Full transcript: Seymour Hersh on London Real
2:21 Brian Rose: This is London Real. I am Brian Rose. My guest today is Seymour Hersh, the investigative journalist, political writer, and author.
2:40 You first gained widespread recognition in 1969 for exposing the My Lai massacre and its cover-up during the Vietnam War. From there you went on to cover the Watergate scandal for the New York Times, and also reported on the secret U.S. bombing of Cambodia in 2004. You detailed the U.S. military’s torture and abuse of prisoners at Abu Ghraib in Iraq, while in 2015 you asserted that the Obama administration had lied about the death of Osama bin Laden. For your work, you’ve received the Pulitzer Prize for international reporting, a record five George Polk Awards, and two National Magazine Awards.
3:13 Just recently you published an article claiming that the sabotage of the Nord Stream pipelines was carried out by the U.S. Navy, the CIA, and the Norwegian Navy under the direct order of President Biden. Seymour, welcome to London Real.
3:28 Seymour Hersh: I’m glad to be here. Great to have you.
3:30 Brian Rose: It seems like you have become super, uh, internet famous in the past week, as independent media like ourselves, uh, is really curious about this story, while mainstream media like the New York Times, Washington Post, and everybody else has completely ignored it. I’m curious if we could just dive into it, see more what happened with Nord Stream. Why does it matter?
3:52 Seymour Hersh: This is the bombing of Nord Stream. It really matters because it happened last fall, late September, and at that point Joe Biden, my president, was pushing very hard, as you know.
4:03 He’s been, he just had this, you know, one-on-one, uh, with Putin, in speeches, in very aggressive, very hostile intentions, are ratcheting up, and um, what he did, the intelligence community is interesting, because many people, the intelligence community, I know it’s hard to say this, they take the oath of office, which they take, it’s to the Constitution, not to the president, not to their boss. And those are the people over the years that I, I’m, you know, I’m, you know, I’m 300 years old, man, and so I’m all, after all these years I know a lot of people that ended up as four stars in all sorts of places, and ended up doing, being involved in some of the most complicated stuff in the government, and so pretty much have a sense of what to do and not to do.
4:52 So I heard about this story um, uh, a month after it happened. Nobody came to me with it. I asked about it, if somebody I knew who was inside, and, and, and so what it was is, Biden wants to go to war, I think, in some unconscious way, uh, with Putin. He wants to mix it up with the Russians. I, I don’t know why, but one thing I can tell you about presidents: um, they have noted that the presidents like Lincoln and Roosevelt, who win wars, become famous presidents, great president.
5:23 So they always have that itch, and particularly a president of war always gets better ratings than a president not at war. Poor Bill Clinton, when he got an office, had had issued a demand about gays in the military, and he was being ridiculed, you know, “don’t ask, don’t tell,” and he’s just being embarrassed by, because he has supported that position, very unprogressive America at that time on gay issues. And so in May, or May or June, of the first year, of six months in office, he ordered the bombing of Baghdad, first major bombing of a major city in the Middle East, uh, nobody else ever, and it was the best day he’s ever had.
6:00 The next day he went to church, reported it was a Saturday. Did the bombing Sunday? He had reporters all over it. It was a great day for him. So you know, that’s just the way it is.
6:08 That’s just the way we respond. And so I I’m just giving you sort of a heuristic approach. I don’t know what really was in his mind. I have a guess, but, uh, about a year, about so, late in Christmas of 2021, before that, the, in December, um, look, like it definitely looked like what was going to go to war. You know, he’d had it with the Ukrainians.
6:35 He thinks they’re sort of sub-level anyway. Some people might remember from the history books, in the early 1930s, Russia let 22 million people starve in the Ukraine. Just took all the grain from them, and they just died. They’ve always treated as a subculture, and we’ve never really been big fans of Ukraine, to you, NATO, and particularly because of the corruption there, right, and also the, the, the fact that the significant body of the leadership, even as late as, uh, now, or be, you know, before this war, were, and war, not seen siglias?
7:04 There was a lot of that crazy stuff going on there, really, but on the other hand, here it was a fun city to visit, with a lot of good restaurants, etc. and so the agency, a group in the covert world, was assigned to a mission. Uh, in December we wanted, we want to do something to convince uh Putin to back down, and we’re yipping and yelling, but the president wasn’t doing it. He was building up the forces, and so the, the term of art I use is important, because anybody on the inside knows, I know something, uh.
7:37 The words used were, the group assembled NSA, CIA, um, uh, not the FBI, I don’t think, Treasury Department, State Department, all the people who could contribute either funding or what you will. They started meeting in a secret room in the, uh, uh, in, in a building across the Executive Office Building, which is on the White House grounds, but it’s separate. It’s a, it’s where they hide most of the, uh, most of the Executive offices are there. They started meeting, and the question being asked of the White House, through intermediaries: this is the president, do you want something reversible, like sanctions, or something irreversible?
8:12 And the word came back, irreversible. That means kinetic. So the option was, of course, take out the pipelines. Why not threaten to? Because since the Kennedy days there’s been a lot of worry, as the Cold War went on, and we had this crazy notion of containment.
8:30 We could contain Communism. In the Kennedy days, even, the Kennedy days, on Russia’s ability to feed gas at a cheap price to Europe was bothersome, because it gave Russia what, what you could call what this White House did call “weaponizing gas.” That’s what they were worried about. Russia was using weaponizing gas, and the fear was we have to hold Germany and NATO, uh, who get a lot. They have no natural resources there in Western Europe, and they were being supplied for a dozen since 2011, when the first pipeline, Nord Stream, there’s two pipelines, the first one was built, began pumping an enormous amount of gas at an incredibly cheap price, building up the German engine.
9:12 You know, the largest chemical company in the world, BASF, is there, and we have all those other bills, the fancy cars that we all love in America. The world loves it. Mercedes, etc. And so, um, what to do about that? That was always a problem.
9:27 So the war starts, and we’re pushing NATO’s involved. We’re pushing Western Union, Western Europe, and the Germans. We want more tanks, planes, guns, you know, et cetera, and at some point, um, and so the idea was give them this option, but once the war started, the people in the field, and they went to Norway, because Norway’s the Norwegian sailors. I actually published a piece today about Norway’s role in Vietnam War. Had a huge role in building up, uh, the Vietnam attacks we made in against the North before the war was even declared.
10:01 And then Norway and the U.S. always have had a close relationship. They were the first one to join NATO in ’49, and got it. It’s very close, and they have very close Navy and underwater crews as well. Well, and also, don’t forget, they have 1,400 miles of, of, of, uh, of ocean. All the way they go, Norway, it goes 1,400 miles from European Oslo, uh, all the way up to the Arctic Circle, where they run into Russia.
10:27 Right? And so we have built, in the last decade, uh, we have put up the most advanced synthetic aperture radar that costs hundreds of millions, if not more, radar to monitor the Russian, uh, nuclear weapons fields across the mountains and into, uh, uh, in, in Russia, northernmost Kola Peninsula. Really cold up there. Anyway, uh and so no ways. We build bases.
10:53 We’ve added to their Air Force. We work closely with their Navy, and of course we work very closely with them in the early, early stages of the Vietnam War. They were running up. We were running Navy SEAL teams and operations long before the war began, and we were, we were working against the North, um, and doing a lot of aggressive stuff that wasn’t that long before anybody in America knew much about the war, that Kennedy has sort of pushed. Too anyway.
11:18 That’s all ancient history. It’s a, it’s a place that fits, because they keep their mouth shut, right? And, um, and I, I was unfair to them, and the story I wrote, I said they made profit. They did make a good profit, because the price of gas has gone up, but they, they want to gas, they ship to, uh, to Western Europe, has only risen about three, four percent since, since this, uh, the pipeline was shut down. The price of gas, though, has made their profit double.
