Full transcript: Jimmy Song on London Real
2:30 This is London Real. I am Brian Rose. My guest today is Jimmy Song, the Bitcoin evangelist, educator and entrepreneur. You have over 20 years of experience as a a programmer and contributor to numerous Bitcoin projects and startups, and as an author, you’ve written four books, including The Little Bitcoin Book, Thank God for Bitcoin, and Bitcoin and The American Dream. You are also the author of Programming Bitcoin, a hands-on guide for those looking to program Bitcoin from scratch.
3:09 Your YouTube channel, Off Chain with Jimmy Song, takes a deep dive into all things Bitcoin, speaking to some of the biggest names in crypto, and offering the latest news and technical updates. You have said that fiat money is an institution of evil and that Bitcoin is a tool for human freedom. Jimmy, welcome to London Real. Well, thanks for having me, Brian. It’s a pleasure to be on, and I’ve been a fan of the show for many years, so it’s a little bit unreal for me to be here.
3:38 Well, it’s fantastic to have you. Love the look, and I love a lot of the IP that you bring to the table and just view of monetary system and fiat and all things Bitcoin. So I can’t wait to jump in and I didn’t know how I was gonna start this but I was watching YouTube over the weekend and up popped our friends Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger at the latest conference in Nebraska which isn’t far from you in Texas and I guess I might start there with getting your thoughts because I’ve got some old-school mentors as well that don’t seem to understand blockchain but I’m curious what you think when you see someone like Munger And I’m just gonna quote him and put it out there so we can go from there You know Charlie Munger who I think is the CFO of Berkshire Hathaway who’s been Warren’s right-hand man for Lord knows how long he said and I’m just gonna say this quote in my life I try to avoid things that are stupid evil and make me look bad in comparison to someone else Bitcoin does all three that was Munger and Buffett said if you told me you owned all the Bitcoin in the world and you Offered me for $25. I wouldn’t take it because what would I do with it?
4:41 What did you think and what would you say when you see comments like that? How do you process it? How do you explain it? Just give me your thoughts, Jimmy. Yeah, the way I process it is, you know, these guys are much older and I’ve noticed sort of like a generational divide when it comes to Bitcoin.
5:00 A lot of people that are younger tend to get it a lot faster because they understand that digital things can have value. For older people, for whatever reason, they think that it needs to be physical, that they need to be able to hold it in their hand in order to have value. And that’s kind of a fallacy that a lot of older folks fall into, especially people like Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger. They’re all very into the older ideas of value. But I mean, if we think about it, there’s lots of digital things that have value.
5:33 Your subscription to Netflix has value. That’s why you pay for it. It’s kind of like saying, okay, well, because I can’t hold it in my hand, it doesn’t have value. That’s the equivalent of saying, because I can’t have a cassette tape or a CD in my hand, it’s not really music or something like that. Of course it’s music.
5:51 You can hear it in your ears. You know, that’s kind of the whole point. But yeah, I suspect that both of those guys, you know, they deserve respect because they’ve been able to play this game. But I actually think that a lot of the ways they’ve made money is actually quite immoral. They’ve been able to leverage and get a lot of cantaloune effects from fiat money printing, and that’s a large part of how they become so rich.
6:21 And when your tool is a hammer and everything looks like a nail, you’re like, what the heck is this Bitcoin thing? Personally, think Warren Buffett in particular lost his fast flow, like 15, 20 years ago, you know, he hasn’t been investing in anything innovative for a while. So I don’t see why people listen to him other than to see, okay, what are older people thinking because there are a group of older people that do look at it. But I don’t, I like we don’t go to, you know, we shouldn’t be going to Bill Gates for health advice.
6:58 I don’t think we should be going to, you know, older people that don’t really understand Digital technology to about Bitcoin, you know, it’s funny because I saw an interview recently with Elon Musk And he said quite bluntly that it seems obvious that sometimes ideas have to die out with the people that have them and I think you know Elon’s very good about just being blunt and Honest with the way he sees systems But when I saw those two guys, you know who you know again lauded for their investment, you know prowess Of course, it is leveraged off that fiat money system and all the borrowing which we can get to it It just made me think, wow, maybe that’s true. Maybe there’s a reason we all have lifespans, and again, my daughter’s 18. She’s got a hot wallet now.
7:42 She grew up in a digital world, and she would never say the same thing they said. And also, like you said, if all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail, and their whole life has been built on this fiat system. One of the things Munger also said after that was, Bitcoin threatens the Federal Reserve system and our currency system. And after talking with people like you on a regular basis, I thought, did he just say that? And so obviously, the institution that built them in their wealth is something they naturally protect, even if they’re trying to be objective, right? And this is kind of what we do as humans, right?
8:17 Yeah, and that’s Upton Sinclair’s quote, it’s, it’s hard to get a man to understand something if his job depends on not understanding it. And that that seems to be the case with Munger and Buffett and many of these older people. And they did make their money off of, you know, all of the money printing that comes through, and they can leverage and do all sorts of weird financial gains. And that’s really the tragedy of, I would say, the last 50 years or so, is that so much of the best and the brightest in the world, right, they want to be Buffett and not, you know, the scientist that makes rockets go to Mars or something like that. Instead, you have all, I mean, think about all the people that graduated with you in college or something. The people from the Ivy League schools and all that, they went to, what industries did they go into? Most likely, they went into investment banking because that was the place that was easiest to work at and make a lot of money rather than, you know, pushing humanity forward and building something that everyone could use and make their lives better. And so it’s, you know, pushing paper around and, you know, leveraging things here and there. And I mean, that became the way in which all of these people made their money. And that just seems completely wasteful. It’s one of the tragedies of the fiat monetary system. Yeah, I think you, Jimmy, have said that like we haven’t
9:49 I haven’t done something properly innovative since we put the man on the moon, I think is what you said. And you see a lot of people like the Gates of the world, who their job is to kind of grow this wealth to become more wealth. But you’re like, okay, but where’s the innovation there? And again, I’m guilty. I was getting an engineering degree at MIT and I got seduced into Wall Street because I was like, wow, look at all this stuff.
10:10 And I went down that route. Just tell me a little bit more of what you think about that. Do you think that is our last big innovation, the man on the moon? Yeah, if you do think about the way humanity has progressed, and this is part of why I wear the cowboy hat, by the way. It’s this idea of going out into the frontier and pushing the boundaries of the frontier.
10:32 And that was how the West was one, was a bunch of frontiersmen that went out and continued to expand civilization that way. And space is, as we say in Star Trek or whatever, it’s the final frontier. It’s the frontier that we want to expand into. And I think that’s where humanity’s destination lies is expanding that way too. But since 1969, when we landed Man on the Moon, its civilization to a large degree has stopped expanding.
11:06 Instead, it’s been mostly naval gazing, right? Like you have trillion or almost trillion dollar companies like Apple, Google, Facebook, and Netflix, I guess, for a while there or Microsoft or whatever. These are all not really pushing anything forward. It’s, okay, well, we can now be more entertained and consume more stuff rather than let’s expand and go out into the frontier and make something new. And that, to me, is what Bitcoin is. It’s like one of the few frontiers left out there rather than something like selling more ads so people can click more.
11:46 I think the quote that I heard a while back, which was very relevant to me as a programmer, is the best and the brightest, for a while there was investment banking, are now competing to get one click, right? Like that extra click, so you get paid on the ads or whatever. That seems just as sad as going into investment banking because all of that is really not expanding the frontiers of human knowledge, expanding the frontiers of human territory or conquest over nature and so on.
12:21 So, Bitcoin is one of the few places, like I said. Yeah, and I love your hat. And I was talking to you a little off camera. I had two grandfathers, my grandpa Rose and my grandpa Benedict, and they had both literally gone West. There’s that old expression, go west, young man.
12:38 And that basically, look, there’s a bunch of potential capital out there. If you go there, you can make something happen. And I live in Britain where that wasn’t the option, right? All the land was spoken for a couple thousand years ago. It was all in the king’s hands.
12:52 So you couldn’t actually go create something. Whereas in America, you could. And I remember my grandma drove me around Phoenix, Arizona where my grandpa’s first farm was, a cotton farm. And she looked out the window and she said, Your grandpa pulled stumps out of the ground for two years before he planted a crop. And it left me speechless the rest of the day because I was like, wow, this was hard work.
13:17 This was creating something from nothing. So I really appreciate your hat and kind of the ethos of that. I had Dan Tapiero from Tenty Holdings that said Bitcoin was like the steam engine. He’s like, it’s that kind of a piece of new technology that it can power people all around the world to now create bigger and newer things. Do you ever think about a parallel or analogy when you try to explain it to like a Munger or a Buffett, what Bitcoin is?
13:43 Because again, since it’s not tangible, it’s hard to see, but most people would agree that the steam engine was this major technological innovation that empowered humans all around the world. Yeah, the way I would explain it is that it is the, money is a base layer of civilization. So it’s hard for people to understand Bitcoin until they really understand money. And a lot of people think that they understand money because they use it, they earn it, they spend it, they save it, whatever, and maybe even they invest it.
