Full transcript: Ido Portal on London Real
0:09 Brian Rose: Thank you so much for having us in your home country in Tel Aviv. I really like it here.
0:14 Ido Portal: Pleasure.
0:15 Brian Rose: It feels like everyone is kind of excited to be here. There seems to be like a passion I don’t know, floating around the place.
0:22 Ido Portal: It’s nice. That’s good to hear.
0:25 Brian Rose: So I’ve got a bit of a confession to make. I’m falling in love with my body again. And I think it’s all your fault.
0:37 Ido Portal: Wow, that’s a big honor. I It’s always amazing to hear how people change their relationship with their body which is them, the relationship with themselves. So if I can facilitate that, it’s a huge thing for me.
0:56 Brian Rose: Because I used to be the BJJ guy, and then the Thai boxing guy, and then the weightlifting guy. But now I swim, I dance, I climb, I run.
1:09 I’m moving pretty much every day of the week now. So something’s a bit different. But at the same time, I find that sometimes I’m still stuck, and I think, okay, that’s a breakdancer, wouldn’t do this, so you have to stop, or a jiu-jitsu guy wouldn’t do this, so you have to stop. So there’s more I need to learn, I think, when it comes to separating my mind from maybe these disciplines that are in my head.
1:37 Ido Portal: Yeah, we all have that problem.
1:39 Like, all of our society is built around this concept of segregation, and it’s not something that happens over a day. You have to digest the idea, play with it, and the freedom comes little by little, along with kind of accepting the weirdness of it, and and just staying playful, right, and open, and being the closest thing that you can be to the genuine self you are at that specific moment, not being held back by some notions of who you need to be and what you ought to be, etc.
2:19 Brian Rose: Does it come down to really being highly present is that how you can progress in a movement sense?
2:27 Ido Portal: Maybe it is. Maybe it’s the opposite. I don’t know, I’m not sure anymore. You know, some of it is some of the stuff that is regarded as technology for meditation, and it’s been presented as that by really people with certain commercial intent, is actually, in my eyes, an anti-technology for meditation.
2:48 Brian Rose: Okay, can you explain?
2:50 Ido Portal: Yeah, you know, I can do a one-arm handstand and sell you the idea that I’m present and I’m in that moment where I’m actually thinking of my grocery list. So if you do something really well, and you can then you can do it on automatic. Okay, Marcelo Garcia can roll with you and just do whatever and think of whatever. So actually that tool became an anti-meditation tool, not a meditation tool. So a lot of what we do well is not serving us to be in that moment, and so I think that’s why I also like to join more movement and stillness together.
3:33 Brian Rose: Okay, because movement in and of its own can move you sometimes in the opposite direction, because you’re too focused on the movement and other things and you’re no longer being in your head.
3:48 Ido Portal: Well, just the action of doing it, getting better at it, means that you need to do it without being present. Okay, it hits as Bruce Lee said, so it is not any more that present moment. It’s more I can be somewhere else, you know. I can be, some fighters, for example, whistle or rhyme or sing or they try to occupy that cognitive side of the brain while they’re doing stuff from a more primordial, automized portion.
4:20 Brian Rose: Okay, so you just try to keep yourself on the learning curve in order to avoid you going back into that state where you might be thinking about the groceries.
4:31 Ido Portal: Exactly.
4:32 Brian Rose: Okay, and so you’re constantly challenging yourself, getting yourself uncomfortable in order to stay kind of in the moment.
4:40 Ido Portal: Yeah, that Japanese state of mind, that word shoshin, the beginner mindset. Being a beginner is a better technology to being present than being really good at what you do.
4:52 Brian Rose: Okay, and that’s also part of the movement thing. You’re a beginner every week.
4:57 Ido Portal: Sometimes people are completely baffled by how bad I am in certain things, because they see me all the time challenging myself instead of pulling the same old tricks from the head. They see me challenged again, and I aspire to be challenged all the time, so I wouldn’t look good when I’m doing that.
5:17 Brian Rose: So you’re not afraid to look like a white belt in your center when you’re training?
5:22 Ido Portal: No, it’s a, yeah, the ego takes a huge part there. But once you understand that, that’s also the way to get really good at a lot of things, then the ego can also come down.
5:38 Brian Rose: So you bargain with the ego.
5:40 Ido Portal: Yeah, you have to, I reckon.
5:43 Brian Rose: I was wondering if you could tell me about 25 years ago on a beach just like this, about 50 miles north, where you fell in love with your body.
5:56 Ido Portal: Yeah, it pretty much started there. I grew up in Haifa, which is a beach town. It’s surrounded, it’s a bay, and surrounded by water basically, and I spent a lot of time on the beach. You can see it on my face. I still do.
6:18 I studied capoeira, and a lot of it was outdoors. A lot of it was happening outside. We are pretty sunny country. There was a Brazilian guy who arrived here, he lived here illegally, I think, for a long, long portion of time, and he was a construction worker, and he used to do capoeira back in Brazil, and he decided, I think, I’m not sure how things developed, but he decided to start to teach, and I found my way into his class, into this capoeira class, and it all started.
6:59 So we used to spend a lot of time on the beach moving, and that was also a connection to music and rhythm, and that flexibility and acrobatics and fighting. So there was so much movement information in capoeira that it was really a great introduction, right? Really an amazing introduction into this concept. Still, it took me almost a decade to realize what it is, really, because at first you thought it was maybe a dance or a martial art or a social event, but it’s so much more.
7:33 First I thought it was capoeira. I just gave it the full respect, and it deserves a lot of respect. It’s a beautiful manifestation, cultural, movement, musical, philosophical, martial manifestation, and it was so complex, and the history is so thick, and the beauty and the language. I just immersed myself into that, and but then some things were left out. Like, I’m an Israeli kid, and I’m doing this 500, going on 600 year old Brazilian Afro-Brazilian martial art, and it’s martial art, but I’m not only a martial artist.
8:14 I’m much more. So there was always these things left out. I would almost feel bad, like listening to Tom Waits. It wasn’t capoeira music. So it was, somehow there was something there that was not complete.
8:30 Brian Rose: Okay, and the conflict started inside you, where you thought, maybe I need to be pure capoeira, but I’m interested in this, and this is catching my attention over here.
8:43 Ido Portal: Yeah, yeah, and I’m so radical in my approach. So I just went into it full-on, but there was always something in me that was yeah, that was there, challenged, even dressing the clothes and and the language. I speak Portuguese, and pretty well, spent many years in Brazil, friendships, and even the philosophy of handling yourself in life, which capoeira is a very kind of street-smart thing.
9:14 Brian Rose: Okay, the word malandraj, to be a malandru, to be a street-smart, what does that mean?
9:22 Ido Portal: It means to slide in and in between the cracks to find solutions, to be, to look ahead. It has many negative connotations, but it also has some positive connotations, which are less known in Brazil, but inside capoeira circles it is more kind of known, researched, understood. So you go to the bank and you immediately look at the line a little bit different, and you zigzag your way across it.
9:57 It’s also kind of an Israeli thing as well. It has a touch to it, and I think that’s why capoeira flourished here.
10:05 Brian Rose: Okay. Interesting, so, like, similar mentalities but still very different?
10:10 Ido Portal: Yeah, it’s still different, because on the short term, malandraj, this street-smart, works really well on the individual level on the short term, but on a state, on a country level, it’s the thing that destroys Brazil.
10:25 Okay, in many ways, and you see that corruption and you see those issues happening on every level, on every layer, and I think here, which is, we’re not devoid of corruption, but we’re less organized in a systematic way, in the way that we think, in the way that we operate, but then on the level of the individual, we sometimes operate some flexibilities which are important as well.
10:57 Brian Rose: And when did you start to diverge, and when could you look in the mirror and say Ido is no longer capoeirista?
11:07 Ido Portal: It was a process.
11:08 It was a gradual process. It didn’t happen over a day, and it took a lot of time to let go of it, and more than kind of understand it, is to allow myself to say, okay, it’s not anymore, to be honest with myself, it’s not anymore just the only thing that I do. It’s more than that, and then it was a gradual process of, I’m doing that as well, until a certain point. Yeah, it was, it opened up the vision. It opened up.
11:47 Brian Rose: Okay, you still do hanging work?
11:50 Ido Portal: Yeah, of course, of course.
11:52 Brian Rose: I do it in the gym now, and I just think about you all the time, you know.