11:44 So the price right now, even though it’s been a warm winter, people are paying. I was three times as much, three to four times as much in Italy, five times as much in France for electricity, and, uh, generates, power plants are generated by oil, and so the price is going up, and, uh, and so anyway, so these guys are watching this, the guys that did it. I mean, and they do, as I say, they take the oath of office to the Constitution, not to the president, and not to their commanding officer.
12:18 These are tough guys. They like to do stuff that make sense of them, so they did plant the bombs. They were ready to go because they could go at any time, but Biden said no. They initially got it done in June. He said no.
12:32 Then, and then by July, August, with the war on, they thought it’s okay. Late September he orders the hit. They do it right, and so they go in in June, because we’re running a NATO exercise, so they came up with a plan. They had the cover. They got the, the divers in there, but then Biden said, I wanna, I wanna make it contingent, right, so he could do it right by remote control later, which was a little bit challenging for them, but they found a way to do that.
12:58 There’s a lot more challenging than I actually wrote about, because um, uh, um, for a lot of reasons. One is, of course, when you communicate to bombs that are set to be triggered by a signal sent by a sonar, it’s low frequency, because the water burns up high frequency. It’s low and slow, and it’s, you know, the way you, the way you do it, uh, to make it really simple, when you’re a kid, you probably played these games, knock knock knock, it’s like, like, three knocks and two little ones.
13:28 So it’s a pulse that triggers the sonar. The sonar reads it. The sonar goes, triggers the post, which triggers the bombs, and this stuff we’re talking about, stuff that can blow up, blow up a major goddamn, um, uh, high-rise, you know, big office building in New York, and you know, that’s real C4, maxed out. You know, it’s really a powerful bomb. Uh, you have to, the pipeline’s covered by steel, and it’s also covered by concrete, because otherwise you don’t want the, this, the salinity in the water, even though Baltic’s much less, much less salty than where they can still salty.
14:02 You don’t want it to eventually corrode, so it’s a big project to blow it up. The problem anyway, and, and you have to hide the bombs so they’re not visible by any Russians coming to inspect. Yeah, you have to, first time they’re built underground, but anyway, um, some of them are go underground, but basically, um, Russians have underwater submarines, unmanned submarines of spying, and they can detect something strange, and we, I don’t know, I do know, the details would have been taken about three books to get it done, and so they actually reached putting it there, once, for to go off in 48 hours.
14:37 You put a timer on it, you know? If a miner’s down there, if a diver’s down there and he sets the bomb, he’s not going to set it for 10 minutes, because it takes them a little while to get out of there, and it’s going to blow sky high. Uh, so they have a 24-hour, 48-hour timer they put, automatically. That’s, you don’t have to trigger it. It’s going to go in two days.
14:54 But the White House, nicks that, not knowing the complications, and then you have a big period of how long they wanted to stay underwater, one day, three days, three months, and so there was a lot of problems about it. This I didn’t write about. They had to go to all the major uh laboratories um, that the Navy has, and by the way, when you say Navy, you’re right, but I will tell you, everybody on that project from the Navy was TDY, that temporary duty. The Pentagon didn’t know.
15:22 Their bosses in the Pentagon did not, I’m turning off my phone. So the Pentagon didn’t know, but so the CIA, they had to go, actually they went to a country called England, which seems to do a lot about underwater stuff, to get help on how to fix it. They did fix it. They made it so it could go off, and then the president decides to do it in late September. By this time, if you remember, last summer it looked like Ukraine had won a great victory.
15:46 They were rolling through, the Russians fell back. Well, it turned out, as the fall went on, at the best you could hope for, by the fall, would be a stalemate, that maybe you can get through the winter and do some serious negotiation, and maybe you can get Russia to back off a little bit on Crimea, not likely, but on some of the provinces that are the provinces, dumb blast, that are in play. So when they popped it, they popped it. Here’s the thinking that I get: Biden decided to blow Nord Stream 2, which was controlled by Germany.
16:21 The first one, Biden, Putin had already shut down the first one in anger off the rhetoric. The second one was pumped, still there, ready to pump. It had it built. It’d be constructed. He shut it down.
16:33 The Germans shut it down, and the fear was Germany was getting anxious about the war. There was so many economic demands. They were also um, uh, uh, there was also pressure from Western Europe, and there were questions being raised about what, what are we doing, are we gonna, you know, there was a lot of fear that they were going to end up in a protracted war with Russia that they would not win, and so biosphere was that shelter, say, the hell with this, I got winter coming, I’m putting, I’m, I’m taking the, I want the gas.
17:04 I don’t want my people, my companies to go dry this winter. He would do the political thing and open up the pipeline. So he took that option away from him, and let me tell you what that means. I’m, I don’t do politics. Politicians call me.
17:17 There’s a lot of stuff going on in Germany now in the Bundestag, and they’re Parliament, about this, a lot of concern about this decision. What he did is he told Europe, all right, since World War II, you guys had depended on it. We had your back, really good, but in this case we value more standing. He’s trying to stand up the Russians more than you. So be cold, to be, you know, have your industry slow down.
17:39 And right now you have the biggest, as I mentioned, BASF talking to China about maybe you know, doing some business there, moving some things there, because they don’t have, the gas costs too much. The biggest corporations in the world, that is the biggest chemical company, are is, is looking forward to a lousy next winter over between September and October and the fall. It was a very mild winter. They built up stocks, so that winter came, they could get through this winter.
18:05 They will get through it, even though prices have gone up. Um, and I think the wunderstar gets the temperatures kept at 60 degrees. A lot of people there are worrying, you know, their ski underwear. I assume everybody in Germany skis. Why not?
18:19 I would, if I were there. Uh, anyway, so the US made a conscious choice to also communicate to Europe that, guess what, our political aims are more important than you and our alliance, which is NATO, which we’re supposed to all stick together. In this case it’s not, and we want to let you know we’re willing to do these things, so they let Putin know and Germany know. You just said it in two sentences. That’s exactly, that’s what the thinking of the people involved, and that’s probably why I was learning as much as I did, because there was a sense that he had, sort of, the president had sort of misused a very significant element, and there you know, uh, look, uh, I’ve been talking to people that that came out.
19:04 I did me a story about a my Massacre. It was 18 months afterwards. Nobody wanted to publish it. Nobody believed the story. There were polls done when I published the first story in some left-wing, little left-wing, just a magazine, a newspaper that had correspond, American correspondence who knew Vietnamese, called Dispatch, but nobody’s paying much attention to it.
19:22 I couldn’t get a major, you know, even though I had been around. Anyway, I can’t tell you how hard it was to not only have interviewed the guy, Calley, that they charged, and have a copy of the charge sheet. It’s still not got a major paper to prove it. It’s not like in this case, I don’t have a document, and so I get so many people that ask me um, um, uh, well, how can you prove it? And I said, I had the same thing after My Lai.
19:51 I didn’t have a video of it. You know, I don’t have a video of these guys under the water digging around, but that’s a crazy standard, because I eventually went to work for the New York Times, um, I got the first real driving job I got after doing My Lai. I was at the New Yorker, the best magazine in the goddamn world at the time. I went and saw the editor, William Shawn. Nobody everybody said, don’t, you won’t even talk to you.
20:14 Within five minutes he hired me, and I did stuff for him for a couple years, and then the editor of the New York Times, Abe Rosenthal, was very conservative, but damn it, he likes stories, and uh, he hired me, and he let me go. He said just go, and I wrote, I wrote stuff. I wrote about the CIA spying on American students. I wrote about the CIA going after Allende. I wrote some NSA stuff that I don’t have to brag about, because in principle I like the idea of having intelligence collection.
20:41 I didn’t like them turning on us. That’s what they did at one point. They began to see how he began the spying on American citizens. Yeah, and they’re too good to do that. They got stopped, and they led this, the famous hearings, the Church Committee, the first time we tried, the Senate tried to do something.