14:10 But really, most people don’t understand money or how it works or what it does or whatever. And part of my pitch is, okay, do you actually understand how money works? Here’s the Federal Reserve System. Here’s the system of central banking. Here’s fiat money.
14:25 Do you understand where loans come from? Like your mortgage for $500,000, 5% over 30 years. Do you know where that money actually comes from? For most people, they have no idea. They think, okay, some sucker deposited $500,000 into the bank and that’s the bank gives them like a 4% interest rate and lends it out at 5% and they make the spread of 1%.
14:50 That’s not how it works at all. No one would ever take the other side of the trade. Think of it as an investor. Would you ever lend out $500,000 on a 30 year term or half a million, or I mean, at 5% interest rate. The interest rate is too low.
15:07 The term is too long and the amount too high for anyone to actually consider doing that. No, the way it works is that they create that money on your behalf and they make it out of thin air and they do it actually risklessly because of Fannie Mae and basically they have insurance against whatever loan because as long as it’s conforming, the federal government through Fannie Mae will cover the loss. So they are incentivized to give out as many loans as possible, as long as it’s conforming.
15:41 And that’s how new money comes into existence. And a lot of people are shocked when they learn about that. Wait, that’s really how it works, that new money just kind of gets created. Yeah, absolutely, this is how your credit cards work. This is how commercial paper works.
15:57 This is how federal deficits grow essentially forever because they create that money to make up the deficit. And once you understand how money works, then you start to understand, okay, why are all of these people going into investment banking? It’s not because they have a passion for investment banking. I mean, I’m sure there are a few, but that’s majority. It’s because it’s a place to make lots of money very easily without, well, not very easily, but relatively easily compared to creating a new product like making an electric car or a rocket to space or something like that, those are very different ways to make money and investment banking tends to be a lot more certain and a lot easier.
16:40 So people go into that because of the monetary system, frankly. And if you look at the innovation, pre-federal reserve and post-federal reserve, we had a lot more stuff like the steam engine, like railroads, like I think it was the Erie Canal that was created entirely on private funds, right? No public funds necessary, no government intervention necessary, they just created it because that was something that a lot of people wanted and you had entrepreneurs go in and do that.
17:13 Instead, you have this giant industry of rent seeking of people that are taxing transactions in one way or another that are in this economy as a result of fiat money. And once you understand that this is a base layer of civilization and it corrupts absolutely everything, then you can understand what Bitcoin solves. It’s a new base layer. And I’m a developer, so I think in terms of stacks of various technologies and so on. I remember back in the late 90s, there were really two options for building websites.
17:50 You had Apache, which was open source, and on Linux and everything else. And you had IIS, which was proprietary made by Microsoft and you had to run it on a Windows machine. And everybody knew that IIS just couldn’t handle the load or scale. It was just a very bad thing to build a website upon. Whereas something like Apache was a lot more scalable and a lot easier to do.
18:17 And I would say that it’s something like that. And it’s, you know, fiat money as I said, Bitcoin is something more like Apache. You know, when you’re trying to have that fiat money conversation with people, Jimmy, what do you usually start? Do you go back to double entry book system, Medicis? Do you go back to gold standard?
18:35 Do you talk about Bretton Woods agreement? And what do you find is the best way to get people sometimes to just open their eyes? I’ve heard you talk before that, you know, back in the day in Europe when we had to fund a war, whether you were the king of England or the king of France, go borrow that from like actual entrepreneurs and literally to pay for the cannons and the salaries. So you couldn’t print money back then. When’s the example, what do you like to use to people to really show them, wow, look what’s happening here behind the scenes, the mortgage is a great example.
19:04 What else do you use for tools? Yeah, so I like to go through the history of money and like how it was metal and then coins and then you had like bills of credit and all the different ways to make this physical commodity more transportable across space. And that’s essentially what fiat money started as. It was a representation of the gold that was in a vault. And then obviously World War I changed a lot of things because so many countries were already on a central banking system where they did have paper representing the gold and then they just suspend convertibility for a while.
19:48 But yeah, the war one is very good because it brings to light, okay, wait, how are we funding all of these wars? And why were World War I and World War II just so incredibly devastating to the world? It was because they were able to essentially steal money from everybody within their borders. When you hyperinflate the currency, you can essentially extract all the resources of your population, rather than having to tax them explicitly, you can do that implicitly.
20:18 And that means that all of the resources then belong to you as a government and you can just keep fighting. And that was why, you know, a small conflict between Austria and Serbia became a giant world war that essentially devastated an entire continent and ultimately led to World War II, which devastated, you know, a large portion of the world. So those tend to be pretty good. It does depend though on sort of what side of the political spectrum that they might be on and so on.
20:52 I could talk about financial privilege for maybe more people on the left. I could talk about personal responsibility a little bit more on the right and inflation and confiscation and things like that. So it really depends, but those tend to go over pretty well. Do you think that all wars are a factor of the fiat money system? would you ever go to that length?
21:17 Well, I think modern wars definitely are. I mean, we would not have spent trillions of dollars in Iraq and Afghanistan if we actually had to pay for it. Part of how the US pays for a lot of these wars abroad is the dollar is the reserve currency of the world. So they can essentially make everybody else pay for it. When you have something like a trade deficit between US and China, where the balance of trade is that the U.S. imports way more Chinese goods than China imports U.S. goods.
21:51 You have a big deficit there. Well, how does that get settled? It used to get settled in gold, and this is why actually the U.S. ended up with so much of a stockpile of gold by the end of World War II and why they had so much leverage. But nowadays, because the dollar is the reserve currency of the world, what ends up happening is, okay, well, now China gets a whole bunch of US Treasuries and that’s money that we printed from nothing.
22:18 So we get all of these goods and services from China for this cash, essentially. And that’s what ends up fueling a lot of these wars, right? Like you spend all this money, but you dilute it further by spreading it around the rest of the world and they end up paying for it. this was what happened in Vietnam and why, you know, like the Bretton Woods system came to an end in 1971. All these countries were pissed.
22:47 Okay, why is the US continuing to spend more money that it doesn’t have, especially in Vietnam? So, you know, France was basically saying, hey, we’re gonna want gold for all these dollars that we have and Nixon shut the gold convertibility window and said, yeah, going to temporarily suspend this, that temporary has been like, what, 51 years now. So it’s a way for the US to have monetary imperialism over the rest of the world. And that’s just something that a lot of people don’t understand, a lot of Americans are ignorant to. You know, my friend, Alex Glatsy, calls this, you know, financial privilege of the West. If you live in El Salvador or Honduras or something, you know the monetary oppression that you’re under.
23:39 You don’t know it if you’re Charlie Munger or Warren Buffett. Yeah, I think we have Alex coming on the show next week and one of the big events that happened obviously was 2020 when we saw lockdown and all of the panic and I was getting ready for a massive fall in markets. I’d been watching the markets for a long time and then all of a sudden they kind of came off the third and then went back up. And I know that’s when people like Michael Saylor, who’s been on the show, took a step back and said, now wait a second, what’s actually happening here?
24:10 And I think it was maybe the first time a lot of people got to see the massive amount and the scale of the printing of money by the Federal Reserve to keep everything normal in times that weren’t normal. Do you often use that as a great example to show people what’s happening? Obviously, it’s the kind of the straw that broke the camel’s back on Michael, And he looked at himself as a CEO with a fiduciary responsibility and thought, wait a second, I can’t hold dollars.
24:36 Maybe he’ll all look at gold and obviously he settled on Bitcoin. Do you use that as a moment to show people that, hey, with the stock market’s up 35% and nothing’s going on but the rent, perhaps we’ve just printed that money. How do you look at that event and can you use that to educate people or does it sometimes fall through? Yeah, I mean, that’s an excellent event to educate people. And for me, it was more 2008 that really opened my eyes because you had this $800 billion TARP bail out.
25:07 And I’m like, where did this one come from? And the stock market did something very similar back then where it dipped for during the crisis. And then as soon as the TARP bail out comes through, everything goes back up. And we go on another Super Bowl run. 2001, the same thing.
25:24 After the Twin Towers and everything else, everything crashes, and then you have this, you know, incredible quantitative easing, essentially. Actually, 2001, I think it was, they kept lowering rates back down to zero, more or less. Quantitative easing comes in in 2008, and way more so in 2020. But each of those events, and you could go even further back, you know, 92, you had that recession, and, you know, stock market crashes, and then starts going up again, starting in like 93, 94, 89.
26:00 I think you had like Black Friday. You could, you know, you could go further back and every, you know, eight to 10 years or so, there’s always some sort of event that causes some consternation, but it always comes with some sort of federal reserve event that causes everything to go back up. The thing to notice though, is that they’ve had to do more and more drastic things. I think in 89, they lowered the interest rate from five and a half to 5.25% or something like that.
26:34 And that was enough to, you know, get everything blowing again, you know, 92, 93, 94. You know, they lowered it just a little bit to like 3%. You know, 2001, they had to lower it to zero. 2008, they had to print $800 billion and start buying mortgage backed securities. 2020, they just had to print like crazy, right?
