Can you be very fit and still move badly? Movement teacher Ido Portal thinks so. In this short clip from his 2015 London Real interview, Brian Rose asks him about the difference between being a strong CrossFit athlete and being a good mover, and Ido’s answer starts with something as simple as waiting for a bus.
It is a brief exchange, but it sums up the idea that made Ido’s approach so influential: that movement is a much wider practice than any single sport or training system.
▶ Watch the full episode: Ido Portal – Move Or Die
Strong is not the same as able
Brian sets up the question. A CrossFitter might be able to power through the workout of the day, with kipping pull-ups and heavy deadlifts, but does that mean they can crawl across a room the way Ido does? He has seen Ido’s lizard crawl, and asks whether he will learn it at the coming weekend’s workshop.
Ido says the lizard crawl is a good example of a movement many fit people will find hard, because it needs a range of motion and mobility in the upper back that most people do not have. But his real example is much more ordinary.
The 30-minute squat
Squat down and wait for the bus for 30 minutes, he suggests. Someone who can back squat 250 kilograms might not be able to simply rest in a deep squat for that long. Their body, in his view, has become specialised for lifting heavy loads in the squat, which was never the position’s original purpose.
For most of human history, he explains, the squat was a resting position, used to gather food, to wait, to eat and to go to the toilet. He calls it “a very basic human layer.” Modern toilets mean many of us rarely squat, and he believes we pay for it, mentioning knee pain, ankle problems and digestion issues. His point is that the body needs that daily folding.
These are just small examples, he says, and the list is endless. “You have to remain humble.”
What cannot be measured
The heart of his critique is about what a system rewards. CrossFit, he says, is about building “a very specific engine for very specific tasks.” Organic, everyday movements do not fit that model, because they cannot easily be measured or loaded. Yet one of those movements might be exactly what you need, whether to ease a particular area of your body or to solve what he calls a riddle of movement that life throws at you.
He is not dismissive. There is a lot of good in CrossFit, he says: people get strong, build some balance, run and learn skills. But in his view it is ultimately about CrossFit, not about movement.
What to take from it
You don’t need to give up your training to take Ido’s point. Try resting in a deep squat, crawling, or moving in ways your programme never asks of you. If those simple things are hard, that may be a gap worth working on, whatever your strength numbers say.
This is Ido Portal’s view on training, not medical advice. If you have joint pain or an injury, speak to a qualified professional before changing your routine.
Who is Ido Portal?
Ido Portal is an Israeli movement teacher and the founder of the Ido Portal Method. Drawing on martial arts, gymnastics, dance and other disciplines, he teaches movement as a practice in its own right rather than as a sport, and became widely known after working with UFC fighter Conor McGregor.
This clip comes from Move Or Die, his second London Real interview, recorded in 2015. London Real later followed him for the documentary Just Move.
See everything Ido Portal has done with London Real on his guest page: Ido Portal on London Real.
More on London Real
Transcript
Transcript: Ido Portal – CrossFit Vs Movement: Why Strong Isn’t The Same As Able
0:00 Brian Rose: Right, so just because you’re a great CrossFitter doesn’t mean you’re a good mover. You might be able to bust out the workout of the day and do your kipping pull-ups and your deadlifts, but that doesn’t mean you can do a lot of stuff, right? Like crawl across the room. That crawl that you do: am I going to learn that this weekend?
0:16 Ido Portal: Yeah, we’ll play with that.
0:17 Brian Rose: OK. What’s it called?
0:19 Ido Portal: I think you’re referring to the lizard crawl.
0:22 Brian Rose: Yeah. So is that a good example of a movement?
0:25 Ido Portal: That’s a good example of a movement that will be difficult because of range of motion and thoracic spine mobility, which will be limited in most cases. But it’s much more human than that. Squat down and wait for the bus for 30 minutes. A CrossFitter with a 250-kilogram back squat might not be able to rest in the squat for 30 minutes, because the body has been made too specialised to lift heavy loads in the squat. But that’s not the original intention behind this position. It’s a resting position. You use it to collect berries, to wait for someone, to eat, to sh*t. And this is a very basic human layer.
1:11 Ido Portal: Yeah, we have toilets. But if we go on the toilet for too long and we forget to squat, we pay with knee pains, we pay with ankle problems, we pay with digestion issues, because we need that folding of the body every day. So these are just small examples. It’s infinite. You have to remain humble.
1:36 Ido Portal: These practices are not about movement. The dogma is different. It’s about building a very specific engine for very specific tasks. What about all the organic movements? What about this movement? It’s very beneficial, but it cannot be conceptualised inside CrossFit, because it cannot be measured. It’s not loaded. But maybe it’s the best thing you need right now, to heal a certain area of your body or to solve a certain kinetic puzzle, some riddle of movement that life throws at you.
2:09 Ido Portal: Getting strong? Yeah, you get strong. You have some balance, you’re doing some tricks, you’re running. There is a lot of good stuff in CrossFit. But it’s not about movement. It’s about CrossFit.