11:58 Ido Portal: Ah, always good.
11:59 Brian Rose: I’ve got room there to hang a little bit, and I, how how often do you prescribe the hanging?
12:06 Ido Portal: Daily, daily, and daily,
12:08 Brian Rose: for what kind of a time interval?
12:10 Ido Portal: I would start people with a pretty intense period of time, like 30 days, where they are focused on doing some hanging throughout the day, five seven minutes a day total time, but they build it up in small sections, maybe 30 seconds, maybe 20 seconds, maybe a minute. Okay, and it’s kind of like a cat stretch for us, right, because we’re not moving on all fours, so we rarely, kind of, the modern lifestyle, very compress the body, and really extend it, and this is kind of a very nice extension.
12:44 It runs through you. You let gravity do the alignment for you, and what better modality to use than gravity? We’re living with gravity. We have a constant relationship with it, although many don’t realize it. And then the other thing, the compression, is the squat, which we’ve talked about before, and just compressing the lower body, and just, yeah, just down here, spending time this is what I would recommend for everyone.
13:09 These two basic things, beyond all the tricks and the elastic bands and the foam rollers and the special stretches, and this is just basic movement tools for humanity.
13:20 Brian Rose: Yeah, and these are just like brushing your teeth. Every day you should be doing these.
13:25 Ido Portal: I think so for most people, and of course there are exceptions, people who there are always certain limitations, proportions, disabilities, but let’s say over 90 percent of people that I see can really benefit from this and do it regularly, and should be doing it just like brushing the teeth.
13:44 Brian Rose: Okay, in the movement experience, you had people down for five minutes, and we started hearing the oohs and ohs after a few minutes. You know, a lot of the big guys had a hard time. You know,
13:59 Ido Portal: yeah, yeah, you build, you know, like you have to really think, what kind of legs do you want to build? What kind of legs do you want to have? And people just don’t realize it, and they go into these practices and they build, you know, big, thick trunk legs, and now they can squat or deadlift a lot of weight, but the basic functionality of their, in their daily life, has been affected as well.
14:29 I don’t want three trunk legs. I want bamboo legs, flexible, strong. Yeah, if the wind comes, it bends, but it doesn’t break, and it can bounce me out. It’s elastic, and I think even some of my students kind of like that and use that term, and yeah, bamboo legs, bamboo.
14:52 Brian Rose: Yeah, okay, flexible, strong, able to do what you want.
14:57 Ido Portal: Yeah, and if they’re too strong, you have a problem. Yeah, if they’re too flexible, you have a problem, and if they’re not elastic enough, you have a problem, and it’s kind of like developing just the right, just the right way, hence the orientation towards more weight, like capacity, or kilograms, or time. It’s not going to work well to develop your body. It’s not complex enough to develop a complex system, right. It’s simplistic, but that’s analog and linear.
15:29 Yeah, it’s not going to the right. It doesn’t respect the complexity of your structure, of your mind, of the way that we are moving. We’re not that animal, and no animal is actually that animal. We’re just more complex than that, but we build it, we build these tools, and, you know, the Dunning-Kruger curve, which is really famous now, a lot of people talk about it, the Dunning-Kruger effect curve, in the beginning you know nothing about it, then you just learn a tiny bit about it, you think you know everything about it, and then you realize you know very little about it, and then finally you hit some upward slope again and you realize it’s more complex than you thought before, but you know something about it.
16:20 It’s like most people, most people on your program, most people on these podcasts, most people around, they suffer from that condition. They think they know everything about it because they’ve learned some things about it, and maybe in another area of life they know a lot more about, but they make the mistake of trying to talk about subjects that they don’t understand, and I see it daily. Okay, and I think, like, we should stick to less confusion, and I try to do that as well.
16:53 I try not to speak too much about things that I’m I mean, the beginning of the curve. Even though it seems to me like I know everything about it, I respect that understanding, so I’ve been avoiding, for example, for many years now, talking about nutrition. It’s like it wasn’t my passion. I know a lot about it in my eyes, but I realized that I don’t know enough to not contribute to the confusion. Right.
17:23 Brian Rose: Okay, you know what works for you, but you’re not ready to talk about it because you haven’t hit that fourth part of that curve?
17:33 Ido Portal: Yes, 100 okay, even ethically I wouldn’t make recommendations for people on an ethical level how to live life. It’s I’ve devoted myself to movement, and I can tell you a lot about that, and shed some light about the complexities of that. I don’t understand it, but I’ve learned enough to understand how little I know about it, and yeah, so I think it’s important somehow to bring that, because there is so much confusion, and we can use these tools, London Real podcasts and internet, but we can also abuse them and just create a stream of information that is unclear, and we’re just trying to present opinions, but we’re suffering now from it as well.
18:23 The age of misinformation, because 20, 30 years ago you had to search for information. Now you have to search for knowledge, right, and then you really have to search for the right information, because there’s so much disinformation.
18:40 Brian Rose: Yeah, wisdom above knowledge.
18:42 Ido Portal: Yeah, right, knowledge is better than information, information is better than data, but wisdom is ultimately where we want to go, and how to make decisions, and according to all this and prior layers.
18:57 Brian Rose: Yeah, I do this now in a suit when I’m waiting for my breakfast in London, and people walk by and they just don’t understand. I also hang in the subway from the thing, and it freaks the English people out.
19:16 Ido Portal: Yeah, I’m sure. I do it in Germany, and I get some weird looks. It’s good stuff.
19:23 Brian Rose: And so when in your mind did you stop becoming a capoeira guy?
19:28 Ido Portal: It wasn’t one moment. It wasn’t an instant, and I don’t like to pinpoint things because it doesn’t happen like that. It’s a bit, it’s a bit like our anatomy. You know what the bicep is?
19:42 The biceps? No, you don’t. You don’t, because inside your system there is no moment on a cellular level where you can tell me that’s bicep tissue. The muscle unravels into a tendon, the tendon unravels into a bone, and it’s a cellular continuum. It’s not, oh, here it’s about here, it’s a muscle, here it’s a tendon.
20:08 It’s more kind of mix and percentages, and it slowly flows together. Hence, you have to carve out a piece to know what it is, but inside the system it doesn’t exist in isolation. And the same with our lives. When did you stop being a capoeira guy? I don’t know.
20:24 I’m, in many ways, I am still capoeira, not just a capoeira guy. I am capoeira. I just became that. I spent so many years talking the talk and walking the walk, and my walk changed, and my rhythmical thing changed, and my taste for music changed, and my, and the way that I communicate with people, and with with sexual partners, with everything. It was all affected, and I don’t think I ever stopped, but in many ways I evolved, and that core thing just became bigger and changed.
21:02 I still have a huge love for that culture. I still like, very much, immersed in it, and also go back to Brazil. I’m next month. I’ll be in Brazil. Okay.
21:14 Um, I owe a huge debt to that movement culture, which I think is one of the most diverse, interesting, stylish, talented pools of movers ever.
21:29 Brian Rose: And tell me about the subsequent development of movement culture as we know it. Portal’s movement culture.
21:40 Ido Portal: Yeah, it’s just, you can’t do it alone. You have to move inside the culture.
21:48 You need a culture to move in, which is, you are starting to, you will start to feel it if you don’t feel it already, very soon, just because you’re already now practicing in a more open way, but you kind of have to find locations and friends to play with, and teachers, but then imagine you have a culture to move in. Imagine you have a community, you meet regularly, and it supports that, and you do it together. We are social beings and movement. It cannot be separated from the structure that occupies it and the cultural context around it.
22:25 So for me that was obvious. We need a tribe. We need a tribe to move in. We need we need support. We can’t do it alone.
22:37 It’s not sustainable. You can do it for a short while with certain practices, but ultimately it wouldn’t serve you in the long term.
22:46 Brian Rose: And that just had a lightbulb moment with me, because I’m always trying to figure out what it is that you do and what it is you’re all about. And the best example was yesterday. I went through Israeli immigration, and they’re like, why are you here?
23:04 I’m here to see Ido Portal, one of your national treasures. And I said, what is he? I said, he’s a movement he’s not a specialist, not an expert. If I called him a guru, he would be looking for me. And yet when I pulled my phone out and showed him literally 15 seconds of you on YouTube moving, they got it.
23:31 Not only did they get it, they were excited, and they wanted to know more about it, and they were pulling the other immigration officers in to look at your video. Why does this happen?