26:56 So each time, it’s kind of like dropping bigger and bigger bombs. And this is the equivalent of financial weapon escalation or something like that. That continues to happen. And the next one, I have no idea what to do, but I imagine it’s going to be way more than a few trillion dollars. It’s probably going to be five or six times that.
27:22 So you’re, I’m thinking like 15 trillion or some ridiculous number that we think is completely crazy. But to answer your question, yeah, like you just go back and be like, okay, like I lived in Boston in the late nineties. The big dig was a big deal and it was, you know, all right, like the federal government is paying for the $18 billion cost overrun. And I was thinking back then, it’s like $18 billion. Who has that kind of money?
27:48 And what project could possibly take that much money? And that number was unreal to me back then. Then 2008 happened and that just made 18 billion seem like completely simple. And then 2020 happens and that makes 800 billion look quaint, right? Like it’s, it just kind of keeps going up like that.
28:07 And that’s, that’s inflation just right in front of you. Yeah, I was actually just in Boston and I saw the end of the big dig and I know it went way over budget for this massive infrastructure project. But also you just made me think we had a guest on the show named Jaco Willink and he’s got an expression, discipline equals freedom, right? It’s US Navy SEAL. And that simple phrase, discipline equals freedom, just says a lot about human’s life.
28:28 If you have discipline about, say, your savings, you might have money to spend, you have discipline about your training routine, you might have a body that works. And yet it feels like whenever there’s a financial event, crisis event, it seems like the Fed steps in and doesn’t really exercise discipline. It kind of lets, guess what? We’re gonna make everything better, even though what we should do is take our medicine, take the hits, go back to innovation. And it seems like we’re not exercising that discipline.
28:56 And so we lose a little freedom each time and we lose really our own currency. You ever look at it that way? And is this kind of like Jeff Booth says in his book, is this why all Fiat currency systems end up crashing from the Romans to the Wehrmacher public to us? Because ultimately it is about human discipline at the end of the day? Yeah, absolutely.
29:16 And I’m a big fan of Jaco as well. And what he says about discipline and needing that almost as a pushback for your own health and your own humanity, really, is absolutely true. And the equivalent, I think, of what the Fed is doing is being sort of that very indulging parent or something like that. And part of it is that politically, we basically live in a gerontocracy or something like that, like the old people rule everything, which is why we had two years of lockdowns.
29:53 Guess who were the people that were most vulnerable? It was the old people that were making all of this decision. So of course, they took it way more serious than, say, somebody that’s 30. So you have this weird dynamic where, As these boomers have aged and gotten into power, they have kind of grown very lazy. They’re used to getting bailed out for their bad decisions, essentially.
30:24 And that generation has, unfortunately, infected all of government, all of society, really. And it is all about making people feel better about the choices that they’ve made, rather than getting them to make better choices. And making better choices requires a lot of discipline. And unfortunately, we’ve made wrong decisions over and over again, just sort of in the name of compassion and not letting people crash and burn, I guess. They’ve bailed people out over and over again.
31:03 And it’s unfortunate, but that’s how democracy tends to work is that people want to be bailed out rather than take their medicine. Yeah, there seems to be a lot of that. And that gerontocracy term, I heard Peter Thiel mentioned that when he was at the Bitcoin Miami conference. I know you were there as well. And it is an interesting way to look at the way that world is run by all these older people that are even getting older and the way they look at things.
31:29 And even though I remember my grandpa’s is giving it to me straight And actually, they had been through some hard times and they were not usually there to take kind of my BS. It does seem like we’ve given people a pass more and more, it’s gonna be okay, here’s a handout, everybody wins first, when over the course of time, obviously, that’s never the case and it seems like it’s expressed now in our currency. And so, along comes Bitcoin, which in a weird way, and the embodiment of discipline equals freedom, right?
31:59 Now you have this fixed asset that is now obvious as this parallel financial system. You mentioned Star Trek recently, and there’s an old episode, I’m talking about the old ones with William Shatner, where there’s like the parallel universe, right? And you got Spock in this world and Spock in the other world. And now we see this Bitcoin world where we’ve had Jeff Booth on the show where he says, well, look, Brian, the price of everything in dollars in the future goes up.
32:22 The price of everything in Bitcoin in the future goes down. So what’s happening here? So enter Bitcoin as a system. How do you now see that? And is it this weird parallel universe that people maybe for the first time can say, oh wow, here’s a discipline system and here’s this normal human system?
32:41 Yeah, it’s definitely a different system and it’s one of the few that hasn’t been infected by fiat money. So almost every other industry, so housing, stocks, bonds to a large degree and everything else, it’s infected by fiat money. And you can see this in asset prices. We saw stock prices go crazy during 2020, 2021. And we saw real estate prices do the same thing.
33:11 We were talking before the show about how everything has gotten more expensive in the respective places that we live. This is because of the money printing. And it’s a lot of the policies that come from fiat money. One of the things that’s kind of subtle that happens with fiat money is that when a government gets into power, they now have control over the printing press and this is through budget deficits essentially. And the moral imperative at that point becomes, okay, you have the power to print money.
33:44 That means you can solve pretty much any problem. That means that instead of me being responsible for my own, taking care of my own stuff, you should do it because you are morally obligated to do it because you have controlled the printing press. So my health, my housing, my job, or whatever, you’re gonna have to provide for me. And it becomes way more socialist, way more communist. And there’s a reason why the fifth plank of the communist manifesto is central banking, essentially.
34:15 It’s this idea that the state needs to control the money and all value needs to flow through the central bank in some way. So, you know, if you want to talk about, like, CBDCs, that ends up being basically the wet dream of any communist or socialist that’s, OK, we get to control value and so on. But going back to Bitcoin being a parallel system, it definitely is because it doesn’t have this expandability. It has this fixed supply. So no one’s going to take care of you for you.
34:49 It’s just you have to go take care of yourself. And it’s all about personal responsibility in that way, where you’re going to be able to save. You try to save in the dollar, and it’s going to continue being debased, whereas with Bitcoin, because of its scarcity and all of the innovations that are happening in society and, you know, sort of like increasing, I think the way Jeff Booth puts it is that everything else is deflationary, and Bitcoin is the money that’s deflationary along with it. You get this really nice way of saving, you get capital accumulation, and you can go do stuff that fits your talents and needs. And that, in turn, means that you can provide goods and services to the market, and that’s the most efficient way to make money rather than being a rent seeker and doing stuff like investment banking or whatever, instead you get to do the stuff that you’re actually really good at. So if you’re really good at making cars or making paintings or doing whatever, you can go do that instead and make the most money doing that rather than making the most money doing something that is essentially rent seeking or taking advantage of the money printing that’s happening. And those are very different systems. And I think you can kind of feel it when you’re inside the Bitcoin community. Now, I’m not going to talk about altcoins, because I think that’s very much more fiat than Bitcoin is. But you can feel the difference
36:26 And how people talk about it, how people have a very low time preference in Bitcoin. People are talking about families, like having lots of children and making sure that they’re planning for the future and not just going to the latest party with Snoop Dogg or something like that, that ripple throws. Strange, isn’t it? Almost how your monetary system affects the kind of person you become. One of the things I’ve noticed big time, Jimmy, being in this space now full-time for like a year is there’s a lot of hope, a lot of optimism, a lot of creation in this space.
37:00 Whereas, like you said, when you’re in the fiat money system, it’s almost like you’re trying to to gain the Fiat money system. So you always hear of the, you know, ever since we were kids, that I, the real estate investor, I bought a house and I borrowed this money against it and I flipped my house and I did this and you’re always thinking, well, how does this work? This is a weird video game, right? And so, like again, it values you if you can gain the Fiat system.
37:23 Again, I went to work for Wall Street from MIT and ended up making 10X what I could have made as a mechanical engineer for Ford Motor Company. And why was I, I was like 24 years old and a vice president at the First National Bank of Chicago when I moved from New York City. And it was like, okay, I was really good at trading fixed income derivatives, but was I creating more value there than I would have in manufacturing at Ford? I don’t know, I guess I was in the Fiat system, right?
37:50 And so therefore it warded me and I repeated that behavior. So it’s an interesting point you make about how that system itself can bring out the type of humans we want. But I guess it makes sense because if again, you’re being rewarded a bit like Munger and Buffet, right? They’re being literally rewarded with cash and accolades because they are very good at this fiat system thing. And so of course they value it and they stick with it and they do more of that.
38:17 If they were potentially in that Bitcoin system, they might behave very differently, right? And I guess this is the essence of what it is, this future human behavior. Yeah, and I mean, think about just like pre federal reserve system, like the people that we used to look up to and honor, you had like, you know, the Einsteins and the Edison’s and Teslas of the world, right inventors, people that were thinking and trying to figure out like new ways to see the world. You know, I mean, I guess maybe Rockefeller a little bit because, you know, he basically changed the entire oil industry and figured out how to make it, you know, he created standard oil and all of that. But there were, these were the people that were admired because they created a good or service to the market that was desperately needed. Nowadays, it’s people like Munger, Buffet, and, you know, the people that run hedge funds that make 30X their money, that, I mean, have they actually made anything with their hands, like ever. Like have they created companies? I mean, once in a while you get the Sam Waltons of the world. I guess people admire Zuckerberg and Sergey Brin and other people like that. But I mean, most of the time it’s the investment managers that people admire and it’s like, okay, the values have completely shifted because of the underlying money and the monetary system has changed the incentive so much that you’re honoring people
39:52 That really haven’t done that much. I mean, yeah, Buffett like brought a bunch of insurance companies together. He has real estate holdings and like furniture companies and, you know, owns a bunch of stock. He knows how to trade, but that’s not really creating a good or service the same way, you know, say Thomas Edison did with, you know, like General Electric and, you know, creating all of these wonderful things. Like that tells me more about the the monetary system then versus now than anything else.