20:57 And by the way, it’s no shock to me that the Democratic Senate, led by Chuck Schumer, uh, I haven’t heard a word from anybody there. There hasn’t been a word said in Congress about this. Yeah, so let’s talk about the reaction to this piece, because first of all, the mainstream media haven’t picked it up at all. Um, the White House press secretary denied it. I think when they were asked by reporters afterwards, well, they went out of their way of denying it when they weren’t even asked.
21:23 Brian Rose: There’s been some Republicans in Congress that are now asking around, saying, wait a second, if this was covert, shouldn’t we have been notified? What has been the reaction? What surprised you about that? What hasn’t surprised you?
21:35 Seymour Hersh: Well, I, I know that if you want to get away from the story, and when I did stuff, I, I mentioned the story I did on the, the sea ice spying, completely contrary to their every law, a set of the books they were never supposed to touch anything like that in America.
21:48 Yeah, I did that. I told the New York Times I’ve been working on it for two years. I formally, editor, two days before I wrote seven thousand words in the paper with seven unnamed sources. Okay, and nobody called up and said, who are the sources? They’d asked me earlier, and they learned who they were, so they, on this story they didn’t.
22:05 They ran it all over the front page, and that’s the power of the Times, which isn’t being used now, but now you use the fact that I’m not naming a source, and you I, I can’t even, do, say anything that I’ve learned that puts anybody in a room, because one thing we’re good at is finding out people who might be talking. You know what I mean? At this point, anybody could know from the source, and, and but uh, I’ve got a long track record that they walk away from.
22:36 This one has to do, I think, with the polarization of the press that maybe Trump started. Trump came in, and you know, you either liked him or you didn’t like him. We soon had Fox News and the New York Post and other papers who were more, more, I guess, to the right, more conservative, and then you had the liberal press in total opposition, so it was a, you know, the, and it stayed because it’s a Democrat in power. The Democratic Senate’s not going to touch it, uh, the Republican House.
23:06 The Republicans own the House. Um, uh, the one guy, in, in, in, in, in the, uh, the one guy that seems to be way out there, who’s quite bright, is Jim Jordan, who’s chairman of a committee. Jordan’s really, I, I’ve watched him run. He was a head of a subcommittee in the House at one point, and he ran, he ran, he ran hearings on very complex money issues. A lot of our money is just that.
23:34 He understands things. He does his homework, but he’s caught up in trying to find out what’s going on with Hunter Biden, the son.
23:40 Brian Rose: You know, that, yeah, you know that sort of peripheral issue. Why they’re not looking at this more seriously? You mentioned that there’s some talking, but there’s been no serious action taken to find out.
23:49 Seymour Hersh: And let me tell you something, let me tell you something about the power of the White House. This happens on the 26th of September, uh, he stiffed Europe basically, and four days later there’s a news conference, and the Press Corps, um, uh, uh, Jake Sullivan is the, the National Security Adviser to the president, uh, one of the Gaggle that was always for expanding NATO during his career. That’s been his, one of his things. So Sullivan gives a briefing, and finally somebody asked them about the pipeline that blew up, and he does the thing, uh, well, we don’t know anything, but he says very carefully, very interestingly, but Denmark and Norway are going to be looking at it, and we’ll, you know, of course we have no idea.
24:32 We’re pretty, it looks like the Russians did it. This, the Russians are behaving in the ways they do, dropping that stuff, the usual stuff, and no reporter seems to know what the president had said, the threat he made earlier. That doesn’t, that isn’t mentioned, because that’s pretty important in, in my aversion of the story. Anyway, um, and he says there’s going to be an investigation. The Swedes and the Danes are doing an investigation.
24:55 Sorry. Okay, we got an answer, a month later. The Swedes and Danes, after their investigation, guess what they report? They conclude that there was something, happened underground, there was an explosion that probably was sabotaged. That was a conclusion, a month later.
25:07 It’s comical, really comical, and meanwhile and so here’s the president, United States. He has the power to do something called to give, to send out something called the tasking order. The president can tasks the community, and he’s got a lot of options. We have something called the Office of National Intelligence, which is the Puba. They’re in charge of all of it, the known and the unknown, and the down and dirty, and they have a director of intelligence who has the charge to do any investigation.
25:36 He’s not asked to do anything. There’s also the CIA, which has a director of intelligence, which, by the way, puts out a lot of superb stuff. All the machinations of the agency, its intelligence is usually, you know, it can sometimes be tilted, but a lot of times it’s quite brilliant and very straightforward, particularly when they work with other allies, and nobody asks them. And then there’s a little black intelligence service. I think one time was called the C shop, where there’s the guys who write the intelligence for our boys who do stuff like in Norway.
26:08 That’s a separate wing. The way it works is the guys in Norway are known to themselves, the header they see. I may know they’re there, but if he asks, should I know more? They’d say no, and he’d say, okay, the White House only knows something’s going on. That’s the way it should be, and that’s the way it was run, but they’re not asked.
26:30 So here’s a White House that’s you know, talking about the Russians might have done it, and there’s investigation in Denmark and Sweden, but the White House isn’t asking anybody in his own agency, which does superb work. They intercept, you know, we have all access to all the communications. Don’t, don’t believe we stopped collecting stuff from here. Please don’t believe that, you know, from your people. We, we love everybody, monitors everybody.
26:52 It’s, it, you know, the Merkel thing was pretty bad, because it got exposed when she was overheard but never asked. So ask a smart guy inside, as I have. So why did they ask? And the answer is, well, because they knew the answer. Why would you ask the community to do something?
27:11 I haven’t find out what we know. We know we did it. Right, but right, so prison doesn’t even think that way, because I don’t know why. So all things point to this. This is the biggest open secret to everybody in the community.
27:23 There’s no doubt to anybody who’s anywhere near this that the US did this, from pipeline people to anybody, uh, the pipeline people, uh, and the people who were involved working with the companies. Don’t forget, it was a huge, big enterprise that put 1,500 miles of pipe underwater, and there was a big community, and they had a lot of people they hired to represent them in Washington, and a lot of very good oil people, uh, worked for them, and then also all the, the Pubas that own the companies that finance the piping. It’s usually done through, you know, you’ll go to, you’ll go to a, uh, some, some major slush fund and get money from them, you know, an investment corporation.
28:08 But basically, I know, I have physical reason to know things in my hand that they all understood right away. It was Russia. It was not Russia, because that made no sense. They always said the only player was, I don’t know, maybe, I don’t know. Is Montenegro part of, I always keep on forgetting the, is Montenegro part of NATO?
28:27 Maybe not. Montenegro did it by itself, but I can guarantee you Nathan can do it, because they’d be shooting themselves in the foot. Right? And so anyway, there you are. You’ve asked the right question.
28:37 Brian Rose: I had a question from a former guest of mine, his name is Jim Rickards. He was a CIA advisor, writes a lot of books about money and about global supplies, and he said this. He said, isn’t the sabotage of Nord Stream tantamount to an act of war by the U.S. against Germany? Even if Olaf Scholz approved the attack, isn’t that an act of treason against his own country? Lastly, he asked, how long will the German people be expected to act as U.S. flunkies?
29:02 I’m curious what you say about that. I hear Olaf is headed to D.C. in the next week or two.
29:08 Seymour Hersh: Well, there was, I’ve been in touch. I’ve been talked to. There’s a lot of groups that are doing investigations, and some of them, even some of the major universities, are doing ad hoc stuff, because it’s so obvious.
29:22 I have no way of knowing what Scholz was told or not. He was with the president when the, when Biden made that blunt statement, “we will stop it, we can.” He was there. He then said something that I did not put in the article, because what he said was, well, I’m, I support America and all that. I didn’t want to suggest that he was saying he agreed with him about what was going on, because I don’t know.
29:46 It’s a question he’s going to have to answer. I hear he’s coming to Washington in a, in maybe, uh, next week, uh, like a good puppy dog. I don’t know. They’ll do the song and dance, right? They’ll deny any knowledge.