23:43 Ido Portal: It’s like all paradigm shifts, in a way, I think. It’s so simple. It’s so, you know, there is the side of people who said, like, it was always there.
23:52 Of course it was always there. We’re living in a body. Of course people were always moving. Movement was always there, and it just needs to be repackaged, and people have these negative connotations to the word repackaging. Well, welcome to humanity.
24:08 That’s how we do things. We need to repackage them in the view of the time that we live in, and the modas, the fashions.
24:19 Brian Rose: Yeah, and the communication tools like the internet, and that was just necessary, obviously, or else it didn’t, it wouldn’t go so big.
24:30 Ido Portal: I don’t have anything really special besides I was in a good timing. I was very lucky to be in a good timing, realizing something that many others subsequently realized, and that just took off.
24:47 That’s that movement thing, that movement culture thing. And, um, yeah, I think it was always there, and it will always be here, and it will probably need to be repackaged again in 200,300 years. Um, but it was necessary, and it happened, and that’s why that’s why it made that ripple effect, right?
25:09 Brian Rose: And the definition of a paradigm shift is that afterwards it looks obvious to everyone.
25:15 Ido Portal: Exactly, right.
25:16 That’s the most common reaction that I get from people. They always say it: you’re saying things that I always knew, and it’s exactly right. That’s the kind of eye-opening moment that you want to have. I don’t have any new insights. There is nothing new under the sun.
25:34 I don’t it’s not inherently different, it’s not new. It’s just I spin the perspective. I turn them to look at it from a different perspective, and then it just happens. It just happens.
25:51 Brian Rose: The concept of the contents and the container, I’m still trying to get my head around it, but maybe it’s a way that people can understand the difference between gymnastics and fighting and dancing and running and CrossFit versus movement.
26:13 Brian Rose: Can you explain it? And is that the way that people can understand movement culture a little bit better?
26:21 Ido Portal: Yeah, what what I do, I’m not interested anymore in being a good acrobat or a good dancer or a good fighter, and people constantly kind of try to put me in those, under these titles. They’re completely wrong. First, I’m not good at them.
26:38 I never said I was. Second, I’m not even interested. I’m interested in the content inside these disciplines, in the ideas, the principles, the master keys that reside inside, which are universal, everlasting, immortal movement principles with the body, maybe not immortal, because maybe we evolve still, so maybe it would change, but right now with this anatomy, physique, these neural networks, the way that our mind works, and it’s pretty long lasting. And so what happens is people, I think, of themselves, I’m the gymnast, I’m the fighter, I’m this, I’m that, and they look at things that I do and they said, this wouldn’t help me in this discipline, this, who cares?
27:36 I’m not trying to go for that. I’m trying to get the liquid from inside the orange, and this is the idea. I give you an orange. The disciplinary approach is you take that orange, put it in your suitcase, travel back home, go back, put it on your shelf. You hold that orange forever.
28:01 Guess what’s going to happen? It’s going to rot, and you never used it. Instead, what you’re supposed to do is peel the orange, eat it, throw the peel away. The container is not to be confused with the content. The movement person would take what he needs from gymnastics, from fighting, from dance, but he would not confuse those reps, those containers, for the content inside.
28:33 What is the content? It’s a human content. It’s movement, it’s ideas, it’s symbols, it’s developing yourself through those things. All the big masters realized it, towards the, some of them towards their last days.
28:47 Brian Rose: What names come to mind?
28:49 Ido Portal: Bruce Lee. Yeah, yeah, Bruce Lee. All the karatekas they all speak the same, because they realize it’s about to get finished. It’s rotting away. The container is gone.
29:02 I gave you a cup of water. You took the cup with the water, put it in the suitcase. You chew on the cup instead of drinking the water. Throw away the cup. So the focus should be replaced there, which brings us to another very important thing.
29:20 Success is not a good orientation. It’s not a good orientation. It’s a filthy word. It’s a nauseating word. I hear it a lot.
29:31 Success. How did you become successful? How to succeed. Books on how to succeed, podcasts on how to succeed. Success is an empty thing.
29:43 It’s misleading. It will leave you empty because it’s simply a container of growth, awareness, and understanding that you need to get, and it happens with success often, but often not, right, because the focus was misplaced.
30:01 Brian Rose: So when I think of successful movers, these are the names that come to mind: Ronaldo, LeBron, Usain Bolt, Federer, right? Most people would agree these are multi-million dollar successes.
30:17 Ido Portal: Yeah, well, they’re not much of movers.
30:20 They are great specialists. They are great soccer players and basketball players. That’s the difference, where the umbrella is very small, and they can play very well that specific game. Take them outside of that game, look what happened to Michael Jordan once he went to baseball. Yeah, it’s the illusion burst.
30:43 Not that I’m saying that anyone can do that. That’s not important. That’s a wrong orientation. The orientation should be to learn something about this body, this mind, the nature of our awareness, through those tools, but it does not mean you don’t do them very intensely. So I practice like a madman, but with complete detachment of the result.
31:10 Okay, I practice full-on. I’m fully obsessed with what I do, but in the end of the day it’s about being a craftsman and not being the success story. Sit down and do your work, brush the brush, the instruments, and you don’t do it with an orientation of like, that’s going to be my most successful piece. You know, I’m going to sell this. You’re just a craftsman.
31:40 You enjoy that process. It’s very different, but also very similar from outside, when viewed from outside.
31:50 Brian Rose: So you’re very careful to look at success and not be seduced by it.
31:57 Ido Portal: Yeah, I can say that I’m not proud of myself for many things, but one thing that I am proud of, and not really of myself, but more in my education, my background, is that I wasn’t moved by that. I had many opportunities to be pulled by those waves of success and money, and but something in me just didn’t think it was fun, and I say it’s not a I didn’t make a hard decision and said no.
32:35 It just didn’t look fine. It looked like a prison, and I still don’t understand how rich people continue in that game once you pass the point of the position, as they say. Yeah, that’s all you need, really, and afterwards it means nothing. And I reached that point a long time ago, and yeah, just the game was different.
33:01 Brian Rose: A lot of people will say yeah, you know, I already have my fitness routine.
33:07 I go to the gym for the hour. I do my weights. I do that, and then I go on with the rest of my life. I’m already a mover. Is that logic flawed?
33:19 Ido Portal: No, no, it’s a, you are, you are a mover. You are moving, hence you are moving, and you are enjoying certain routines, and there is nothing but respect towards that, and you can be happy baking bread. You can be fulfilled doing anything in this life, but the problem starts once ignorance is no longer there, and the bliss is not present, and once you jump to the next layer there is no coming back, and that’s what happened to me, and that’s what I’m trying to help people with, and educate people with, but I realize that you can lift weights and be fulfilled, and use that as your mastery, program, self-mastery, an awareness tool, etc., everything will be lost.
34:11 As complex and as beautiful as these practices are, these deeper practices are more complex practices. They also will be lost in a moment. So I have nothing but respect for it, but like I said, there is no turning back, and I have to work with where I got as I developed, as I climbed the ladder of memes and understandings, and as I became empty again by things that made me happy.
34:42 Brian Rose: A decade ago. What are some of those things?
34:46 Capoeira?
34:47 Ido Portal: Right, yeah, acrobatics, dance. Yeah, yeah, a lot of things, a lot of these kinds of reps and disciplines. They’re not Ido, they’re not Brian. They’ve been made as kind of templates, but they cannot really hit what you need specifically.
35:13 Ido Portal: We need a more flexible tailor suit, and that’s why for me it was about learning my physicality, your physicality, his physicality, and creating a tool that is flexible enough to operate with that. There are many similarities, and we cannot jump there from the beginner level. That’s another common misconception, where creative tools are being empowered upon beginners, which end up being total wankery. For example, many different teachers and people in disciplines and outside of disciplines who try to empower their students with open creative tools, but these tools are too advanced for that level.
36:06 So I tell someone, just move, just move. All you need to do is just move, and he would just be repeating the same patterns without an ability to jump forward. We have collective knowledge. We are the collective knowledge beings. We’ve been collecting information and knowledge for many, many generations, and we need to use that to reach a certain level where now we can add upon our own creation.
36:34 Bruce Lee said it very well, and he repackaged the philosophy that was known from before: absorb what is useful, disregard what is useless, and add what is uniquely yours. But many people fall into only one of these things. They either absorb what is useful, hence they go to collective knowledge, teach me BJJ, teach me the techniques, that’s all that I do. They don’t. They disregard what is useless.