40:25 Yeah, that’s a really interesting point, Jimmy. I was actually just like I said in Boston a couple weeks ago with my daughter looking at universities and I stopped by MIT and out on the outside of the walls, like you said, it’s like Newton and all these people that had these incredible game-changing ideas that brought about like huge magnifications in what we were as a human species. But like in today, if you go on Instagram, Like you said, it’s usually someone flexing their jet, or like you said, it’s a BlackRock partner, or it’s something.
40:56 And also, we’ve kind of become a victim of what we value most, I guess, which is that kind of fiat currency, which has now got out of control. And so, we kind of value the people that somehow gain that system. And I guess it all ends like the Romans, to a certain extent, right? Where they continue to devalue, devalue, maybe get debauched. And I’ll just, on that point, how do you see this fiat system or the dollar system ending?
41:22 Because that’s always interesting. You know, a lot of people talk about it, but also it’s hard for me to see it ending anytime soon, even though, like you said, these crises are happening more often with literally exponential-sized printings, but how does it end? That’s a great question. And I think we can learn a little bit from, you know, the lessons of the Wai’amai Republic, even what’s happened in Zimbabwe, Venezuela, and many others. But generally, there’s some sort of crisis of confidence.
41:54 And I think we’re getting there. I don’t know if we’re quite there yet with the monetary system. There’s certainly a political crisis almost everywhere. There’s a lot of movement towards populism in most countries where, you know, they want a little more, they tend to go a little more nationalist and maybe even isolationist to some degree, but they’re sick of, you know, like jobs flowing outward, for example. And that’s something that, at least in the US, has happened over the last 50 years.
42:30 All manufacturing has essentially gone overseas. And this is something that you can predict with a fiat money printing with central banking. And if you study Richard Cantillon, who was an economist from like 1720. And he noted, you know, he was observing the Bank of England, which is the world’s first central bank and said, well, here’s what happens is all the manufacturing jobs go elsewhere because labor is just cheaper. And that’s essentially what’s happened to the United States.
43:00 Most manufacturing has gone out and you’re not gonna be able to bring those back until the money reforms. And that’s not something that a lot of people really understand or have figured out. They like the role of the dollar and the ability to print money essentially at will until the world gets saturated with it or there’s some sort of crisis of confidence. But I do see something like the Ukraine conflict doing something, right? Because what we saw with the Ukraine conflict is, essentially the financial system completely, like said no to Russia. And in doing that, it undermined its reserve status because they essentially seized all of the Russian assets. Now, you might think that they’re deserving of that or whatever, but when you take something like that away, well, Russia is no longer going to be on the dollar standard ever, and a lot of their allies are not going to be on there.
44:04 And you see Europe paying for all of the gas that Russia is providing in rubles, and the ruble is stronger than ever because of the dynamic that’s just sort of happened. That reserve currency status, I think, starts crumbling partly due to this particular conflict, but I think there will be more, especially if we get into any sort of conflict with China over Taiwan or something like that. That could really destroy confidence in the U.S. dollar. And then at that point, it’s kind of a gradually then suddenly thing. We’ll see the structures of the U.S. dollar hegemony sort of like crumbling, and then all of a sudden it’ll be, okay, we’ll be onto something else. That could be another fiat currency, it could be gold, it could be Bitcoin.
44:53 I think Bitcoin is inevitable eventually, but when that happens, how that happens, that’s more a geopolitical macroeconomic question and it really depends on sort of specific things that happen. But yeah, I think it’ll happen in the next 20, 30 years, something like that. You mentioned some interesting points there. I was very surprised the way that the US flexed its muscles with the dollars in the Ukrainian Russia conflict. And again, regardless of whether you think about the conflict, to just pull that status of a dollar, if you have a dollar, You can keep your dollar or that you’re gonna be able to use this as reserve currency to just to take it away from a citizen or an actor, you know based on the the acts of a dictator of that country I was very surprised and I guess the US did it because they could or there was pressure to or they thought they might win That political war but like you said it kind of stuck in a notch and that reserve currency That’s probably gonna really hurt it over time. And I was really surprised by how swiftly it acted I guess it thought it was a way of trying to fight back against Russia, which we typically did militarily But in a weird way almost cut off our nose to spite the face by saying guess what?
46:10 That thing you thought was really valuable. You can’t have any more and guess what? No one else thinks it’s valuable So it might have pushed people more towards either the yuan and I’d love to talk about CBDC’s when it comes to that Or like you said maybe Bitcoin. So yeah, I’ve had a lot of people on talking about how that probably advanced that you know While I’m on that topic. What do you think of the yuan of the CBDC?
46:32 I’ve had a couple conversations about this on the show I had Alex Masinski a Celsius that said World War three will be a currency war between these two digital currencies the dollar and you Want and we’ll see how that plays out and then where Bitcoin is left I’ve also had Chris Giancarlo in here who was the CFTC chairman for four years He was responsible for the Bitcoin future contract Who’s you know who’s talking about how he studied the digital yuan and 60 million people are using it And it’s as dark as we think it’s gonna be as in very Incredible way of controlling people in their currencies What are some of your thoughts on those two currencies about how that’s gonna be a war? I guess it’s already happening right now, is it? Yeah, the interesting thing about currency that again like a lot of people think they understand money but they really don’t, is that the dollar, the euro, the yuan, they’re all used politically to essentially monetarily oppress different countries.
47:33 So one of the things that I’ve been learning a lot more about is, you know, the three-letter organizations, the IMF, the World Bank, the World Economic Forum, and so on. One of the realities of that is the IMF is sort of seen by the public as kind of a benevolent organization that gives loans to poor countries or something like that. It’s nothing of that kind. It exists as a way to monetarily oppress these places. And the way it works is essentially the IMF gets a bunch of money from their member countries, mostly the US. The US gives them money that they print out of their hand. Here you go. Here’s billions of dollars now go loan it to different countries. They make the loans to a country like El Salvador, Honduras, or whatever, usually within their sphere of influence. And then they tell them, okay, in order to take this money, you have to implement financial austerity, which is a way of saying, okay, we’re going to tell you exactly how you can spend it. And the leaders of that country are happy to take it because it feels like free money to them. And they help themselves by embezzling a lot of it.
48:42 But they can’t spend it on the things that they actually really want to, or the populace is demanding, which is infrastructure, right? Like they want roads, they want sewers, they want hospitals, they want stuff like that. Instead, they have to spend it on all kinds of things that the West tells them to spend it on. And that ends up being horrible because they can’t pay them loans back. And when they can’t pay the loans back, well, guess what? The Western countries say, well, you have to pay the loans back. What do you have? Well, we have all this land and resources from our country. All right, so go sell the mineral rights or the plantations or whatever. A lot of these places in Central America are called Banana Republics for a reason, right? Chiquita Banana literally owned a lot of these tracks of land in those places as a result of financial machinations like this. And it’s a form of monetary oppression where these countries end up being owned by Western corporations or whatever. And they’re able to take the best resources and not just land and mineral rights or whatever, but also the people because the monetary imbalance means that a lot of these people want to go work in the US. So the best and the brightest from Honduras or El Salvador, they go illegally immigrate to the US and take care of gardens and build homes for rich people in the US and nothing gets built back home, right? This is what monetary oppression looks like and
50:15 It’s done without a single shopping fire, which is very interesting in light of what you said about it being a monetary war because in a sense we’re already in that sort of like monetary hegemony over the world already. Now that’s the IMF. China’s been doing something very similar with the Belt and Road Initiative and they do that with Southeast Asian countries and African countries and so on and they do the exact same thing. They’ll lend them money and then when they can’t pay back they take the resources of the country and now they have influence, monetary oppression, and so on. Even countries like France, if you study the CAF, which is Central African Frank, it’s a way to oppress these countries. And it’s not a surprise that a lot of African immigrants come into France to work and build stuff for French people rather than, you know, their own countries. And this is the dynamic that we’ve had as a result of the monetary system that we’re in. Now, as we get into CBDCs and so on, how is this going to change everything?