29:59 Brian Rose: The problem is that the White House is in the position, the only thing they can do to salvage something in this mess they’ve made is deny it, so they’re never going to admit it, right? It just won’t happen. It’ll be one of the great mysteries of the Western civilization. And, uh, anyway, and ultimately it was probably a smart power move, because they’ve shown their strength, and like you said, Biden’s popularity has gone up. It’s probably his only chance of winning an election.
30:26 Is by doing this. Of course, two days ago he shows up in Ukraine in Kyiv, next to Zelensky, with his sunglasses on, walking around. I mean, it all seems to be going along the same lines. This is the way to get reelected. I’m curious what you think about that.
30:43 Seymour Hersh: Well, I, I, the thing I published today was about Lyndon Johnson and, and Norwegians working with us, and Johnson lying to start the war. And, and, and when you are, it’s only a four-minute speech. I actually have the whole speech. You could listen to it if you wanted to, on the thing. There was a link to it, and it, you know, I, I’m a Vietnam War junkie.
31:05 I mean, I, when you start, once you start doing me, lie. I’ve been, I’ve been looking at things in Vietnam since then, and it, I learned something five years ago that I didn’t know, and I’ve been working with Kovic. It slowed up everything, but I, I’ll tell you um, um, the number killed in Vietnam usually is put between two and three million, as if there’s not much difference, you know? Like, I can’t believe the implicit racism of that. But that’s another thought, but the Johnson speech, he lied about everything, you know.
31:37 He claimed that the North Vietnamese did something they didn’t do, and he claimed they were doing it all the time, when we, really, our SEALs have been working in there going after radar stuff. We even had a couple SEALs, uh, wounded in North Vietnam, and they managed to get to the coast, where they were, they were, they were rescued, and by the way, um, and won the Medal of Honor, and secrecy. I wrote about that today. The show mendacity usually can work when a president does it, but look what happened to us when Johnson gave that speech in ’64.
32:07 You had 58,000 Americans killed, and you had two to three million Vietnamese. That’s the number we don’t know. The number killed, we know that many died. How many were directly from the war, died, because of, of, of being involved or in the area where the war was? Some died of old age, I’m sure, too, but not many.
32:24 There are a lot of killing. And so when you look at it that way, you say to yourself, what are these guys doing? You know, wagging a finger in the face of a Chinese, in public, in public, provoking the Chinese, pushing hard, or Putin, uh, two days ago announced he was gonna put all of his nuclear subs on full alert. You know, I mean, wow. Yeah, I mean, where are we going?
32:48 Brian Rose: What does he want? And what? Yeah, and we want the election. I’m serious. What does he want out of this?
32:53 Seymour Hersh: What does Biden want out of this? Is that what you’re asking? Yeah. He wants to get reelected. That’s all.
32:57 Brian Rose: I think, I just, just my opinion, I think that’s all people in political power care about. I ran to be mayor of London a few years ago, on a whim, and I got a small glimpse into that world, and that is the most important thing for anybody in that office. It’s the next election, and they will do what it takes to get it, and they seem to be very myopic in order to make that happen. Just really quickly, see more. There’s an incredible film, which I’m sure you’ve seen, called The Fog of War, that, with where Robert McNamara talks about so many things you, you speak about from the Vietnam War, and he ends that movie talking about nuclear war.
33:33 And I think he had, by chance, gotten an opportunity to bump into uh Castro, I think, um, many, many years later, yeah, and talking about the standoff there, and I think he asked him, he said, would you have launched those missiles? And he said, yes, I would have. And he said, how could you, how could you even say that to me, that you would have started a thermonuclear war, based on just coming to a head in that situation, knowing all the death it would have caused?
34:02 And his final message to everyone was, you need to be very, very careful about these weapons we have, because, uh, people in certain circumstances are apt to deploy them without really understanding the ramifications, and it feels like we’re coming very close to that now. Sure. It’s so funny you say that, because when I did the My Lai stuff, a big accident was a Harper’s magazine then did a, um, uh, 35-page excerpt from my book. I published a book on it, that came up, and in different stock, and so who knows, X hundreds more thousands.
34:41 Seymour Hersh: And it was a big deal, and when that came out, McNamara’s son, he had a son and daughter that were against the war. This is a very tortured man who did, what I’m telling you, what Johnson did, lied about everything. McNamara was with him on that line. He wanted that war as much as anything in 1964. He wanted to go and get the commies.
35:00 I don’t know what it’s about, but his son told me. He called me and said, uh, in tears, pretty much, I’m in the foam board. It’s 1969, and he said, you know, when the article came, I, I, dad works after dinner in this library, and I, I left it on this table in the library after dinner, before, before he went in, and when he went to sleep, I, you know, like an 18-, 19-year-old kid, he was probably listening to the top 10 music, you know, whatever kids do, smoking a joint.
35:30 I don’t know what they did, though. So anyway, he went down and was in the fireplace, and he called me to say how upset he was about it. So, years later, three years, four years later, I go to Vietnam, finally, because I didn’t want to go. I just didn’t want to see that there was a ditch where everybody was killed that I wrote about. That, this, I couldn’t.
35:47 You can’t imagine, as an American, to see what our voice did, and there was much more going on there that I finally learned. But anyway, and so I, I went, and when I went back, I called the son. I told him I went back, and, uh, I went back there, and I said, just wanted to talk about it. I, I, he didn’t remember calling me, but he, he did dispute it, and then he said to me, you know, my, I asked him if he made, he was very alienated from his father, and I asked, he’s a, he’s a lovely kid, uh, runs a walnut farm in California, very high-end, and I asked him if he um, he didn’t dispute that happened.
36:25 He knew how angry he was, and he said, you know, when my father was, I uh, I was with them the moment he passed away, and this is the former head of Ford Motor Company, a very sure guy, you know, a very big star of the Kennedy years. He said, my dad asked me, he said, you think God will accept me for what I’ve done? And he said, I said yes, and I told him that was the right thing to say. How could you not say that? Well, very moving.
39:25 Will God accept me? Because he knew, yeah. There’s a lot of souls at his life, you know, what I think about. I was in the Army, and I was a terrible child. I was, you know, I had to avoid the draft, because I’d go on a long school and bounce out of there so fast it wasn’t funny.
39:39 I hated wall, but I wasn’t dumb. I knew I wasn’t dumb, but I, you know, I worked as a bar, do those things. Like, I didn’t go to Harvard or Yale, and I was an editor of the Harvard Yale, you know, or the Harvard Crimson, Yale Daily News. My father died of cancer when I was 16, and he ran a ghetto business in the black part of Chicago, and I ran it while going to college. I was, when I got to the Washington Bureau, I was the strangest thing they’d ever seen.
40:02 I, I didn’t, I didn’t belong to an eating club. I’m one of these guys who are writing, slightly. Anyway, and so uh, I can leave all these stories out. You don’t need to know them all. Yeah.
40:15 I think, uh, Magnum era. You can tell in that movie, he’s, he’s tortured by a lot of the things that he had, the decisions he made. Um, well, I’ll tell you one thing he did. He always answered every call I gave him after that. Really?
40:28 Wow. And he did. I mean, I don’t know if that was a way of solace, but, but I I always could talk to him, and, uh, the group. The regret was there, in a way, you know. He, he, uh, it’s, it’s got to be on your soul when you have a war that awful.
40:43 Brian Rose: And so are we, are we approaching something very dangerous? I mean, we think it seems like the Biden administration has an agenda. They’re going all in on Ukraine even though, like you said, it doesn’t make sense. It was notoriously not a regime that we liked or wanted to support, or we thought was corrupt, and now it’s what’s putting us on this head-on collision to Russia. Meanwhile, the mainstream media has seemed to decide to just go with whatever the administration is saying and not even report the facts of what’s happening in Ukraine.
41:12 Seymour Hersh: Well, but even the way they handled the communiques, you know, the, you know, the covering, uh, Tony Blinken, the Secretary of State, went to China after refusing to go because of balloons. We could deal with that some other time, but the whole story of that is comical, really comical.