37:02 That is the next level, where they say this doesn’t work for me, even though it’s inside collective knowledge, and it worked for some people. For me, doesn’t work. And then there are the people who are adding what is uniquely theirs, but you cannot start from adding what is uniquely yours to something that you don’t have yet. If you want to be really in a creative mode, I take you into a forest. I take a baby into a forest, and I let him grow from nothing.
37:31 He would merely develop, maybe, maybe not, even Stone Age tools, even in this lifetime. So we’re not there, right? We’re not there. So to empower people to just move, that’s great, but it should happen at the right level, where collective knowledge and self-knowledge are joined. For me that’s important, right?
37:55 Brian Rose: Not too much of one or the other.
37:57 Ido Portal: Yes, because without the collective, you’ll make Stone Age tools. With only the collective, you’ll just repeat after everyone exactly, and you don’t find yourself.
38:07 Brian Rose: Right. Okay, okay, can you explain this meme ladder?
38:10 Because I’m uh, I think it’s an interesting point, but for people that don’t understand, what is the meme ladder?
38:18 Ido Portal: We are symbol collectors, basically. And how did, as a boy, as a child, how did you learn the word chair, for example? Chair was an object that was shown to you, but you also had to make other connections. It’s made of wood.
38:34 What is wood? Wood comes from trees. What is a tree? A tree is a plant. What is a plant?
38:42 Plant grows. What is to grow? Grow. Small, too big. What is small, too big?
38:49 Small, too big. Yes, no. We got to the most basic, zero, one. Okay, so that’s a ladder of memes and ideas. That’s the invisible loop that we are, as Hofstadter calls it.
39:03 It’s it’s a complexity jump, and in our physicality we’ve made many such jumps, where first we were just moving, and then we started to develop all these specialty tools, and this is martial arts, and this is dance, and this is, and then started to create hybrids, hybrids like contact improvisation, which was, whoa, what is it? Or capoeira before that. Right? What is capoeira? Is it a dance, is it a fight, is it a tactical game, is it music?
39:33 Is it, and then people kind of, whoa, whoa, what is that, what is that, and they have to jump to the next level, and you jump to the next level through struggle. Hence when that security guard asks you what is movement, you have to tell him, welcome to the struggle, to the challenge. Now he has to go through getting beat up by the idea, and climbing and clawing his way. Many people wouldn’t make it to the other side. He’s breaking down things in his brain that he had assumed to be true.
40:00 Brian Rose: Yeah, now you get the bad news, they’re not true.
40:03 Ido Portal: Brain, well, I wouldn’t say it like this. Only you have to break up some things, but you have to also build up some things. Okay, and it’s not just about truth, it’s about the perspective on truth. They’re all true in a way, and they’re all false.
40:19 It’s not better, it’s just different, and it’s more, it’s more complex. You’re shedding light on areas which were in the shades before, hence you progressed in the perspective.
40:33 Brian Rose: Okay, all right. Why is it that as humans we don’t have a user manual to tell us these things and what to do? Would we be better off if we had something like this?
40:45 Ido Portal: I think that’s part of the evolutionary process. Figure it out. Figure it out, because by figuring it out, you grow. So how does this work? Oh, like as a child, like, right, you learned how to, you learned how to walk.
41:02 You figured it out. You know who taught you how to walk? Not your parents. Nobody teaches his child how to walk. That’s not true.
41:12 That’s not honest. You learned how to walk. It can only be learned and figured out, and that’s the beauty of the struggle.
41:23 Brian Rose: Yeah, that’s a very Albert Camus, the Sisyphus approach. The struggle, pushing that rock up the mountain, is enough to fill our hearts.
41:35 Ido Portal: That’s the nature of being alive, evolving, increasing awareness, enjoying this reality that nobody knows what it is. So I think it’s a good thing that we have to struggle, and once we eliminate the struggle, great emptiness hits, and it happens on a micro level for us all the time. Reaching goals. Yeah, it’s a very emptying moment. Yeah, yeah.
42:02 Brian Rose: I have a 10-month-old boy, and I think I told you he’s crawling now, and he’s about to walk, and you said to me, you said, Brian, he’s closer to the source than you are. And is that what you mean?
42:17 Ido Portal: Yeah, yeah. He is. He’s operating tools that are superior to yours in many ways, tools of intuition, tools of connection, without yet terminology and language, taming the process.
42:30 Imagine, how do you figure movement out these days? You’re all up, you’re trying to figure out how your hips move in some breakdancing move, or some other sequence in BJJ, by thinking more external rotation, more internal, and that doesn’t work well.
42:49 Brian Rose: That same language is kind of betraying me, because I have to go through that layer of translation as opposed to feeling it.
42:59 Ido Portal: Yes, your intuition is on a very low level. You cannot make associations very easily, as that boy, he’s closer to the source.
43:08 Brian Rose: He is. He’s like the cat that we’re so impressed with, and a cat is not even that. You know, there are more closer animals to that source. It’s a domesticated animal.
43:23 Ido Portal: Yeah, and so figuring it out happens much easier using those tools, because what you can do with your mind is beautiful.
43:33 We’ve constructed this reality, this technology, but movement-wise it’s a poor tool, and it can only serve you as the admiral of the ship, but the actual sailing will be done by the rowers, and those are much more primordial, primal tools: intuition, sensation, emotion, and that connection. Children have it, animals have it much better than us.
44:03 Brian Rose: Okay, because the mind hasn’t gotten in the way. Language didn’t get in the way.
44:10 Ido Portal: The mind is not there yet, you know, hindering the process.
44:15 Fears are not categorized yet as fears, and we don’t get blocked.
44:20 Brian Rose: So it’s part of what you teach: removing the mind.
44:24 Ido Portal: And I cannot really teach it, but it’s something that I try to facilitate. It’s something that I try to facilitate for the people around, and I hint in that direction, and I try to install certain tools, and certain, I leave some breadcrumbs in hopes that people will take the right path, but it’s not up to me, and I cannot control that. Don’t think of a pink elephant.
44:52 That’s the problem. You cannot teach it. Okay, you cannot teach undoing. You have to learn it.
45:02 Brian Rose: I want to ask you about the mind-body connection, and if it’s something that you think about, that you try to teach, and for me it feels like, as a human race, we’re all going this way.
45:20 We’re all going up into our heads, and it feels like even with the internet and technology, it’s more about what our brains tell us to do, and less about what we’re feeling inside our body. I just wanted to get what you think about that, and is this also what movement culture is about?
45:41 Ido Portal: It’s a term, mind-body connection. They are connected. You cannot teach it, cannot affect it.
45:48 It’s there. It’s there. There is no disconnect. So how can I teach you connect? It’s very similar to the term, this, bull, another term, mindfulness.
46:01 The problem is that the mind is full. We try to empty it. I don’t want to teach you mindfulness. I want to teach you mindlessness. So sometimes I think we don’t really think about these terms that are handed to us, and we just accept them, and continue to contribute to their confusion.
46:22 And so I’m not teaching any mind-body connection. It’s already connected. You cannot separate it, and the mind alone cannot exist. We we’ve tried. There needs to be body support.
46:34 But I’m teaching body practices that also affect the mind, and I teach mind practices that also affect the body, and the practicing is a holistic system, and respecting it all. And this separation in people’s heads, in their philosophy, this created limitations and problems, etc. So voice, breath, movement, thinking, all should be joined together, and more into action, into movement. That’s something that I try to bring together. So sometimes my students will be asked to sing in specific conditions and cases, or to vocalize actions, or a certain work with the breath, and all in pro-level action.
47:37 But everything is already connected. It’s just what do you do with that connection?
47:43 Brian Rose: And talk to me about randomness. Do you try to throw randomness into your students’ lives, into your life, and how much of that is part of movement culture?
47:55 Ido Portal: Yeah, it’s a big part, and there is a lot of tools of chaos, what we call tools of chaos, and we’re living in a random thing.
48:05 We’re living in a chaotic scenario. We don’t have control over it, and by trying to take hold of it too tightly, we completely miss the mark and are unable to operate in this chaotic environment. So we’re definitely inserting that into the practice, so people get used to it, learn to operate with it, and not get deluded into thinking they are in control. Nobody is in control. So the dosages, three sets of 10 reps, they can work in certain cases, in certain scenarios, but there is a need of a more well-embracing tool.