51:24 Well, I mean, CBDCs are horrible for the people within the countries and for somebody like the Chinese Communist Party, they’re going to be able to like oppress at an unprecedented rate. Like, oh, you bought this thing. We’re not now going to take away your bank account or prevent you from traveling anywhere, can’t buy any train tickets or anything like that, and that’s in line with their communist Marxist roots, so that kind of makes sense. But I am a little bit skeptical that it’ll happen in the US, and the reason is that the banks have too much of a lobby, and the thing that a CBDC allows a government to do is take out all of the middlemen. So right now the system of central banking means that you have a central bank, but you also have lots of other banks that are within that Federal Reserve system. So they call it a central bank because it’s a bank for banks. You have all these member banks that are part of this giant bank called the central bank and they do all of the settlement through it. If you have a CBDC you can get rid of all of those banks and you have a direct consumer to central bank relationship where every citizen has a relationship with the central bank. And that’s what the Chinese Communist Party wants.
52:48 I think in the US, the banking lobby is still too strong for a wholesale elimination of their entire industry by having something like a CBDC. So I don’t think it’ll happen in the US. But what I do foresee is that Bitcoin becomes the currency of the resistance within a lot of these countries. And it is to a degree already, you know, in Russia, like a lot of services have just blocked Russian citizens wholesale and said, OK, like you can’t use it if you’re if you’re within this IP range or whatever. Well, if they want to pay for a gooder service outside of Russia, what are they doing? Well, they’re getting Bitcoin, right? Like Bitcoin activity is through the roof in both Ukraine and Russia. And that should tell you everything you need to know. There’s a lot of people not just using it for goods and services, but to get out of the country, sell everything that we have. I disagree with this government. I want to get out and have opportunity somewhere.
53:48 I already work for a Western company anyway. Let me immigrate to Poland or Hungary or something and continue working from there. I want to bring my whole family. It’s allowing a lot more mobility for those people. It’s allowing for a lot more freedom and ability to sort of make your make something of yourself rather than being subject to the tyranny of government yeah I think that conflict we just saw whether you’re in Ukraine and going through this madness or you’re in Russia and your stocks are going to zero your real estate prices are going to zero because your overnight rates are going up and now you can’t even own certain currencies or if you’re in Canada and you happen to attend a protest and they freeze your accounts.
54:34 They’re all great arguments for having some Bitcoin, maybe some stablecoins and we can get your thoughts on that, but having something that’s not controlled by a central bank, you know, for sure. Just to get your final thoughts on digital dollar, like I said, I had Chris Giancarlo in here and he has something called the Digital Dollar Initiative where he said, look Brian, we already have kind of a digital dollar because it’s basically, you know, a sequel spreadsheet, right, of basically accounts. And I think Breedlove has said this before, where that’s what the Federal Reserve anyways.
55:05 And John Carlos said, look, what if we can make our CBDC something that embodies all the great American values, which we celebrate, a lot of those with your hat, which is freedom, the lack of censorship, all the things that we’ve seen happen on these social channels when payments networks are suspended from other channels. He said, what if we could make it in the spirit of democracy freedom to where it was always going to be something that wasn’t censored, et cetera, et cetera. Do you think there is a point in setting something like that up because it’s gonna be adopted sooner or later?
55:39 Or do you think that is just rife with problems because we’re encouraging it being adopted? Yeah, I don’t know if such a thing is possible because the very idea of a central bank digital currency is that there’s always a trusted third party and that is the central bank. They sit in the middle of every bilateral transaction. So if I’m trying to pay you, Brian, it has to go through the central bank before it gets to you, instead of a direct peer-to-peer connection.
56:10 And that’s what Bitcoin is. It’s this ability to do peer-to-peer transactions. And that means nobody can censor it. Nobody can confiscate it. Nobody can do anything about it.
56:19 If we wanna do a transaction, it’s voluntary, we do it and that’s it. But having a central bank dollar or digital currency or anything like that, implicitly says that there’s somebody sitting in the middle. And you might think, well, all right, I could still do cash transactions or something, and they’re not a third party to that. Yes, that’s true in the very strict sense that your dollars are flowing from one person to another, but they still have some control because they can print more of it and take value away from the dollar that you’re sending and essentially debase that dollar so that you’re sending less value essentially in person and so on.
57:03 So the whole idea of a freedom based central bank digital currency, I don’t think it’s viable because you have to have a trusted third party at some point whether it’s directly in a CBDC or something like that or even in cash where they control their entire supply but they control the denominator of the currency. And if they can increase the denominator, well, it doesn’t matter that your numerator steady, it’s still getting debased. So I don’t think that’s viable.
57:37 And this is an argument that a lot of people put forward about altcoins is, okay, well, doesn’t this extra feature make it better or something like that? And I’m like, no, no, it doesn’t. Because if you have, you could put all the bells and whistles you want on the dollar, I’m still not gonna want it because they can’t print more money and they have the incentive and motivation to whenever we get into a crisis. So I don’t want to hold the dollar. I would much rather hold something that has a fixed cap, a supply that’s not going to change.
58:11 And when you add a feature to an altcoin but at the same time centralize it, like it takes away the whole point. Like you now are centralized, you have a trusted third party And that that makes it worse that that essentially introduces a An intermediary to every bilateral transaction I would rather have the bilateral transaction where no one can interfere and that that’s what Bitcoin is You know one of the things that Michael Saylor said when he was on the show and I’ll never forget Jimmy as he said Bitcoin is digital property now You know and he talks about this kind of vision of you know Manhattan and being blocked out and you can vision these things and If for me, it was a really good analogy because I kind of could finally get it my mom. She’s 78 years old She lives in San Diego. She owns property and I was thinking, you know What if she was a single mother raised three kids, but she only has that option because she lived in America and she was able to acquire That what if someone else in the world could also have digital property by investing in Bitcoin and having an asset that a government Couldn’t take away. So it’s helpful. But towards the end of the show Michael said, you know, what that’s digital property But there’s still a need for maybe a currency because people don’t always want to move their property like a currency And I’m curious what you think of that obviously we’ve seen places like El Salvador adapted as a currency
59:33 But as you know a lot of people don’t want to sell their Bitcoin or give it up even for a transaction How do you think Bitcoin has been as a currency? How can it get better and do you agree our digital property and currency potentially separate things? Yeah. So we’re essentially talking about two different properties of money. And one is as a store of value. The other is as a method of payment. And store of value wise, I think Bitcoin is superior to anything that we’ve ever seen before because of its fixed supply. And the last 10 years, you can just look at the charts. Anybody that’s held Bitcoin for five years has always made money. And that’s kind of an incredible thing to be looking at. Now, as a method of payment, it’s a little different because there are fees, at least on chain and so on, but we have something called the Lightning Network, which makes it very convenient to transmit. But as you said, a lot of people don’t like spending their Bitcoin because it keeps going up in value. And I I always tell this story about the beef jerky that I bought back in 2013, right?
1:00:42 There was a beef jerky provider that started taking Bitcoin in 2013. I bought a hundred dollars worth of beef jerky, which was a quarter of Bitcoin at the time because Bitcoin was $400. You know, that’s a $10,000 beef jerky at this point, which, you know, it doesn’t feel good to do that. And I since then realized like should spend my fiat money first. And once you get on a Bitcoin standard where your savings are in Bitcoin, you do this slow spending of Bitcoin based on your needs and so on. It’s not nearly as consumptive as being on a dollar standard, but you do need to do that at some point.
1:01:26 I think Lightning has proven out to be a really good method of payment platform. And we’re seeing that in El Zante, in El Salvador, where every merchant takes Lightning and there’s no problems doing that. And for them, it’s interesting because they are mostly a cash-based society and they don’t have their own currency. So they’ve been they have been using US like literal cash US dollars all over the place. But with with Bitcoin, because they have cell phones, they don’t have to go beg Visa or MasterCard to start their network in their local place.
1:02:06 Instead, they just use their phones and use lightning. So there is that potential to be a massive improvement for places that don’t have the digital infrastructure necessary or these large credit card companies, or, you know, if you’re in Hong Kong, or something, octopus card network, or M-Pesa network, or something like that, if you don’t have those networks, then then you can use lightning as a means to do that. Otherwise, you know, I think for a lot of people in Western countries, method of payment is not really that big a problem. You have credit cards, you have Venmo, you have PayPal, you have, you know, Google Pay and Apple Pay, and all these other things. So for people in the Western world, I think it’s much more, okay, you store your savings in Bitcoin, and then you convert it as you need to pay the bills that come out of these method of payment thing. So a lot of people, what they’ll do is, you know, credit card is due at this date in the month, and they’ll sell just enough to pay that bill, you know, as as it comes due. And it’s a little bit of a pain, make making sure that that’s managed properly. But that’s, that’s kind of what a lot of people do and you know that that ends up being a decent substitute for method of payment. What do you tell people when they ask you about the price of Bitcoin? We did our 10-year anniversary show back in October and on that day Bitcoin I think was hitting its high at 68,000. I don’t think that was a coincidence by the way
1:03:32 And then obviously we’ve seen it come down and go below 40 and of course everyone probably asks you where’s Bitcoin going? It’s something that’s talked about a lot but for someone who’s been in this space and sees this as kind of an alternative reality to humanity in a sense. Do you engage with that conversation? Do you talk about it? But also you must know the volatility of it and the future price of it is on the minds of people that hold it, especially the newbies to that currency or that asset.
1:04:01 So how do you have that conversation about the price of Bitcoin? And of course, I’ll ask, where is it going? Well, I’ll answer the volatility question first. And this is something that a lot of people complain about because they’re like, why is this so volatile? It can’t be really a currency unless it’s volatile, unless it’s not volatile.