41:29 Brian Rose: Are you going to do a piece on what really happened with the balloons?
41:34 Seymour Hersh: No, because it’s too trivial. But I will tell you what.
41:37 There were contracts given to the University of Fairbanks in northern Alaska. There’s no, they needed coverage over the, when most of the major airlines go from the Asia to America over the polar co- over the pole, the North Pole. There’s no weather station there, and the pilots, even though at 30,000 feet it’d be nice to know if there was a sudden downdraft or something going on below, they needed to know. So the Fairbanks got this contract to send up, uh, balloon-type things.
42:06 They were vehicles, really. That’s what they shot down, uh, to monitor, monitor the weather. They had a federal contract. The government paid for that, and of course nobody’s talking about that. They shot it down by accident, or they shot it down to make it look like they were doing so.
42:20 I don’t know what they did. Okay, you know, no, I have no idea with it, what they were doing, but anything to, to make a fight with China, you know? That’s the way it goes.
42:30 Brian Rose: And, um, does it surprise you? See more than an 85-year-old guy writing on Substack can break something that shocks the world?
42:37 Seymour Hersh: I, I didn’t know how powerful Substack was. I, I have a friend, Matt Taibbi, who writes a lot for Substack. He was telling me, you gotta, he pushed me into it. He said, it’s amazing, and I will tell you um, it’s a very discerning crowd, because a lot of people have been waiting for somebody to explicate the, the Gulf thing. It was just a mystery.
42:59 I, I don’t know why. My old newspaper, I’ve said, like I’ve said privately to somebody I know there, and I’ve said not, not that much, only a couple of times, as New York Times, the pipeline people know something, but nobody’s chasing it. It’s just, and look, uh, do I see the Democrats, as I said, doing, having a hearing on it? You know, when I was, when we were in My Lai days, the Democrats were against, were against, trying to stop the war, with a lot of Republicans there.
43:28 There were moderate Republicans that were just fantastic. Then you had a real group of legislators who understood, again, that we were in it, going in a death spiral there, not only to our own people, but to a lot of people in Asia. And by the way, if you want to know about containment, if you looked at what happened in Saigon in ’75, we fell. Saigon fell, and a couple weeks later, Cambodia, the Communists took over, crazies, and a couple weeks after that, eventually, in Laos, fell.
43:56 So the whole purpose that we gave for explaining the war was, we had it, it was to contain Red China and North Vietnam, contained the Communists, and so the whole, so everything we were fighting for collapsed within a month. And guess what happened? Nothing. Nothing. They all became, eventually, we’re the largest trading partner of Vietnam now, which used to be North, Vietnam, was the North, one, the country’s unified.
44:24 Nothing happened. So all that stuff we were doing, like containing China, who lost the content? The whole notion of containment, that’s what I’ve been looking at. It falls on its head. It was just wrong.
44:36 And so when David Halberstam, who was a wonderful guy and a friend of mine, wrote a book called The Best and the Brightest, and I, I know, I, I always wondered, because they weren’t that bright. They may have been the first in that class at Harvard, but in the real world, you know, they they, like McNamara, who was head of Ford, yeah, was a whiskey, um, they had no common sense when it came down to it. And I, but I understand now that title was sarcastic.
45:01 I wish David died long ago, and I wish I could ask them about it.
45:04 Brian Rose: So anyway, this, this policy of containment, would you look at the left? Would you look at our treatment of Ukraine through that same lens? Are we fighting a battle that we’re gonna look, look at 50 years from now and say, that was just ridiculous?
45:17 Seymour Hersh: You can’t, you can’t push something uphill.
45:19 You can’t stop. But everybody, every business knows, if you go to, if you go do anything in the Ukraine, the first thing you have to do is start paying off everybody. Right? And I will tell you that the rap on Zelensky, the Zelensky’s not unaware of the money to be made from American, and let’s just put it there. I want, I don’t want to say something that I shouldn’t, but, uh, just because it’s none of my business, and, um, but, uh, the corruption there, it goes up to the top, and you know, that we’ve, we’ve, you know, he’s, he’s been told, you know, cut it out.
45:56 And you know, I don’t understand, uh, I, I don’t understand. It’s, it’s clear that the, the, the Ukrainian Army has been eviscerated, and the people are suffering terribly, and he’s keeping on going, and Biden’s keeping on going, instead of pushing like a mother for peace. You’re, Boris Johnson did his thing. He, I think it’s pretty clear in March or April when he went to, he screwed up some peace officer underway. The Turkeys, the Turks, were doing peace talks, and the Erdoğan, who I don’t like at all, because he’s, he’s a, you know, he’s very undemocratic.
46:32 Erdoğan is keeping Sweden out of NATO because he was, he’s, I’m sure he’s enraged at the fact that he had something going, and we blew it in the spring with the Russians, because he has good context. He was, he was taking oil from Russia, excess oil. Russia’s done fine, you know? Uh, there are economies in a downfall. Inflation’s high, the same as it is here, uh, but it’s not as bad as in the rest of the world, certainly not as bad as in the UK, and uh, he’s certainly holding on, and the fact that there’s no more McDonald’s is, uh, is a blow to some people in Moscow, but they’re carrying on, and the sanctions haven’t worked.
47:09 You know, talk about sanctions, let me talk to tell you about Fidel Castro and a country called Cuba. They’ve been sanctioned since 1960. Yeah, they’re still there, right? It’s, age is the most overrated tool in the world, with the, uh, uh, the, the irreversible methods. Right?
47:28 There’s stuff, there’s language I use in that piece that anybody on the inside knows. There’s some the whole question that was asked. I described pretty much where that meeting was. I don’t mention the floor, but they know It’s a hidden floor, right? They just, I, I did a lot of things that were tip-offs to the guys.
47:45 Don’t go after me too hard, but they did anyway. No option.
47:48 Brian Rose: Interesting. They, is the CIA or the administration?
47:51 Seymour Hersh: No, no, CIA.
47:52 You know, I, you know more. You know, I get a lot of points.
47:56 Brian Rose: Okay. Who’s they? Who’s they?
47:58 Seymour Hersh: The White House. They know that there’s words I use, and phrases I use, that meant that, meant, you know, they met. You, I had, I had people there. Yeah, you know, not directly, maybe, maybe indirectly. I’m not saying it.
48:12 It’s very easy. Once somebody goes to a meeting, he’s got to tell staff people, and there’s always husbands and wives. I had somebody there. In a sense, I don’t want to, I don’t want to go farther than that, but they should have known better, and they, you know, they have no option.
48:28 Brian Rose: And the Post and the Times, is this an unspoken agreement they have with a left-leaning White House, where they just don’t mention this story, and they get access, they get coverage?
48:38 They’re all aligned. They’re all on the same team. What is that?
48:41 Seymour Hersh: Well, you know, I, I will say this, that both papers have a lot of good correspondence. There’s people there I know.
48:47 The Post has gotten thinner. They’ve hired a lot more young people, and you’ll see a story, an important story, about something going on in the war, with five, this story is written by five people, which means that the boss runs it, you know, the, the, the take on the, the take on the story is coming from the top, how to tilt it, if it is, because when you have that many young people writing a story, who writes it? Not one. That’s not five. They can write a story, they all kill each other.
49:13 If they did, I haven’t known it. I’ve been working. So what I, my guess is that um, uh, they’re persuaded by one source. The fact that I don’t name a source after them is, and the problem is it’s always been the same problem, even when I worked there. Um, is that I’ve had people inside that are willing to be critical about what’s going on, and the people, the problem is a source now for a lot of the people covering the White House.
49:41 I was assigned by the New York Times. That’s the best job in the world, to be the White House correspondent. Um, and Abe Rosenthal, the editor, I thought, even though he disagreed with me politically, anything he liked, my stories, and I stayed two days there, because the idea of an inside source is, maybe the press secretary after the meeting, and so briefing us over, would whisper, and he’d go into his office, and maybe they’d bring in a deputy, some deputy from one of the bureaus, and they give him a private briefing.