48:49 It’s kind of like herding, a concept to herd the cloud of movement, because if you try to hug it, it disappears, and what, it’s gone. So you have to kind of treat it with a more general, gentle, wide tool, and to make some sense of it, because you can hurt and manipulate smoke, but tweezers are not a good tool for that, and that’s a common mistake in movement. People try to kind of own that totally, and what they’re left with is nothing. No movement, just a routine, just a routine repetition of the same actions, a container and not the content.
49:39 And I do this breakdancing move again and again and again and again, and it gets better. Guess what? It doesn’t have anything to teach me anymore, but I’m seduced by the success of it, by the reactions, by the sensation that I get performing something well, until I would hit the wall, and it would crash, and everything would look empty again, and I don’t care for that move anymore. So instead of going through that struggle and crashing into the wall, I try to circumvent the problem and realize, don’t get addicted to it, don’t operate by what you like so much.
50:23 It doesn’t have to be fun to be fun. It’s a good quote I like from Mark Twight, mountaineering guy.
50:30 Brian Rose: Yeah, it’s not, what does he mean by that?
50:33 Ido Portal: It means that you shouldn’t operate just by what you found what you find pleasurable, successful in it. It doesn’t have to be fun to be fun.
50:43 You can suck at something badly, and it has the most to teach you, the most growth to give you, and it should be the most fun, but you have to first disengage from the success orientation and become the craftsman to see that.
50:58 Brian Rose: You once told me, I don’t plan, I react. Is that what this is? A bit about?
51:04 Ido Portal: Definitely part of it.
51:05 Yeah, it’s like, okay, we plan to walk across this beach, but now there is an obstacle. I react to that obstacle, but if I’m too tight by that plan, I now I am lost. I hit an obstacle, we have to restart, instead of simply maybe moving around, maybe changing the path, maybe becoming more flexible. Um, and this is something that I try to do with myself, to wake up every day and prepare myself for betrayal, loss, emptiness, depression. Prepare myself for that.
51:49 It’s inevitable. It’s a very, uh, Marcus Aurelius orientation. If you prepare yourself, it’s not then, it’s not so bad. You’re flexible, you can work with it, but it’s something that people pray would never happen, and they block it out of their mind until the moment it happens, and then it’s too late.
52:13 Brian Rose: That’s almost this concept of being fragile and anti-fragile, and almost kind of preparing your body and your mind for things that you don’t see coming.
52:25 Ido Portal: Almost definitely. Yeah, the work of Nassim Taleb affected a lot of my thinking, and I think he is a once-in-a-lifetime thinker this generation, and the way that he thinks and talks of things made me abandon a lot of my old terminologies that were pointing in this direction, because I realized he’s so much better at it, so I just embraced his terminology and thinking process, and this anti-fragility is a big one.
52:55 Brian Rose: Can you explain how the concept of anti-fragile applies to your work, and even your life?
53:02 Ido Portal: Yeah, so you have to prepare for that black swan, as we said. We have to prepare for the moment of a crack, injury, loss, betrayal, as we said. All these severe, bad events, negative events, they are not a possibility, they are a certainty. They arrive, they will arrive again. When will you get injured the next time?
53:26 Maybe tomorrow. Who knows what can happen? Who will you lose in this life? Everyone. What is the certainty?
53:37 From the moment you’re born, you’re born into the grave. You know this drawing, this Buddhistic, Buddhist drawing, the woman giving birth to the baby, into the grave. We are born into the grave. We know where we’re going. So what is going on?
53:54 How, what are we blocking here? It’s in front of our eyes. It’s a certainty. People are dying in our lives around us. We are going to die, and there is a certain acceptance, and working within that, and getting used to it, and it’s training.
54:09 You have to train yourself to change the way that you approach it, and how you think of it, and how you deal with it. And anti-fragility is, in a way, to accept that and make yourself a little bit more robust and prepared, and getting stronger and stronger every time you hit such an event, and you survive it. You should be getting stronger by it, not get destroyed and sent back by it. So for example, if I get an injury, it’s an opportunity for growth. I immediately go into active mode.
54:46 I research it, and I develop that part, and that piece, so that it would never happen again, versus I rest, I wait for recovery to happen to me, I get stronger, I anti-fragilize myself. Next time, that area, whether it was everywhere, would be better off. I would be able to deal with it on a knowledge level, on the robustness of the articulation, in the neural pathways, the motor program is more developed, so that I can protect myself, etc.
55:21 Brian Rose: Yeah, that also brings up your relationship with pain, because that injury might equal this word called pain, the four-letter word.
55:31 How do we understand that relationship, and know when pain is the time to stop, or the pain is the time to adapt?
55:39 Ido Portal: Yeah, the people at the beginning of the curve, the Dunning-Kruger curve, think that they know what pain is. Now we realize we don’t know. We don’t know. It’s a very complex phenomenon.
55:51 People used to say pain is showing you don’t go here. It’s a stimulus, it’s a signal, it’s an input to shock. Total, over-simplistic, completely wrong. Pain is inevitable. Many times it points you in the right direction.
56:09 For example, pain in training, certain injuries to resolve them. We know nowadays you have to push through pain. For example, you had a knee surgery, an ACL reconstruction, and afterwards in your physiotherapy, the physiotherapist is going to push you through a lot of pain to recover it. And if he shies away, oh, it’s painful, I’m going to stop, you’re not going to recover. You’re going to get limited range of motion, calcifications, adhesions, problems.
56:38 So that relationship should be revisited. Pain is not as simple as we thought before. We have to understand it, play with it, dance with it. We have to start to put shades inside the monochromatic point of view, and it takes time to know that, and only you can do it with your pains. Hence, again, I cannot teach you.
57:09 I can, you can just learn it. I can give you some pointers, some ideas, and then you have to go through the process of dancing with your own pain, to realize, is this really escalating me, or is this moving me in the right direction? And is this pain total, is it a ghost? Is this a totally bogus thing? It’s a phantom phenomenon.
57:31 It happens in our nervous system. People have pains in limbs that don’t exist anymore. So what does that say? How do I work with that? It’s a big big subject.
57:44 Brian Rose: Yeah, one of the things you do is you bring all sorts of different people and you put them in the same room, and you’ll put a dancer in with a fighter, with, uh, maybe a CrossFitter, and you get them talking to each other, and so there’s kind of a higher level, almost like a unification level, of what you’re doing. Do you think about that much, or can you explain that? And did that just happen without an intention?
58:14 Ido Portal: A lot of specialists, a lot of people with certain movement specialties, um, gravitated towards the work they still do.
58:23 Yeah, NBA players, NFL players, UFC fighters, MLB players, and contemporary dancers, the best troupes in the world, Cirque du Soleil people, um, yeah, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera, and they just saw something in that idea, in that movement idea, and they came in to take, but then I made them give, so much, because they have so much in-depth, microscopic and telescopic, um, insight that can benefit a lot of people. Contemporary, let’s say, a classical dancer can tell you a lot about preparing and working on your ankles, and it’s something that is well understood, well researched there. So that cross-communication is another big plus of the movement culture, is to bring everyone together.
59:24 We’re more similar than different. Let’s share, let’s exchange, let’s see who is really thinking about these things, and can offer some good tools for another.
59:36 Brian Rose: Your big annual gathering is happening in a few weeks in Thailand, where you’re going to put hundreds of these people in the same room. What’s going to happen there? If I was an outsider and I walked in, what are the things I’m going to see?
59:54 Brian Rose: And then why do you do it?
59:56 Ido Portal: Uh, I do it to give the community a place of meeting and to share some insight from research, to be together, and to move together. Back to the culture. There’s no movement practice without a social practice. Yes.
1:00:14 Okay. And what happens there is a beautiful cross-section. Actually, I say that it happens on two levels. There is the learning from the teachers, and this is great, and we try to bring very interesting points of view and present them in a very digestible way, but then there is also the cross-communication in between the group itself, which is beautiful in and of its own, and just a lot of passion, and people staying up to small hours of the night, exchanging, moving together, still practicing by the poolside, and going into the rooms and doing things, and just crazy, crazy insights and mobility, crazy wisdom.
1:01:02 Brian Rose: And you’re bringing lectures in as well?
