would become much more difficult, as I put a strain on the wrist and do not yet have the mechanical leverage to transition. So if I try to transition from here to a support, it would probably slip off. That can be done later on in more advanced stages, but in the beginning, super important.
13:44 Ido Portal: So the next thing that we will do is: let’s go through a false grip chin-up or pull-up. And you would assume the same position here, and you will lower only as far as you can comfortably lower while maintaining that grip, and then pull to the centre of your chest. It can mean going all the way through, or just a partial range of motion. Try.
14:20 Brian Rose: The other thing I find when I’m doing this exercise…
14:23 Park official: Are you [unclear]?
14:26 Brian Rose: Oh, you’re back.
14:27 Park official: This is Royal Parks. [unclear] attach anything to the trees, because all the trees are protected under Royal Parks regulation.
14:35 Brian Rose: OK.
14:47 Ido Portal: It’s a concept of restricted movement, and we were just restricted from doing movement.
14:52 Brian Rose: How does that make you feel, when we’re trying to move in a park and we can’t because of the authorities?