50:10 That’s an inside source now. But inside sources in the operators, no, they can get a lot of four stars to talk to them, or the, the the ace, to a four-star. But finally, the one-star that really is kissing, a moaning about what’s going on, they don’t find those guys this way. You can’t find them in Washington. You have to go to the field to do it, so I think it’s just a question of the definition of a good source has changed.
50:37 Now it’s somebody you know from the White House telling you. Uh, the reason I had so much trouble with some of the stories I wrote about, the killing, you mentioned the killing of Bin Laden. I didn’t dispute that the bit that Obama authorized the killing. I just disputed all the propaganda he did afterwards to make himself look like a hero. And even then, you know, it was 2011.
50:59 He was a African-American, elected, and a bright guy, very bright, um, and, um, I thought, okay, he’s running for re-election, so he’s going to tilt it, but I wrote, what I, I wrote some stories, and they did back off. You know, they had the way they told the story is Bin Laden was not a prisoner. He was, uh, they’re free. He decided the way to escape from the Americans, after he did what he did in Afghanistan, was go to a resort community about 30, 25 miles north of Islamabad.
51:30 You could call it the Martha’s Vineyard of Islamabad. If it’s 110 degrees there, it’s 95 in the bottom, and live in a villa there all by himself. It’s a good place to hide out, with one mile away, literally, from the major, the West Point of the, uh, of the Pakistani military, uh, Armed Forces. I mean, come on, he was a prisoner. And so that isn’t the way the White House split it.
51:52 They put it, they found him because of incredible work by the CIA tracking down people, and so they told a bunch of lies about it. So I just, I wrote about that. I didn’t, I didn’t attack the basic premise, but boy did I get massacred for that. You, you can’t, you can’t do that. It’s like, it’s like, two weeks after 9/11, uh, they were giving briefings all the time.
52:13 Brennan, who was the head of counterintelligence, later rewarded by being head of the CIA, were on the phone. The reporters could call in to a number, and they give a briefing all, and the president sometimes got on the phone. It’s like whatever was said in the two weeks after that, with the president running for re-election, was gospel. So when I write something different, the press was really mad at me. How dare you?
52:35 And my thought is, didn’t those reporters have a mother to tell them what makes sense and what doesn’t make sense? What they wrote, that Bin Laden had two AK-47s, or two women in front of them, when they caught him with AK-47s, protecting him, trying to diminish him in the Arab world, uh, and the Arab Sunni aggressive world. Um, and uh, there was one time that one of the stories was that he had 900 pounds, 500,500, 500,500, uh, 900-pound bills sold in the, uh, the jacket of the, uh, the lining in one of his jackets, as if that was going to be his escape money.
53:14 Another story they put out had him sitting on a computer watching pornography. I mean, they just did it, and it all went down. My favorite one is the, the U.S. News, one of the national newspapers, had a, uh, one of the SEALs that went on the mission smuggling a dog, and they had a story about the dog that stood guard when they were doing the mission to keep the local citizens from watching it. And I remember thinking to myself, oh my God, the SEALs have a dog that barks in Urdu.
53:43 It was the dumbest story of all, but it was just on and on. They just fed the press, and they ate it all. They ate every bit of the stories about bin Laden, was this or that. And so I, a year later, in a London review, by the way, with the same checkers as I used at the New Yorker, and a wonderful editor, when I pushed the bubble a little bit, I didn’t say he didn’t kill him. It wasn’t, you know, it’s just like, it was, I, I reigned on their parade.
54:07 So we have that going on. The president has juice. This guy has juice, and he’s using it the wrong way, and I think the, I think the correspondence should, you know, listen to some of the colonels in general that are on television. Uh, there’s some of them are really very smart, talking about the war, um, and, uh, some of them I know very well, and they’re really, they were really at the top of the food chains in terms of understanding, and they’re on all the news breaks, sometimes on Fox, which is the enemy, that doesn’t make what they say less important.
54:40 And they’re not, they’re listening to the briefers in the White House or the Pentagon. The briefers we now have, I would probably say, in terms of, well, what the leadership of the Pentagon, there’s been better leadership. I mean, there’s been better leadership. It’s not the top of the game, and um, uh, and but that’s always a fact. I mean, you know, to get to the top, you have to, you know, you have to kiss a lot of butt to make it from colonel to general, and it just stays in, it gets to be a habit.
55:13 Brian Rose: Seymour, what does Putin do from here? First of all, does, does I mean, technically Gazprom owns part of this pipeline. Is he offended by this explosion? Does he, what’s his next move from here? And does this act, especially if it goes uninvestigated or unpunished, empower Biden to do more of this?
55:33 Are we going to look back 20 years from now and say it all started with Nord Stream?
55:38 Seymour Hersh: Well, obviously, the reason I ran the video of McNamara, uh, Johnson telling that lie in early 1964, before the, before the American troops were there, is that that’s a fear of mine. You know, not that I’m all-powerful, but that’s, that’s what happened in Vietnam. And if I, I have no idea what Putin thinks. I read his speeches, and um, I, uh, if you remember two, three years ago, particularly Britain, all the stories where he’s dead, he’s got some kind of cancer.
56:07 This is floating all over, the British gossip of Britain was even stronger than it was in America, on that, big. And, uh, they were, there’s such certitude that he had some kind of cancer. He was taking this drug, but he’s clearly, uh, articulate, and he said it in Sochi, oh, three, four years ago. He talked about America brandishing the bomb, nuclear bomb, and he said, you know, uh, we’re not afraid. We’ll go to God.
56:32 Even if we do it first, God will accept us if we, if we have to do it to protect ourselves. He said that. That was a language you know. He’s, he’s, he’s not a communist. He is somebody who believes in the great Soviet mythology.
56:46 Um, I’ve read two differing CIA profiles, and I wasn’t supposed to see him. There were two differing profiles that were done The CIA uses a lot of psychoanalysts, in the trade, in the business, and they use him. I mean, guys who, guys who treat have private patients but also write stuff. They take the intercepts and look at him, and then write an analysis of, you know, bright guys, and uh, one was sort of the standard. The other one is much different.
57:18 The other was talking about, he’s got, he, he’s more rational. I’ll just tell you what it said, uh, because I was given it. It’s described that he was, he said he thinks himself as a judo expert, and he was in Japan doing a tour, and he was taken to a judo thing, a judo contest. It said there was one very aggressive woman who was throwing everybody, and she said to him, come. He said no, well, you’re a woman, I’ll win so easily, and she says, well, try me.
57:46 So we put on the, with the clothes. He spoke. Maybe he was already dressed. Maybe he was going to do an exercise there. He does fancy himself to be a good judoka, and she threw him in three minutes.
57:54 Right? Yeah, and he took the heat, and that, with what the shrink wrote, the analyst wrote, was this is a guy that knows, when, when you know he’s not irrational. But it was a very interesting one. They didn’t promulgate it because it went against the trade. That’s how I happened to see it.
58:13 They didn’t. The agency did not promulgate it. I don’t think they briefed the wife on it, but he’d done many for the White House, they had. So I don’t know if we have a good fix on Putin. I know he’s, he believes in the Soviet world.
58:25 I mean, he does believe in it, in the same way, just as. And so I, I’m not smart enough. I, I don’t read Russian. I read his speeches. I haven’t read the last one.
58:36 Um, I certainly read the one 10 years ago at one of the international meetings when he said, why don’t you bring me in? The NATO, I want to be part of Europe, and we poo-pooed that. I just, but he’s not gonna, he’s gonna win this war. I don’t think I do. I believe there are other people who said the same thing I’m saying.
58:55 I do believe he does not want to conquer Western Europe. I don’t believe he wants to retake Germany. I don’t believe he wants anything more. He wants this buffer, right? This Ukrainian buffer, and he sees the, the Ukrainians his little wife.