1:01:05 Ido Portal: There are lectures every year. Yeah, this year there is a lecture by a dancer named Rasmus Almei, who’s a great thinker of movement. And a few years ago he sent me his thesis, his PhD thesis, and I was very impressed, and I asked him to come and reflect upon the movement practice. He’s also a practitioner, which is very important for me.
1:01:30 I always bring practitioners as well,
1:01:33 Brian Rose: whose ideas are out there right now that you’re being drawn towards. We obviously talked about Nassim and his work with antifragile and black swan, but what are some of the ideas that are bouncing around Ido’s head right now when it comes to philosophies, or mindsets, or even new movement patterns that are exciting you?
1:01:58 Ido Portal: A lot of things. Taoism, Stoicism, and I mentioned Marcus Aurelius earlier.
1:02:04 Brian Rose: What did most people not understand correctly about the Stoics, in your mind?
1:02:10 Ido Portal: Yeah, I think it’s well understood, but maybe not applied very well. People are very inspired by the idea, but I’m not sure it’s going beyond that into the practical level. And it’s again something that takes a lot of practice. It’s hardcore practice. You need to put yourself into it.
1:02:26 It’s not, you’re not going to read a book and it’s going to happen for you right now. Most people just read that book and leave it at that, because you’re waking up every morning and putting yourself in a painful environment, which is to accept the fact that these things might happen to you, to make peace with them. Yeah, you just have to you have to bring the word practice into your life. Practice. Are you practicing?
1:02:52 People read, but they don’t practice. They don’t have a practice. This is a huge part of what we’re trying to teach. We said the word movement culture, movement happening in a cultural perspective, but one of the other very important terms is a movement practice, a human practice. Movement is life on a cellular level.
1:03:18 On a philosophical level, there is movement, there is life. Hello? There is life here. No movement, no life. So it’s a human practice.
1:03:30 Most people don’t have a practice. They don’t know this word. Some people have a martial art practice or a dancing practice, but they don’t have a human practice where they unify all that they do, not on a movement level, not on another level, relationships, health, physical, emotional, sensory. So, um, I really believe in that word, and I try to bring everything under that perspective. There is something beautiful in Stoicism.
1:04:06 Brian Rose: Great, bring it into practice. How do we do that?
1:04:09 Ido Portal: Start to manufacture tools to address that, to take it, to make it your own.
1:04:15 Brian Rose: I think it was your mother who was a Taoist and a Buddhist, and who probably injected your brain with a lot of these thoughts. But I think you told me once that when you were younger it wasn’t obvious how to process them.
1:04:30 Brian Rose: Is this some of her thinking bubbling to the surface?
1:04:34 Ido Portal: Yeah, yeah. She definitely affected me in many, many ways, and one of the most influential people on me, in her very soft and non-assuming way, and she’s still practicing Buddhism, and she works with narrative therapy and its connection to Buddhism.
1:04:55 Brian Rose: What is narrative therapy?
1:04:57 Ido Portal: The narrative is, in the center of it, of course.
1:05:01 The narrative is the story, the story that you tell yourself. The bride, Brian, is a story. If you take it down into the most tiny bits, Brian doesn’t exist. Is a collection of stories. Hence, what really happened to you is not as powerful as what you tell yourself happened to you.
1:05:25 An old-school psychotherapy, Freudian, was dealing a lot with that. What really hap, what happened there? Let’s dig into it. It’s not as powerful as the stories that you tell yourself. Narrative therapy focuses on that, and I love that, and I also work a lot with narratives, and with stories.
1:05:48 Ido Portal: I’m a storyteller, and I love the power of stories. I think it’s a very potent access. It seems as if it’s the back door, but maybe it’s the entry and the front door.
1:06:02 Brian Rose: Yeah, I think you told me your mother once did something called The Last Year of Your Life, which was a process where,
1:06:12 Ido Portal: yeah, she was part of a course called The Last Year of My Life. A lot of people with terminal illnesses are doing that course, and also some thinkers, therapists, and yeah, just people from all kinds of walks of life.
1:06:30 And it is about that appreciation, that meditating upon death, that realization that of the temporary, it’s all it’s all temporary. I think it was a very powerful experience for her and affected her in many ways, and she shared with me some of that throughout the years.
1:06:56 Brian Rose: Is that something that you still try to do, to meditate on your death Every day?
1:07:04 Ido Portal: Yeah, yeah. It’s, like I said, it’s the It’s the elephant in the room.
1:07:11 It’s all there. It’s there. We can drug ourselves out of seeing it. We can hype ourselves up. We can go into the water and forget about it, and we can occupy ourselves in the skyscrapers, but it’s there.
1:07:34 It’s always in the background. It’s coming for you. It’s something that you will meet. I think we’ve developed a relationship that is very flawed with it, where we ignore it, and we try to compress it and shy it away, and by the time it meets you, it can happen in moments. It can really destroy you, because of it, instead of developing a healthier relationship with that.
1:08:05 It’s a bit like a fight, let’s say. It’s inevitable. You live in a culture and in a time where a fight is inevitable, but you don’t prepare for it. You just kind of try not to think of it, and by the time it will happen, you’ll have a major issue, instead of developing a healthier relationship with The fight, protecting yourself, experiencing some of it to a certain extent, playing with that. Yeah, I think it’s valuable.
1:08:36 Brian Rose: One of the phrases that you always talked about, that I think your mother said, and that is, empty your cup. What does that mean?
1:08:48 Ido Portal: It’s a very common phrase, I think. You want to receive content first, understand content. It has to be carried by a carrier, a container.
1:09:00 I cannot deliver water to you. I need my hands. I need a cup. I need something. I need a container.
1:09:08 Okay, that’s the nature of all beautiful things, love, life, movement. They have to be carried by a container. The container might be a poem, might be a movement riddle, might be a discipline. It has many different shapes and sizes.
1:09:28 Brian Rose: Okay, so how do you carry it?
1:09:31 Ido Portal: Empty the container that you have, that you possess, fill it with the content, deliver it into you, digest it, make it into yourself. It becomes you. It’s not enough to carry the water around. You have to drink it, and it becomes you. Then you don’t need the container anymore.
1:09:51 That’s what we said before. Don’t get obsessed with the container. It’s just to deliver, but you need a container. People demonize techniques, for example. No, they are essential.
1:10:06 Techniques are containers of knowledge. So that’s the idea.
1:10:13 Brian Rose: If you think of a future world of movement, what does progress look like to you?
1:10:22 Ido Portal: Um, I don’t know. I don’t presume to know.
1:10:27 Ido Portal: It’s too unpredictable. It’s too chaotic, and it depends on the community, on this culture, on the world, and where it will take it, and what it will do with it, and what will be the needs in people’s lives, and I’m not here to dictate that, and hence I’m not so planning, but I’m reacting to what is needed as well and what I need. Um, yeah, so I think it’s going to happen naturally, as everything will settle down, and maybe there would be a need of specific tools of health inside it.
1:11:07 Maybe it will need specific tools of education for children, for example. Maybe we will need tools for the older people. Maybe we will need tools for increasing physical intelligence. Maybe we will need tools for solving problems that will arise in the environment. I don’t know right now.
1:11:28 I’m more reacting and trying to address the needs, my needs, my selfish needs, and the needs of others around me, and people of different ages, of different capacities, need different things.
1:11:50 Brian Rose: Are you optimistic?
1:11:52 Ido Portal: I’m a realist. You know the joke? The optimist sees the cup half full.
1:12:00 The pessimist sees the cup half empty, and the realist sees that the cup is twice the size that it needs to be.
1:12:10 Brian Rose: So on my flight over here, they gave me a pillow and they gave me a blanket, and it was just about the right temperature. I had water, a little bit of food. I was extremely comfortable, and I’m curious what you think about killing people with comfort. Are we a little bit too protected now as humans?
1:12:38 Ido Portal: Yeah, of course. Yeah, it’s a common issue. It’s a common problem. We’ve taken the road of satisfaction, protection, safety, pleasure, comfort, to a ridiculous level, and now we meet the other side of it already, and I think we had to hit that wall to kind of go back towards a more centerpiece. Hence you see also people going through some grueling, putting themselves through some grueling stuff as well, like CrossFit training.
1:13:15 Brian Rose: That’s a reaction to going the other way too far.
1:13:19 Ido Portal: Yeah, I think I think it is.