1:04:20 But we’ve kind of gotten spoiled because of the US dollar and FX trading and central bank vaccinations. If you think about other currencies like the yen or the yuan or the euro or something like that, the central banks of all of those places make sure that their currency relative to the dollar stays within a peg range. And that peg range, at least for the Japanese yen, has been plus or minus 20% of 100 yen per dollar for a long time. Similar thing with the euro, it’s been about a dollar to a euro for a long time, dollar 20 to a euro for a long time, something like that. Swiss franc, the yuan, all of them have a range. And the way it’s managed is when it gets too high, the central bank will will print more of their own currency when it gets too low, they will use their dollar reserves to buy up their own currency and essentially make it go to the peg range that it wants.
1:05:25 And that’s how it’s managed. That volatility would be much higher if central banks weren’t, quote unquote, managing it. So in a sense, because Bitcoin is decentralized and doesn’t have a central bank, you’re going see a lot more volatility than you would in other places. Now, with regard to price, there’s a very simple economic equation. We have a fixed supply and increasing demand. The only release valve at that point is price. So over the long term, it’s a great investment. And like the reason why people ask about, okay, where’s the price going is because they want to know when to get in and they want to feel like they got a good deal. And we’re used to this from a fiat monetary standpoint, because that’s how we’ve been trained essentially. Like, oh, okay, you want to look for a deal at this point, and then everyone jumps in and gets this thing at a deal. They want to feel like they’ve timed the market as if that’s actually doing work. Really, that’s kind of like rent seeking activity. It’s trying to time the market or whatever. I think that’s a very fiat mentality.
1:06:36 What I tell people is, OK, just whatever you do, if you think about it in terms of five years or decade, you’re going to be OK. No one’s ever lost money holding Bitcoin for five years. And if you hold it for five, ten years, it’ll be fine. But do it with the money that you’re going to hold for 5-10 years and not something that you need next week. Because if you’re looking for something that’s done next week, then that’s going to increase next week. You’re just trying to make something for nothing. You’re trying to rent seek. You’re trying to be sort of the clever trader that’s on the good side of the trade instead of somebody that’s providing value. If you want to go earn money, go earn money. Like go flip burgers at McDonald’s if you need to. But likely you have a skill that’s probably more valuable and you could go earn money and then put those you know live below your means and put whatever extra you have into Bitcoin and that will grow. That’s how this game is incentivized to be played is with a very long-term focus and if you’re looking for at a short-term focus that’s not going to work and also let me just rent a little bit on this one thing. Everybody wants the upside of Bitcoin, but they’re not willing to take the volatility. What they want is essentially something that doesn’t exist.
1:08:02 They want risk-free return forever. That doesn’t exist. If you reduce risk, then it’s going to have the same value or depreciate over time. If it has a higher volatility or more risk, then you’re going to have more upside. That’s just how markets work.
1:08:21 And that’s how, you know, if there were something that steadily went up over all time, then it would get armed to death by everybody else. So that’s, you know, volatility and reward are two sides of the same point. And that’s unfortunately or fortunately how you have to see it. Right, a little dose of reality there. Are you surprised that with all the information and the adoption and people talking more and more about it and even the attendance at the Miami Bitcoin Conference that the price has lagged a little bit this year?
1:08:57 Has that surprised you at all? Well, in a sense it doesn’t, but in a sense it does. Like there is a lot more demand for Bitcoin in various places, but there’s also a lot more demand for dollars. And that’s a part that I think we’re kind of discounting. In terms of like the Turkish Lira or the Nigerian Naira, I think Bitcoin is at all time highs because those currencies are relatively weak compared to the dollar.
1:09:29 So depending on what you’re measuring against, yeah, you’re doing fantastic, or not as well. But with respect to the dollar, the macroeconomic environment is very strange right now because you do have the Federal Reserve trying to tighten a lot more because of all of the talk around inflation. We did just have like an 8.5% print in the CPI and so on. So there’s a lot of motivation to at least appear more fiscally responsible. And that tightening is, I think it’s the DXY symbol like the relative dollar strength index, it’s near all time highs and stuff like that.
1:10:11 That’s playing into the factor of why the Bitcoin versus the dollar has been more or less steady because there is this dollar demand all over the place. Even in the stock market, a lot of stocks that were flying high in the middle of the pandemic, like Zoom and Netflix and so on, they’ve all like come down 70% or something like that. In large part because people would rather, there’s more dollar demand. You, if you can get, you know, eight and a half percent on like inflation protected bonds or something like that, then you might wanna do that rather than this.
1:10:52 As the interest rates on these other products become higher then it’s gonna flow out of these assets that were inflated during or that were asset inflated essentially during the crisis. So we have some weird macroeconomic trends that are working against sort of like the Bitcoin adoption. But yeah, that’s why I would say it’s kind of worked out the way it did. Super helpful. And again, I appreciate your summary earlier of the IMF and kind of the kind of financial wars that have been waged for a long time.
1:11:30 You know, when I joined Wall Street in 93, we just come off the Latin American debt crisis. So I got to see, I think it was the IMF’s handiwork, as they kind of pressured Argentina to take this money. Like you said, they got a cool name that’s an acronym and it seems like sent from God, these financial saviors, but then they put all these conditions that over time kind of grind you into all leads towards resources going to the U.S., right? And there’s a bunch of organizations like that that are out there working their ways With great branding, let’s be honest, the Federal Reserve has great branding, IMF as well, and don’t get me started on certain health organizations as well, WHO, and you just kind of say, okay, yeah, they seem like the smart people, the official people, you nod, but in the meantime, they’re all working their kind of agenda.
1:12:24 Curious what you think about not only the monetary war, but the information war, because it’s something we got a real dose of in 2020, and we saw a lot of technology platforms saying you could say this, you couldn’t say this. And recently, of course, we’ve seen your fellow Texan, Elon Musk, go ahead and make this bid and purchase of Twitter, which again is really interesting because it’s one of those companies that, again, it’s a source of information for so many people in this world. What do you think of, first of all, Elon buying Twitter?
1:12:57 Second of all, how do you look at kind of the information war when you’re already pretty privy on what that financial war looks like? Yeah, great question. So with respect to Elon, he’s trying to buy Twitter, I think in a sense to make sure he doesn’t get canceled. I think like that seems to me like his major motivation is if he controls that platform, it’s gonna be very hard to cancel him because his account won’t go away. He does seem like he’s somebody that cares a lot about free speech, especially his point of view, because I think it was Babylon B that canceled off of Twitter or their countless suspended, something like that.
1:13:43 And he’s been on that show a few times and so on. So protecting that and having it as a platform, I don’t see that as being very different than, say, Jeff Bezos buying Washington Post or Carlos Slim buying the New York Times. A lot of these media organizations are for sale because they essentially lose a lot of money. Elon Musk is doing it a little bit better because at least Twitter sells a bunch of ads and so on. But as to your second question of the information war, yeah, that is, in a sense, money is part of that.
1:14:21 And it’s this whole idea of propaganda. And it’s the influencing of others. And money is very closely linked with this. Because if you think about money, it’s really value that is being transferred from person to person. And that value, the perception of value, is influenced by what you think other people think the value of that thing is.
1:14:49 So there’s a significant amount of information wars that are going on. The thing I will say about that in particular is that it used to be a lot easier to run a propaganda campaign. So you would just say something on the evening news and a few newspapers and that was it. And that would be enough to get people to believe that animal fat is unhealthy for you or something like that. And that’s, you know, We could talk about health if you want, but that’s like one instance of where the propaganda was very successful to the point where people weren’t eating red meat, even though it’s like one of the best things for you.
1:15:37 Later on, with the advent of the internet and everything else, we’ve had these like walled silos of Facebook, Google and Twitter just sort of like come up out of this. Largely because if you have money, There’s all sorts of incentives to centralize for that reason, because nobody wants to pay half a penny for an article or something like that. There’s no real rails to do that. Instead, we have online ads, which have essentially served as a currency in a fiat system, which is a very crappy way to do it.
1:16:13 I look at an ad, it’s worth like 1,600th of a penny to somebody and that’s what gets sold instead of me actually paying for the article, which is, I think, the way it should be and the way I think it will be with the Bitcoin standard. But that information flow, because of it being non-monetizable to a large degree, it, you have this price of free, so you have a lot of influencing going back and forth, and the means have only gotten more potent, And a lot more people are susceptible to rhetoric as a result. And it’s essentially ended up with a few silos of really official sources of information.