59:09 It’s a racist view, um, but uh, and he’ll win. He’ll win. Well, he just is a necessity. You have to have a Ukraine that’s, that we overthrew the government, a pro-Russian government, in 2014. Right now it’s pretty much acknowledged, um, the, uh, the under-secretary of state, Victoria Nuland, was overheard on an intercept that was made public at the time, probably by the Russians, you know, talking to the ambassador about who should we pick to run the next government.
59:35 I mean, you can’t get away from that one. They don’t, people, the press doesn’t want to write about that too much, either. Uh, uh, I don’t know, but I know, uh, I, I, I, I wouldn’t, I wouldn’t mess with the guy, and he has the resources. I wouldn’t move missiles that are aimed, that could be turned, the defensive missiles, we say that everybody in the community knows can be turned around within half a day into an offensive group. He doesn’t do some mechanical take off, some take off some metal and put on some different metal, could be done within a day.
1:00:08 I wouldn’t do that. I wouldn’t have done that. We did that in Poland. That’s our message in Poland.
1:00:13 Brian Rose: Right, in Poland, you got it, it’s like 80, 80 kilometers from the border of Russia, and maybe 80 miles, I never remember.
1:00:19 So we’ve been provoking them for the past 10, 20, 30, 40 years, and we continue to. It’s been, it’s been the game all along. I mean, it’s been the game. It’s fascinating, because you see more, and then when I’ve had Jim Rickards in as well, former CIA advisor. I had a guy named Andrew Bustamante with former CIA, and they all categorically said Russia is going to win this war.
1:00:39 It’s, it’s there’s just no other way. And yet when you look to mainstream media, especially in Britain and in the US, it’s the complete opposite narrative. It’s the Ukrainian with his everyday, Russia’s on the ropes, it’s just a matter of time, they’re fighting the freedom fight. It’s the complete opposite narrative.
1:00:57 Seymour Hersh: Well, there was a story in the paper today.
1:00:59 I just looked at the headlines, where it said, “accuses Russia.” The Washington Post accuses Russia of more, of a gross of tortures and assassinations and war crimes galore.
1:01:10 Brian Rose: It’s so frustrating, because, like, you talking to sophisticated people who know stuff, uh, and know stuff that they’re not telling you about. See stuff.
1:01:19 Seymour Hersh: I have people that see stuff, and listen.
1:01:22 Just Russian history, in the, in the final days in Stalingrad, the great victory. The Russians were losing. Get this: 2,400 killed and wounded every four hours, and muddled through, and took the, took the Germans down. Took them down. I read.
1:01:42 There were some wonderful novels written by some of the German GIs, the soldiers who were in that war, describing it, when they went, came home, and five years later, they went, you know, like, they’re human beings. They’re bright. Germans are really interesting. They’re well read. Uh, the Max Planck Institute in, in, in, in Berlin is one of the all-time great academic places in the world.
1:02:03 And so, you know, there’s, and, and if they, uh, the Germans, you know, they’re, they’re just, they’re very, they’re very bright. They, for me, I’ve been giving speeches in English for 10, 12 years there, at the university, with no translator. They all mastered languages, and, uh, they know how to party. You know, you can, uh, you can find Brooklyn beer in a lot of places. They have the, like, Brooklyn Lager, which is you wouldn’t think you’d find in, if you could find it in Berlin.
1:02:31 They know the taste of the Westerners, and so I, I don’t know why we have to go this way. And so, look, I’m just one yokel, you know, whisper-yelling in the outline, and I’ve had this, I’ve, you know, when I did, be like, most of the, the first poll I saw showed that 53 or 54 of the people thought I was just nuts. I’m a liar. This didn’t happen. You know, that I’ve gone through that on a lot of the stories.
1:02:57 Brian Rose: How did you, how did you push My Lai through? How did you ultimately get the coverage you got? Could it have been buried?
1:03:02 Seymour Hersh: I had to go to underground newspaper, and if you hadn’t pursued it, would no one have ever heard that story, or at least not believed it? God, really.
1:03:09 And I will tell you something else I learned. I have a lot of internal papers that most of them came from the, the, we declassify in America and the National Archives, and I, I found I had a wonderful person who worked at the archives who worked for me and knew how to find stuff that nobody wanted to be, but it wasn’t hidden. It just nobody would ask for it. It was, it was cataloged in a funny way, let’s put it that way. And so what happened is I also learned when I kept on reporting, I wrote it.
1:03:38 I wrote two books about it, one about, one about the cover-up, what I called the West Point Protective Association. And by the way, people should watch it. It was Errol Morris that did the interview with The Fog of War. People should look at it again. It’s very interesting to hear McNamara talk about it, because there’s a lot to be learned now from that.
1:03:57 From that, it’s online. I’m sure. I am a friend of Worlds, I have to confess that. But anyway, um, and so uh, it’s, they get back to the point, uh, I’ve, I found out from talking to the kids, I saw 60 or 70. I just kept on going to see the kids, the kids who were home, because they were two-year commitments, it was a year and a half later, two-thirds of them were back home, a lot didn’t want to talk about it.
1:04:27 A lot felt unbelievably guilty about what they did, and there was much more going on than just murdering, as you can guess, with, and but then I found out that there was a village a couple clicks away, everybody out there was also wiped out. So when I began asking questions about that, all of a sudden Westmoreland was then running the war and was promoted to be chief of staff, in the, as on the Joint Chiefs. Westmoreland began putting out all sorts of weapons, worrying about me.
1:04:55 What does he know? Why is he getting into that? And so that always struck me as, was there a policy? And that’s what I’ve been working on for the last couple years, three years. I found the answers.
1:05:07 Was there a policy? Well, you can’t, you can’t, when you’re dealing with a culture where the GIs went to Vietnam, and the first thing they discovered is these hard-working Communists. They had no refrigerators. What the hell, who are these people? You know, they’re not worth much.
1:05:23 They don’t have refrigerators, and one of the things the GIs couldn’t cope with is when they would be evacuated. We, we go and we’d evacuate people from, whether we knew there were a lot of Communist troops there, the villages. We’d evacuate the villages that they lived in for 800 years, read a vacuum of, some, some resettlement place, when we did it. The choppers would come to move them, and in that culture, uh, in our culture, children go first. In that culture, the mama has to go in and make sure it’s safe, and so the mamas would come in, and the guys would say, get out of here, these are for the kids, and the mama would keep on coming, and they club them.
1:05:58 They hit them with their rifles and knock them out, maybe, and, you know, leave them bleeding and take the kids in, not knowing the culture, because we taught them. We sent them there knowing nothing except they were commies. They’re all commies. It was that. And so I happen to have some hands-on knowledge of how really bad it was, and there were things that went on that they didn’t write about, because I didn’t want to make this is ’69.
1:06:24 The war was still going on. I didn’t want to make every style of Amy’s soldier load up his gun and start killing Americans. Yeah, because of what happened to me. Like, it was much worse. That’s enough.
1:06:33 You got my bleeding all over you. Oh my God. You’re gonna, yeah, you’re gonna have to get that beautiful suit cleaned. Yeah, put so much blood on you, poor guy. It’s fascinating.
1:06:41 Brian Rose: Seymour, I had a Navy SEAL here named Jocko Willink, who has a podcast now, and he’s, he’s written some really amazing books, and he spent three hours dissecting the My Lai massacre, and just looked at it as, as also just a leadership failure, and went through almost minute by minute what was being said on the radios and everything that happened. And it was just fascinating to see someone from the military going in and looking at what a mess of what happened, and trying to figure out why, and how, that, to make sure something like that never happened. Don’t understand.
1:07:13 Seymour Hersh: The kids, come on, West Point has a lot of problems, but they produce a lot of kids that haven’t integrity. They produce a lot of people that just protect their bosses and know how to get ahead. But I, after that, I ran into somebody who won a Medal of Honor, who had to leave the war, had to resign his commission, because he could not lead troops anymore, as stupidly as being told to do it, send them up a mountain, where the North Vietnamese have all the guns on top of them, because the lieutenant, criminal, wanted to get a battle, a star, and because every lieutenant colonel in that war, the Vietnam war, after a certain period, after ’68, already, by, until the end, if they serve six months without getting shot, they got a Silver Star.