1:13:21 Brian Rose: I think that appreciation is, uh, has hit us in a way, and people are running marathons and going through some really intense stuff, but not because they grew up in some tough neighborhood and they became boxers. People like Georges St-Pierre, and choosing that life because it makes them feel alive, it makes them more balanced, evolve, discover. Yeah, and that’s a reaction to us being too comfortable.
1:13:50 Ido Portal: I think it is, because these people had a need. They felt a need for something else in their lives, and comfort was not serving that. I in my life it was the same. Discomfort was not hitting the mark. I wasn’t happy when I’m aiming for maximal comfort, safety, and pleasure, I become empty, depressed, in pain.
1:14:14 So when there is not enough of it, I also have a problem. Each one has to find his own balance within that.
1:14:22 Brian Rose: All right, and you think we’re going back the other way as a society? Are we still getting to this ultra comfort? Uh, too much food, no movement.
1:14:32 Ido Portal: If necessary, it’s over-simplistic. Society is not driving in one direction. Now it’s scattered, and there are many vectors. Some people are going there, some people are going there, some people are going there, and because there are so many ideas, so many ways of life, so much knowledge, beyond many, many lifetimes, and it gets bigger and bigger, and now we are moving in all different directions. And that, I think, is a major problem with all kinds of optimistic and pessimistic points of view of humanity, that they assume we’re moving in this direction, in that direction.
1:15:10 Now we’re moving in all directions, and the mass will dictate, sometimes, the planetary environmental effects. So while in Europe you have to pay a lot of money to get a plastic bag in the supermarket, in China they would bombard you with endless plastic bags. There are many different ways of life and levels of consciousness and ideas. It’s not that easy.
1:15:43 Brian Rose: One of your famous phrases is, people are not made of sugar.
1:15:48 Brian Rose: And maybe it’s even an Israeli mentality, toughen up a little bit. Do you think the world needs a little more of that in certain areas?
1:15:58 Ido Portal: Yes. In other areas it needs to toughen less, such as Africa. Okay, yeah.
1:16:04 Some people are growing up in some gruesome stuff, kids going through hell. Yeah, people barely making it, so they don’t need to toughen up more. They need some comfort, basic hygiene, conditions. But definitely in the West, yeah, we need some toughening up, and since the message usually in our mediums hits Western culture more, that was my orientation, to offer people the advice.
1:16:40 Brian Rose: There’s a phrase in America now.
1:16:43 It’s called a trigger warning, and I think it was started in universities, when students would go to learn about something, they had to be warned that the information might trigger an emotional response.
1:16:59 Brian Rose: Um, is this a made-of-sugar side of the spectrum, in your opinion, with certain things?
1:17:05 Ido Portal: Yeah, okay. Yeah, we are alarmed, we are oversensitive, and over-alarmed by certain things, and that fear creates its own problems and pains and issues around it, sometimes more than the actual condition.
1:17:21 Fear is an extremely powerful thing in our lives. It’s one of the most primal, basic inputs that we use, but it took over our lives, because we come from an environment with many dangers and risks, and it was a very potent protective tool, but now it became a hindrance. I think happiness is not a good orientation, but fearlessness is a much more powerful thing to get rid of. Some fear, you will never be fearless, but the orientation might be good for us nowadays.
1:18:06 Less fear and more awareness of how do I perceive things. I am the seer, I am the seen, and I’m the seen. Everything we are creating this environment by how we see it, and the narrative that we make of it. So our fears are a major, major already digestion of what we see, and that becomes the scene that affects the reality of the virtual, as Slavo calls it.
1:18:42 Brian Rose: I love it.
1:18:43 Ido Portal: The reality of the virtual is more powerful than reality. It’s a virtual thing. Your fears, you’re afraid of this, you’re afraid of that, but that becomes the reality. It’s more powerful than the actual reality, and it becomes actual reality.
1:19:01 Brian Rose: Who is this gentleman over here who seems to be enjoying himself, and maybe doing a little bit of movement that’s inspired by Ben-Gurion, the very legendary Prime Minister of Israel, who the story tells, was a student of Moshe Feldenkrais, who created the Feldenkrais Method.
1:19:22 Ido Portal: And there is a very famous photo of him practicing handstands, which he used to practice as part of his movement practice, back in the day. So they turned it into a small, funny statue. And yeah, I think there was a lot of movement happening here by a lot of different figures, whether it’s Krav Maga founder Imi Lichtenfeld, and Moshe Feldenkrais, and other Israeli thinkers and movers, and yeah, who were doing it back when I was an itch in my daddy’s pants, not even.
1:20:02 Brian Rose: Why, why, and why movers like that in Israel? Is it the climate? Was it new ideas, new ways of thinking, new people?
1:20:12 Ido Portal: Major part of it is survival. Surviving the horrors of Europe 80 years ago.
1:20:18 A major part of it is the climate, that is supportive of more movement. Definitely, colder countries, less movement. A lot of influences from Europe, from from North Africa, from various immigrants meeting here together in this sunny place and sharing some of their culture and habits, and a need to protect ourselves, a small country surrounded by enemies. All these needs, all these parameters, I think brought together something, and some movement as well.
1:20:56 It brought the need for movement for whether it’s self-defense, whether it’s dealing with, drying the swamps in the north of Israel, no water supply, no real good water supply here. We always suffer from that, and constant threats, terror, wars. And then also people’s bodies, which come from different climates and arrived here with a certain gene pool, and they have problems, health issues, and joints, and pains, and aches, and all this is contributing something.
1:21:33 Brian Rose: So it’s a country of immigrants. It’s a crucible of cultures. And when you grew up, you had a massive influx of Russian immigrants, and so you got a whole new set of movers into your life when you were younger, right?
1:21:51 Ido Portal: Was definitely a major affecting force on me. In 1991, the Iron Curtain fell, and we received 1 million immigrants from the Soviet Union countries, and they arrived, and we were at school, and boom, they all of a sudden were these weird kids, dressed weird, looking different, and they come, and we, I was very much intrigued and became close friends with, and then they had this movement culture that they brought, very, very rich movement culture, one of the most inspiring, in-depth, developed movement cultures, I believe, in the world.
1:22:36 So I’m very much inspired by the Brazilian, by the Chinese, and by the Russians, and there are other countries I love. The Thais, for example, their movement culture, but these are very rich, rich movement culture countries, and they brought in boxing and fencing and ballroom dancing, all this stuff, and they had a lot of methodology and science behind it, and that gave me that orientation as well, that scientific point of view, and I’m still very much inspired by it.
1:23:09 Brian Rose: I keep thinking of a young Ido growing up somewhere where he didn’t have the beach, he didn’t have capoeira, he didn’t have a million Russian immigrants coming into a country of five million, who might have just been given a surfboard somewhere.
1:23:26 Brian Rose: I mean, you wouldn’t be you.
1:23:29 Ido Portal: Now, probably not. Probably not you, but probably also some creative forces would have found a way through different cracks to reach similar states, somehow, somehow reaching the same place, different but somehow the same, because I shouldn’t have gotten where I got in terms of thinking and evolving. If you look at my colleagues, friends, and they stayed within that, and they did not realize there was a bigger umbrella around that specific concept.
1:24:14 They realized other things that I did not realize. It’s not better or worse, but something in me was crying for that, and I’m very different to my family. Nobody’s clear where that orientation comes from. So maybe it’s in my DNA. Maybe it’s something that is really come from inside.
1:24:39 I’m not sure. I’m not much of a practitioner. I said it before, I always say it. I’m not a very gifted practitioner. People see me move and say, wow, but relating that to the amount of practice I put into it, everybody would do it, or many people would do it.
1:24:54 I’m not, maybe I’m not a terrible practitioner, but I’m not a very good practitioner. If I look at my culture, most of my students are above and beyond where they start, and how quickly they developed. But I am, I have, I’m not a, I’m not a very intelligent on a level of, you know, that kind of a level. I have some creative outlet. I have some thinking processes.
1:25:25 I have some movement and body knowledge, and all together, all these small quantities, it comes together, came together to doing it, thinking about it, sharing it. Um, but when I take it down to the small dosages, it’s not much. So maybe there was something unifying that is a bigger, maybe it’s environmental. I’m not sure. I asked myself this question many times.
1:25:52 If I grew up in Hawaii with a surfboard, maybe, maybe I wouldn’t reach it. I don’t know. Maybe I would.