1:17:05 I guess you could call it the Ministry of Truth or something like that. And that’s very concerning from a freedom perspective, because we know that that’s a part of the communist So essentially we’re we’re becoming way more Marxist and you know It’s not a coincidence that we’ve gone in that direction from an information stand standpoint as we’ve you know Done more with more socialist money with fiat money Yeah, it’s gonna be interesting to see where we go from here Again, the price tag for Twitter is quite significantly higher than the the Washington Post It was a 55 40 50 billion to keep him from being canceled But I think there’s a lot of motivations for him doing that. It’s gonna be interesting to see what that happens To that platform obviously, you know, we stream on these big tech platforms But in the past they’ve also told us we can’t say certain things and taking down certain videos so we felt what it’s like to be on the front of that and You know a lot of people don’t understand that most of what they’re seeing in some way is being controlled censored band shadow band or even the people creating it know not to say some things because they might be the rewarded or canceled off the platform so it’s an interesting way and I guess I’ll use that to go to my next question which is metaverse and maybe the company called meta now which is Facebook which was one of the controllers of that information you know I’ve had guests on
1:18:33 This show that are building you know what they call the open metaverse where It’s all going to be blockchain based where we communicate with each other and again one of my guests I think was Raul Paul said look WhatsApp group is a metaverse It’s a way we digitally communicate and you can take that to the next level with an oculus thing on etc But we clearly like communicating digitally. Do you think we need to look out with a company like meta Controlling that from a corporation or would you rather it being seen controlled on a blockchain in an open metaverse? even if that blockchain might not be Bitcoin?
1:19:08 That’s my question for you. Yeah, I don’t think blockchain is useful for anything like a metaverse. The amount of data that you’re talking about is way too much. And it’s essentially, if you know technically what a blockchain is, it’s a record of transactions, right? It’s a form of a database and it’s especially slow.
1:19:27 And the problem that it’s set to solve was decentralized consensus. How can I know whether or not this, these records are legit. And the way they do that is by using energy, using proof of work. And once you find proof of work, okay, then I don’t need to worry about the communication coming from other people and knowing whether or not this is part of the consensus or not. I can just check.
1:19:50 And if I can verify on my own without the help of anybody else, then I know this is legit. That’s what a blockchain is. It’s a database secured by proof of work so that you know that it is the canonical database without having to rely on other people to tell you what it is. I don’t think that’s really viable in any other sort of context because it’s very slow, it’s very expensive, it’s really hard to scale, it’s really hard to change. You can add new features.
1:20:21 So it is the wrong tool for the job for almost anything other than Bitcoin. So when like a lot of people like, I don’t know, like the people that are touting blockchain or whatever. I’ve been watching this space since, you know, 2011 and the blockchain, not Bitcoin meme, I think came in around 2014. There were like four or five different companies founded at that time just to try to see, okay, is there blockchain technology, like applicable to, uh, you know, this space or that space or healthcare or ads or, you know, creators or whatever, none of them panned out to do anything.
1:20:59 And they discovered the same thing that I did when I used to work at Paxos, you can’t make a square circle. Like you’re trying to centrally control a database that’s decentralized. You can’t make a decentralized centralized thing. So I don’t think that’s the way it goes. I think much more often what you’ll see is sort of like mini peer-to-peer groups or maybe even federated servers or something like that for the metaverse.
1:21:29 And those are happening today with respect to chat. Like you can have a Discord group, you just want a Discord server. So instead of Slack having their giant server and everyone logging into Slack, you just run a server and you can go and chat with people there. You can do something similar with video too, if you wanna do peer to peer instead of going through a centralized entity like Zoom or Skype or something like that. And those are all protocols that are being built on Lightning because you don’t want those things to be free.
1:22:03 It costs somebody something to run their own server. So I think that’s the direction it’ll go. And in order to really be decentralized, this is the insight that I think I’ve had over the past few years as I studied Bitcoin. You need to run your own server. You need to host your own data.
1:22:23 The reason why Facebook, Google, Twitter, all of these companies have gotten so big is because we’ve given up control of our data because it’s too cumbersome to run our own server. So instead, we let them run the servers and we store our data there. And of course, them being sort of the central party in that, they can cut you off whenever they want to, kick you out, or, you know, censor the data or modify the data or control the data that’s being served to everybody else.
1:22:55 If you’re hosting your own data, running your own server, then it’s now you control it. And this is the direction I think we’re going towards with the decentralized web being built on top of Lightning. And interestingly enough, this was the promise of the internet when it first started. It was supposed to be everybody running their own servers and serving content to each other rather than everything being in one silo and being completely centralized like Facebook is.
1:23:22 And then like Facebook being able to cancel you are saying, oh, you know what, that content’s no good or we don’t agree with it, or we’re enforcing government, truth, whatever. And you’re not allowed to post that or we’re gonna put this warning. It becomes a much more peer to peer thing. And that’s, I think the internet that we’ve always wanted that we’re going back towards because we have a monetary layer that allows people to pay for things. And now you can host your own data and charge people a fraction of a penny, you know, one 25th of a cent in order to transfer this portion of a video or stream something or whatever.
1:24:04 And that’s, I think, the world that we’re headed towards with Bitcoin. What was the most exciting thing you felt or heard or saw when you were at the recent Bitcoin conference in Miami was there, obviously it was big. There was a lot of, you know, big people there as well. Peter Thiel throwing money on the stage, and you were obviously on the news desk there, but what did you see or feel from that latest conference? Well, the thing that I felt was that this thing is getting really, really big.
1:24:39 I’ve been to a lot of Bitcoin conferences over the last five years, and this was by far the biggest. It took you 20 minutes to go from one end the place to the other. Like most Bitcoin conferences, you can go to every room in like one minute. It doesn’t take very long. So the scale of the thing just felt way, way bigger.
1:25:03 And I think that’s reflective of the number of people that are getting into this space. I think DCG did a study that said something like 26 million Americans have some exposure to Bitcoin in some way. It could be through GBTC or through actually owning it or having an account on Coinbase or something like that, but 26 million, that’s almost like 10%. ARP is only like 40 million members, so we’re looking at a much larger number, I think, in the years to come. So I felt that, definitely, that the community is getting much bigger. But it’s also interesting that it’s skewing much younger. And the one thing that struck me from the conference, and it was part of a talk that Michael Saylor was doing. And he was saying, you know, I have a lot of billionaire friends, and, you know, they’ll come and talk to me about Bitcoin. And almost always the reason why they want to talk to me about Bitcoin is because their kids are. Which is like, oh, that’s very interesting, because I heard the same thing in El Salvador. The people that got into El Salvador at Bitcoin Beach were the kids.
1:26:16 Mike Peterson was paying for kids to go clean up the beach in Lightning and they would go then go learn way more about it and then their family would have some medical emergency or you know need to pay rent and the kid would be like hey you know I have a hundred dollars here like do you want to use it and the parents would be blown away that’s how that community was won over. So the thing that I felt after this conference was okay it really is sort of like this generational thing that you talked about earlier, where it’s the young people that are going to make this, that are really going to drive this thing going forward, and not, you know, the established gerontocracy that, that are very resistant against it. It’s the young people understand it, they get it, and they’re really starting to develop it. And that’s where the future is and that’s what I felt.
1:27:13 And you teach a lot of people how to code and program you know in this Bitcoin space and that’s especially of yours I know you have events and things like that I also know you have six kids who are up and coming you know my daughter’s 18 we just went to Boston to look at universities and you know she sees what I’m doing here and she wants to study philosophy and I said look you can do both you know what did Mark Twain said never let your school get in the way of your education so you know she can learn this but also be in touch with what’s happening in the Bitcoin space. What do you teach the young people if they want to get involved in the space, if they want to code, and then what do you teach your own children about the space? Yeah, so what I tell them is, you know, Bitcoin is like the wild west. Again, going back to the hat and everything else. It’s got a lot of danger, but it’s also got a lot of opportunity.
1:28:06 And you mentioned the whole go west young man kind of thing that was said in the 1800s. The reason why they said that was because on the East Coast where a lot of these people would grow up, you would learn to become a baker or a lawyer or an accountant or something like that. And you’d have competition from people that were baker’s lawyers or accountants for like the last 30 years. They have a huge list of clients. It’s going to be hard to sort of like get them to switch, right?
1:28:37 Because this was back when, you know, you had a relationship with these people. So you’re not going to like give them up very easily. So they would say, go West, young man. And the idea was, well, if you’re a baker, it’s not to go out there and like go dip for gold or something like that. If you’re a baker, there aren’t that many bakers out in the West.
1:28:58 If you’re an accountant, there aren’t that many accountants out in the West. If you’re a lawyer, there aren’t that many lawyers out in the West. So you’re going to have this opportunity to really establish yourself and make something of yourself and pull yourself up by the bootstraps and really serve a good or a service to the community that they really need. And that was the idea. And for me, if you’re a young person and you’re thinking about this space, Well, go do whatever it is that you’re good at, but incorporate Bitcoin into it.
1:29:33 If you are in an accountant, well, the 60, 70-year-old accountants are not really learning about Bitcoin. They already have their clients. But if you’re an accountant and learn Bitcoin and know how to do all of the tax implications and figure out how to help people that way, well, you’re gonna have a lot more clients and you’re gonna be the export. Marco Santori, who was an early Bitcoiner, I think he came out of a mid-tier law school, but he’s the premier lawyer in the Bitcoin space right now.
1:30:08 And this is because he got into the Bitcoin law space very early, he recognized it. So he studied everything about it, all the statutes and all the things that would be relevant. Now, he’s a sought after lawyer in the Bitcoin space Bitcoin space because he knows all about law and Bitcoin, that intersection. So if you are a young person, go figure out what you’re good at and find the intersection with Bitcoin. And I promise you, you’re going to be essentially going out West.