1:07:54 And there was a group in Saigon, a group of kids, that wrote the awards. They were all fake, but everybody got a Silver Star. So if you served as a, a technical, you know, and I mean, that was written about. My friend Gloria Emerson, who worked for The New York Times, it was a wonderful reporter. She wrote about it.
1:08:10 The Times, they want to run it. This is in ’71, ’72. They fought that story for days. She finally said, she wrote a letter to the foreign editor. She said his name, what, doesn’t matter, his name, and she said, using his name, we when you were in Vietnam, you filed through, we filed through Reuters.
1:08:31 Reuters has the best communication, Northstar, whatever they called it. Even when I was there in Hanoi, I had a file through Northstar. It made me feel bad. I had to go to a, in North Vietnam, I had to give a lot of money, ten thousand dollars, to a, a, a, a cable office in Illinois, that they probably used to buy bullets to kill my ally, my fellow soldiers. But I had to do it.
1:08:51 And, um, and so she said to the, one of the senior editors of The New York Times. He held the story for three days. It doesn’t matter what his first name is. She said, uh, uh, saying his first name, uh, if you do not run that story, I will resign. Repeat, resign.
1:09:09 Repeat, resign. And she was a wonderful correspondent, and, uh, and she did it for three days, and finally they ran the story. Wow. That wasn’t always easy, and not just for me, for others too. If you wanted to report things that were uncomfortable, but this one, uh, one of the things, I, the, I gotta go, man.
1:09:26 I got somebody else, you know. I got Ralph Nader to talk to him, and I, Ralph McMuff calls, I always say yes. Ralph. Yeah, because he’s, he, you know, he made a mistake. He ran against, he ran against the Democrats, but he did so much to make things in the world safer, for children, safety.
1:09:43 He’s legendary. This, the thing is, um, my answer to the problem of the media is not the reporters. The New York Times has a bunch of really first-rate guys. It’s, I think 90% of the editors should go, and 90% of the others on national television should go, because they got the wrong idea. They don’t get it, and I do.
1:10:07 I said that. I’ve said that for years, and I don’t say it casually. I’ve watched at the Times that when they had a choice to promote somebody, most of the time they pick somebody who would go along more than somebody who would be a little more truculent, and um, uh, I left the Times, because they happened to pick somebody in to be promoted in the Washington Bureau, who’s a wonderful editor. And one day, I was, I was doing something in 1979 for the Washington Bureau.
1:10:36 I was, and, uh, something about corporations, and he came to me and he said, um, well, I think your time’s up here. I said, why? I was writing about a corporation that had troubles, and it, the, the letter, the, the, the, the, the cable that he got from the, the head of the, um, business desk and the editor of the business pages of the Times was, you know, size on this, but you have to be careful, because we all know he’s notoriously anti-business. I quit the next day.
1:11:09 You know, I mean, this is, he thought it was most the stupidest goddamn metal he’s ever seen, because I write stuff to make corporation people unhappy. Yeah. Duh. That you know, I don’t know, Seymour, I think what’s missing here is proper old-school, well-trained journalists like you in this world, and you know, they don’t make them like you anymore. And look, I watched All the President’s Men.
1:11:34 I watch, you know, a fictionalized version of a time maybe when there was real reporting being done, and making hard decisions being made by these editors in chief, and I don’t even know if that exists anymore. Maybe it never will exist again, and that’s why it takes an 85-year-old Psy to break this story when nobody else can. Um, that’s why I’m sure people talk to me about it, because they knew I would do it. Yeah, what do I care about slings and arrows?
1:12:02 I mean, when you, when you have an, when you have an, uh, interview with a guy that is accused of killing 109 Vietnamese, uh, pre-meditated killing, in a place called My Lai, and you have a copy of the Army charge sheet, and you can’t get newspapers. Yeah. Maybe Nixon is President. I’ll tell you something about America, though, that sticks with me. Here, I did that story, and I’m sticking two fingers in the eye of Richard Nixon, the newly elected Republican president.
1:12:29 And, um, in most countries, I would be in the gulag, but then instead, uh, fame, fortune, and glory. I’m exalted. Do you know what I mean? Yeah. How can I walk away from this country?
1:12:41 You know, for two people where I came from, the wrong side of the tracks, in the wrong side of a, on the wrong side of a city. Yeah, yeah. The only thing I did all my life was read. I never bought, I read the school books, but I always read, so that was another factor. I read about, you know, I wrote a lot about the early days of the Roman Church and the Inquisition, so we’ve been there before, and we’ve had bad times when the leadership didn’t know what was going on.
1:13:06 I’m leaving, because we’ve talked now for two days.
1:13:09 Brian Rose: Yeah, it’s been fantastic, but uh, we’ll close on that note. I know what you do. I know what you do. No, that’s great.
1:13:16 I appreciate it. You’re on it. We’ll close on that note, and like you said, there’s still hope as long as we keep these freedoms alive, alive, and freedom of speech and freedom of the press. There’s always hope, and like you said, you know, we’re not the gulag. These aren’t being shut down right now.
1:13:29 We’re still able to spread these messages. There’s still hope, right? So see more. Very much appreciate. You, people can follow you on Substack.
1:13:36 Is that the best way to get your publications?
1:13:38 Seymour Hersh: I guess so. Yeah, yeah. It’s pretty easy. I mean, I guess a lot of people found it, and a lot of people, by the way, on Substack.
1:13:45 I don’t think I’m their buddy, you know? So I get these hundreds of emails a day, and I stay up sometimes, oh, I think seven, that’s, the two or three, an answer, because, as a reporter, you know, when you’re a journalist, you know, you got, you got to respond, particularly to other journalists. You got to do it. And so, but it’s fun. Yeah, Substack is, I, I just, I’m, I’m astonished at what a good place it is.
1:14:06 Brian Rose: Yeah, and now it’s all over the world, and now you’re an overnight success.
1:14:10 Seymour Hersh: No, I wasn’t. I have my days. Don’t forget about it. You know, I went, a lot of prizes, you said, and, uh, no, I, I’ve been there before, and I know it’s, it doesn’t mean much.
1:14:20 You know, it doesn’t mean much. You, you know, you, you can’t think there’s no easy path. You got to keep on, you know, you got to keep on digging.
1:14:27 Brian Rose: We’ll see more. I appreciate the reporting you did.
1:14:30 I appreciate the fact you, uh, you take it very seriously to keep your sources protected. I take very seriously the fact that you put all sorts of coded messages in there, to where the people that should know, know that you know. There’s a lot of nuance, but with what you did in there, and I don’t even understand all of it. So please keep reporting, um, and let’s have you back sometime in the future, and maybe get to London too. We can do this in person.
1:14:53 Seymour Hersh: Oh, London’s, well, London is always fun. It is great, great hotels, but I don’t know about the, uh, I’m hearing a lot of complaints about the prices, the price of energy now. Yeah, and the inflation, and uh, it’s, it’s, uh, but
1:15:07 Brian Rose: No, but London itself survived, you know? That, yeah. And we’ll find you some beverages, a little Claridge’s, and the good, the, the West End is still the West End.
1:15:17 Seymour Hersh: I always love London. It’s a great city, it’s a great city.
1:15:21 Brian Rose: We’ll find you some Brooklyn Lager as well if you get here. Appreciate your reporting, your boldness, your bravery. Keep it going, and, uh, we’ll talk to you next time on the show.
1:15:34 Seymour Hersh: Thank you, sir. It’s a pleasure talking to you, sir. You have information, and that’s helped, makes it easier for me. Bye-bye, all right. Bye-bye.
1:15:40 Brian Rose: Thank you, take care. Bye.