1:25:59 Brian Rose: Seems to me you always ask the question why. Seems like you keep asking that to yourself, and whereas a lot of people would be satisfied with a capoeira practice or even a movement practice, you seem to be constantly tearing your house down and trying to build it up, and then tearing it down again.
1:26:18 So it seems like you’re always trying to find how that relates to something else, or something bigger.
1:26:27 Ido Portal: Is that, that’s a very important trick to do. I’ll tell you what it is. It’s not what many, many times people say, by jumping to the next layer, I confuse myself until I lose track altogether of one location, meaning and gospel, by always relating to a different layer. I’m able to live.
1:26:52 It’s the invisible loop. It is able to sustain me. I am fulfilled. I am challenged, but I am hitting the mark and challenged again, and this is very important. I think a lot of people, they hit the end mark, they set a goal, they reach it.
1:27:11 It is the wrong goal to set, not a good goal to set. It’s because now you’re going to have to restart the whole thing, and now, yeah, maybe, maybe you already start to understand that you’re going to hit that new goal as well. So now you have a bigger problem. Instead, I oriented myself always to confusion, to confuse myself. Yeah, not others, confuse myself, and by jumping to different layers, levels, and increasing in complexity one more time, but eventually also coming back down to the start of the loop.
1:27:50 So it’s not just increasing in complexity, but in a way the increasing complexity also eventually goes back down to the simplest matter, and again and again and again.
1:28:02 Brian Rose: Yeah, and you do this physically and mentally.
1:28:06 Ido Portal: Exactly. Yeah, philosophically, physically. The ideas, and what is the meaning of this?
1:28:12 Yin and yang. The real meaning of it is to place the opposites together. We kind of know it, but again it doesn’t hit us. You’re doing strength training. Why don’t you place next to it the contradictory practice, softness training?
1:28:33 No, you don’t do it. You do breakdancing, but why don’t you surround it with a contradictory or complementary, depending on how you want to look at it, practice? So again we didn’t really make those ideas ours. Doing that is endless, and it’s very balanced, but we have an addictive state of mind, and we go into this practice mode, blind, until we hit the wall. I’ve hit it so many times, my butt hurts, and I just try to do it in a smarter way every time.
1:29:21 So I’m less going towards that direction, even with current projects. I’m not in a rush to fulfill them or succeed in them, because I know it’s not the deal, it’s not the real thing.
1:29:34 Brian Rose: Some would say it’s about the journey, that’s yours, and it’s powerful.
1:29:39 Ido Portal: You know, again, like people hear it, and it’s important to actually embody that, and yeah, do that, and revisit that, and say it, and fake it until you make it, because that’s the way to get there. It’s like all you need to do is to believe in it.
1:29:57 It doesn’t need to feel right. Fake it until you make it. It will be. It will be yours.
1:30:03 Brian Rose: Is this one of the reasons you constantly move yourself as well, different countries, different cities, different projects?
1:30:12 Ido Portal: Um, that was more of a practical thing to share, and what pulled me, it pulled me out, and I wanted to see the world, and it was important for me to have a glimpse of the world, because what do you really know about movement culture before you visited the culture? Right, all cultures and different movement cultures and different experiences and different possibilities. But then it’s also a trap. It can also be a trap, where the no-routine becomes routine, so now, at times, I’m, yeah, I’m trying to find more stability to challenge myself with stability.
1:30:56 Brian Rose: Right. Okay, right, and what can I expect to do with you these next few days?
1:31:04 Ido Portal: And we’ll do some movement sessions, practice and bits, and we will use all kinds of containers, playful tools and games and tasks, challenges, kinetic chains, and riddles, and core, repetitive, cyclic exercises, dance-oriented or martial-oriented or more object-manipulatory. And we’ll just play around with some things, and I’ll show you the type of practice that we go through, and we take our students through, and we educate people with, and the actual content of it is of no significant value.
1:31:58 The actual appearance of it, hence it can be a handstand, it used to be, people got stuck on there, and this weekend we won’t be doing handstands, for example, or it can be gymnastics rings, or the next day it can be a rope, or the next day it can be a stick. That’s not really important. The important bit is the journey, the content inside of that, and we will try to focus on that by destroying and changing the tools all the time, until you get a more general sensation.
1:32:36 That’s the major problem for many people who try to practice movement with good intention. They don’t practice movement. They practice some movements, and they get addicted to their success and the tools that they use, etc. They can’t really move well. I’m baffled by it again and again.
1:32:51 The movement culture became a tricking culture in many places, and then inside there is an island of the movement culture, of practitioners, and teachers, people who are practicing really the essence and not so much gravitating towards specific orientations and skills, because that’s how you’re going to get really better. You have to isolate yourself to those tools, but if you’re not interested in getting better, who cares? So stop with the goals. Stop trying to get the ten ring muscle-ups, and focus on the big picture of that, bracing the movement.
1:33:27 That goal is important on the short term, because it has to give you that focus. Get that ten ring muscle-ups, but then, okay, what’s that? Oh, it’s an empty moment. I got it. What do I do now?
1:33:40 Maintain it. Okay, how long is that going to last? So that is important for you to get, then change perspective, and go at it again, and don’t even orient yourself towards you know, the dependency of getting that, but just practice, use that potential to practice yourself, your strength, your emotional capacity. I cannot make it. I break down.
1:34:08 I build myself up. I’m developing emotionally. I’m developing around me in a culture. I practice together, so we develop culturally and socially. I develop my physicality.
1:34:19 My muscles are affected, my tendons, my neural networks. That’s the important bit. But then bring yourself back to the simplest goals. They are important. They orient you, and they move you forward.
1:34:33 I use them on a short term, but not on the long term. I don’t mistake them for long-term goals. So be present, enjoy the process, enjoy the struggle, have the goals, don’t get obsessed with those goals, and change them around regularly so you can get to your true destination, which is the journey. So there is no destination. It’s the actual journey, and it cycles you back in, and that’s what you do.
1:34:58 You do dancing, that’s great. Go full with it, with the passion, build it up, get your windmills, another turn, 20 turns, 21 turns, 20, etc., but then also learn to let go of it. Okay, I had a nice journey here. Now I’m going to switch gears. I’m going to go towards this direction, because it’s the same practice.
1:35:17 You’re still practicing it. It’s not like, oh yeah, I stopped practicing windmills, and now it went to, I used to do 22, now I can only do six. Yeah, it will happen, and who cares, because you’re still practicing the bigger thing, the more important thing, which is your humanity, your physicality, your movement capacities. So some things will degrade in the short term, but the bigger lessons will continue to evolve. Okay, constantly giving ourselves riddles and forcing ourselves to re-examine, and re-examine, and yes, and that’s the process.
1:35:55 Yes, and it’s hard to do to ourselves, hence we need teachers, we need communities, we need people who are willing to obsess themselves to lead the way. There were always pathfinders. This is not, some people are degrading that, not respecting that. Don’t be, you know, nobody needs a teacher, everybody can teach you. I don’t believe in that.
1:36:20 I always believed in teachers. I always gave myself to teachers and followed them, because they could see beyond the point that I was at, and they helped me see more, and it gave me so much. So I always believed in the teacher-student relationship. I always believe in the pathfinders that can assist, that can help open the eyes, but I also believed in empowering people as they progress, as the practice progresses, to become their own pathfinders. But that doesn’t happen immediately.
1:36:52 It’s a process. So all these things together.
1:36:55 Brian Rose: A wise man once told me, when you find the right teacher, learn whatever he has to teach you. I think you told me that.
1:37:04 Ido Portal: Yeah, yeah, that’s the pathfinder.
1:37:06 It doesn’t matter what you want to learn. It matters that you found a good connection to a source, because it doesn’t matter what you want to learn. You’re learning the same stuff. You play the violin, you bake bread, or you practice movement, but ultimately it’s a human practice. It’s a practice of awareness.
1:37:26 Your violin is going to degrade, your movement is going to degrade, everyone is going to decay, disappear, but some awareness, some growth, inside this journey is the most beautiful thing that we can do, even if it is temporary, even if it does not last. It is the struggle up the hill with the rock, the Sisyphus, to fill our hearts. It’s enough to feel your heart.
1:37:52 Brian Rose: I look forward to the next few days. I’ve already learned a ton.
1:37:57 Brian Rose: So I’ll see you later for dinner. Thank you so much.
1:38:18 Ido Portal: It’s always a pleasure.