1:30:40 You can go make something of yourself and you can have opportunity and do something that will benefit a lot of people. And that’s the dream, right? this ability to not only add value to other people, but make money doing it, it’ll be awesome. We’re gonna call this show Go West, young man. I just decided.
1:31:04 You know, Jimmy, we’ve always talked about spirituality on the show and I was wondering if we could finish and talk a little bit about your faith because I think it’s an important part of who you are. And I was just wondering how you have that conversation with people, what it’s meant to you. And yeah, tell me. Yeah, thank you for asking that question. So when a lot of people, you mentioned that I have six kids, I do a lot of teaching and I do make a lot of content, I write columns and do podcasts and so on.
1:31:36 So a question that I’ll get off it is, how the heck do you do all that stuff? What is it? And I’ve told them, okay, I’ve narrowed my life down to four things. And if it doesn’t fit into one of those categories, I just don’t do it anymore. And those four things are my faith.
1:31:52 They all start with that, by the way, so it’s easy to remember. My faith, my family, my fitness, and my finances. If it doesn’t fit into one of those categories, I just don’t do it. So I used to play fantasy football, another F. I don’t do that anymore.
1:32:09 I used to be on Facebook a lot. I deleted my account, I don’t do that anymore. It’s this process of elimination that’s really brought me to the place where I could really go deep in my faith. And one of the things that I’ve realized is that, you know, Bitcoin is a, it’s truth in some ways, a little T truth, not big T truth. The big T truth is of course for me, God.
1:32:34 And that’s a big part of who I am. And it’s, in a sense, the opposite of Pia, Pia sort of like corrupts everything. I think God makes everything holy. And this is, you know, the reality of Jesus Christ for me is he sanctifies absolutely everything that I’ve been doing, which is amazing. So, you know, one of the books that I wrote with Robert was a guest on your show and, you know, six other people was Thank God for Bitcoin.
1:33:04 And the way I describe it is, you know, I’m trying to Orange Pill Christians, but I’m also trying to Christ Pill Bitcoiners. And there is sort of a synergy, largely because there’s this commonality of low time preference behavior. And that’s what we call it in Bitcoin. But in Christianity, I think that’s something that you would call it the virtue of prudence, the ability to think far ahead and have wisdom about what it is that you are going to be experiencing later as a result of the actions that you’re doing now.
1:33:40 And the way I sort of sell Bitcoin to Christians is it’s a lot like Christianity, where if you don’t understand the problem of sin, of how you are broken inside, then Christ does not make any sense. And in the same way, unless you understand the brokenness of the financial system, you really won’t understand what Bitcoin actually solves. And for Bitcoiners, it’s, okay, well, there’s some very practical questions of, okay, I want to leave a legacy, I want to live a good life, not just now, but 20, 30, 40 years from now, what do I do?
1:34:20 A lot of them think about meaning in their life. How do I get more meaning in their lives? And I’m sure you would agree having children is one of the most meaningful things that you can ever do. And having a family and accomplishing things that matter over the long term, those are all really spiritual questions. And these are questions that I get often at Bitcoin conferences, and exploring that ultimately leaves you, I think, from little t-truth to big t-truth.
1:34:53 And that’s been, for me, a very rewarding part of my work in the space. And yeah, it’s a giant blessing, not just for my finances, but for me spiritually. Yeah, that’s so important. I’m so glad you talk about that. You know, one of the questions I asked most of my guests at the end of a long London Real episode Jimmy is you know, what’s gonna happen to us and what’s the what’s the lesson and Repeatedly over and over Jimmy these guests with a diverse ranges from a bodybuilder to an author to an activist would say Brian We are all one. That’s what they would say at the end of the show And you know, it was a very spiritual thing to say that a lot of times took people off guard guard and yet in this space in Bitcoin I feel like people are more on that frequency and I always appreciate to hear people’s faiths because you know it usually has something along those lines as well of trying to get people to see kind of this bigger picture of what’s going on with it with the human species and you know I’ve come kind of full circle when it comes to looking at religion and I’ve had people like dr. Jordan Peterson in here talking to me about how, you know, the Bible and how it’s actually, it’s the human DNA and the story form.
1:36:13 And I’ve started to think about that and trying to, you know, get my head around what a lot of these things are and how they were created and what they’re trying to show us and teach us. And I think it’s really fascinating. And the older I get, the more I understand and appreciate religion somehow. Whereas when you’re a kid, it’s easily sometimes to reject it as something that feels like oppressive. So it’s great to hear that it inspires you and it’s something I’m constantly thinking about and thinking about more lately.
1:36:43 And especially as we’ve had certain guests on the show that like you said, 25 years ago, would never make it on the evening news. Now we can have these long-form nuanced conversations with people and start to explore some really essential ideas. So it doesn’t surprise me that your faith is at the basis of a lot of what you do. Yeah, and I think it’s great that you and a lot of your, you know, listeners and viewers, I think they’re exploring it too. And that’s a part of, I think, becoming a man is, hey, what is the purpose of my life?
1:37:17 Or what am I doing all of this for? And if you don’t have a good answer to that, it’s going to be very unsatisfying even accomplishing certain things because, you know, you can live for yourself and have sort of like this hedonistic lifestyle, which, you know, like, you know, when you’re younger, it sounds great, right? Like, oh, I can get all the sex I want. I can have all the money I want, and I could spend it on whatever. But that doesn’t have a lasting legacy.
1:37:44 It’s very dark if that’s all you’re going after. And I think one of the things that your show does so well is get them focused on something more than the here and now because like you said you know discipline is freedom there there is sort of like meaning beyond you know the immediate gratification of your needs and that in itself is a wonderful thing to have something long-term that you want to do and accomplish and that ultimately will and then your spiritual salvation. Yeah, it’s that ultimate lesson in life that you won’t get from MTV or Instagram.
1:38:27 And that is what we really are here to do is as Shep Gordon, one of my guests on the show who had a movie made about him by Mike Myers called Supermensch. He lives in Hawaii. I just saw Bezos post a picture with him. And he said, Brian, we’re here to be of service. That’s what he said.
1:38:44 And so when I started this show 11 years ago, I had found after 40 years that making money for Brian got really unfulfilling really quick. And so even though it doesn’t seem very obvious to ultimately be of service is actually the way to really find your happiness, your purpose. So yeah, it’s ultimately a great lesson we try to get across. So yeah, appreciate your perspective on that. Final thoughts, Jimmy, for anybody here who’s listening to us, who wants to learn more about the space, curious about the future of the space, Just wanna know what kind of message you leave people with.
1:39:21 The message I would leave them with is that, you know, like just get off of zero if you’re curious about Bitcoin. You know, if you own zero of it, then you’re not gonna be motivated to learn. And once you do have a little bit, then you can start going down the rabbit hole. This is, at least in my experience, the way most people learn about it is they buy a little bit of it And because they’re invested, they’re motivated to learn more about it. And as it goes out, they learn even more about it and they go down the rabbit hole.
1:39:53 And it’s a little tea truth about money and the way that works and all of the different sort of philosophical things that come out of that. And if you are honest with yourself and are curious philosophically, I think you’ll come out in the end like questioning a lot of different things. And you know, I see this show as sort of like a red pill kind of show about all kinds of stuff, not just finances, but you know, obviously like your body and discipline and you know, food or you know, different body hacks that you can do and things like that.
1:40:31 You know, all of those things are good to question because then that forces you to learn things from first principles. And that’s ultimately the place that you wanna get to, You know, starting with a smaller thing as buying a little Bitcoin, so you learn more about it. And once you do learn things from first principles and really have a good grasp of what’s going on, that’ll change your life. Like philosophy is reality. And when you have a different mental model of the world, it changes absolutely everything.
1:41:04 And I wish you luck on that journey. No, I couldn’t agree more. Start small, start now. and experience that. Just like you can start your movement practice, your spiritual practice, all that stuff now, and then learn from the source, right?
1:41:18 What’s the best way for them to follow you? I know you’re big on Twitter. I know you do some incredible writing and obviously you teach people how to code. What’s the best way for people to learn more? Yeah, so I’m at Jimmy Song on Twitter.
1:41:30 My website is programmingbitcoin.com. That’s the title of my first book. And you can learn about all the stuff that I’m doing there. I also write a column for Bitcoin Magazine. Bitcoin song sheet, so you can go look me up there, and I’ll just rant about random stuff.
1:41:46 Kind of like the topics on your show, sometimes you’ll do one thing and sometimes another. I’ll do that, but relate it to Bitcoin. Fantastic. Jimmy, thank you so much for everything you contribute. I really enjoyed this conversation.
1:41:57 Next time, let’s do it either in Austin or in London, and we’ll sit down for a proper in-person chat. And I will wear my custom fitted suit to match yours. Good, bring me a hat as well. All right, great stuff. Thanks so much Jimmy. Follow this man. We appreciate you all here at London Real and stay with me here But we’ll see you all next time. Take care. Bye